Abstract
Experimental work on systems showing evidence of the coexistence of superconductivity and magnetic order is reviewed. The presently known systems are shown to be “superconducting spin glasses” rather than “ferromagnetic superconductors”. In those systems where the magnetic order is expected to be long-ranged (up to now) superconductivity vanishes as soon as the magnetic order appears. But it is not excluded that magnetic order with a correlation length larger than the superconductive coherence length can coexist with superconductivity.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
V.L.Ginzburg: Soviet Phys. JETP4, 153–160 (1957) (Transl. of J. Exptl. Theoret. Phys.31, 202–210, 1956)
R.A.Hein, R.L.Falge,Jr. B.T.Matthias, C.Corenzwit Phys. Rev. Lett.2, 500–502 (1959)
N.E.Phillips, B.T.Matthias: Phys. Rev.121, 105–107 (1961)
D.K.Finnemore, D.L.Johnson, J.E.Ostenson, F.H.Spedding, B.J.Beaudry: Phys. Rev.137, A550–556 (1965
D.K.Finnemore, D.C.Hopkins, P.E.Plamer: Phys. Rev. Lett.15, 891–893 (1965)
P.Steiner, D.Gumprecht, S.Hüfner: Phys. Rev. Lett.30, 1132–1135 (1973)
D.Gumprecht, P.Steiner, S.Hüfner: Physic Lett.48, 269–270 (1974)
L.J.Williams, W.R.Decker, D.K.Finnemore: Phys. Rev. B2, 1287–1293 (1970)
S.J.Poon, J.Durand: Bull. Am. Phys. Soc.22, 338 (1977)
G.Zimmermeyer, B.Roden: Z. Physik B24, 377–379 (1976)
B.T.Matthias, H.Suhl, E.Corenzwit: Phys. Rev. Lett.1, 449–450 (1958)
M.Wilhelm, B.Hillenbrand: J. Phys. Chem. Solids31, 559–565 (1970) and Stanford Conf. on Superconductivity (August 1969)
M.Wilhelm, B.Hillenbrand: Physica55, 608–614 (1971)
M.Wilhelm, B.Hillenbrand: Z. Naturforsch26a, 141–149 (1971)
M.Peter, P.Donzé, Ø.Fischer, A.Junod, J.Ortelli, A.Treyvaud, E.Walker, M.Wilhelm, B.Hillenbrand: Helvetia Physica Acta44, 345–358 (1971)
D.J.Erickson, C.E.Olsen, R.D.Taylor: InMössbauer Effect Methodology, Vol.8, ed. by J.J.Envermann (Plenum Press, New York 1973) p. 13
R.D.Taylor, W.R.Decker, D.J.Frickson, A.L.Giorgi, B.T.Matthias, C.E.Olsen, E.G.Szklarz:Proc. 13th Int. Conf. on Low Temperature Physics, Vol.II, Boulder 1972, ed. by K.D.Timmerhaus, W.J.O'Sullivan, and E.F.Hammel (Plenum Press, New York, London 1974) p. 605.
G.Rupp: J. Phys. F (Metal Phys.)3, 1403–1416 (1973)
K.Kumagi, K.Asayama: J. Phys. Soc. Japan (Letters)39, 543–544 (1975)
B.Hillenbrand, M.Wilhelm: Physics Lett31A, 448–449 (1970)
B.Hillenbrand, K.Schuster, M.Wilhelm: Z. Naturforsch.26a, 1684–1691 (1971)
S.Roth, K.Ibel, W.Just, J. Phys. C. (Solid State Phys.)6, 3465–3468 (1973); J. Appl. Cryst.7, 230–232 (1974); and Proc. Int. Conf. on Magnetism Vol.4, Moscow (1974) p. 410–414
J.W.Lynn, D.E.Moncton, W.Thomlinson, L.Passell: Bull. Am. Phys. Soc.22, 339 (1977)
H.Suhl, B.T.Matthias, E.Corenzwit: J. Phys. Chem. Solids11, 346–348 (1959)
B.Hillenbrand, M.Wilhelm: Physics Lett.40A, 387–388 (1972)
T.E.Jones, E.P.Chock, P.M.Chaikin: Bull. Am. Phys. Soc.22. 339 (1977)
M.B.Maple: Physics Lett.26A, 513–514 (1968)
M.B.Maple Solid State Commun.12, 653–656 (1973)
