Abstract
In recent years, decision makers, policy analysts, and other actors, have become increasingly aware of sustainability, and begun to combine economic, social and environmental criteria in their efforts to maintain competitiveness, long-term growth and development. In multiple stakeholder settings, the presence of diverse objectives and conflicting criteria often leads to a complex multi-criteria decision problem. The multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) offers an integrated framework to model and study sustainability criteria and related inter-criteria relationships. In this paper, we review some of the most significant literature on environmental sustainability, and categorise it to show how and why MCDA models are widely used and becoming increasingly popular. Our systematic analysis suggests that, there has been significant growth in environmental applications of MCDA in diverse areas, ranging from energy management and policy to land use, recycling management and sustainable tourism. Among the various MCDA methods and techniques, analytical hierarchy process, TOPSIS, and goal programming are the most frequently used approaches. Many authors use a combination of different MCDA techniques to balance various factors important to achieve sustainability related goals. We expect sustainability related criteria to be an essential consideration in most future multi-criteria models.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Some papers were backed by more than one research grant.
We exclude all publications based on multiple continental origins collaborations (N = 400).
References
Afgan, N. H., & Carvalho, M. G. (2002). Multi-criteria assessment of new and renewable energy power plants. Energy, 27(8), 739–755.
An, D., Xi, B., Ren, J., Wang, Y., Jia, X., He, C., et al. (2017). Sustainability assessment of groundwater remediation technologies based on multi-criteria decision making method. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 119, 36–46.
Arlinghaus, R., Mehner, T., & Cowx, I. G. (2002). Reconciling traditional inland fisheries management and sustainability in industrialized countries, with emphasis on Europe. Fish and Fisheries, 3, 261–316.
Bansal, S., Biswas, S., & Singh, S. K. (2017). Fuzzy decision approach for selection of most suitable construction method of Green Buildings. International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment, 6(1), 122–132.
Bottero, M., Comino, E., & Riggio, V. (2011). Application of the analytic hierarchy process and the analytic network process for the assessment of different wastewater treatment systems. Environmental Modelling and Software, 26(10), 1211–1224.
Buchholz, T., Luzadis, V. A., & Volk, T. A. (2009a). Sustainability criteria for bioenergy systems: Results from an expert survey. Journal of Cleaner Production, 17, S86–S98.
Buchholz, T., Rametsteiner, E., Volk, T. A., & Luzadis, V. A. (2009b). Multi criteria analysis for bioenergy systems assessments. Energy Policy, 37(2), 484–495.
Buchholz, T. S., Volk, T. A., & Luzadis, V. A. (2007). A participatory systems approach to modeling social, economic, and ecological components of bioenergy. Energy Policy, 35(12), 6084–6094.
Chai, J., Liu, J. N., & Ngai, E. W. (2013). Application of decision-making techniques in supplier selection: A systematic review of literature. Expert Systems with Applications, 40(10), 3872–3885.
Charnes, A., & Cooper, W. W. (1952). Chance constraints and normal deviates. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 57, 134–148.
Charnes, A., & Cooper, W. W. (1959). Chance-constrained programming. Management Science, 6, 73–80.
Charnes, A., Cooper, W. W., & Rhodes, E. (1978). Measuring the efficiency of decision making units. European Journal of Operational Research, 2, 429–444.
Chhipi-Shrestha, G., Hewage, K., & Sadiq, R. (2017). Fit-for-purpose wastewater treatment: Conceptualization to development of decision support tool (I). Science of the Total Environment, 607–608, 600–612.
Colapinto, C., Jayaraman, R., & Marsiglio, S. (2017). Multi-criteria decision analysis with goal programming in engineering, management and social sciences: A state-of-the art review. Annals of Operations Research, 251, 7–40.
Costi, P., Minciardi, R., Robba, M., Rovatti, M., & Sacile, R. (2004). An environmentally sustainable decision model for urban solid waste management. Waste Management, 24(3), 277–295.
Eichhorn, M., Tafarte, P., & Thrän, D. (2017). Towards energy landscapes—“Pathfinder for sustainable wind power locations”. Energy, 134, 611–621.
Elghali, L., Clift, R., Sinclair, P., Panoutsou, C., & Bauen, A. (2007). Developing a sustainability framework for the assessment of bioenergy systems. Energy Policy, 35(12), 6075–6083.
Eltayeb, T., Zailani, S. & Ramayah, T. (2011). Green supply chain initiatives among certified companies in Malaysia and environmental sustainability: Investigating the outcomes. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 55, 495–506.
Erol, I., Sencer, S., & Sari, R. (2011). A new fuzzy multi-criteria framework for measuring sustainability performance of a supply chain. Ecological Economics, 70(6), 1088–1100.
