Summary
In 2 clinical studies in 40 conscious human volunteers and 164 orthopedic patients histamine-release responses were diagnosed, defined and classified. Polygeline (Haemaccel) in its now outdated formulation [40] was chosen as a clinical histamine releaser. The main interest was not concentrated on the extreme, the “classical” anaphylactic response, but on theaverage histamine-release response found in clinical experiments with so many drugs in the last 10 years.
In human volunteers 600 ng/kg histamine was i. v. injected. Indicants for a systemic anaphylactoid reaction with the highest incidence ratio were tachycardia, plasma histamine levels >1 ng/ml, “metallic taste”, flush, congestion of head, “wet eyes” and tears, hypertension and headache. Following polygeline none of these subjects developed a life-threatening reaction, but 12 showed a systemic response, 11 a cutaneous reaction and 17 were non-responders. Indicants for a systemic anaphylactoid reaction with the highest incidence ratio were plasma histamine levels >1 ng/ml, tachycardia, wheals, sensation of heat, narrowness of throat, hypertension, headache and wet eyes or tears.
In a prolective, cohort study in the orthopedic patients 3 subjects with life-threatening reactions, 27 with systemic response, 96 with cutaneous reaction and 38 non-responders were included. Indicants with the highest incidence ratio were tachycardia, plasma histamine levels >1 ng/ml, erythema and wheals, cough, flush, stuffy nose and facial oedema. With this trial the indicants for diagnosing a systemic histamine release response in volunteers were validated in patients to a large extent.
Thus the average histamine-release response was defined by clinical signs such as tachycardia and mild hypertension, scattered hives such as spots of erythema and wheals, respiratory symptoms in the laryngeal and nasal region, such as cough, narrowness in the throat, stuffy nose and sneezingand by pathological plasma histamine levels (>1 ng/ml). In addition histamine-release responses were differentiated as cutaneous responses, systemic responses and life-threatening responses by clinical and operational criteria and by plasma histamine levels. Using clinical trials and medical decision making procedures the incidence of systemic histamine-release responses in patients higher by two orders of magnitude than in other studies reported hitherto.
Zusammenfassung
In 2 klinischen Studien bei 40 wachen Freiwilligen und 164 orthopädischen Patienten wurde versucht, Histaminfreisetzungsreaktionen zu diagnostizieren, zu definieren und zu klassifizieren. Haemaccel in einer heute klinisch nicht mehr verwendeten Zubereitung [40] wurde als klinischer Histaminfreisetzer verwendet. Das Hauptinteresse galt nicht der extremen, der klassischen anaphylaktischen Reaktion, sondern einer durchschnittlichen Histaminfreisetzung, die in klinischen Untersuchungen der letzten 10 Jahre mit so vielen Arzneimitteln gefunden wurde.
Bei den Freiwilligen wurden 600 ng/kg Histamin intravenös verabreicht. Indikatoren für eine systemische anaphylaktoide Reaktion mit der höchsten Inzidenzrate waren Tachykardie, Plasmahistaminspiegel über 1 ng/ml, metallischer Geschmack, Flush, Kopfdruck, feuchte Augen oder Tränen, Hypertension und Kopfschmerzen. Nach Haemaccel-Infusion zeigte keiner der Probanden eine lebensbedrohliche Reaktion, aber 12 eine systemische und 11 eine Hautreaktion, während bei 17 keine Symptome gefunden werden konnten. Indikatoren mit der höchsten Inzidenzrate waren wiederum Plasmahistaminspiegel über 1 ng/ml, Tachykardie, Quaddeln, Hitzegefühl, Enge im Hals, Hypertension, Kopfschmerzen und Tränen.
