Abstract
Phenology is a key feature in the description of species niches to capture seasonality in resource use and climate requirements. Species distribution models (SDMs) are widespread tools to evaluate a species’ potential distribution and identify its large-scale habitat preferences. Despite its chief importance, data phenology is often neglected in SDM development. Non-migratory bats of temperate regions are good model species to test the effect of data seasonality on SDM outputs because of their different roosting preferences between hibernation and reproduction. We hypothesized that (1) the output of SDMs developed for six non-migratory European bat species will differ between hibernation and reproduction; (2) models built from datasets encompassing both ecological stages will perform better than seasonal models. We employed a dataset of 470 independent occurrences of bat hibernacula and 400 independent records of nursery roosts of selected species and for each species we developed separate winter, summer and mixed (i.e. generated from both winter and summer occurrences) models. Seasonal and mixed potential ranges differed from each other and the direction of this difference was species-specific. Mixed models outperformed seasonal models in representing species niches. Our work highlights the importance of considering data seasonality in the development of SDMs for bats as well as many other organisms, including non-migratory species, otherwise the analysis will lead to significant biases whose consequences for conservation planning and landscape management may be detrimental.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Algar AC, Kharouba HM, Young ER, Kerr JT (2009) Predicting the future of species diversity: macroecological theory climate change and direct tests of alternative forecasting methods. Ecography 32:22–33
Allouche O, Tsoar A, Kadmon R (2006) Assessing the accuracy of species distribution models: prevalence kappa and the true skill statistic (TSS). J Appl Ecol 43:1223–1232
Altringham JD (2011) Bats: from evolution to conservation. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Amorim F, Carvalho SB, Honrado J, Rebelo H (2014) Designing optimized multi-species monitoring networks to detect range shifts driven by climate change: a case study with bats in the North of Portugal. PLoS ONE 9(1):e87291
Ardestani EG, Tarkesh M, Bassiri M, Vahabi MR (2015) Potential habitat modeling for reintroduction of three native plant species in central Iran. J Arid Land 7:381–390
Arlettaz R, Christe P, Lugon A, Perrin N, Vogel P (2001) Food availability dictates the timing of parturition in insectivorous mouse-eared bats. Oikos 95:105–111
Austin MP (2002) Spatial prediction of species distribution: an interface between ecological theory and statistical modelling. Ecol Model 157:101–118
Austin MP, Van Niel KP (2011) Improving species distribution models for climate change studies: variable selection and scale. J Biogeogr 38:1–8
Balestrieri A, Bogliani G, Boano G, Ruiz-González A, Saino N, Costa S, Milanesi P (2016) Modelling the distribution of forest-dependent species in human-dominated landscapes: patterns for the pine marten in intensively cultivated lowlands. PLoS ONE 11:e0158203
Barbet-Massin M, Thuiller W, Jiguet F (2010) How much do we overestimate future local extinction rates when restricting the range of occurrence data in climate suitability models? Ecography 33:878–886
Barbet-Massin M, Jiguet F, Albert CH, Thuiller W (2012) Selecting pseudo-absences for species distribution models: how where and how many? Methods Ecol Evol 3:327–338
Barve N, Barve V, Jiménez-Valverde A, Lira-Noriega A, Maher SP, Peterson AT, Villalobos F (2011) The crucial role of the accessible area in ecological niche modeling and species distribution modelling. Ecol Model 222:1810–1819