Ferdows, K. (1997). Making the most of foreign factories, Harvard.
Govindan, K., Khodaverdi, R., & Jafarian, A. (2013). A fuzzy multi criteria approach for measuring sustainability performance of a supplier based on triple bottom line approach. Journal of Cleaner Production, 47, 345–354.
Graymore, M. L. M., Wallis, A. M., & Richards, A. J. (2009). An Index of Regional Sustainability: A GIS-based multiple criteria analysis decision support system for progressing sustainability. Ecological Complexity, 6(4), 453–462.
Greco, S., Ehrgott, M., & Figueira, J.-R. (2016). Multiple criteria decision analysis. State of the art surveys. New York: Springer.
Heravi, G., Fathi, M. & Faeghi, S. (2017). Multi-criteria group decision-making method for optimal selection of sustainable industrial building options focused on petrochemical projects. Journal of Cleaner Production, 142, 2999–3013.
Henriques, C. O., & Antunes, C. H. (2012). Interactions of economic growth, energy consumption and the environment in the context of the crisis—A study with uncertain data. Energy, 48(1), 415–422.
Hornsby, C., Ripa, M., Vassillo, C., & Ulgiati, S. (2017). A roadmap towards integrated assessment and participatory strategies in support of decision-making processes. The case of urban waste management. Journal of Cleaner Production, 142, 157–172.
Huang, G. H., & Xia, J. (2001). Barriers to sustainable water-quality management. Journal of Environmental Management, 61(1), 1–23.
Huanga, I. B., Keislerb, J., & Linkovc, I. (2011). Multi-criteria decision analysis in environmental sciences: Ten years of applications and trends. Science of the Total Environment, 409(19), 3578–3594.
Hung M. L., Ma, H. W., & Yang W. F. (2007). A novel sustainable decision making model for municipal solid waste management. Waste Management 27, 209–219.
Hyde, K. M., Maier, H. R., & Colby, C. B. (2005). A distance-based uncertainty analysis approach to multi-criteria decision analysis for water resource decision making. Journal of Environmental Management, 77(4), 278–290.
Jayaraman, R., Colapinto, C., La Torre, D., & Malik, T. (2015a). Multi-criteria model for sustainable development using goal programming applied to the United Arab Emirates. Energy Policy, 87, 447–454.
Jayaraman, R., Colapinto, C., La Torre, D., & Malik, T. (2017a). A weighted goal programming model for planning sustainable development applied to Gulf Cooperation Council Countries. Applied Energy, 185, 1931–1939.
Jayaraman, R., Colapinto, C., Liuzzi, D., & La Torre, D. (2017b). Planning sustainable development through a scenario-based stochastic goal programming model. Operational Research, 17(3), 789–805.
Jayaraman, R., La Torre, D., Malik, T., & Pearson, Y. E. (2015b). Optimal work force allocation for energy, economic and environmental sustainability in the United Arab Emirates: A goal programming approach. Energy Procedia, 75, 2999–3006.
Jayaraman, R., Liuzzi, D., Colapinto, C., & Malik, T. (2017c). A fuzzy goal programming model to analyze energy, environmental and sustainability goals of the United Arab Emirates. Annals of Operations Research, 251(1–2), 255–270.
Jeong, J. S., García-Moruno, L., Hernández-Blanco, J., & Sánchez-Ríos, A. (2016). Planning of rural housings in reservoir areas under (mass) tourism based on a fuzzy DEMATEL-GIS/MCDA hybrid and participatory method for Alange, Spain. Habitat International, 57, 143–153.
Jiang, Z., Zhang, H., & Sutherland, J. W. (2011). Development of multi-criteria decision making model for remanufacturing technology portfolio selection. Journal of Cleaner Production, 19(17–18), 1939–1945.
Keivanpour, S., Ait, Kadi D., & Mascle, C. (2017). End-of-life aircraft treatment in the context of sustainable development, lean management, and global business. International Journal of Sustainable Transportation, 11(5), 357–380.
Khan, F. I., Sadiq, R., & Veitch, B. (2004). Life cycle iNdeX (LInX): A new indexing procedure for process and product design and decision-making. Journal of Cleaner Production, 12(1), 59–76.
Lombardi, P., Abastante, F., Sara, T. M., & Toniolo, J. (2017). Multicriteria spatial decision support systems for future urban energy retrofitting scenarios. Sustainability (Switzerland), 9(7), 1252.
Lozano-Oyola, M., Blancas, F. J., González, M., & Caballero, R. (2012). Sustainable tourism indicators as planning tools in cultural destinations. Ecological Indicators, 18, 659–675.
Luthra, S., Govindan, K., Kannan, D., Mangla, S. K., & Garg, C. P. (2017). An integrated framework for sustainable supplier selection and evaluation in supply chains. Journal of Cleaner Production, 140, 1686–1698.
