Abstract
Rip currents are the primary hazard on surf beaches, and early studies described them as fast, shore-normal flows that extended seaward of the surf zone. Based on this traditional view, commonly promoted safety advice was to escape a rip current by swimming parallel to the beach. However, recent studies have shown dominant rip current re-circulation within the surf zone and have endorsed floating as an appropriate escape strategy. Here, a first quantitative assessment of the efficacy of various rip current escape strategies, with a focus on the underlying physical processes, is presented. A field study was conducted at Shelly Beach, NSW, Australia, measuring three rip currents (two open beaches, one topographic) over 3 days in varying wave conditions. Floating was found to be a longer duration, more variable escape strategy (\( \overline{t} \) = 3.8 min, σ = 2.4 min), than swimming parallel (\( \overline{t} \) = 2.2 min, σ = 1.0 min). Neither of the scenarios is 100 % foolproof, and both fail in some scenarios, making simplified safety recommendations difficult. Swim parallel failures are related to swimming against the alongshore current of the rip circulation. Float failures related to surf zone exits, with the highest exit rate occurring in the topographic rip. Float failures also occurred due to multiple re-circulations without the person attaining safe footing on the bar. The variable spatial and temporal behaviour of rip currents suggests that a single escape strategy safety message is inappropriate. Instead, a combined approach and scenario-specific safety advice should be considered by beach safety practitioners to promote to the public.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abt S, Whittle R, Taylor A, Love D (1989) Human stability in a high flood hazard zone. Water Resour Bull 25(4):881–890
Austin M, Scott T, Brown J, Brown J, MacMahan J, Masselink G, Russell P (2010) Temporal observations of rip current circulation on a macro-tidal beach. Cont Shelf Res 30(9):1149–1165
Austin M, Scott T, Russell P, Masselink G (2012) Rip current prediction: development, validation, and evaluation of an operational Tool. J Coastal Res 29(2):283–300
Bowen A (1969) Rip currents: 1. Theoretical investigations. J Geophys Res 74(23):5467–5478
Brander R (1999) Field observations on the morphodynamic evolution of a low-energy rip current system. Mar Geol 157(3):199–217
Brander R, MacMahan J (2011) Future challenges for rip current Res and community outreach. In: Leatherman S, Fletemeyer J (eds) Rip currents—beach safety, physical oceanography, and wave modelling. CRC Press, Boca Raton, pp 1–29
Brander R, Bradstreet A, Sherker S, MacMahan J (2011) Responses of swimmers caught in rip currents: perspectives on mitigating the global rip current hazard. Int J Aquatic Res Educ 5(4):476–482
Brander R, Dominey-Howes D, Champion C, Del Vecchio O, Brighton B (2013) Brief communication: a new perspective on the Australian rip current hazard. Nat Hazards Earth Syst Sci 13(6):1687–1690
Brighton B, Sherker S, Brander R, Thompson M, Bradstreet A (2013) Rip current related drowning deaths and rescues in Australia 2004–2011. Nat Hazards Earth Syst Sci 13(4):1069–1075
Brown J, MacMahan J, Reniers A, Thornton E (2009) Surf zone diffusivity on a rip-channeled beach. J Geophys Res Oceans 114:C11015
Bruneau N, Castelle B, Bonneton P, Pedreros R, Almar R, Bonneton N, Bretel P, Parisot J-P, Sénéchal N (2009) Field observations of an evolving rip current on a meso-macrotidal well-developed inner bar and rip morphology. Cont Shelf Res 29(14):1650–1662
Caldwell N, Houser C, Meyer-Arendt K (2013) Ability of beach users to identify rip currents at Pensacola Beach, Florida. Nat Hazards 68(2):1041–1056
Castelle B, Coco G (2012) The morphodynamics of rip channels on embayed beaches. Cont Shelf Res 43:10–23
