Abstract
A number of studies have appeared in the area of cross-country consumption comparisons, where a common system of demand equations is used to model the consumption patterns of all countries. Under this approach, tastes are taken to be the same internationally. Such an assumption of identical tastes was forcibly advocated by the dual Nobel laureates, Stigler and Becker, who argued that tastes neither change capriciously nor differ importantly between people. In this paper, we use the system-wide approach to demand analysis to analyse the alcohol consumption patterns of drinkers from 10 high-income industrialised countries and verify Stigler and Becker’s (Rev Econ Statist 59:113–118, 1977) hypothesis by testing whether pooling the data across countries is acceptable. We also present the implied demand elasticities for beer, wine and spirits for the 10 countries and discuss the use of these elasticities in policy-related applications.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Babor T, Caetano R, Casswell S, Edwards G, Giesbrecht N, Graham K, Grube J, Gruenewald P, Hill L, Holder H, Homel R, Osterberg E, Rehm J, Robin R, Rossow I (2003) Alcohol: no ordinary commodity—research and public policy. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Baker P, McKay S (1990) The structure of alcohol taxes: a hangover from the past?. The Institute for Fiscal Studies, London
Brewers Association of Canada (1997) Alcoholic beverage taxation and control policies: international survey, Ninth edn. Ottawa
Chang H, Griffith G, Bettington N (2002) The demand for wine in australia using a systems approach: industry implications, Paper 9. Agribus Rev 10:1–12
Chen DL (1999) World consumption economics. World Scientific, New Jersey
Clements KW, Johnson LW (1983) The demand for beer, wine and spirits: a system-wide approach. J Bus 56:273–304
Clements KW, Selvanathan EA (1987) Alcohol Consumption. In: Theil H, Clements KW (eds) Applied demand analysis: results from system-wide approaches. Ballinger, Cambridge, pp 185–264
Clements KW, Selvanathan S (1991) The economic determinants of alcohol consumption. Aust J Agric Econ 35:209–231
Clements KW, Yang W, Zheng SW (1997) Is utility additive? The case of alcohol. Appl Econ 29:1163–1167
Comanor WS, Wilson TA (1974) Advertising and market power. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Cook PJ, Moore MJ (2000) “Alcohol”. In: Culyer AJ, Newhouse JP (eds) Handbook of health economics, Vol. 1, Chapter 30
Duffy M (1987) Advertising and the inter-product distribution of demand: a rotterdam model approach. Euro Econ Rev 31:1051–1070
Duffy MH (1991) Advertising and the consumption of tobacco and alcoholic drink: a system-wide analysis. Scott J Politi Econ 38:369–385
Duffy M (2001) Advertising in consumer allocation models: choice of functional forms. Appl Econ 33:437–456
Duffy M (2003) On the estimation of an advertising augmented, cointegrating demand system. Econ Modell 20(1):181–206
Edwards G et al (1994) Alcohol policy and the public good. Oxford University Press, New York
Houthakker HS (1960) Additive preferences. Econometrica 28:244–257
Johnson JA, Oksanen EH (1974) Socio-economic determinants of the consumption of alcoholic beverages. Appl Econ 6:293–301
Johnson JA, Oksanen EH (1977) Estimation of demand for alcoholic beverages in Canada from pooled time series and cross-section. Rev Econ Statist 59:113–118
Jones AM (1989) A systems approach to the demand for alcohol and tobacco. Bull Econ Res 41:86–101
Kravis IB, Heston AW, Summers R (1978) International comparisons of real product and purchasing power. The John Hopkins University Press, Baltimore
Labys WC (1976) An international comparison of price and income elasticities for wine consumption. Aust J Agric Econ 20:33–36
Laitinen K (1978) Why is demand homogeneity so often rejected?. Econ Lett 1:187–191
