Abstract
The objective of this study was to demonstrate that appropriate targeting and quality monitoring of institutional care of the elderly is possible using person-based information on residents of nursing homes. This cross-sectional study used Minimum Data Set (MDS) assessments of nursing home residents in 6 US states, Copenhagen, Reykjavik, and selected locations in Italy and Japan. The outcome measures were life expectancy at age 65, population over 65, percentage over 65’s in nursing homes, and clinical characteristics of nursing home residents from a multinational database ofRAi/MDS assessments. We found that Japan has the highest life expectancy, and the second lowest expenditure on health care. The United States has the highest expenditure on health care and intermediate life expectancy. Italy has the highest proportion of population over 65 and the lowest proportion of over 65’s in nursing homes. Iceland, a relatively young country, has the highest proportion of over 65’s in nursing homes. Residents in Italy and the United States had the most severe physical, cognitive and clinical characteristics, those in Iceland the least. There was wide variation in markers of quality of care, with no country either uniformly good or bad across multiple measures. In conclusion, headline statistics comparing nations’ percentage of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) spent on health care, age structure of the population, percentage of over 65’s in nursing homes and clinical characteristics bear no consistent relationship. Local policy and practice also affect quality of care. Standardized assessment enables comparisons at local, national and international levels making passible further research on targeting and the appropriate use of institutional care, thus permitting a range of efficiency measures to be developed to inform policy.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Kane R.L., Kane R.A., Finch M., Harrington C, Newcomer R., Miller N., Hulbert M.: S/HMO’s, The Second Generation: Building on the experience of the first Social Health Maintenance Organisation Demonstrations. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 45: 101–107, 1997.
Department of Health of the UK.: NHS responsibilities for meeting continuing health care needs, HSG(95) 8. Department of Health, London, 1995.
Institute of Medicine of the USA: Improving quality of care in nursing homes. National Academy Press, Washington DC, 1986.
Morris J.N., Hawes C., Fries B.E., Phillips C.D., Mor V., Katz S., Murphy K., Drugovich M.L., Friedlob A.S.: Designing the National Resident Assessment Instrument. Gerontologist 30: 293–307, 1990.
Hawes C, Morris J.N., Phillips C.D., Mor V., Fries B.E., Nonemaker S.: Reliability estimates for the Minimum Data Set for Nursing Home Resident Assessment and Care Screening (MDS). Gerontologist 35: 172–178, 1995.
Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD): Health Data. Electronic Editions Catalogue. OECD, Paris, 1996.
Sgadari A., Morris J.N., Fries B.E., Ljunngren G., Jonsson P.V., Du-Pasquier J-N., Schroll M.: Efforts to establish the reliability of the RAI. Age Ageing 26-S2: 27–30, 1997.
Fries B.E., Schneider D.P., Foley W.J., Gavazzi M., Burke R., Cornelius E.: Refining a case-mix measure for nursing homes: Resource Utilisation Groups (RUG-III). Med. Care 32: 668–685, 1994.
Morris J.N., Fries B.E., Mehr D.R., Hawes C., Phillips C.D., Mor V., Lipsitz L.A.: The MDS Cognitive Performance Scale. J. Gerontol. 49: 174–182, 1994.
Mor V., Branco K., Fleishman J., Hawes C, Phillips C, Morris J., Fries B.E.: The structure of social engagement among nursing home residents. J. Gerontol. 50: P1–P8, 1995.
Harrington C, Curtis M.: State variations and trends in preadmission screening programs. J. Appi Gerontol. 15: 414–432, 1996.
Caring for People: Community Care in the Next Decade and Beyond. HMSO, London, 1989.
Department of Health: Implementing Community Care: population needs assessment good practice guidance. HMSO, London, 1993.
Challis D.J., Carpenter G.I., Traske K.J.: Assessment in continuing care homes: Towards a national standard instrument. Joseph Rowntree Foundation/Personal Social Services Research Unit, Canterbury, 1996.
Challis D.J., Davies B.: Case Management in Community Care. Gower, Aldershot, 1986.
Davies B.: Care Management, Equity and Efficiency: The international experience. PSSRU, University of Kent, Canterbury, 1992.
Morris J.N., Fries B.E., Steel K., Ikegami N., Bemabei R., Carpenter G.I., Gilgen R., Hirdes J.P., Topinkova E.: Comprehensive clinical assessment in community setting - Applicability of the MDS-HC. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 45: 1017–1024, 1997.
Hirdes J.P., Satz CA., Kozak J., Lepp V.: Identifying an appropriate case mix measure for chronic care: Evidence from an Ontario pilot study. Health Care Management Forum 9: 40–46, 1996.
Carpenter G.I., Ikegami N., Ljunngren G., Carrillo E., Fries B.E.: RUG-III and Resource Allocation: comparing the relationship of direct care time with patient characteristics in five countries. Age Ageing 26-S2: 61–65, 1997.
Phillips C, Zimmerman D., Bernabei R., Jonsson P.: Using the Resident Assessment Instrument for quality enhancement in nursing homes. Age Ageing 26-S2: 77–81, 1997.
Leicester M.C., Pollock A.M.: Community care in South Thames (West) Region: is needs assessment working? Public Health 110: 109–113, 1996.
Kane R.A.: Improving the Quality of Long-term Care. JAMA 273: 1376–1380, 1995.
Kane R.A.: Establishing an empirical basis for long-term care. Gerontologist 34: 581–582, 1994.
Fries B.E., Ikegami N.: Heading in the right direction. Gerontologist 34: 582–583, 1994.
Carpenter G.I., Calnan M.: Grey Matters. Health Service Journal Jan. 9: 22–23, 1997.
Hirdes J.P., Carpenter G.I.: Health outcomes among the frail elderly in communities and institutions: Use of the Minimum Data Set (MDS) to create effective linkages between research and policy. Canadian Journal on Aging/Canadian Public Policy 16: 53–69, 1997.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Carpenter, G.I., Hirdes, J.P., Ribbe, M.W. et al. Targeting and quality of nursing home care. A five-nation study. Aging Clin Exp Res 11, 83–89 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03399645
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03399645