In einer prolektiven Cohortstudie wurden aus 600 orthopädischen Patienten 164 ausgewählt: 3 hatten eine lebensbedrohliche Reaktion, 27 eine systemische und 96 eine Hautreaktion, 38 Patienten zeigten keine Symptome. Indikatoren mit der höchsten Inzidenzrate waren wiederum Tachykardie, Plasmahistaminspiegel über 1 ng/ml, Erytheme und Quaddeln, Husten, Flush, verstopfte Nase und Gesichtsödem. Damit wurden durch die Patientenstudie die Indikatoren für eine systemische Histaminfreisetzungsreaktion in Probanden zu einem großen Teil validiert. So läßt sich eine durchschnittliche Histaminfreisetzungsreaktion als eine systemische anaphylaktoide Reaktion charakterisieren, mit klinischen Symptomen wie Tachykardie und leichte Hypertension, verstreuten Effloreszenzen, respiratorischen Symptomen im Bereich des Kehlkopfs und der Nasenschleimhautund durch pathologische Plasmahistaminspiegel (>1 ng/ml). Außerdem wurden die Histaminfreisetzungsreaktionen in kutane, systemische und lebensbedrohliche Reaktionen eingeteilt, wobei klinische und operationale Kriterien sowie Plasmahistaminspiegel für die Klassifikation verwendet wurden.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adelmann B, Schöning B (1980) Binding of native and denaturated collagen to immunoglobulins and cold insoluble globulin in serum of patients undergoing orthopaedic surgery. Klin Wochenschr 58:625–629
Ahnefeld FW, Fischer F, Frey R, Kilian J, Schöning B (1979) Der Infusionszwischenfall nach künstlichen Plasmasubstituten im Meldekollektiv der Arzneimittelkommission. Anaesthesist 28:207–220
Austen KF (1974) Systemic anaphylaxis in the human being. New Engl J Med 291:661–664
Beaven MA, Jacobsen S, Horáková Z (1972) Modification of the enzymatic isotopic assay of histamine and its application to measurement of histamine in tissues, serum and urine. Clin Chim Acta 37:91–103
Black JW, Duncan WAM, Durant CJ, Ganellin CR, Parsons EM (1972) Definition and antagonism of histamine H2-receptor. Nature 236:385–390
Bristow MR, Sageman WS, Scott RH, Billingham ME, Bowden RE, Kernoff RS, Snidow GH, Daniels JR (1980) J Cardiovasc Pharmacol 2:487–515
Clarke RSJ, Dundee JW (1981) Adverse reactions to intravenous induction agents. In: Thornton JA (ed) Adverse reactions to anaesthetic drugs. Excerpta Medica/Elsevier North Holland, Amsterdam, pp 29–46
de Dombal FT, Staniland JR, Clamp SE (1981) Geographical variation in disease presentation. Does it constitute a problem and can information science help? Med Decis Making 1:59–69
Doenicke A, Lorenz W (1970) Histaminfreisetzung und anaphylaktoide Reaktionen bei Narkosen. Biochemische und klinische Aspekte. Anaesthesist 19:413–417
Doenicke A, Lorenz W, Beigl R, Bezecny H, Uhlig G, Kalmar L, Praetorius B, Mann G (1973) Histamine release after intravenous application of short-acting hypnotics: a comparison of etomidate, althesin (CT 1341) and propanidid. Br J Anaesthesia 45:1097–1104
Doenicke A (1975) Propanidid. In: Arias A, Llaurado R, Nalda MA, Lunn JN (eds) Proc. IV. Europ. Congr. Anesthesiology. Excerpta Medica, Amsterdam, pp 107–113
Dukor P, Kallós P, Schlumberger HD, West GB (1980) Genetic aspects and anaphylactoid reactions. in: PAR. Pseudo-allergic reactions. Involvement of drugs and chemicals, vol 1. Karger, Basel, pp 1–307
Editorial (1981) Histamine and antihistamines in anaesthesia and surgery. Lancet 2:74–75
Fisher MMCD (1979) Intradermal testing in the diagnosis of acute anaphylaxis during anaesthesia — results of five years experience. Anaesthesiol Intens Care 7:58–61
Galen RS, Gambino SR (1975) Beyond normality: the predictive value and efficiency of medical diagnoses. Wiley & Sons, New York, pp 1–185
Gill PW, Leaper DJ, Guillou PJ, Staniland JR, Horrocks JC, de Dombal FT (1973) Observer variation in clinical diagnosis — a computer aided assessment of its magnitude and importance in 552 patients with abdominal pain. Meth Inform Med 12:108–113