Macleod, C. J. A., Scholefield, D., & Haygarth, P. M. (2007). Integration for sustainable catchment management. Science of the Total Environment, 373(3), 591–602.
Madlener, R., & Stagl, S. (2005). Sustainability-guided promotion of renewable electricity generation. Ecological Economics, 53(2), 147–167.
Moretti, L., Di Mascio, P., & Bellagamba, S. (2017). Environmental, human health and socio-economic effects of cement powders: The multicriteria analysis as decisional methodology. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 14(6), 645.
Morrissey, A. J., & Browne, J. (2004). Waste management models and their application to sustainable waste management. Waste Management, 24(3), 297–308.
Ng, S. T., Chen, Y., & Wong James, M. W. J. M. W. (2013). Variability of building environmental assessment tools on evaluating carbon emissions. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 38, 131–141.
Nordhaus, W. (1991). To Slow or Not to Slow: The Economics of the Greenhouse Effect. Economic Journal, 101(407), 920–937.
Onu, P. U., Quan, X., Xu, L., Orji, J., & Onu, E. (2017). Evaluation of sustainable acid rain control options utilizing a fuzzy TOPSIS multi-criteria decision analysis model frame work. Journal of Cleaner Production, 141, 612–625.
Opricovic, S. (1998). Multicriteria optimization of civil engineering systems. Belgrade: Faculty of Civil Engineering.
Pask, F., Lake, P., Yang, A., Tokos, H., & Sadhukhan, J. (2017). Sustainability indicators for industrial ovens and assessment using fuzzy set theory and Monte Carlo simulation. Journal of Cleaner Production, 140, 1217–1225.
Pohekar, S. D., & Ramachandran, M. (2004). Application of multi-criteria decision making to sustainable energy planning—A review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 8, 365–381.
Raju, K. S., Duckstein, L., & Arondel, C. (2000). Multicriterion analysis for sustainable water resources planning: A case study in Spain. Water Resources Management, 14(6), 435–456.
Rodger, J. A., & George, J. A. (2017). Triple bottom line accounting for optimizing natural gas sustainability: A statistical linear programming fuzzy ILOWA optimized sustainment model approach to reducing supply chain global cybersecurity vulnerability through information and communications technology. Journal of Cleaner Production, 142, 1931–1949.
Rostamzadeh, R., Govindan, K., Esmaeili, A., & Sabaghi, M. (2015). Application of fuzzy VIKOR for evaluation of green supply chain management practices. Ecological Indicators, 49, 188–203.
Saaty, T. (2008). Decision making with the analytic hierarchy process. International Journal of Services Sciences, 1(1), 83–98.
Saaty, T. L. (2016). The analytic hierarchy and analytic network processes for the measurement of intangible criteria and for decision-making. In S. Greco, M. Ehrgott, & J. Rui Figueira (Eds.), Multiple criteria decision analysis. State of the art surveys (Vol. 1, pp. 363–419). New York: Springer.
San Cristóbal, J. R. (2012). A goal programming model for environmental policy analysis: Application to Spain. Energy Policy, 43, 303–307.
Santos, J., Flintsch, G., & Ferreira, A. (2017). Environmental and economic assessment of pavement construction and management practices for enhancing pavement sustainability. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 116, 15–31.
Santoyo-Castelazo, E., & Azapagic, A. (2014). Sustainability assessment of energy systems: Integrating environmental, economic and social aspects. Journal of Cleaner Production, 80, 119–138.
Scrucca, F., Severi, C., Galvan, N., & Brunori, A. (2016). A new method to assess the sustainability performance of events: Application to the 2014 World Orienteering Championship. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 56, 1–11.
Shen, L., Olfat, L., Govindan, K., Khodaverdi, R., & Diabat, A. (2013). A fuzzy multi criteria approach for evaluating green supplier’s performance in green supply chain with linguistic preferences. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 74, 170–179.
Tan, Y., Shuai, C., Jiao, L., & Shen, L. (2017). An adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system (ANFIS) approach for measuring country sustainability performance. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 65, 29–40.
Vanclay, J. K. (2012). Impact factor: Outdated artefact or stepping-stone to journal certification? Scientometrics, 92(2), 211–238.
Vié, A., Colapinto, C., La Torre, D., & Liuzzi, D. (2019). The long-run sustainability of the European Union countries. Assessing the Europe 2020 strategy through a fuzzy goal programming model. Management Decision, 57(2), 523–542.
Waeber, P. O., Nitschke, C. R., Ferrec, A. L., Harshaw, H. W., & Innes, J. L. (2013). Evaluating alternative forest management strategies for the Champagne and Aishihik Traditional Territory, southwest Yukon. Journal of Environmental Management, 120, 148–156.
