A critical assessment of methods for determining organic phosphorus in savanna soils

Abstract

 Two newly introduced extraction techniques for determining total organic P (P₀) were compared with the standard high-temperature ignition method in selected savanna soils of Nigeria. The two extraction techniques were: (1) concentrated H₂SO₄ and dilute base sequential extraction (18 N H₂SO₄ and 0.5 N NaOH) and (2) basic EDTA method (0.25 M NaOH plus 0.05 M Na₂EDTA). The concentrated H₂SO₄ and dilute base method extracted significantly higher total P₀ than the high-temperature ignition method and the basic EDTA extraction. The high-temperature ignition and the basic EDTA extraction gave similar total P₀ values (mean=91 mg kg^–1 for ignition and 90 mg kg^–1 for basic EDTA). The precision of the methods, determined by coefficients of variation (CV, %) associated with each P₀ determination method in the soils, was better for the concentrated H₂SO₄ and dilute base extraction method (CV=13%) than the ignition method (CV=18%) and the basic EDTA method (CV=15%). The high C : P₀ ratios determined for the high-temperature ignition and basic EDTA extraction indicated that the two methods underestimated total P₀ in the soils. The concentrated H₂SO₄ and dilute base sequential extraction appears to be suitable for the rapid determination of P₀ in savanna soils because the method can be simplified to a single-step analysis.