Abstract
As additive manufacturing (AM) process evolves from rapid prototyping to the end-of-use product manufacturing process, manufacturing constraints have largely been alleviated and design freedom has been significantly broadened, including shape complexity, material complexity, hierarchical complexity, and functional complexity. Inevitably, conventional Design Theory and Methodology (DTM) especially life-cycle objectives oriented ones are challenged. In this paper, firstly, the impact of AM on conventional DTM is analyzed in terms of design for manufacturing (DFM), design for assembly (DFA), and design for performance (DFP). Abundance of evidences indicate that conventional DTM is not qualified to embrace these new opportunities and consequently underline the need for a set of design principles for AM to achieve a better design. Secondly, design methods related with AM are reviewed and classified into three main groups, including design guidelines, modified DTM for AM, and design for additive manufacturing (DFAM). The principles and representative design methods in each category are studied comprehensively with respect to benefits and drawbacks. A new design method partially overcoming these drawbacks by integrating function integration and structure optimization to realize less part count and better performance is discussed. Design tools as a necessary part for supporting design are also studied. In the meantime, the review also identified the possible areas for future research.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Reuleaux F (1861) Konstrukteur. Vieweg und Sohn, Braunschweig
Reuleaux F (1875) Theorische kinematic. Vieweg und Sohn, Braunschweig
Tomiyama T, Gu P, Jin Y, Lutters D, Kind C, Kimura F (2009) Design methodologies: industrial and educational applications. CIRP Anna Manuf Technol 58(2):543–565
Watts D, Hague R (2006) Exploiting the design freedom of RM. In: Proceeding of the solid freeform fabrication Symp., Austin, TX, August 14-16, Cambridge University Press, pp 656-667
Hague R, Mansour S, Saleh N (2003) Design opportunities with rapid manufacturing. Assem Autom 23(4):346–356
Standard A F2792. (2012) Standard terminology for additive manufacturing technologies. ASTM F2792-10e1
Hopkinson N, Dickens P (2006) Emerging rapid manufacturing processes. In: Rapid manufacturing—an industrial revolution for the digital age. John Wiley, Chichester. pp 55-80
Prakash WN, Sridhar VG, Annamalai K (2014) New product development by DFMA and rapid prototyping. ARPN J Eng Appl Sci 9(3):274–279
Hopkinson N, Gao Y, McAfee DJ (2006) Design for environment analyses applied to rapid manufacturing. Proc Inst Mech Eng D J Automob Eng 220(D10):1363–1372. doi:10.1243/09544070jauto309
Campbell RI, Hague RJ, Sener B, Wormald PW (2003) The potential for the bespoke industrial designer. Des J 6(3):24–34
Masters M, Mathy M (2002) Direct manufacturing of custom-made hearing instruments, an implementation of digital mechanical processing. Paper presented at the SME Rapid Prototyping Conference and Exhibition, Cincinnati, OH, USA, April
Bourell DL, Leu MC, Rosen DW (2009) Roadmap for additive manufacturing: identifying the future of freeform processing. The University of Texas, Austin
Loughborough U Rapid Manufacturing Research Group. http://www.lboro.ac.uk/departments/mm/research/rapid-manufacturing/index.html. Accessed 28 September 2014
Gibson I, Rosen DW, Stucker B (2010) Additive Manufacturing technologies: rapid prototyping to direct digital manufacturing. Springer, US
Thomas D (2010) The development of design rules for selective laser melting. Dissertation, University of Wales, UK
Regenfuss P, Ebert R, Exner H (2007) Laser micro sintering—a versatile instrument for the generation of microparts. Laser Tech J 4(1):26–31
