Summary
In this paper we have discussed in detail the aspects of separability of the energy differences obtained from coupled cluster based “direct” methods such as the open-shell Coupled Cluster (CC) theory and the Coupled Cluster based Linear Response Theory (CC-LRT). It has been emphasized that, unlike the state energiesper se, the energy differences have a semi-local character in that, in the asymptotic limit of non-interacting subsystemsA, B, C, etc., they are separable as ΔE A , ΔE B , ΔE A + ΔE B , etc. depending on the subsystems excited. We classify the direct many-body methods into two categories: core-extensive and core-valence extensive. In the former, we only implicitly subtract the ground state energy computed in a size-extensive manner; the energy differences are not chosen to be valence-extensive (separable) in the semi-local sense. The core-valence extensive theories, on the other hand, are fully extensive — i.e., with respect to both core and valence interactions, and hence display the semi-local separability. Generic structures of the wave-operators for core-extensive and core-valence extensive theories are discussed. CC-LRT is shown to be core-extensive after a transcription to an equivalent wave-operator based form. The emergence of valence disconnected diagrams for two and higher valence problems are indicated. The open-shell CC theory is shown to be core-valence extensive and hence fully connected. For one valence problems, the CC theory and the CC-LRT are shown to be equivalent. The equations for the cluster amplitudes in the Bloch equation are quadratic, admitting of multiple solutions. It is shown that the cluster amplitudes for the main peaks, in principle obtainable as a series inV from the zeroth order roots of the model space, are connected, and hence the energy differences are fully extensive. It is remarkable that the satellite energies obtained from the alternative solutions of the CC equations are not valence-extensive, indicating the necessity of a formal power series structure inV of the cluster amplitudes for the valence-extensivity. The alternative solutions are not obtainable as a power series inV. The CC-LRT is shown to have an effective hamiltonian structure respecting “downward reducibility”. A unitary version of CC-LRT (UCC-LRT) is proposed, which satisfy both upward and downward reducibility. UCC-LRT is shown to lead to the recent propagator theory known as the Algebraic Diagrammatic Construction. It is shown that both the main and the satellite peaks from UCC-LRT for the one valence problems are core-valence extensive owing to the hermitized nature of the underlying operator to be diagonalized.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Coester F (1958) Nucl Phys 7:421; Coester F, Kümmel H (1960) Nucl Phys 17:477; Kümmel H (1961) Nucl Phys 22:177
Kümmel H, Lührmann KH, Zabolitzky JG (1978) Phys Rep 36C:1 for an extensive survey of the closed-shell CC approach to nuclear structure
Cizek J (1966) J Chem Phys 45:4256; (1969) Adv Chem Phys 14:35
Bartlett RJ (1981) Ann Rev Phys Chem 32:359 for an exhaustive survey of the closed shell CC theory for electronic structure. Open shell CC developments upto the time are also covered
Mukherjee D, Moitra RK, Mukhopadhyay A (1975) Mol Phys 30:1861; (1977) Mol Phys 33:955
Mukherjee D (1979) Pramana 12:203; Haque A, Mukherjee D (1984) J Chem Phys 80:5058
Offerman R, Ey W, Kümmel H (1976) Nucl Phys A273:349; Ey W (1978) Nucl Phys A296:189
Lindgren I (1978) Int J Quantum Chem S12:33; Solomonson S, Lindgren I, Martensson AM (1980) Phys Scripta 21:351; Solomonson S, Martensson Pendrill AM (1984) Phys Rev A30:712; Lindgren I (1985) Phys Rev A31:1273
Kutzelnigg W (1982) J Chem Phys 77:3081; Kutzelnigg W, Koch S (1983) J Chem Phys 79:4315
Haque A, Kaldor U (1985) Chem Phys Lett 117:347; (1985) Chem Phys Lett 120:261; (1986) Chem Phys Lett 128:45; Kaldor U (1987) J Comp Chem 8:448; (1987) J Chem Phys 87:467; (1986) Int J Quantum Chem S20:445
Mukherjee D (1986) Chem Phys Lett 125:207; (1986) Proc Ind Acad Sci 96:145; (1986) Int J Quantum Chem S20:409; Mukherjee D (1988) in: Arponen J, Bishop R, Mannien M (eds) Condensed matter theories, Vol 3. Plenum Press, NY
Lindgren I, Mukherjee D (1987) Phys Rep 151:93
Kutzelnigg W, Mukherjee D, Koch S (1987) J Chem Phys 87:5902; Mukherjee D, Kutzelnigg W, Koch S (1987) J Chem Phys 87:5911; Koch S, Mukherjee D (1988) Chem Phys Lett 145:321