C.A.Luengo, M.B.Maple: Solid State Commun.12, 757–762 (1973)
Y.Asada: J. Phys. Soc. Japan41, 26–31 (1976)
P.Duffer, S.G.Sankar, V.U.S.Rao, R.L.Bergner, R.Obermyer: phys. stat. sol. (a)31, 655–660 (1975)
A.M.Toxen, P.C.Kwok, R.J.Gambino: Phys. Rev. Lett.21, 792–794 (1968)
H.E.Hoenig, P.v.Blanckenhagen: Proc. II. Conf. on Crystal Field Effects in Metals and Alloys, Zürich (1976)
J.E.Crow, R.D.Parks: Physicals Lett.21, 378–379 (1966)
R.P.Guertin, J.E.Crow, R.D.Parks: Phys. Rev. Lett.16 1095–1097 (1966)
J.E.Crow, R.P.Guertin, R.D.Parks: Phys. Rev. Lett.19, 77–81 (1976)
H.Jones, Ø.Fischer, G.Bongi, A.Treyvaud: Solid State Commun.10, 927–931 (1972)
K.Yasukochi, Y.Kuwasawa, K.Skizawa: Physics Lett.28A, 12–13 (1968)
Y.Kuwasawa, K.Sekizawa, N.Usui, K.Yasukochi: J. Phys. Soc. Japan27, 590–600 (1969)
R.L.Bergner, V.U.S.Rao, S.G.Sankar: AIP Conf. Proc. (USA) No.29, p. 325–326 (1976) (Proc. of 21st Annual Conf. on Magnetism and Magnetic Materials, Philadelphia, 1975)
Ø.Fischer, A.Treyvaud, G.Bongi, H.Jones, R.Flükiger: J. Phys. F (Metal Phys.)4, 1187–1203 (1974)
G.Bongi, R.Flükger, A.Treyvaud, Ø.Fischer, H.Jones, D.Schneider: J. Low Temp. Phys.17, 223–246 (1974)
G.H.Bongi, R.Flükiger, A.Treyvaud, Ø.Fischer: J. Low Temp. Phys.23, 543–569 and 571–597 (1976)
N.E.Alekseevkii, Ch.Bazan, N.M.Dobrovolskii V.I.Tsebro: JETP Lett.20, 211–212 (1974) [Transl. of ZhETF Pis. Red.20 465–468 (1974)]
N.E.Alekseevskii, E.J.Leyarovski, L.N.Leyarovska, V.I.Tsebro: J. Phys. C (Solid State Phys.)8, L585–588 (1975)
N.E.Alekseevskii, C.Bazan, N.M.Dobrovolskii, V.I.Nizhankowskii, V.I.Tsebro, V.M.Zakosarenko: Physics Lett.54A, 371–372 (1975)
H.Barz: Physics Lett.54A, 233–234 (1975)
Ø.Fischer, A.Treyvaud, R.Chevrel, M.Sergent: Solid State Commun.17, 721–724 (1975)
J.Bolz, G.Crecelius, H.Maletta, F.Pobell: J. Low Temp. Phys., to be published
J.J.Hauser, M.Robbins, F.J.DiSalvo: Phys. Rev. B8, 1038–1042 (1973)
W.Klose, P.Entel, H.Nohl: Physics Lett.50A, 186–188 (1974)
P.Entel, M.Crisan, G.Bongi, W.Klose: J. Low Temp. Phys.23, 157–176 (1976)
R.H.Willens, E.Buehler: J. Appl. Phys.38, 405–406 (1967)
W.A.Fertig, D.C.Johnston, L.E.DeLong, R.W.McCallum, M.B.Maple, B.T.Matthias: Phys. Rev. Lett.38, 987–990 (1977)
M.Ishikawa, Ø.Fischer: Solid State Commun. (1977) to be published
R.D.Parks: InSuperconductivity, Vol.2, ed. by P.R.Wallace (Gordon and Breach, New York, London, Paris 1969) p. 625–690
K.H.Bennemann, J.W.Garland: Intern. J. Magnetism,1, 97–122 (1971)
Ø.Fischer, M.Peter: InMagnetism, Vol. V., ed. by G.T.Rado and H.Suhl (Academic Press, New York, London 1973) p. 327–352
V.Jaccarino, M.Peter: Phys. Rev. Lett.9, 290–292 (1962)
R.Avenhaus, Ø.Fischer, B.Giovannini, M.Peter: Helvetia Physica Acta42, 649–662 (1969)
Ø.Fischer, M.Decroux, S.Roth, R.Chevrel, M.Sergent: J. Phys. C (Solid State Phys.)8, L474–477 (1975)
O.Entin-Wohlman: Phys. Rev. B12, 4860–4866 (1975)
G.Heber: Appl. Phys.10, 101–110 (1976)