Wohlers TT (2010) Wohlers Report 2010: additive manufacturing state of the inudstry: annual worldwide progress report. Wohlers Associates
Tomiyama T A classification of design theories and methodologies. In: ASME 2006 International Design Engineering Technical Conferences and Computers and Information in Engineering Conference, 2006. American Society of Mechanical Engineers, pp 43-51
Reich Y (1995) A critical review of general design theory. Res Eng Des 7(1):1–18
Suh NP (1990) The principles of design. Oxford University Press, New York
Pahl G, Beitz W, Feldhusen J, Grote K-H (2007) Engineering design: a systematic approach, vol 157. Springer, US
Gu P, Hashemian M, Nee A (2004) Adaptable design. CIRP Ann Manuf Technol 53(2):539–557
Weber C CPM/PDD–an extended theoretical approach to modelling products and product development processes. In: Proceedings of the 2nd German-Israeli Symposium on Advances in Methods and Systems for Development of Products and Processes, 2005. pp 159-179
Albers A, Matthiesen S, Ohmer M (2003) An innovative new basic model in design methodology for analysis and synthesis of technical systems. In: DS 31: Proceedings of ICED 03, the 14th International Conference on Engineering Design, Stockholm
Bralia J (1986) Handbook of product design for manufacturing: a practical guide to low-cost production. McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1986:1120
Boothroyd G, Dewhurst P, Knight WA, Press C (2002) Product design for manufacture and assembly. M. Dekker, New York
Hague R, Mansour S, Saleh N (2004) Material and design considerations for rapid manufacturing. Int J Prod Res 42(22):4691–4708
Hague R, Campbell I, Dickens P (2003) Implications on design of rapid manufacturing. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part C. J Mech Eng Sci 217(C1):25–30
Hague R (2006) Unlocking the design potential of rapid manufacturing. In: Hopkinson N, Hague R, Dickens P (eds) Rapid manufacturing: an industrial revolution for the digital age. Wiley, USA
Perez KB, Williams CB Combining additive manufacturing and direct write for integrated electronics—a review. In: 24th International Solid Freeform Fabrication Symposium—An Additive Manufacturing Conference, SFF 2013, August 12, 2013 - August 14, 2013, Austin, TX, United states, 2013. 24th International SFF Symposium—An Additive Manufacturing Conference, SFF 2013. University of Texas at Austin (freeform), pp 962–979
Lopes AJ, MacDonald E, Wicker RB (2012) Integrating stereolithography and direct print technologies for 3D structural electronics fabrication. Rapid Prototyp J 18(2):129–143
Palmer J, Jokiel B, Nordquist C, Kast B, Atwood C, Grant E, Livingston F, Medina F, Wicker R (2006) Mesoscale RF relay enabled by integrated rapid manufacturing. Rapid Prototyp J 12(3):148–155
Kerbrat O, Mognol P, Hascoët JY (2011) A new DFM approach to combine machining and additive manufacturing. Comput Ind 62(7):684–692
Rosen DW (2007) Computer-aided design for additive manufacturing of cellular structures. Comput-Aided Des Applic 4(5):585–594
Choi J-W, Yamashita M, Sakakibara J, Kaji Y, Oshika T, Wicker RB (2010) Combined micro and macro additive manufacturing of a swirling flow coaxial phacoemulsifier sleeve with internal micro-vanes. Biomed Microdevices 12(5):875–886
Mudge RP, Wald NR (2007) Laser engineered net shaping advances additive manufacturing and repair. Weld J 86(1):44
Andreasen MM, Kähler S, Lund T (1983) Design for assembly. Ifs Publications, London
Mavroidis C, DeLaurentis KJ, Won J, Alam M (2001) Fabrication of non-assembly mechanisms and robotic systems using rapid prototyping. J Mech Des 123(4):516–524
Chen YH, Chen ZZ (2011) Joint analysis in rapid fabrication of non-assembly mechanisms. Rapid Prototyp J 17(6):408–417. doi:10.1108/13552541111184134