Castelle B, Coco G (2013) Surf zone flushing on embayed beaches. Geophys Res Lett 40(10):2206–2210
Castelle B, Michallet H, Marieu V, Leckler F, Dubardier B, Lambert A, Berni C, Bonneton P, Barthélemy E, Bouchette F (2010) Laboratory experiment on rip current circulations over a moveable bed: drifter measurements. J Geophys Res Oceans 115:C12008
CoSMoS (Coastal Storm Modelling System) (2013) Rip currents: Dutch coast. http://cosmos.deltares.nl/RipCurrentsNL/index.html. Accessed Mar 2013
Drozdzewski D, Shaw W, Dominey-Howes D, Brander R, Walton T, Gero A, Sherker S, Goff J, Edwick B (2012) Surveying rip current survivors: preliminary insights into the experiences of being caught in rip currents. Nat Hazards Earth Syst Sci 12(4):1201–1211
Dusek G, Seim H (2013a) A probabilistic rip current forecast model. J Coastal Res 289:909–925
Dusek G, Seim H (2013b) Rip current intensity estimates from lifeguard observations. J Coastal Res 29(3):505–518
Fletemeyer J, Leatherman S (2010) Rip currents and beach safety education. J Coastal Res 261:1–3
Haas K, Svendsen I, Haller M, Zhao Q (2003) Quasi-three-dimensional modeling of rip current systems. J Geophys Res Oceans 108(C7):3217
Haller M, Dalrymple R, Svendsen I (2002) Experimental study of nearshore dynamics on a barred beach with rip channels. J Geophys Res: Oceans 107(C6):3061
Haller M, Honegger D, Catalan P (2013) Rip current observations via Mar radar. J Waterway Port Coastal Ocean Eng. doi:10.1061/(ASCE)WW.1943-5460.0000229
Hartmann D (2006) Drowning and beach-safety management (BSM) along the Mediterranean beaches of Israel—a long-term perspective. J Coastal Res 226:1505–1514
Hatfield J, Williamson A, Sherker S, Brander R, Hayen A (2012) Development and evaluation of an intervention to reduce rip current related beach drowning. Accid Anal Prev 46:45–51
Houser C, Barrett G, Labude D (2011) Alongshore variation in the rip current hazard at Pensacola Beach, Florida. Nat Hazards 57(2):501–523
Johnson D, Pattiaratchi C (2004) Transient rip currents and nearshore circulation on a swell-dominated beach. J Geophys Res Oceans 109:C02026
Klein A, Santana G, Diehl F, Menezes J (2003) Analysis of hazards associated with sea bathing: Results of five years work in oceanic beaches of Santa Catarina State, Southern Brazil. J Coastal Res SI35:107–116
Long J, Özkan-Haller H (2005) Offshore controls on nearshore rip currents. J Geophys Res Oceans 110:C12007
MacMahan J, Reniers A, Thornton E, Stanton T (2004) Surf zone eddies coupled with rip current morphology. J Geophys Res Oceans 109:C07004
MacMahan J, Thornton E, Stanton T, Reniers A (2005) RIPEX: observations of a rip current system. Mar Geol 218(1):113–134
MacMahan J, Brown J, Thornton E (2009) Low-cost handheld global positioning system for measuring surf-zone currents. J Coastal Res 25(3):744–754
MacMahan J, Brown J, Brown J, Thornton E, Reniers A, Stanton T, Henriquez M, Gallagher E, Morrison J, Austin MJ, Scott TM, Senechal N (2010) Mean Lagrangian flow behavior on an open coast rip-channeled beach: a new perspective. Mar Geol 268(1):1–15
MacMahan J, Reniers A, Brown J, Brander R, Thornton E, Stanton T, Brown J, Carey W (2011) An introduction to rip currents based on field observations. J Coastal Res 27(4):III–IV
McCarroll R, Brander R (2013) Spatial variability in circulation and cross-shore exchange across multiple rip channels on an embayed beach. Paper presented at the Coasts and Ports, Sydney, Australia, Sep 2013
MHL (2011) Manly Hydraulics Lab. Offshore wave data, Sydney
Miloshis M, Stephenson WJ (2011) Rip current escape strategies: lessons for swimmers and coastal rescue authorities. Nat Hazards 59(2):823–832
Reniers A, Roelvink J, Thornton E (2004) Morphodynamic modeling of an embayed beach under wave group forcing. J Geophys Res Oceans 109:C01030