Goth A (1972) Histamine release by drugs and chemicals. In: Schachter M (ed) Histamine and antihistaminics, International Encyclopedia Pharmacology Therapy, vol 74/1. Pergamon Press, Oxford, pp 25–43
Healy MJR, Mitchell FL (1974) Quality control and normal values. In: Curtius HCh, Roth M (eds) Clinical biochemistry. Principles and methods. de Gryter, Berlin, pp 594–617
Horwitz RJ, Feinstein AR (1979) Methodological standards and contradictory results in case-control research. Am J Med 66:556–562
International Federation of Clinical Chemistry (IFCC), Committee on standards: Approved recommendation (1978) on quality control in clinical chemistry, part 2. Assessment of analytical methods for routine use. J Clin Chem Biochem 18:78–88 (1980)
Kaplan AP, Horáková Z, Katz SI (1978) Assessment of tissue fluid histamine levels in patients with urticaria. J Allergy Clin Immunol 61:350–354
Kazimierczak W, Diamant B (1978) Mechanisms of histamine release in anaphylactic and anaphylactoid reactions. Progr Allergy 24:295–365
Kuhn TS (1970) The structure of scientific revolutions. International encyclopedia unified science, vol 2, no 2. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago London, pp 1–209
Lecomte J (1956) Endogenous histamine liberation in man. In: Wolstenholme GWW, O'Connor CM (eds) Ciba foundation symposium on histamine. Churchill, London, pp 173–174
Levey St, Jennings ER (1950) The use of control charts in the clinical laboratory. Am J Clin Pathol 20:1059–1066
Levi R, Zavecz JH, Lee Chi-Ho, Allan G (1979) Histamine-drug-disease interactions and cardiac function. In: Yellin TD (ed) Histamine receptors. Spectrum Publ, New York, pp 99–113
Levi R, Allan G (1980) Histamine-mediated cardiac effects. In: Bristow M (Ed) Drug-induced heart disease. Elsevier-North Holland, Amsterdam, pp 377–395
Lorenz W, Benesch L, Barth H, Matejka E, Meyer R, Kusche J, Hutzel M, Werle E (1970) Fluorometric assay of histamine in tissues and body fluids: Choice of the purification procedure and identification in the nanogram range. Z Anal Chem 259:94–98
Lorenz W, Reimann H-J, Barth H, Kusche J, Meyer R, Doenicke A, Hutzel M (1972a) A sensitive and specific method for the determination of histamine in human whole blood and plasma. Hoppe-Seyler's Z Physiol Chem 353:911–920
Lorenz W, Doenicke A, Meyer R, Reimann H-J, Kusche J, Barth H, Gessing H, Hutzel M, Weissenbacher B (1972b) Histamine release in man by propanidid and thiopentone: Pharmacological effects and clinical consequences. Br J Anaesthesia 44:355–369
Lorenz W, Seidel W, Doenicke A, Tauber R, Reimann H-J, Uhlig R, Mann G, Dormann P, Schmal A, Häfner G, Hamelmann H (1974a) Elevated plasma histamine concentrations in surgery: Causes and clinical significance. Klin Wochenschr 52:419–425
Lorenz W, Thermann M, Messmer K, Schmal A, Dormann P, Kusche J, Barth H, Tauber R, Hutzel M, Mann G, Uhlig R (1974b) Evaluation of histamine elimination curves in plasma and whole blood of several circulatory regions: A method for studying kinetics of histamine release in the whole animal. Agents Actions 4:336–356
Lorenz W, Barth H, Karges HE, Schmal A, Dormann P, Niemeyer I (1974c) Problems in the assay of histamine release by gelatin: o-phthaldialdehyde-induced fluorescence, inhibition of histamine methyltransferase and H1-receptor antagonism by Haemaccel. Agents Actions 4:324–335
Lorenz W, Barth H, Thermann M, Schmal A, Dormann P, Niemeyer I (1974d) Fluorometric histamine determination in canine plasma under normal conditions, following application of exogenous histamine and during histamine release by Haemaccel. Hoppe-Seyler's Z Physiol Chem 355:1097–1111
Lorenz W (1975) Histamine release in man. Agents Actions 5:402–416
Lorenz W, Doenicke A, Messmer K. Reimann H-J, Thermann M, Lahn W, Berr J, Schmal A, Dormann P, Regenfuss P, Hamelmann H (1976) Histamine release in human subjects by modified gelatin (Haemaccel) and dextran: An explanation for anaphylactoid reactions observed unter clinical conditions? Br J Anaesthesia 48:151–165