Agarwala M, Bourell D, Beaman J, Marcus H, Barlow J (1995) Direct selective laser sintering of metals. Rapid Prototyp J 1(1):26–36
Siu YK, Tan ST (2002) Modeling the material grading and structures of heterogeneous objects for layered manufacturing. Comp-Aided Des 34(10):705–716
Tolochko N, Mozzharov S, Laoui T, Froyen L (2003) Selective laser sintering of single- and two-component metal powders. Rapid Prototyp J 9(2):68–78
Chiu W, Yu K (2008) Direct digital manufacturing of three-dimensional functionally graded material objects. Comp-Aided Des 40(12):1080–1093
Oxman N, Keating S, Tsai E Functionally graded rapid prototyping. In: 5th International conference on advanced research in virtual and physical prototyping, VR@P 2011, September 28, 2011 - October 1, 2011, Leiria, Portugal, 2012. Innovative developments in virtual and physical prototyping - Proceedings of the 5th International Conference on Advanced Research and Rapid Prototyping. Taylor and Francis Inc., pp 483-489
Oxman N (2007) Get real towards performance-driven computational geometry. Int J Archit Comput 5(4):663–684
Oxman N (2010) Material-based design computation. Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Oxman N (2010) Structuring materiality: design fabrication of heterogeneous materials. Archit Des 80(4):78–85
Oxman N (2011) Variable property rapid prototyping: inspired by nature, where form is characterized by heterogeneous compositions, the paper presents a novel approach to layered manufacturing entitled variable property rapid prototyping. Virtual Phys Prototyp 6(1):3–31
Franky (2011) 3D printing in the world’s greatest museum of art and design i.materialise. http://i.materialise.com/blog/entry/3d-printing-in-the-worlds-greatest-museum-of-art-and-design. Accessed October 29 2014
Ponche R, Hascoet JY, Kerbrat O, Mognol P (2012) A new global approach to design for additive manufacturing. Virtual Phys Prototyp 7(2):93–105
DMRC (2012) Direct Manufacturing Research Center Annual Report. https://mb.uni-paderborn.de/fileadmin/dmrc/Research/Publications/dmrc_report_2012.pdf. Accessed 28 September 2014
Ponche R, Kerbrat O, Mognol P, Hascoet JY (2014) A novel methodology of design for Additive manufacturing applied to additive laser manufacturing process. Robot Comput Integr Manuf 30(4):389–398. doi:10.1016/j.rcim.2013.12.001
Becker R, Grzesiak A, Henning A (2005) Rethink assembly design. Assem Autom 25(4):262–266
Atzeni E, Iuliano L, Minetola P, Salmi A (2010) Redesign and cost estimation of rapid manufactured plastic parts. Rapid Prototyp J 16(5):308–317
Adam GAO, Zimmer D (2014) Design for additive manufacturing—element transitions and aggregated structures. CIRP Journal of Manufacturing Science and Technology 7 (1):20-28. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cirpj.2013.10.001
Popsecu D (2007) Design for rapid prototyping: implementation of design rules regarding the form and dimensional accuracy of RP prototypes. Annals of Daaam for 2007 & Proceedings of the 18th International Daaam symposium: intelligent manufacturing & automation: focus on creativity, responsibility, and ethics of engineers
Kruf W, van de Vorst B, Maalderink H, Kamperman N Design for rapid manufacturing functional SLS parts. In: Intelligent Production Machines and Systems-2nd I* PROMS Virtual International Conference 3-14 July 2011. Elsevier, p 389
Kim GD, Oh YT (2008) A benchmark study on rapid prototyping processes and machines: quantitative comparisons of mechanical properties, accuracy, roughness, speed, and material cost. 222 (B2):201-215. doi:10.1243/09544054JEM724
Mahesh M, Wong Y, Fuh J, Loh H (2004) Benchmarking for comparative evaluation of RP systems and processes. Rapid Prototyp J 10(2):123–135
