Abstract
An application is highlighted that introduced natural language to an organisation to replace a structured query language. Users were introduced to natural language while a parallel group of users was introduced to a structured query language. The exposure to natural language and the structured query language in parallel was done not as a strict scientific study. It was done as a means of introducing a natural language interrogation tool to the company. This does not detract from its usefulness because so little work has been done on natural language evaluation in a business environment (Jarke, Turner, Stohr, Vassiliou, White Michielson 1985, Krause 1979). This application involved users using natural language to solve real world problems as opposed to controlled laboratory experiments (Reisner 1977, Welty and Stemple 1981). The users of the natural language and the structured query language worked in the same open plan office environment. The new users of the natural language system were initially happy with it, but over a period of months began to migrate and preferred the structured query language tool.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
Bibliography
Birkhead. E. The Natural. DEC Professional. Vol 8. Part 9. (1989).
Burton. A., Steward. A , and Davenport. C. Natural Language & Pattern Matching Problems. British Computer Society Information Retrieval Specialist Group. lIth Information Retl1eval Research Colloquium. (1989).
Copestake. A.. and Sparck-Jones. K. Natural Language Interfaces To Databases, The Knowledge Engineering Review. No 5. part 4. (1990).
Ellis, D., Theory and explanation in information retrieval systems, Journal of Documentation, Vol 26 no 1, (1984).
Engellieson, B., and McBryde. R. Natural Languages Markets: Commercial Strategies, Ovum Ltd., ISBN 0903969610, (1991)
Harris, L. R. User oriented Data Base Query with the ROBOT Natural Language Query System. International Journal of Man-Machine Studies, Vol 9, (1977).
Hendrix, G. G. Natural Language Interface. American Journal Of Computational Linguistics. Vol 8, Part 2, (1982).
Jarke, J., Turner,I. A., Stohr, E. A.. Vassiliou. Y .White, N. H . and Michielsen, K. A Field Evaluation Of Natural Language For Data Retrieval. IEEE Transactions On Software Engineering, Vol. SE-ll, No.1, January. (1985).
Kowalski, R, and Kriwaczek, F. Artificial Intelligence Masters, Video by Addison Wesley, VUAL-3. (1986).
Krause, J. Preliminary Results of a User Study with the User Speciality Languages System. and Consequences for the Architecture of Natural Language Interfaces. IBM Heidelberg Scientific Center TR 79.04.003, Heidelberg, Germany, (1979).
Lehman. H., Ott, N., and Zoeppritz. M. User Experiments with Natural Language for Data Base Access. Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on Computational Linguistics, Bergen, Norway, (1978).
McEnery. A, M., Oakes M, P., and Reid, D. C. Pantheon: Rapid Prototyping of Natural Language Interfaces To Large Databases. Proceedings of British Computer Society Twelfth Information Retrieval Research Conference. (1990)
Morik, K. Customers Requirements for Natural Language Systems: Results of an Enquiry. International Journal of Man Machine Studies. Vol 21, (1984).
Paxton, A. E., and Turner, E. J. The Application Of Human Factors To The Needs Of The Novice Computer User. International Journal of Man-Machine Studies. Vol 20, (1984).
Petrick, S. R. Natural Language Database Query Systems. Technical Report RC 10508 mM Thomas J Watson Research Laboratory Yorktown Heights, (1984).
Rich, E. Natural Language Interfaces. Computer, September, (1984).
Shneiderman, B. A Note On Human Factors Issues Of Natural Language Interaction Information Systems, Vol 6, no 2, (1981).
Sidhu, J. Use of Natural Language in Industry, Dept. Manufacturing Engineering Nottingham Polytechnic Internal Report, (1991).
Small, D. W., and Wheldon., L, J. An Experimental Comparison Of Natural and Structured Query Languages. Human Factors Vol 25,. no 3, (1983).
Smithson, S. The Evaluation Of Information Retrieval Systems: A Case Study Approach. Prospects For Information Retrieval Informatics. Vol 10, (1989).
Vassiliou, Y., Jarke, I., Stohr, E. A. Turner, I. A., and White, N. H. Natural Language For Database Quelies: A Laboratory Study. MIS Quarterly, December (1983).
Velardi, P. Entity Relationship Approach To The User. Proc Of The Seventh International Conference. Rome November (1988).
Weischedel, R M. Issues and Red Henings In Evaluating Natural Language Interfaces. Empirical Foundations of Information and Software Science IV; Empirical Methods of Evaluation of Manmade Intelfaces, Proceedings of the FOUlth Symposium. Bolt Beranek and Newman Laboratories, Massachusetts, USA. (1986).
Welty., C and Stemple., D. W. Human Factors compatison of a procedural and non procedural query language. ACM Transaction Of Database Systems, Vol 6, no 4 (1981).
Whittaker., S. and Stenton. P. User studies and the design of Natural Language Systems. Proceedings of the European ACL, Manchester. (1990).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 1993 British Computer Society
About this paper
Cite this paper
Sidhu, J. (1993). Natural Language For Database Retrieval- A Practical Perspective. In: McEnery, T., Paice, C. (eds) 14th Information Retrieval Colloquium. Workshops in Computing. Springer, London. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4471-3211-0_13
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4471-3211-0_13
Publisher Name: Springer, London
Print ISBN: 978-3-540-19808-6
Online ISBN: 978-1-4471-3211-0
eBook Packages: Springer Book Archive