Lorenz W, Doenicke A, Dittmann I, Hug P, Schwarz B (1977) Anaphylaktoide Reaktionen nach Application von Blutersatzmitteln beim Menschen: Verhinderung dieser Nebenwirkung von Haemaccel druch Prämedikation mit H1- und H2-Rezeptorantagonisten. Anaesthesist 26:644–648
Lorenz W, Doenicke A (1978a) Anaphylactoid reactions and histamine release by intravenous drugs used in surgery and anaesthesia. In: Watkins J, Ward AM (eds) Adverse response to intravenous drugs. Academic Press, London; Grune and Stratton, New York, pp 83–112
Lorenz W, Doenicke A (1978b) Histamine release in clinical conditions. Mount Sinai J Med 45:357–386
Lorenz W, Doenicke A, Schöning B, Mamorksi I, Weber D, Hinterlang E, Schwarz B, Neugebauer E (1980) H1+H2-receptor antagonists for premedication in anaesthesia and surgery: A critical view basing on randomized clinical trials with Haemaccel and various antiallergic drugs. Agents Actions 10:114–124
Lorenz W, Doenicke A, Schöning B, Neugebauer E (1981a) The role of histamine in adverse reactions to intravenous agents. In: Thornton JA (ed) Adverse reactions of anaesthetic drugs. Elsevier/North-Holland, Amsterdam, pp 169–238
Lorenz W, Doenicke A, Schöning B, Karges H, Schmal A (1981b) Incidence and mechanisms of adverse reactions to polypeptides in man and dog. In: Hennessen W (ed) Standardization of albumin, plasma substitutes and plasma-pheresis. International Symposium WHO/IABS. Development of biological standard, vol 48. Karger, Basel, pp 207–304
Lorenz W, Ohmann Ch, Immich H, Schreiber RL, Scheibe O, Herfarth Ch, Feifel G, Beger H (1982a) Bericht über die zweite Arbeitstagung der Chirurgischen Arbeitsgemeinschaft für klinische Studien der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Chirurgie. Chirurg (in press)
Lorenz W, Schmal A, Schult H, Lang S, Weber D, Lüben L, Kapp B (1982b) Histamine release in dogs by wetting agents: Analysis of various components in cremophor El and development of a compound with reduced toxicity. Agents Actions 12:64–80
Lusted LB (1968) Introduction to medical decision making. CH. C. Thomas, Springfield, IL, pp 1–279
Messmer K, Lorenz W, Sunder-Plassmann L, Klövekorn W, Hutzel M (1970) Histamine release as cause of acute hypotension following rapid colloid infusion. Naunyn-Schmiedebergs Arch Pharmakol 267:433–445
Moss J, Rosow CD, Savarese JJ, Philbin DM, Kniffen KF (1981) Role of histamine in the hypotensive action of d-tubo-curarine in humans. Anesthesiology 55:19–25
O'Duffy G, Chahl LA (1970) The influence of laboratory anaesthetics on the increased cutaneous vascular permeability responses to histamine and 5-hydroxytryptamine in rats. J Pharmacol Methods 4:231–235
Paton WDM (1958) Release of histamine. Progr Allergy 5:79–148
Parkin JV, Lorenz W, Barth H, Rohde H, Ohmann Ch, Thon K, Weber, D, Crombach M (1982) Assay and identification of histamine in human gastric aspirate by a fluorometric-fluoroenzymatic technique. Its application in patients with chronic duodenal ulcer. Agents Actions 12:17–25
Pavek K (1977) Anaphylactic shock in the monkey: its hemodynamics and mediators. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 21:293–307
Pavek K, Piper PJ, Smedegard G (1977) Anaphylatoxin-induced shock and two patterns of anaphylactic shock: hemodynamics and mediators. Acta Physiol Scand. 105:393–403
Philbin DM, Moss J, Akins CW, Rosow CE, Kono K, Schneider RC, Ver Lee ThR, Savarese JJ (1981) The use of H1 and H2-histamine antagonists with morphine anesthesia: a double-blind study. Anesthesiology 55:292–296
Ring J, Messmer K (1977) Incidence and severity of anaphylactoid reactions to colloid volume substitutes. Lancet 1:466–469