Bates D, Maechler M, Dai B (2008) Lme4: linear-mixed effects models using S4 classes R package version 099375-27. http://www.lme4rforger-projectorg/
Beaumont LJ, Pitman AJ, Poulsen M, Hughes L (2007) Where will species go? Incorporating new advances in climate modelling into projections of species distributions. Glob Change Biol 13:1368–1385
Bellamy C, Altringham J (2015) Predicting species distributions using record centre data: multi-scale modelling of habitat suitability for bat roosts. PLoS ONE 10:e0128440
Biscardi S, Russo D, Casciani V, Cesarini D, Mei M, Boitani L (2007) Foraging requirements of the endangered long-fingered bat: the influence of micro-habitat structure water quality and prey type. J Zool 273:372–381
Bosso L, Mucedda M, Fichera G, Kiefer A, Russo D (2016a) A gap analysis for threatened bat populations on Sardinia. Hystrix 27:212–214
Bosso L, Di Febbraro M, Cristinzio G, Zoina A, Russo D (2016b) Shedding light on the effects of climate change on the potential distribution of Xylella fastidiosa in the Mediterranean basin. Biol Invasions 18:1759–1768
Bosso L, Luchi N, Maresi G, Cristinzio G, Smeraldo S, Russo D (2017a) Predicting current and future disease outbreaks of Diplodia sapinea shoot blight in Italy: species distribution models as a tool for forest management planning. For Ecol Manag 400:655–664
Bosso L, De Conno C, Russo D (2017b) Modelling the risk posed by the Zebra Mussel Dreissena polymorpha: Italy as a case study. Environ Manag 60:304–313
Bosso L, Smeraldo S, Rapuzzi P, Sama G, Garonna AP, Russo D (2018) Nature protection areas of Europe are insufficient to preserve the threatened beetle Rosalia alpina (Coleoptera: Cerambycidae): evidence from species distribution models and conservation gap analysis. Ecol Entomol 43:192–203. https://doi.org/10.1111/een12485
Breiner FT, Guisan A, Bergamini A, Nobis MP (2015) Overcoming limitations of modelling rare species by using ensembles of small models. Methods Ecol Evol 6:1210–1218
Breiner FT, Guisan A, Nobis MP, Bergamini A (2017) Including environmental niche information to improve IUCN Red List assessments. Divers Distrib 23:484–495
Burgman MA, Fox JC (2003) Bias in species range estimates from minimum convex polygons: implications for conservation and options for improved planning. Anim Conserv Forum 6(1):19–28
Carretero MA, Sillero N (2016) Evaluating how species niche modelling is affected by partial distributions with an empirical case. Acta Oecol 77:207–216
Carvalho SB, Brito JC, Pressey RL, Crespo E, Possingham HP (2010) Simulating the effects of using different types of species distribution data in reserve selection. Biol Conserv 143:426–438
Chuine I (2010) Why does phenology drive species distribution? Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 365:3149–3160
Cooper-Bohannon R, Rebelo H, Jones G, Monadiem A, Schoeman MC, Taylor P, Park K (2016) Predicting bat distributions and diversity hotspots in southern Africa. Hystrix. https://doi.org/10.4404/hystrix-27.1-11722
de Castro Pena JC, Kamino LHY, Rodrigues M, Mariano-Neto E, de Siqueira MF (2014) Assessing the conservation status of species with limited available data and disjunct distribution. Biol Conserv 170:130–136
Di Febbraro M, Roscioni F, Frate L, Carranza ML, De Lisio L, De Rosa D, Loy A (2015) Long-term effects of traditional and conservation-oriented forest management on the distribution of vertebrates in Mediterranean forests: a hierarchical hybrid modelling approach. Divers Distrib 21:1141–1154
Di Febbraro M, Martinoli A, Russo D, Preatoni D, Bertolino S (2016) Modelling the effects of climate change on the risk of invasion by alien squirrels. Hystrix 27(1):1–8