Sinha D, Mukhopadhyay S, Mukherjee D (1986) Chem Phys Lett 129:369; Sinha D, Mukhopadhyay S, Chaudhuri R, Mukherjee D (1989) Chem Phys Lett 154:544; Chaudhuri R, Mukhopadhyay D, Mukherjee D (1989) Chem Phys Lett 162:393
Pal S, Rittby M, Bartlett RJ, Sinha D, Mukherjee D (1987) Chem Phys Lett 137:273; (1988) J Chem Phys 88:4357
Kroto HW, Matti GY, Suffolk RJ, Watts JD, Rittby M, Bartlett RJ (1990) J Am Chem Soc 112:3779
Ben-Shlomo S, Kaldor U (1988) J Chem Phys 89:956; Kaldor U (1990) Chem Phys 140:1; (1990) J Chem Phys 92:3680
Stolarczyk LZ, Monkhorst HJ (1985) Phys Rev A32:725, 743; (1988) Phys Rev A37:1980, 1926
Nakatsuji H (1985) J Chem Phys 83:5743; (1987) Theor Chim Acta 71:201
Jeziorski B, Paldus J (1988) J Chem Phys 88:5673
Monkhorst HJ (1977) Int J Quantum Chem S11:421; Dalgaard E and Monkhorst HJ (1983) Phys Rev A28:1217
Paldus J, Cizek J, Saute M, Laforgue A (1978) Phys Rev A17:805; Saute M, Paldus J, Cizek J (1979) Int J Quantum Chem 15:463
Nakatsuji H (1978) Chem Phys Lett 59:362; (1979) Chem Phys Lett 67:329; Nakatsuji H, Hirao K (1978) J Chem Phys 68:2053; (1978) J Chem Phys 68:4279; Nakatsuji H (1983) Int J Quantum Chem S17:241
Mukherjee D, Mukherjee PK (1979) Chem Phys 39:325; Ghosh S, Mukherjee D, Bhattacharyya SN (1981) Mol Phys 43:173; Ghosh S, Mukherjee D, Bhattacharyya SN (1982) Chem Phys 72:161; Ghosh S, Mukherjee D (1984) Proc Ind Acad Sci 93:947
Emrich K (1981) Nucl Phys A351:379
Sekino H, Bartlett RJ (1984) Int J Quantum Chem S18:255
Takahashi M, Paldus J (1986) J Chem Phys 85:1486
Geertsen J, Rittby M, Bartlett RJ (1989) Chem Phys Lett 164:57
Koch H, Jensen HJ Aa, Jorgensen P, Helgaker T (1990) J Chem Phys 93:3345; Koch H and Jorgensen P (1990) J Chem Phys 93:3333
Banerjee A, Simons J (1981) Int J Quantum Chem 19:207; (1983) Chem Phys 81:297; (1984) Chem Phys 87:215
Laidig WD, Saxe P, Bartlett RJ (1987) J Chem Phys 86:887; Bartlett RJ, Dykstra CE, Paldus J (1984) in: Dykstra CE (ed) Advanced theories and computational approaches to the electronic structure of molecules. Reidel, Dordrecht
Chaudhuri R, Mukherjee D, Prasad MD (1987) in: Mukherjee D (ed) Lecture Notes in Cheimstry, Vol 50. Springer, Berlin
Mukherjee D, Pal S (1989) Adv Quantum Chem 20:291
Bloch C (1958) Nucl Phys 6:329
Goldstone J (1957) Proc Roy Soc A239:267
Hubbard J (1957) Proc Roy Soc A240:539
Hugenholtz NM (1957) Physica 23:481
Brandow B (1967) Rev Mod Phys 39:771; (1977) Adv Quantum Chem 10:187
Lindgren I (1971) J Phys B7:2441; Lindgren I, Morrison J (1981) Atomic many body theory. Springer, Heidelberg
Mukherjee D (1988) in: Arponen J, Bishop RF, Mannien M (eds) Condensed matter theories, Vol 3. Plenum, N.Y.
Hose G, Kaldor U (1979) J Phys B12:3827; (1980) Phys Scripta 21:357; (1982) J Phys Chem 86:2133
Schucan TH, Weidenmuller Y (1972) Ann Phys 73:108; (1973) Ann Phys 76:483
Jeziorski B, Monkhorst HJ (1981) A24:1668
Chaudhuri R, Sinha D, Mukherjee D (1989) Chem Phys Lett 163:165
Mukhopadhyay D, Mukherjee D (1989) Chem Phys Lett 163:171
Mukhopadhyay D, Mukherjee D (1991) Chem Phys Lett 177:441
Meissner L, Kucharski SA, Bartlett RJ (1989) J Chem Phys 91:6187; (b) Meissner L, Bartlett RJ (1990) J Chem Phys 92:561
Meissner L, Bartlett RJ (1989) J Chem Phys 91:4800
Mukhopadhyay S, Chaudhuri R, Mukhopadhyay D, Mukherjee D (1990) Chem Phys Lett 173:181; (b) Mukhopadhyay S (1989) PhD Thesis, Jadavpur University (India)
Bloch C, Horowitz J (1958) Nucl Phys 8:91
Coope JAR, Sabo DW (1977) J Comput Phys 23:404
Lindgren I (1985) Phys Scripta 32:291, 611
Mukhopadhyay D, Mukherjee D, to be published
Frantz LM, Mills RL (1960) Nucl Phys 15:16
Meissner L, Bartlett RJ (1990) preprint and the proceedings of the Harvard Symposium on Coupled Cluster Theory (1990); J Chem Phys 94:6670
Schirmer J (1982) Phys Rev A26:2395. Schirmer J, Cederbaum LS, Walter O (1983) Phys Rev A28:1237; Tarantelli A, Cederbaum LS (1989) in: Kaldor U (ed) Lecture Notes in Chemistry, Vol 52. Springer, Heidelberg
Mukherjee D, Kutzeinigg W (1989) in: Kaldor U (ed) Lecture Notes in Chemistry, Vol 52. Springer, Heidelberg
Prasad MD, Pal S, Mukherjee D (1985) Phys Rev A31:1287
Bartlett RJ, Kucharski SA, Noga J (1989) Chem Phys Lett 155:133; Watts JD, Trucks GW and Bartlett RJ (1989) Chem Phys Lett (1989) 157:359
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Mukhopadhyay, D., Mukhopadhyay, S., Chaudhuri, R. et al. Aspects of separability in the coupled cluster based direct methods for energy differences. Theoret. Chim. Acta 80, 441–467 (1991). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01119665
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01119665