Lau H-H (1975) Cost of alcoholic beverages as a determinant of alcohol consumption. In: Gibbins RJ, Israel Y, Kalant H (eds) Research advances in alcohol and drug problems, Vol 22. Wiley, New York, pp 211–245
Malmquist S (1948) A statistical analysis of the demand for liquor in Sweden. University of Uppsala, Uppsala
McGuinness T (1983) The demand for beer, spirits and wine in the UK, 1956–1979. In: Grant M, Plant M, Williams A (eds) Economics and alcohol. Croom Helm, London, pp 238–242
Meisner JF (1979) ’The sad fate of the asymptotic Slutsky symmetry test for large systems. Econ Lett 2:231–233
Nelson JP (1997) Economic and demographic factors in U.S. alcohol demand: a growth-accounting analysis. Empir Econ 22: 83–102
Nelson JP (1999) Broadcast advertising and U.S. demand for alcoholic beverages. South Econ J 65:774–990
Niskanen WA (1962) The demand for alcoholic beverages. Rand Report. Rand Corporation, Santa Monica, p 2583
Nyberg A (1967) Alkololijuomien kulutus ja hinnat (Consumption and Prices of Alcoholic Beverages). The Finnish Foundation for Alcohol Studies, Helsinki
Pearce D (1986) The demand for alcohol in New Zealand, Discussion Paper no. 86.02. Department of Economics, The University of Western Australia
Quek KE (1988) The demand for alcohol in Canada: an econometric study. Discussion Paper No. 88.08. Department of Economics, The University of Western Australia
Saisu MA, Balasubramanyam VN (1997) Income and price elasticities of demand for alcoholic drinks. Appl Econ Lett 4:247–251
Salo M (1990) Alkoholijuomien vähittäskulutuksen analyysi vuosilta 1969–1988. (An analysis of off-premises retail sales of alcoholic beverages, 1969–1988.) Taloudellinen tutkimum ja suunnittelu, Tutkimusseloste no.15. Helsinki
Stone R (1951) The role of measurement in economics. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Selvanathan EA (1988) Alcohol consumption in the UK, 1955–85: a system-wide approach. Appl Econ 20:1071–1086
Selvanathan EA (1989) Advertising and alcohol demand in the UK: further results. Int J Advert 8:181–188
Selvanathan EA (1991) Cross-country alcohol consumption comparisons: an application of the Rotterdam demand system. Appl Econ 23:1613–1622
Selvanathan EA, Clements KW (1995) Recent developments in applied demand analysis. Springer, London
Selvanathan EA, Selvanathan S (2003) International consumption comparisons: OECD vs LDC. World Scientific, New Jersey
Selvanathan S (1987) A Monte Carlo test of preference independence. Econ Lett 25:259–261
Selvanathan S (1993) A system-wide analysis of international consumption patterns. Kluwer, Boston
Stigler G, Becker G (1977) De Gustibus non est: disputandum. Am Econ Rev 67:76–90
Theil H (1975/76) Theory and measurement of consumer demand. Two Volumes. North-Holland, Amsterdam
Theil H, Clements KW (1987) Applied demand analysis: results from system-wide approaches. Ballinger, Cambridge
Theil H, Suhm FE (1981) International consumption comparisons: a system-wide approach. North-Holland, Amsterdam
Walsh BM (1982) The demand for alcohol in the UK: a comment. J Industr Econ 30:439–446
Walsh BM, Walsh D (1970) Economic aspects of alcohol consumption in the Republic of Ireland. Econ Social Rev 12:115–138
Wette HC, Zhang J-F, Berg RJ, Casswell S (1993) The effect of prices on alcohol consumption in New Zealand 1983–1991. Drug Alcohol Rev 12:151–158
Wong AY-T (1988) The demand for alcohol in the UK 1920–1938: an econometric study. Discussion Paper No. 88.13. Department of Economics, The University of Western Australia
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Selvanathan, S., Selvanathan, E.A. Another look at the identical tastes hypothesis on the analysis of cross-country alcohol data. Empirical Economics 32, 185–215 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00181-006-0078-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00181-006-0078-1