Abstract
In this paper we seek to summarize the current knowledge about numerical instabilities such as checkerboards, mesh-dependence and local minima occurring in applications of the topology optimization method. The checkerboard problem refers to the formation of regions of alternating solid and void elements ordered in a checkerboard-like fashion. The mesh-dependence problem refers to obtaining qualitatively different solutions for different mesh-sizes or discretizations. Local minima refers to the problem of obtaining different solutions to the same discretized problem when choosing different algorithmic parameters. We review the current knowledge on why and when these problems appear, and we list the methods with which they can be avoided and discuss their advantages and disadvantages.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Allaire, G.; Francfort, G.A. 1993: A numerical algorithm for topology and shape optimization. In: Bendsøe, M.P.; Mota Soares, C.A. (eds.)Topology design of structures, pp. 239–248. Dordrecht: Kluwer
Allaire, G.; Kohn, R.V. 1993: Topology optimization and optimal shape design using homogenization.In: Bendsøe, M.P.; Mota Soares, C.A. (eds)Topology design of structures, pp. 207–218. Dordrecht: Kluwer
Ambrosio, L.; Buttazzo, G. 1993: An optimal design problem with perimeter penalization.Calc. Var. 1, 55–69
Beckers, M. 1996: Optimisation topologique de structures continues en variable discretes.Technical Report OF-38, LTAS, University of Liège
Beckers, M. 1997a: Methodes du perimetre et des filtres pour l'optimisation topologique en variable discretes.Technical Report OF-45, LTAS, University of Liège
Beckers, M. 1997b: Optimisation topologique de structures tridimensionelles en variable discretes.Technical Report OF-44, LTAS, University of Liège
Bendsøe, M.P. 1989: Optimal shape design as a material distribution problem.Struct. Optim. 1, 193–202
Bendsøe, M.P. 1995:Optimization of structural topology, shape and material. Berlin, Heidelberg, New York: Springer
Bendsøe, M.P.; Guedes, J.M.; Haber, R.B.; Pedersen, P.; Taylor, J.E. 1994: An analytical model to predict optimal material properties in the context of optimal structural design.Trans. ASME, J. Appl. Mech. 61, 930–937
Bendsøe, M.P.; Kikuchi, N. 1988: Generating optimal topologies in optimal design using a homogenization method.Comp. Meth. Appl. Mech. Engng. 71, 197–224
Bendsøe, M.P.; Kikuchi, N.; Diaz, A.R. 1993: Topology and generalized layout optimization of elastic structures. In: Bendsøe, M.P.; Mota Soares, C.A. (eds.)Topology design of structures, pp. 159–205. Dordrecht: Kluwer
Chambolle, A. 1995: Image segmentation by variational methods: Mumford and shah functional and the discrete approximations.SIAM J. Appl. Math. 55, 827–863
Díaz, A.R.; Sigmund, O., 1995: Checkerboard patterns in layout optimization.Struct. Optim. 10, 40–45
Duysinx, P. 1997: Layout optimization: A mathematical programming approach. (Submitted). Also:DCAMM Report No. 540, Technical University of Denmark
Guedes, J.M.; Taylor, J.E. 1997: On the prediction of material properties and topology for optimal continuum structures.Struct. Optim. 14, 183–192
Haber, R.B.; Bendsøe, M.P.; Jog, C. 1996: A new approach to variable-topology shape design using a constraint on the perimeter.Struct. Optim. 11, 1–12
Jog, C.S.; Haber, R.B. 1996: Stability of finite element models for distributed-parameter optimization and topology design.Comp. Meth. Appl. Mech. Engng. 130, 203–226
Johnson, C.; Pitkäranta, J. 1982: Analysis of some mixed finite element methods related to reduced integration.Mathematics of Computations 38, 375–400
Leblond, J.B.; Perrin, G.; Deveaux, J. 1994: Bifurcation effects in ductile metals with damage delocalization.J. Appl. Mech. 61, 236–242
Mullender, M.G.; Huiskes, R.; Weihnans, H. 1994: A physiological approach to the simulation of bone remodelling as a self-organizational controll process.J. Biomech. 11, 1389–1394
Niordson, F.I. 1983: Optimal design of plates with a constraint on the slope of the thickness function.Int. J. Solids & Struct. 19, 141–151
Petersson, J. 1997a: A finite element analysis of optimal variable thickness sheets. (Submitted). Also:Mat. Report No. 1996-4, December 1996, Technical University of Denmark
Petersson, J. 1997b: Some convergence results in perimeter-controlled topology optimization. (Submitted). Also:Report LiTH-IKP-R-995, Linköping University, Sweden
Petersson, J.; Sigmund, O. 1998: Slope constrained topology optimization.Int. J. Numer. Meth. Engng. 41, 1417–1434
Sigmund, O. 1994:Design of material structures using topology optimization. Ph.D. Thesis, Department of Solid Mechanics, Technical University of Denmark
Sigmund, O. 1997: On the design of compliant mechanisms using topology optimization.Mech. Struct. Mach. 25, 495–526
Sigmund, O.; Torquato, S. 1997: Design of materials with extreme thermal expansion using a three-phase topology optimization method.J. Mech. Phys. Solids 45, 1037–1067
Sigmund, O.; Torquato, S.; Aksay, I.A. 1998: On the design of 1–3 piezocomposites using topology optimization.J. Mat. Res. 13 (4)
Zhou, M.; Rozvany, G.I.N. 1991: The COC algorithm, Part II: Topological, geometry and generalized shape optimization,Comp. Meth. Appl. Mech. Engng. 89, 197–224
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Sigmund, O., Petersson, J. Numerical instabilities in topology optimization: A survey on procedures dealing with checkerboards, mesh-dependencies and local minima. Structural Optimization 16, 68–75 (1998). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01214002
Received:
Revised:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01214002