Shellabear M (1999) Benchmark study of accuracy and surface quality in RP models. Brite/EuRam Report BE-2051, Task 4 (2)
ASTM (2012) ASTM WK38342 new guide for design for additive manufacturing. ASTM International, West Conshohocken, doi: draft under development
Segonds F (2011) Contribution to the integration of a collaborative design environment in the early stages of design. PhD, Arts et Metiers ParisTech
Boyard N, Rivette M, Christmann O, Richir S (2014) A design methodology for parts using additive manufacturing. High value manufacturing: advanced research in virtual and rapid prototyping. 399-404
Rodrigue H, Rivette M, Calatoru V, Richir S Une méthodologie de conception pour la fabrication additive. In: 2011. Congrès International de Génie Industriel
Andreassen E, Lazarov BS, Sigmund O (2014) Design of manufacturable 3D extremal elastic microstructure. Mech Mater 69(1):1–10
Moodie ALR, Angle JP, Tackett EC, Rupert TJ, Mecartney ML, Valdevit L (2013) Ceramic and hybrid micro-architected materials for high temperature applications. In: Long Beach, CA, . SAMPE 2013 Conference and exhibition: education and green sky - materials technology for a better world. pp 34-43
Lin CY, Wirtz T, LaMarca F, Hollister SJ (2007) Structural and mechanical evaluations of a topology optimized titanium interbody fusion cage fabricated by selective laser melting process. J Biomed Mater Res A 83(2):272–279
Rezaie R, Badrossamay M, Ghaie A, Moosavi H (2013) Topology optimization for fused deposition modeling process. Procedia CIRP 6:521–526
Joo JJ, Reich GW, Westfall JT (2009) Flexible skin development for morphing aircraft applications via topology optimization. J Intell Mat Syst Struct 20(16):1969–1985
Bickel B, Bächer M, Otaduy MA, Lee HR, Pfister H, Gross M, Matusik W (2010) Design and fabrication of materials with desired deformation behavior. In: ACM Transactions on Graphics (TOG), . vol 4. ACM, p 63
Evans A, Hutchinson J, Fleck N, Ashby M, Wadley H (2001) The topological design of multifunctional cellular metals. Prog Mater Sci 46(3):309–327
Ma Z-D, Wang H, Kikuchi N, Pierre C, Raju B (2006) Experimental validation and prototyping of optimum designs obtained from topology optimization. Struct Multidiscip Optim 31(5):333–343
Zhou M, Xi J, Yan J (2004) Modeling and processing of functionally graded materials for rapid prototyping. J Mater Process Technol 146(3):396–402
Blouin VY, Oschwald M, Hu Y, Fadel GM (2005) Design of functionally graded structures for enhanced thermal behavior. In: ASME 2005 International Design Engineering Technical Conferences and Computers and Information in Engineering Conference. Am Soc Mech Eng pp 835-843
Rännar L-E, Glad A, Gustafson C-G (2007) Efficient cooling with tool inserts manufactured by electron beam melting. Rapid Prototyp J 13(3):128–135
Chen Y, Zhou S, Li Q (2011) Microstructure design of biodegradable scaffold and its effect on tissue regeneration. Biomaterials 32(22):5003–5014
Castilho M, Dias M, Gbureck U, Groll J, Fernandes P, Pires I, Gouveia B, Rodrigues J, Vorndran E (2013) Fabrication of computationally designed scaffolds by low temperature 3D printing. Biofabrication 5(3):035012
Faur C, Crainic N, Sticlaru C, Oancea C (2013) Rapid prototyping technique in the preoperative planning for total hip arthroplasty with custom femoral components. Wien Klin Wochenschr 125(5–6):144–149
Bendsøe MP, Ben-Tal A, Zowe J (1994) Optimization methods for truss geometry and topology design. Struct Optim 7(3):141–159
Dorn WS, Gomory RE, Greenberg HJ (1964) Automatic design of optimal structures. J Mecanique 3(1):25–52
Bendsøe MP, Kikuchi N (1988) Generating optimal topologies in structural design using a homogenization method. Comput Methods Appl Mech Eng 71(2):197–224