Wang, Q., Dai, H.-N., & Wang, H. (2017). A smart MCDM framework to evaluate the impact of air pollution on city sustainability: A case study from China. Sustainability (Switzerland), 9(6), 911.
Wang, J.-J., Jing, Y.-Y., Zhang, C.-F., & Zhao, J.-H. (2009). Review on multi-criteria decision analysis aid in sustainable energy decision-making. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 13(9), 2263–2278.
Wątróbski, J., Jankowski, J., Ziemba, P., Karczmarczyk, A., & Zioło, M. (2019). Generalised framework for multi-criteria method selection. Omega, 86, 107–124.
Wolfslehner, B., & Vacik, H. (2008). Evaluating sustainable forest management strategies with the analytic network process in a pressure-state-response framework. Journal of Environmental Management, 88(1), 1–10.
Zavadskas, E. K. & Antucheviciene, J. (2007). Multiple criteria evaluation of rural building’s regeneration alternatives. Building and Environment, 42(1), 436–451.
Zeng, G., Jiang, R., Huang, G., Xu, M., & Li, J. (2007). Optimization of wastewater treatment alternative selection by hierarchy grey relational analysis. Journal of Environmental Management, 82(2), 250–259.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Appendix
Appendix
Source title | Authors |
---|---|
6th International Conference on Environmental Informatics, ISEIS 2007 | Monprapussorn et al. (2014) |
8th International Conference on Environmental Engineering, ICEE 2011 | Medineckiene et al. (2011) |
Agricultural Water Management | Blanco-Gutiérrez et al. (2011) |
Agronomy for Sustainable Development | Sadok et al. (2009), Colomb et al. (2013), Liu and Zhang (2013) and Wohlfender-Bühler et al. (2016) |
American Journal of Environmental Sciences | Babaie-Kafaky et al. (2009) |
American Water Works Association Annual Conference and Exposition (ACE 2009) | Liner and De Monsabert (2009) |
Aquaculture Economics and Management | Sylvia (1997) and Martinez-Cordero and Leung (2004) |
Archives of Environmental Protection | Mahmood et al. (2017) |
ASABE—9th International Drainage Symposium 2010 | Noory et al. (2010) |
Biomass and Bioenergy | Ziolkowska (2013), Sinclair et al. (2015) and Vaidya and Mayer (2016) |
Biomass Supply Chains for Bioenergy and Biorefining | Sacchelli (2016) |
Building and Environment | Tiwari and Parikh (2000), Zavadskas and Antucheviciene (2007, 2010), ALwaer and Clements-Croome (2010), San-José Lombera and Garrucho Aprea (2010), Wang et al. (2010), Pons and Aguado (2012) and Samani et al. (2015) |
Business Strategy and the Environment | Dou et al. (2015), Escrig-Olmedo et al. (2017) and Raut et al. (2017) |
Cahiers Agricultures | Colomb and Glandières (2014) |
Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering | Upadhyaya and Moore (2012) |
Canadian Journal of Forest Research | Diaz-Balteiro et al. (2016) |
Carpathian Journal of Earth and Environmental Sciences | Onose et al. (2015) |
Clean Technologies and Environmental Policy | Dorini et al. (2011), Vinodh and Girubha (2012), Akhtar et al. (2014), Liew et al. (2014), Sedláková et al. (2015), Santos et al. (2016), Ubando et al. (2016), Kumar et al. (2017a, b), Patole et al. (2017) and Vo et al. (2017) |
Computers, Environment and Urban Systems | Cao et al. (2012) |
17th IEEE International Conference on Environment and Electrical Engineering, 1st IEEE Industrial and Commercial Power Systems Europe, EEEIC/I and CPS Europe 2017 | Giacomini et al. (2017) |
Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology | Chang et al. (2011) |
Desalination | Sa-nguanduan and Nititvattananon (2011), Grubert et al. (2014), Aliewi et al. (2017) and Lior (2017) |
Desalination and Water Treatment | Afgan and Darwish (2011). |
Ecological Applications | Schwenk et al. (2012) |
Ecological Complexity | Graymore et al. (2009) |
Ecological Economics | van Pelt (1993), Madlener and Stagl (2005), Sell et al. (2006), Thankappan et al. (2006), Gamper and Turcanu Prato (2007), Prato and Herath (2007), Parra-López et al. (2008), Erol et al. (2011) and Garmendia and Gamboa (2012) |