Doko T, Fukui H, Kooiman A, Toxopeus AG, Ichinose T, Chen W, Skidmore AK (2011) Identifying habitat patches and potential ecological corridors for remnant Asiatic black bear (Ursus thibetanus japonicus) populations in Japan. Ecol Model 222:748–761
Domíguez-Vega H, Monroy-Vilchis O, Balderas-Valdivia CJ, Gienger CM, Ariano-Sánchez D (2012) Predicting the potential distribution of the beaded lizard and identification of priority areas for conservation. J Nat Conserv 20:247–253
Dormann CF, McPherson JM, Araújo MB, Bivand R, Bolliger J, Carl G, Davies RG, Hirzel A, Jetz W, Kissling WD, Kühn I, Ohlemüller R, Peres-Neto PR, Reineking B, Schröder B, Schurr FM, Wilson R (2007) Methods to account for spatial autocorrelation in the analysis of species distributional data: a review. Ecography 30:609–628
Dubuis A, Pottier J, Rion V, Pellissier L, Theurillat JP, Guisan A (2011) Predicting spatial patterns of plant species richness: a comparison of direct macroecological and species stacking modelling approaches. Divers Distrib 17:1122–1131
Ducci L, Agnelli P, Di Febbraro M, Frate L, Russo D, Loy A, Roscioni F (2015) Different bat guilds perceive their habitat in different ways: a multiscale landscape approach for variable selection in species distribution modelling. Landsc Ecol 30:2147–2159
Engler JO, Rödder D, Stiels D, Förschler MI (2014) Suitable reachable but not colonised: seasonal niche duality in an endemic mountainous songbird. J Ornithol 155:657–669
Erickson JL, West SD (2002) The influence of regional climate and nightly weather conditions on activity patterns of insectivorous bats. Acta Chiropterol 4:17–24
Feng X, Papeş M (2017) Can incomplete knowledge of species’ physiology facilitate ecological niche modelling? A case study with virtual species. Divers Distrib 23:1157–1168
Feuda R, Bannikova AA, Zemlemerova ED, Di Febbraro M, Loy A, Hutterer R, Colangelo P (2015) Tracing the evolutionary history of the mole Talpa europaea through mitochondrial DNA phylogeography and species distribution modelling. Biol J Linn Soc 114:495–512
Fielding AH, Bell JF (1997) A review of methods for the assessment of prediction errors in conservation presence/absence models. Environ Conserv 24:38–49
Fourcade Y, Engler JO, Rödder D, Secondi J (2014) Mapping species distributions with MAXENT using a geographically biased sample of presence data: a performance assessment of methods for correcting sampling bias. PLoS ONE 9:e97122
Fourcade Y, Besnard AG, Secondi J (2018) Paintings predict the distribution of species, or the challenge of selecting environmental predictors and evaluation statistics. Glob Ecol Biogeogr 27:245–256
Franklin J (2010) Mapping species distributions: spatial inference and prediction. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Frick WF, Reynolds DS, Kunz TH (2010) Influence of climate and reproductive timing on demography of little brown myotis Myotis lucifugus. J Anim Ecol 79:128–136
Grindal SD, Collard TS, Brigham RM, Barclay RM (1992) The influence of precipitation on reproduction by Myotis bats in British Columbia. Am Midl Nat 128:339–344
Guisan A, Thuiller W (2005) Predicting species distribution: offering more than simple habitat models. Ecol Lett 8:993–1009
Guisan A, Zimmermann NE (2000) Predictive habitat distribution models in ecology. Ecol Model 135:147–186
Guisan A, Tingley R, Baumgartner JB, Naujokaitis-Lewis I, Sutcliffe PR, Tulloch AI, Martin TG (2013) Predicting species distributions for conservation decisions. Ecol Lett 16:1424–1435
Haghani A, Aliabadian M, Sarhangzadeh J, Setoodeh A (2016) Seasonal habitat suitability modeling and factors affecting the distribution of Asian Houbara in East Iran. Heliyon 2:e00142
Hanley JA, McNeil BJ (1982) The meaning and use of the area under a receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve. Radiology 143:29–36