K.H.Fischer:Proc. Int. Conf. on Magnetism, 1976, Part II, ed. by P.F.deChâtel and J.J.M.Franse (North Holland Amsterdam, New York, Oxford 1977) p. 813–819 [appears as Physica 86-88B, 813–819 (1977)]
N.B.Hannay, T.H.Geballe, B.T.Matthias, K.Andres, P.Schmidt, D.MacNair: Phys. Rev. Lett.14, 225–226 (1965)
A.V.Zvarykina, Yu.S.Karimov, M.E.Volpin, Yu.N.Novikov: Fiz. Tver. Tela13, 28–32 (1971)
B.T.Matthias: Physics Lett.37A, 249–250 (1971)
J.M.Voorhoeve, N.Van DenBerg, M.Robbins: J. Solid State Chemistry1, 134–137 (1970)
G.V.S.Rao, M.W.Shafer, L.J.Tao: Mat. Res. Bull.8, 1231–1240 (1973)
R.N.Shelton, R.W.McCallum, H.Adrian: Phys. Lett.56A, 213–214 (1976)
A.A.Abrikosov, L.P.Gorkov: Soviet Physics JETP12, 1243–1253 (1961) [Transl. of J. Exptl. Theoret. Phys.39, 1781–1796 (1960)]
E.Müller-Hartmann, B.Schuh, J.Zittartz: Solid State Commun.19, 439–442 (1976); and E.Müller-Hartmann, H.Shiba: Z. Physik B23, 143–147 (1976); and the previous articles of a series cited therein
M.B.Maple, W.A.Fertig, A.C.Mota, L.E.Delong, D.Wohlleben, R.Fitzgerald: Solid State Commun.11, 829–834 (1972)
J.Keller, P.Fulde: J. Low Temp. Phys.4, 289–298 (1971); see also: P.Fulde and I.Peschel: Adv. Physics21, 89 (1972)
G.Pepperl, E.Umlauf, A.Meyer, J.Keller: Solid State Commun.14, 161–165 (1974)
K.H.Bennemann: Phys. Rev. Lett.17, 438–443 (1966)
J.Keller, R.Benda: J. Low Temp. Phys.2, 141–155 (1970)
P.W.Anderson, H.Suhl: Phys. Rev.116, 898–900 (1959)
L.P.Gorkov, A.I.Rusinov: Sov. Physics JETP19, 922–931 (1964) [Transl. of J. Exptl. Theoret. Phys.46, 1363–1378 (1964)]
P.Fulde, K.Maki: Phys. Rev.141, 275–280 (1966)
D.Rainer: Z. Physik252, 174–188 (1972)
Yu.A.I.Izyumov, Yu.N.Skryabin: Fiz. metal metalloved38, 912–917 (1974);37, 1127–1137 and 921–929 (1974) [Translated in Phys. Met. & Metallogr. (G.B.)]
P.Entel, W.Klose: J. Low Temp. Phys.17, 529–538 (1974)
P.Entel, W.Klose:Proc. 14th Int. Conf. on Low Temperature Physics, Vol.3 Otaniami, Finland, ed. by M.Crusius and M.Vuorio (North Holland, Amsterdam, Oxford and American Elsevier Publishing Company, New York 1975) p. 434–437
P.Entel, W.Klose, Ø.Fischer, G.Bongi: Z. Physik B21, 363–368 (1975)
M.B.Maple: Appl. Phys.9, 179–204 (1976)
K.H.Bennemann, J.W.Garland, F.M.Mueller: Phys. Rev. Lett.23, 169–173 (1969)
N.R.Werthamer, E.Helfand, P.C.Hohenberg: Phys. Rev.147, 295–302 (1966); see also: K.Maki, Phys. Rev.148, 362 (1966)
B.T.Matthias, H.Suhl: Phys. Rev. Lett.4, 51–52 (1960)
L.Neumann: Z. Physik253, 404–414 (1972)
S.Skalski, O.Betbeder-Matibet, P.R.Weiss: Phys. Rev.136, A 1500–1518 (1964)
K.H.Bennemann, J.W.Garland: Phys. Rev.159, 369–373 (1967)
C.E.Violet, R.J.Borg: Phys. Rev.149, 540–551 (1966)
J.L.Tholence, R.Tournier: J. Phys. (Paris)35, 235 (1974)
A.P.Murani: Phys. Rev. Lett.37, 450–453 (1976)
A.P.Murani, S.Roth, P.Radhakrishna, B.D.Rainford, B.R.Coles, K.Ibel, G.Goeltz, F.Mezei: J. Phys. F (Metal Phys.)6, 425–432 (1976)
U.Gonser (Ed.):Mössbauer Spectroscopy, Topics Appl. Phys., Vol. 5 (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York 1975)