Ecological Indicators | Mendoza and Prabhu (2004), Sattler et al. (2010), Wolfslehner and Vacik (2011), Lozano-Oyola et al. (2012), Pelzer et al. (2012), Ferretti and Pomarico (2013), Herva and Roca (2013), Cabello et al.(2014), Pinar et al. (2014), Hadian and Madani (2015), Michailidou et al. (2015), Rostamzadeh et al. (2015), Govindan et al. (2016a, b), Molinos-Senante et al. (2016), Veisi et al. (2016) and He et al. (2017) |
Ecological Modelling | Bouman et al. (1998), You et al. (2014) |
Ecological Modelling | |
ECOS 2015—28th International Conference on Efficiency, Cost, Optimization, Simulation and Environmental Impact of Energy Systems | Milutinović et al. (2015) |
Ecosystem Services | Nin et al. (2016) |
EM: Air and Waste Management Association’s Magazine for Environmental Managers | McPhee and Powell (2011) |
Energy | Bose and Anandalingam (1996), Afgan and Carvalho (2002), Lipošćak et al. (2006), Cowan et al. (2010), Jovanovic et al. (2010), Henriques and Antunes (2012), Pérez-Fortes et al. (2012), Scarpellini et al. (2013), Cartelle Barros et al. (2015), Ren et al. (2015), Zhang et al. (2015), Shakouri and Aliakbarisani (2016), Zhong et al. (2016), Büyüközkan and Karabulut (2017), Eichhorn et al. (2017) and Zhang et al. (2017) |
Energy Policy | Buchholz et al. (2007), Elghali et al. (2007), Buchholz et al. (2009b), Phdungsilp (2010), Perimenis et al. (2011), San Cristóbal (2012), Hong et al. (2013), Morimoto (2013), Maxim (2014), Goldrath et al. (2015), Jayaraman et al. (2015), Klein and Whalley (2015), Moreira et al. (2015), Chanthawong and Dhakal (2016), Cai et al. (2017) and Gambelli et al. (2017) |
Energy Sources, Part B: Economics, Planning and Policy | Polatidis and Haralambopoulos (2007) |
Environment and Livelihoods in Tropical Coastal Zones: Managing Agriculture-Fishery-Aquaculture Conflicts | Trung et al. (2006) |
Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design | Nagurney (2015) |
Environment International | Li et al. (2014) |
Environment Systems and Decisions | Collier et al. (2013), Pagsuyoin et al. (2015) and Collier et al. (2017). |
Environment, Development and Sustainability | Latinopoulos et al. (2012), Sironen et al. (2015) and Qureshi et al. (2017) |
Environmental Earth Sciences | Pourebrahim and Mokhtar (2016) |
Environmental Engineering and Management Journal | De Luca et al. (2015) |
Environmental Engineering Science | Hu et al. (2011) and Soltani et al. (2013) |
Environmental Geology | Van Cauwenbergh et al. (2008) |
Environmental Health: A Global Access Science Source | Macmillan et al. (2016) |
Environmental Impact Assessment Review | Browne and Ryan (2011), Schetke et al. (2012), González et al.(2013), Ng et al.(2013), Blancas et al. (2015), Pardo-Bosch and Aguado (2016), Scrucca et al. (2016), Wellington and Lewis (2016), Sierra et al. (2017) and Tan et al. (2017) |
Environmental Management | Manoliadis (2001), Brody et al. (2004), Hill et al. (2006), Liu (2007), Marttunen and Hämäläinen (2008), Vizzari and Modica (2013), Marušák et al. (2015), Uhde et al. (2015) and Seghezzo et al. (2017) |
Environmental Modelling and Software | Bottero et al. (2011) and Carpani et al. (2012). |
Environmental Monitoring and Assessment | Ohman et al. (2007), Pandey et al. (2012) and Azarnivand and Chitsaz (2015) |
Environmental Practice | Kropp and Lein (2013) |
Environmental Progress and Sustainable Energy | Dinh et al. (2009) and Kuleli Pak et al. (2017) |
Environmental Science and Policy | Marques et al. (2015), Curiel-Esparza et al. (2016) and Diaz-Sarachaga et al. (2017) |
Environmental Science and Pollution Research | Asif and Chen (2016), Pitz et al. (2016) and Nujoom et al. (2017) |
Environmental Science and Technology | Adhitya et al. (2011), Sparrevik et al. (2012) and Zhang et al. (2014) |
Environmental Science Research | Minciardi et al. (2011) |
Environmental Science: Nano | Erbis et al. (2016) |
European Journal of Environmental and Civil Engineering | Terracciano et al. (2015) |
Forest Ecology and Management | Martins and Borges (2007) and Giménez et al. (2013) |
Forest Policy and Economics | Grošelj et al. (2016). |
Forest Science | Pesonen et al. (2001) |
Fresenius Environmental Bulletin | Papadaki et al. (2003) |
Geoingegneria Ambientale e Mineraria | Abastante et al. (2012) and Bottero et al. (2013) |
Geosystem Engineering | Nuong et al. (2011) |
Green Energy and Technology | Öztayşi et al. (2013) |