Hayes MA, Cryan PM, Wunder MB (2015) Seasonally-dynamic presence-only species distribution models for a cryptic migratory bat impacted by wind energy development. PLoS ONE 10:e0132599
Herkt KMB, Skidmore AK, Fahr J (2017) Macroecological conclusions based on IUCN expert maps: a call for caution. Glob Ecol Biogeogr 26:930–941
Hernandez PA, Graham CH, Master LL, Albert DL (2006) The effect of sample size and species characteristics on performance of different species distribution modeling methods. Ecography 29:773–785
Hijmans RJ, Cameron SE, Parra JL, Jones PG, Jarvis A (2005) Very high resolution interpolated climate surfaces for global land areas. Int J Climatol 25:1965–1978
Hirzel AH, Hausser J, Chessel D, Perrin N (2002) Ecological-niche factor analysis: how to compute habitat-suitability maps without absence data? Ecology 83:2027–2036
Holte D, Köppen U, Schmitz-Ornés A (2017) A comparison of migratory strategies of partial migratory raptors from Germany. J Ornithol 158:579–592
Hoying KM, Kunz TH (1998) Variation in size at birth and post-natal growth in the insectivorous bat Pipistrellus subflavus (Chiroptera: Vespertilionidae). J Zool 245:15–27
Huston MW (2002) Introductory essay: critical issues for improving predictions. In: Scott JM, Hugland PJ, Morrison ML et al (eds) Predicting species occurrences: issues of accuracy and scale. Island Press, Washington, DC, pp 7–21
Jiguet F, Barbet-Massin M, Henry PY (2010) Predicting potential distributions of two rare allopatric sister species the globally threatened Doliornis cotingas in the Andes. J Field Ornithol 81:325–339
Kabir M, Hameed S, Ali H, Bosso L, Ud Din J, Bischof R, Redpath S, Ali Nawaz M (2017) Habitat suitability and movement Corridors of Grey Wolf (Canis lupus) in Northern Pakistan. n. PLoS ONE 12(11):e0187027. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0187027
Kwon HS, Kim BJ, Jang GS (2016) Modelling the spatial distribution of wildlife animals using presence and absence data. Contemp Probl Ecol 9:515–518
Le Roux M, Redon M, Archaux F, Long J, Vincent S, Luque S (2017) Conservation planning with spatially explicit models: a case for horseshoe bats in complex mountain landscapes. Landsc Ecol 32:1005–1021
Lewis SE (1993) Effect of climatic variation on reproduction by pallid bats (Antrozous pallidus). Can J Zool 71:1429–1433
Liu C, Berry PM, Dawson TP, Pearson RG (2005) Selecting thresholds of occurrence in the prediction of species distributions. Ecography 28:385–393
Lobo JM, Jimenez-Valverde A, Hortal J (2010) The uncertain nature of absences and their importance in species distribution modelling. Ecography 33:103–114
Marmion M, Parviainen M, Luoto M, Heikkinen RK, Thuiller W (2009) Evaluation of consensus methods in predictive species distribution modelling. Divers Distrib 15:59–69
Masing M, Lutsar L (2007) Hibernation temperatures in seven species of sedentary bats (Chiroptera) in northeastern Europe. Acta Zool Lit 17:47–55
Mathewson PD, Moyer-Horner L, Beever EA, Briscoe NJ, Kearney M, Yahn JM, Porter WP (2017) Mechanistic variables can enhance predictive models of endotherm distributions: the American pika under current past and future climates. Glob Chang Biol 23:1048–1064
Miller-Rushing AJ, Weltzin J (2009) Phenology as a tool to link ecology and sustainable decision making in a dynamic environment. New Phytol 184:743–745
Mitchell-Jones AJ, Amori G, Bogdanowicz W, Spitzenberger F, Krystufek B, Stubbe CM (1999) The Atlas of European mammals. Poyser Natural History, London
Morganti M, Preatoni D, Sarà M (2017) Climate determinants of breeding and wintering ranges of lesser kestrels in Italy and predicted impacts of climate change. J Avian Biol. https://doi.org/10.1111/jav01179