Rozvany G, Zhou M, Birker T (1992) Generalized shape optimization without homogenization. Struct Optim 4(3–4):250–252
Allaire G, Jouve F, Toader A-M (2002) A level-set method for shape optimization. C R Math 334(12):1125–1130
Wang MY, Wang X, Guo D (2003) A level set method for structural topology optimization. Comput Methods Appl Mech Eng 192(1–2):227–246. doi:10.1016/S0045-7825(02)00559-5
Xie Y, Steven GP (1993) A simple evolutionary procedure for structural optimization. Comput Struct 49(5):885–896
Young V, Querin O, Steven G, Xie Y (1999) 3D and multiple load case bi-directional evolutionary structural optimization (BESO). Struct Optim 18(2–3):183–192
Wang SY, Tai K (2005) Structural topology design optimization using genetic algorithms with a bit-array representation. Comput Methods Appl Mech Eng 194(36–38):3749–3770. doi:10.1016/j.cma.2004.09.003
Chen Z, Gao L, Qiu H, Shao X (2009) Combining genetic algorithms with optimality criteria method for topology optimization. In: Bio-Inspired Computing. BIC-TA'09. Fourth International Conference on, 2009. IEEE, pp 1-6
Wang H, Rosen DW Parametric modeling method for truss structures. In: ASME 2002 International Design Engineering Technical Conferences and Computers and Information in Engineering Conference, 2002. Am Soc Mech Eng, pp 759-767
Costa L, Vilar R, Reti T, Deus A (2005) Rapid tooling by laser powder deposition: process simulation using finite element analysis. Acta Mater 53(14):3987–3999
Alimardani M, Toyserkani E, Huissoon JP (2007) A 3D dynamic numerical approach for temperature and thermal stress distributions in multilayer laser solid freeform fabrication process. Opt Lasers Eng 45(12):1115–1130
Ancău M, Caizar C (2010) The computation of Pareto-optimal set in multicriterial optimization of rapid prototyping processes. Comput Ind Eng 58(4):696–708
Ponche R (2013) Méthodologie de conception pour la fabrication additive, application à la projection de poudres. Ecole centrale de nantes-ECN
Vayre B, Vignat F, Villeneuve F (2012) Designing for additive manufacturing. Procedia CIRP 3(0):632–637. doi:10.1016/j.procir.2012.07.108
Vayre B, Vignat F, Villeneuve F (2013) Identification on some design key parameters for additive manufacturing: application on electron beam melting. Forty Sixth Cirp Conference on Manufacturing Systems 2013 7:264-269. doi:10.1016/j.procir.2013.05.045
Rosen DW (2007) Design for additive manufacturing: a method to explore unexplored regions of the design space. In: Eighteenth Annual Solid Freeform Fabrication Symposium. pp 402-415
Y. Tang, Hascoet JV, Zhao YF (2014) Integration of topological and functional optimization in design for additive manufacturing. Paper presented at the ASME 2014 12th Biennial Conference on Engineering Systems Copenhagen, Denmark
Bin Maidin S (2011) Development of a design feature database to support design for additive manufacturing (DfAM). Dissertation, Loughborough University, UK
3DSYSTEMS (2015) Geomagic Design X. http://www.rapidform.com/products/xor/overview/. Accessed Feb. 18 2015
ISTI-CNR (2015) Meshlab. http://meshlab.sourceforge.net/. Accessed Feb. 18 2015
Beaman JJ, Atwood C, Bergman TL, Bourell D, Hollister S, D R (2004) Assessment of European Research and Development in Additive/Subtractive Manufacturing. National Science Foundation (NSF)
ISO (2013) Standard specification for additive manufacturing file format (AMF) Version 1.1. http://www.iso.org/iso/catalogue_detail.htm?csnumber=61944. Accessed Feb. 20 2015
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Yang, S., Zhao, Y.F. Additive manufacturing-enabled design theory and methodology: a critical review. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 80, 327–342 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-015-6994-5
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-015-6994-5