Green Logistics and Transportation: A Sustainable Supply Chain Perspective | Bai et al. (2015) and Jabbarzadeh and Fahimnia (2015) |
Habitat International | Onur and Tezer (2015) and Jeong et al. (2016) |
IAHS-AISH Publication | Simonovic (2001) |
Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal | White and Noble (2012) |
Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research | Singh and Lou (2006) |
Informes de la Construccion | Neri et al. (2010) |
Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management | von Stackelberg (2013) and De Luca et al. (2015) |
International Journal of Ecology and Development | John and Sharma (2014) |
International Journal of Environment and Pollution | Toman et al. (1999) |
International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health | Moretti et al. (2017) |
International Journal of Environmental Science and Technology | Ezebilo and Animasaun (2011), Hu et al. (2012), Tuzkaya (2013) and Afsordegan et al. (2016) |
International Journal of Environmental Technology and Management | De Montis and Nijkamp (2006), Munda (2006), Halog and Chan (2008) and Munda et al. (2009) |
International Journal of Global Environmental Issues | Awasthi and Omrani (2009) |
International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control | Volkart et al. (2016) |
International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment | Pineda-Henson and Culaba (2004), Güereca et al. (2007), Bachmann (2013), Kucukvar et al. (2014), Ren et al. (2015), (2017a, b) and Subramanian et al. (2017) |
International Journal of Recycling of Organic Waste in Agriculture | Ganoulis (2012) |
International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment | Bansal et al. (2017) |
International Journal of Sustainable Development and Planning | Meney and Pantelic (2015) |
International Journal of Sustainable Development and World Ecology | Miranda (2001), San-José et al. (2007), Poveda and Lipsett (2014), Salling and Pryn (2015), Ahmed et al. (2016), Demir et al. (2016), Fernandes et al. (2017) and Myllyviita et al. (2017) |
International Journal of Sustainable Transportation | Keivanpour et al. (2017) |
International Journal of Technology Management and Sustainable Development | Khatri and Srivastava (2016) |
International Journal of Water Resources Development | Ghanbarpour et al. (2005) |
ITEE 2005—2nd International ICSC Symposium on Information Technologies in Environmental Engineering, Proceedings | Filho et al. (2005) |
Journal of Air Transport Management | Karaman and Akman (2017). |
Journal of Cleaner Production | Khan et al. (2004), Jiang et al. (2011), Acosta-Alba et al. (2012), Castellini et al. (2012), Ajukumar and Gandhi (2013), Freitas and Magrini (2013), Govindan et al. (2013), Infante et al. (2013), Khalili and Duecker (2013), Oltean-Dumbrava et al. (2013), Yeh and Xu (2013), Liu et al. (2014), Ma and Okudan Kremer (2014), Sacchelli et al. (2014), Santoyo-Castelazo and Azapagic (2014), Ahmed Ali et al. (2015), Alikhani and Azar (2015), Biju et al.(2015), Kannegiesser et al.(2015), Kantas et al. (2015), Lam and Lai (2015),Mota et al. (2015), Pires et al. (2015), Pubule et al. (2015), Zhang and Haapala (2015), Zhao and Li (2015), Aktin and Gergin (2016), Aydiner et al. (2016), Chauhan and Singh (2016), Coskun et al. (2016), Garg and Lam (2016), How et al. (2016), Liang et al. (2016), Mangla et al. (2016), Motevali Haghighi et al. (2016), Oltean-Dumbrava et al. (2016), Onat et al. (2016), Ozcan-Deniz and Zhu (2016), Quader et al. (2016), Renatus and Geldermann (2016), Väisänen et al. (2016), Alencar et al. (2017), Arampantzi and Minis (2017), de Almeida et al. (2017), Hatami-Marbini et al. (2017), Heravi et al. (2017), Hornsby et al. (2017), Kopacz et al. (2017), Limleamthong and Guillén-Gosálbez (2017), Liu et al. (2017), Luthra et al. (2017), Madan Shankar et al. (2017), Onu et al. (2017), Pask et al. (2017), Rahmanpour and Osanloo (2017), Rodger and George (2017), Schmitt et al. (2017) and Sun et al. (2017) |
Journal of Environmental Accounting and Management | Marvuglia et al. (2015) and Rochikashvili and Bongaerts (2017) |
Journal of Environmental Health Science and Engineering | Ziaabadi et al. (2017) |
Journal of Environmental Informatics | Ben-Awuah et al. (2012) |