Muscarella R, Galante PJ, Soley-Guardia M, Boria RA, Kass JM, Uriarte M, Anderson RP (2014) ENMeval: an R package for conducting spatially independent evaluations and estimating optimal model complexity for Maxent ecological niche models. Methods Ecol Evol 5:1198–1205
Nagel A, Nagel R (1991) How do bats choose optimal temperatures for hibernation? Comp Biochem Physiol Part A 99:323–326
Newton I (2008) The migration ecology of birds Elsevier Amsterdam
Olson DM, Dinerstein E, Wikramanayake ED, Burgess ND, Powell GV, Underwood EC, Loucks CJ (2001) Terrestrial ecoregions of the world: a new map of life on earth: a new global map of terrestrial ecoregions provides an innovative tool for conserving biodiversity. Bioscience 51:933–938
Olsson O, Rogers DJ (2009) Predicting the distribution of a suitable habitat for the white stork in Southern Sweden: identifying priority areas for reintroduction and habitat restoration. Anim Conserv 12:62–70
Ortega Z, Pérez-Mellado V (2016) Seasonal patterns of body temperature and microhabitat selection in a lacertid lizard. Acta Oecol 77:201–206
Papadatou E, Butlin RK, Altringham JD (2008) Seasonal roosting habits and population structure of the long-fingered bat Myotis capaccinii in Greece. J Mammal 89:503–512
Perry RW (2013) A review of factors affecting cave climates for hibernating bats in temperate North America. Environ Rev 21:28–39
Peterson AT (2011) Ecological niches and geographic distributions (MPB-49)(No 49) Princeton University Press
Pio DV, Engler R, Linder HP, Monadjem A, Cotterill FP, Taylor PJ, Salamin N (2014) Climate change effects on animal and plant phylogenetic diversity in southern Africa. Glob Chang Biol 20:1538–1549
Racey PA, Swift SM (1981) Variations in gestation length in a colony of pipistrelle bats (Pipistrellus pipistrellus) from year to year. J Reprod Fertil 61:123–129
Raes N (2012) Partial versus full species distribution models. Nat Conserv 10:127–138
Razgour O, Rebelo H, Di Febbraro M, Russo D (2016) Painting maps with bats: species distribution modelling in bat research and conservation. Hystrix. https://doi.org/10.4404/hystrix-271-11753
R Development Core Team (2012) R: A language and environment for statistical computing, reference index version, 2(0)
Rebelo H, Tarroso P, Jones G (2010) Predicted impact of climate change on European bats in relation to their biogeographic patterns. Glob Chang Biol 16:561–576
Reddy S, Davalos LM (2003) Geographical sampling bias and its implications for conservation priorities in Africa. J Biogeogr 30:1719–1727
Rodrigues L, Zahn A, Rainho A, Palmeirim JM (2003) Contrasting the roosting behaviour and phenology of an insectivorous bat (Myotis myotis) in its southern and northern distribution ranges. Mammalia 67:321–336
Rubio-Salcedo M, Psomas A, Prieto M, Zimmermann NE, Martínez I (2017) Case study of the implications of climate change for lichen diversity and distributions. Biodivers Conserv 26:1121–1141
Russo D, Di Febbraro M, Rebelo H, Mucedda M, Cistrone L, Agnelli P, De Pasquale PP, Martinolo A, Scaravelli D, Spilinga C, Bosso L (2014) What story does geographic separation of insular bats tell? A case study on Sardinian Rhinolophids. PLoS ONE 9:e110894
Russo D, Di Febbraro M, Cistrone L, Jones G, Smeraldo S, Garonna AP, Bosso L (2015) Protecting one protecting both? Scale-dependent ecological differences in two species using dead trees the rosalia longicorn beetle and the barbastelle bat. J Zool 297:165–175
Russo D, Cistrone L, Budinski I, Console G, Della Corte M, Milighetti C, Ancillotto L (2017) Sociality influences thermoregulation and roost switching in a forest bat using ephemeral roosts. Ecol Evol 7:5310–5321
Silva TL, Vale CG, Godinho R, Fellous A, Hingrat Y, Alves PC, Brito JC (2017) Ecotypes and evolutionary significant units in endangered North African gazelles. Biol J Linnean Soc 122:286–300
