Abstract
The problem under consideration is a numerical study of the effects of thickness on lift for low-aspect-ratio wings in steady incompressible inviscid flow at moderate of attack. At these angles of attack the flow separates along the leading edge giving rise to a lift substantially higher than that computed by classical attached-flow potential theory. The problem is treated as a perturbation expansion in a small thickness parameter. The lifting elements of the flow are modeled using a nonlinear vortex-lattice method which replaces the leading and trailing-edge vortex sheets by segmented straight vortex filaments. The thickness elements of the flow are modeled with a mean-plane source distribution and a modification to the wing boundary conditions. Results are obtained for wings with biconvex and NACA 0012 sections which compare well with available experimental data. The important observation that the effect of thickness is to decrease the lift is made.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bartlett, G.E. and Vidal, R.J.: Experimental investigation of influence of edge shape on the aerodynamic characteristics of low aspect ratio wings at low speeds, Journal of the Aeronautical Sciences 22 (1955) 517–533.
Peckham, D.H.: Low speed wind tunnel tests on a series of uncambered pointed wings with sharp edges. ARC R&M 3186 (1961).
Wentz, W.H. and McMahon, M.C.: An experimental investigation of the fields about delta and double delta wings at low speeds, NASA CR 521 (1966).
Wentz, W.H.: Effects of leading edge camber on low speed characteristics of slender delta wings, NASA CR 2002 (1972).
Hummel, D.: On the vortex formation over a slender wing at large angles of incidence, Paper No. 15, AGARD CP 247 (1979).
Jacquet, B.N. and Brewer, J.D.: Low speed static stability and rolling characteristics of low aspect ratio wings of triangular and modified triangular planforms, NACA RM No. L8L29 (1948).
Smith, J.H.B.: Inviscid fluid models, based on rolled-up vortex sheets, for three dimensional separation at high Reynolds number, Paper No. 9, AGARD LS 94 (1978).
Lamar, J.E. and Campbell, J.F.: Recent studies at NASA Langley of vortical flows interacting with neighboring surfaces, AGARD Symposium on Vortical Type Flows, Rotterdam, the Netherlands (1983).
Hoeijmakers, H.W.M.: Computational vortex flow aerodynamics, AGARD CP 342, Paper No. 18 (1983).
Polhamus, E.C.: A concept of the vortex lift of sharp edge delta wings based on a leading edge suction analogy, NASA TND-3767 (1966).
Lamar, J.E. and Gloss, B.B.: Subsonic aerodynamic characteristics of interacting lifting surface with separated flows around sharp edges predicted by a vortex lattice method, NASA TND-7921 (1975).
Lan, C.E. and Hsu, C.H.: Effects of vortex breakdown on longitudinal and lateral-directional aerodynamics of slender wings by the suction analogy. AIAA 82-1385 (1982).
Johnson, F.T., Tinoco, E.N., Lu, P. and Epton, M.A.: Three dimensional flow over wings with leading edge vortex separation, AIAA Journal 18 (1980) 367–380; also AIAA 79–0282 (1979).
Kandil, O.A., Mook, D.T. and Nayfeh, A.H.: Nonlinear prediction of aerodynamic loads on lifting surfaces. Journal of Aircraft 3 (1976) 22–28.
Kandil, O.A., Chu, L.C. and Yates, E.C.: Hybrid vortex method for lifting surfaces with free vortex flow, AIAA 80-0070 (1980).
Zorea, C. R. and Rom, J.: The calculation of nonlinear aerodynamic characteristics of wing and their wake in subsonic flow, 20th Israel Annual Conf. on Aviation and Astronautics (1978) 36–48.
Gordon, R. and Rom, J.: Calculation of nonlinear subsonic characteristics of wings with thickness and camber at high incidence, AIAA Journal 23 (1985) 817–825.
Kulfan, R.M.: Wing airfoil shape effects on the development of leading edge vortices, AIAA 79-1675 (1979).
Lamar, J.E.: Private communication.
Manro, M.E.: Aeroelastic loads predicted for an arrow wing, NASA CR 3642 (1983).
Plotkin, A.: Thickness and camber effects in slender wing theory, AIAA Journal 21 (1983) 1755–1757.
Weber, J.: Second order small perturbation theory for finite wings in incompressible flows, ARC R&M 3759 (1972).
Sells, C.C.L.: Iterative methods for thick cambered wings in subcritical flow, ACR R&M 3786 (1974).
Ashley, H. and Landahl, M.T.: Aerodynamics of Wings and Bodies, Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, Inc., Massachusetts (1965).
Woodward, F.A.: An improved method for the aerodynamics analysis of wing-body-tail configurations in subsonic and supersonic flow, NASA CR-2228 (1973).
Dodbele, S.S.: Lift due to thickness for low aspect ratio wings in incompressible flow, Ph.D. Thesis, Dept. of Aerospace Engineering, University of Maryland (1984).
Dodbele, S.S. and Plotkin, A.: Lift due to thickness for low aspect ratio wings in incompressible flow, AIAA 85-1588 (1985).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Dodbele, S.S., Plotkin, A. Loss of lift due to thickness for low-aspect-ratio wings in incompressible flow. J Eng Math 21, 3–16 (1987). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00127688
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00127688