Journal of Environmental Management | Diaz-Balteiro and Romero (2004), Starkl and Brunner (2004), Hyde et al. (2005), Azadi et al. (2007), Zeng et al. (2007), Wolfslehner and Vacik (2008), Balana et al. (2010), Boggia and Cortina (2010), Garfì et al. (2011), Mustajoki et al. (2011), Rowley et al. (2012), Liu et al. (2013), Morio et al. (2013), Volchko et al. (2013), Waeber et al. (2013), Boggia et al. (2014), Bartke et al. (2016), Cappuyns (2016), Diaz-Balteiro et al. (2016) and Zheng et al. (2016) |
Journal of Environmental Planning and Management | Tsai et al. (2013), Hossaini et al. (2015), Grilli et al. (2017), Oses et al. (2017) and Thabrew et al. (2017) |
Journal of Environmental Quality | Manoliadis (2001) |
Journal of Environmental Studies | Pourkhabbaz et al. (2013) and Rezaee et al. (2014) |
Journal of Food, Agriculture and Environment | Del Campo Gomis et al. (2010) and Baležentiene and Užupis (2012) |
Journal of Hydrology | Safavi et al. (2016) |
Journal of Industrial Ecology | Kalbar et al. (2016) |
Journal of Material Cycles and Waste Management | Houng and Cheng (2013) |
Journal of Materials and Environmental Science | Sivaprakasam et al. (2015) |
Journal of Polymers and the Environment | Colwill et al. (2012) |
Journal of Sustainable Forestry | Mendoza et al. (2002) and Carabelli et al. (2007) |
Journal of the American Water Resources Association | Chen and Tung (2007) and Kim and Chung (2015) |
Journal of Transport Geography | Accorsi et al. (2015) |
Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management | Liner and De Monsabert (2011), Riegels et al. (2013), Panagopoulos et al. (2014), Li et al. (2015) and Zhou et al. (2015) |
Land Use Policy | Antunes et al. (2006), Munda (2006), La Rosa et al. (2014), Verburg et al. (2014), Bojesen et al. (2015), Nuuter et al. (2015), Ravier et al. (2015), Ottomano Palmisano et al. (2016 a, b), Chopin et al. (2017) and Osmani and Zhang (2017). |
Landscape and Urban Planning | Hajkowicz and Collins (2009) |
Landscape Ecology | McAlpine et al. (2010) |
Management of Environmental Quality | Pati and Vrat (2010), Bottero (2015) and Stevovic et al. (2017) |
Mathematical and Computational Forestry and Natural-Resource Sciences | Sironen et al. (2013) |
Mechanism Design for Sustainability: Techniques and Cases | De Felice and Petrillo (2013) |
Nature Environment and Pollution Technology | Mor and Ramachandran (2017) |
Ocean and Coastal Management | Datta et al. (2010), Pourebrahim et al. (2014), Fetanat and Khorasaninejad (2015) and Najafinasab et al. (2015) |
Polish Journal of Environmental Studies | Zarkesh et al. (2012), Mavi et al. (2013) and Gürlük and Uzel (2016) |
Proceedings of Institution of Civil Engineers: Waste and Resource Management | Achillas et al. (2010) |
Proceedings of the 11th International Conference on Civil, Structural and Environmental Engineering Computing, Civil-Comp 2007 | Kokoli et al. (2007) |
Proceedings of the 23rd International Conference on Efficiency, Cost, Optimization, Simulation, and Environmental Impact of Energy Systems (ECOS) | Bauer et al. (2010) and Oliveira and Antunes (2012) |
Proceedings of the Summer School Francesco Turco | Orrù et al. (2013) and Coppola et al. (2014) |
Process Safety and Environmental Protection | Stewart et al. (2003), Azapagic et al. (2013) and Mahjouri et al. (2017) |
Progress in Industrial Ecology | Harpet et al. (2013) and Khalili et al. (2013) |
Recycling: New Research | Minciardi et al. (2008) |
Resources | Schmid et al. (2016) |
Resources Policy | Chen et al. (2015) and Bui et al. (2017) |
Resources, Conservation and Recycling | Pires et al. (2011), Shen et al. (2013), Antonopoulos et al. (2014), Mirabi et al. (2014), Haji Vahabzadeh et al. (2015), Mangla et al. (2015), Agrawal et al. (2016), Ameli et al. (2016), Inghels et al. (2016), An et al. (2017), Badri Ahmadi et al. (2017) and Santos et al. (2017) |
Revista Brasileira de Gestao e Desenvolvimento Regional | de Carvalho et al. (2013) |
Proceedings of the 13th International Symposium on River Sedimentation, ISRS 2016 | Yazdandoost and Farahani (2017) and Yazdandoost and Khorami (2017) |