Smeraldo S, Di Febbraro M, Ćirović D, Bosso L, Trbojević I, Russo D (2017) Species distribution models as a tool to predict range expansion after reintroduction: a case study on Eurasian beavers (Castor fiber). J Nat Conserv 37:12–20
Speakman JR, Rowland A (1999) Preparing for inactivity: how insectivorous bats deposit a fat store for hibernation. Proc Nutr Soc 58:123–131
Speakman JR, Thomas DW (2003) Physiological ecology and energetics of bats. In: Kunz TH, Fenton MB (eds) Bat ecology. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 430–490
Syfert MM, Smith MJ, Coomes DA (2013) The effects of sampling bias and model complexity on the predictive performance of MaxEnt species distribution models. PLoS ONE 8:e55158
Thuiller W (2003) BIOMOD–optimizing predictions of species distributions and projecting potential future shifts under global change. Glob Chang Biol 9:1353–1362
Thuiller W, Araújo MB, Lavorel S (2004) Do we need land-cover data to model species distributions in Europe? J Biogeog 31(3):353–361
Thuiller W, Richardson DM, Pyšek P, Midgley GF, Hughes GO, Rouget M (2005) Niche-based modelling as a tool for predicting the risk of alien plant invasions at a global scale. Glob Chang Biol 11:2234–2250
Thuiller W, Lafourcade B, Engler R, Araújo MB (2009) BIOMOD–a platform for ensemble forecasting of species distributions. Ecography 32:369–373
Tulloch AI, Sutcliffe P, Naujokaitis-Lewis I, Tingley R, Brotons L, Ferraz KMP, Rhodes JR (2016) Conservation planners tend to ignore improved accuracy of modelled species distributions to focus on multiple threats and ecological processes. Biol Conserv 199:157–171
Tuttle MD, Stevenson D (1982) Growth and survival of bats. In: Kunz TH (ed) Ecology of bats. Plenum Press, New York, pp 105–150
Vale CG, Campos JC, Silva TL, Gonçalves DV, Sow AS, Martínez-Freiría F, Brito JC (2016) Biogeography and conservation of mammals from the West Sahara-Sahel: an application of ecological niche-based models and GIS. Hystrix 27:1–10
Van Horn B (2002) Approaches to habitat modelling: the tensions between pattern and process and between specificity and generality. In: Scott JM et al (eds) Predicting species occurrences: issues of accuracy and scale. Island Press, Washington
Wiens JA (2002) Predicting species occurrences: progress, problems, and prospects. In: Scott JM, Heglund PJ, Morrison ML, Haufler JB, Raphael MG, Wall WA, Samson FB (eds) Predicting species occurrences: issues of accuracy and scale. Island Press, Washington, DC, pp 739–749
Wiens JA, Stralberg D, Jongsomjit D, Howell CA, Snyder MA (2009) Niches models and climate change: assessing the assumptions and uncertainties. Proc Natl Acad Sci 106:19729–19736
Wisz MS, Hijmans RJ, Li J, Peterson AT, Graham CH, Guisan A (2008) Effects of sample size on the performance of species distribution models. Divers Distrib 14:763–773
Zhang J, Nielsen SE, Chen Y, Georges D, Qin Y, Wang SS, Thuiller W (2017) Extinction risk of North American seed plants elevated by climate and land-use change. J Appl Ecol 54:303–312
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank the Eurobats Advisory Committee for providing bat occurrence records for many of the countries within the Agreement range. We also thank two anonymous reviewers for the valuable comments made on a previous ms version.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Communicated by David Hawksworth.
Electronic supplementary material
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Smeraldo, S., Di Febbraro, M., Bosso, L. et al. Ignoring seasonal changes in the ecological niche of non-migratory species may lead to biases in potential distribution models: lessons from bats. Biodivers Conserv 27, 2425–2441 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10531-018-1545-7
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10531-018-1545-7