Rothschild AM (1966) Histamine release by basic compounds. In: Rocha e Silva M, Rothschild HA (eds) Histamine and antihistaminics. Handbook of experimental pharmacology, vol 18/1. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg New York, pp 386–430
Schöning B, Koch H (1975) Pathergiequote verschiedener Plasmasubstitute an Haut und Respirationstrakt orthopädischer Patienten. Anaesthesist 24:507–516
Schöning B, Lorenz W (1981a) Prevention of allergoid (cutaneous anaphylactoid) reactions to polygeline (Haemaccel) in orthopaedic patients by premedication with H1-and H2-receptor antagonists. In: Hennessen W (ed) Standardization of albumin, plasma substitutes and plasma-pheresis. International Symposium WHO/IABS, Development of biological standard, vol 48. Karger, Basel, pp 241–249
Schöning B, Lorenz W (1981b) Anaphylaktoide Reaktionen. Klinikarzt 10:621–633
Schöning B, Lorenz W, Doenicke A (1982) Prophylaxis of anaphylactoid reactions to a polypeptidal plasma substitute by H1- and H2-receptor antagonists: Synopsis of three randomized controlled trials. Klin Wochenschr 60:1048–1055
Seidel G, Groppe G, Meyer-Burgdorff C (1974) Contrast media as histamine liberators in man. Agents Actions 4:143–150
Serafini W (1976) L'histamine dans l'allergie humaine. In: Roche e Silva M, Rothschild HA (eds) Histamine and antihistaminics, vol 18/1. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg New York, pp 899–917
Smedegård G, Revenäs, B. Lundberg C, Arfors K-E (1981) Anaphylactic shock in monkeys passively sensitized with human reaginic serum. I. Hemodynamics and cardiac performance. Acta Physiol Scand 111:239–247
Smith PHL, Kagey-Sobotka A, Bleecker ER, Traystman R, Kaplan AP, Gralnick H, Valentine MD, Permutt S, Lichtenstein LM (1980) Physiological manifestations of human anaphylaxis. J Clin Invest 66:1072–1080
Stevenson DD, Arroyave CM, Bhat KN, Tan EM (1976) Oral aspirin challenges in asthmatic patients: a study of plasma histamine. Clin Allergy 6:493–505
Strackham K (1977) Vergleichende Untersuchung über die Volumenwirkung einer Zweidrittel-Elektrolytlösung sowie einer 4%igen Dextranlösung in der Phase der Narkoseeinleitung. Infusionstherapie 4:129–132
Uvnäs B (1981) Comment in the Symposium on Histamine and Antihistaminics, Munich
Watkins J, Clarke RSJ (1978) Report of a symposium: adverse responses to intravenous agents. Br J Anaesthesiol 50:1159–1164
Watkins J (1979) Anaphylactoid reactions to i.v. substances. Br J Anaesthesia 51:51–60
Watkins J (1981) Mechanisms and factors predisposing towards adverse response to intravenous anaesthetic substances. In: Thornton JA (ed) Adverse reactions to anaesthetic drugs. Excerpta Medica/Elsevier North-Holland, Amsterdam, pp 137–167
Weber E (1980) Schäden nach Langzeitbehandlung. In: Schnieders B, Grosdanoff P (eds) Zur Problematik von chronischen Toxizitätsprüfungen. Reimer, pp 217–222
Weinstein MC, Fineberg HV, Elstein AS, Frazier HS, Neuhauser D, Neutra RR, McNeil BJ (1980) Clinical decision analysis. Saunders, Philadelphia, pp 1–351
Weiss S, Robb GP, Ellis LB (1932) The systemic effects of histamine in man. With special reference to the responses of the cardiovascular system. Arch Intern Med 49:360–396
Wolstenholme GWW, O'Connor CM (1956) Ciba foundation Symposion on Histamine. Churchill, London, pp 1–472
Wulff HR (1976) Rational diagnosis and treatment. Blackwell, Oxford, pp 1–182
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
Dedicated to Professor Otto Lindenschmidt
Supported by grant of Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (Lo 199/10 and Lo 199/13-6)
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Lorenz, W., Doenicke, A., Schöning, B. et al. Definition and classification of the histamine-release response to drugs in anaesthesia and surgery: Studies in the conscious human subject. Klin Wochenschr 60, 896–913 (1982). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01716946
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01716946