Science of the Total Environment | Macleod et al. (2007), Katukiza et al. (2010), Sorvari and Seppälä (2010), Cucchiella et al. (2013), Chen et al. (2014), Molinos-Senante et al.(2014), Volchko et al. (2014), Behzadian and Kapelan (2015), Molinos-Senante et al. (2015), Rosén et al. (2015), Kumar et al. (2016), Ren et al. (2106) and Chhipi-Shrestha et al. (2017) |
Silva Fennica | Diaz-Balteiroet al. (2011) |
Soft Computing Applications for Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency | Pilar De La Cruz et al. (2014) |
Stochastic Environmental Research and Risk Assessment | Xu et al. (2014) and Wang and Chen (2015) |
Sustainability | Halog and Manik (2011), Attardi et al. (2012), Cerreta and De Toro (2012) and Kropp and Lein (2012) |
Sustainability (Switzerland) | Barata et al. (2014), Chen et al. (2014), Mari et al. (2014), Mitraka et al. (2014), Ortega et al. (2014), Zhao and Guo (2014), Apanavičiene et al. (2015), Canto-Perello et al. (2015), Carnero (2015), Chang et al. (2015), Chen (2015), De Mare et al. (2015), Grafakos et al. (2015), Jang et al. (2015), Jia et al. (2015), Mihai et al. (2015), Park et al. (2015), Wang et al. (2015), Zhao and Guo (2015), Cavallaro et al. (2015), Dobrovolskienė and Tamošiūnienė (2016), Dong et al. (2016),Falcone et al. (2016), Hwang et al. (2016), Li et al. (2016), Lu et al. (2016a, b), Nekhay and Arriaza (2016), Pipatprapa et al. (2016), Pons et al. (2016), Tang et al. (2016), Tsai et al. (2016), Xu et al. (2016), Zhao et al. (2016), Zhou et al. (2016), Chou et al. (2017), García et al. (2017), Grimaldi et al. (2017), Huang et al. (2017), Kluczek (2017), Lombardi et al. (2017), Scharfy et al. (2017), Wang et al. (2017a, b, c), Yu and Su (2017) and Zhou and Hu (2017) |
Sustainability Impact Assessment of Land Use Changes | Paracchini et al. (2008) |
Sustainability Science | Bausch et al. (2014) and Alyami et al. (2015) |
Sustainability: Multi-Disciplinary Perspectives | Petrie et al. (2012) |
Sustainable Practices: Concepts, Methodologies, Tools, and Applications | Grigoroudis et al. (2013) |
Sustainable Production and Consumption | Atilgan and Azapagic (2016), Gumus et al. (2016) and Onat et al. (2016) |
Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment | Bryce et al. (2014), Khoo and Teoh (2014), Rao et al. (2015), Ren and Lützen (2015), Izadikhah and Farzipoor Saen (2016) and Umer et al. (2017) |
Urban Water Journal | Piratla (2016) |
USDA Forest Service—General Technical Report PNW | Mendoza and Martins (2006) |
Waste and Biomass Valorization | San Martin et al. (2017) |
Waste Management | Costi et al. (2004), Morrissey and Browne (2004), Hung et al. (2007), Minciardi et al. (2008), Zhu and Huang (2011), Karmperis et al. (2013), Josimović et al. (2015), Wibowo and Deng (2015) and de Souza et al. (2016) |
Waste Management and Research | Mirdar Harijani et al. (2017) |
Water (Switzerland) | Zhang et al. (2014) and Borrego-Marín and Riesgo (2016) |
Water and Environment Journal | Kalbar et al. (2013) |
Water Policy | Wu et al. (2017) |
Water Resources Management | Raju et al. (2000), Calizaya et al. (2010), Fasakhodi et al. (2010), Ferreira and Teegavarapu (2012), Hashemi et al. (2013), Aydin et al. (2014), Kaviani et al. (2014), Toosi and Samani (2014) and Haider et al. (2015) |
Water SA | Yilmaz and Harmancioglu (2010) |
Water Science and Technology | Makropoulos et al. (2006), Diaper and Sharma (2007), Moura et al. (2011) and Plakas et al. (2016) |
Water Science and Technology: Water Supply | Ganoulis (2003) and Hamouda et al. (2012) |
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment | Bakopoulou e t al. (2007), Lacquaniti and Sala (2009), Sabokkhiz and Sabokkhiz (2010) and Guerrero et al. (2013) |
World Environmental and Water Resources Congress 2012: Crossing Boundaries, Proceedings of the 2012 Congress | Hadian et al. (2012) and Rastgoftar et al. (2012) |
WSEAS Transactions on Environment and Development | Duarte et al. |
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Colapinto, C., Jayaraman, R., Ben Abdelaziz, F. et al. Environmental sustainability and multifaceted development: multi-criteria decision models with applications. Ann Oper Res 293, 405–432 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10479-019-03403-y
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10479-019-03403-y