Reniers A, MacMahan J, Thornton E, Stanton T (2006) Modelling infragravity motions on a rip-channel beach. Coastal Eng 53(2):209–222
Reniers A, MacMahan J, Thornton E, Stanton T (2007) Modeling of very low frequency motions during RIPEX. J Geophys Res Oceans 112:C07013
Reniers A, MacMahan J, Thornton E, Stanton T, Henriquez M, Brown J, Brown J, Gallagher E (2009) Surf zone surface retention on a rip-channeled beach. J Geophys Res Oceans 114:C10010
RESCDAM (2000) The use of physical models in dam-break flood analysis. Final report of Helsinki University of Technology data, December 2000. Appendix 2 to Final Report of RESCDAM, June 2001
Roelvink D, Reniers A, van Dongeren A, van Thiel de Vries J, McCall R, Lescinski J (2009) Modelling storm impacts on beaches, dunes and barrier islands. Coastal Eng 56(11):1133–1152
Scott T, Masselink G, Austin M, Russell, P (submitted manuscript, 2013) Controls on macrotidal rip current circulation and hazard. [submitted to Geomorphology]
Scott T, Russell P, Masselink G, Wooler A (2009) Rip current variability and hazard along a macro-tidal coast. J Coastal Res SI 50:1–6
Shepard F, Emery K, La Fond E (1941) Rip currents: A process of geological importance. J Geol: 337-369
Sherker S, Williamson A, Hatfield J, Brander R, Hayen A (2010) Beachgoers’ beliefs and behaviours in relation to beach flags and rip currents. Accid Anal Prev 42(6):1785–1804
Short A (2007) Australian rip systems—friend or foe? J Coastal Res SI50: 7–11
Short A (2010) Role of geological inheritance in Australian beach morphodynamics. Coastal Eng 57(2):92–97
Short A, Hogan C (1994) Rip currents and beach hazards: Their impact on public safety and implications for coastal management. J Coastal Res SI12:197–209
Short A, Masselink G (1999) Embayed and structurally controlled beaches. In: Short AD (ed) Handbook of beach and shoreface morphodynamics. Wiley, Chichester, pp 230–250
Short A, Trenaman N (1992) Wave climate of the Sydney region, an energetic and highly variable ocean wave regime. Mar Freshw Res 43(4):765–791
Song D, Bae H, Furmanczyk K (2011) Observation and forecasting of rip current generation in Haeundae Beach, Korea, Plan and Experiment. J Coastal Res SI64:946–950
Spydell M, Feddersen F, Guza R, Schmidt W (2007) Observing surf-zone dispersion with drifters. J Phys Oceanography 37(12):2920–2939
HR Wallingford (2005) R&D outputs: Flood risks to people, Phase 2, FD2321/TR1, The risks to people methodology, 92 pp
Williamson A, Hatfield J, Sherker S, Brander R, Hayen A (2012) A comparison of attitudes and knowledge of beach safety in Australia for beachgoers, rural residents and international tourists. Aus N Z J Public Health 36(4):385–391
Winter G, Dongeren van A, Schipper de M, Thiel de Vries van J (2012) Rip Current Observations at Egmond aan Zee. Paper presented at the NCK-Days: Crossing Borders in Coastal Research, Enschede, the Netherlands, March 2012
Wright L, Short A (1984) Morphodynamic variability of surf zones and beaches: a synthesis. Mar Geol 56:93–118
Wright L, Cowell P, Coffey F (1980) Nearshore oceanography and morphodynamics of the Broken Bay-Palm Beach region, NSW: Implications for offshore dredging. Coastal Studies Unit, Tech. Rep. No. 80/1, University of Sydney, 208 pp
Acknowledgments
This project was funded by Australian Research Council (ARC) Linkage Project LP110200134 and by Surf Life Saving Australia (SLSA). MacMahan and Brown were also supported by NSF OCE-0926750. Thank you to Patrick Rynne for his video documentary of the experiment (http://waterlust.org/RIP.html). Special thanks to the many volunteers who helped with the fieldwork, particularly the swimmers and floaters.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
McCarroll, R.J., Brander, R.W., MacMahan, J.H. et al. Evaluation of swimmer-based rip current escape strategies. Nat Hazards 71, 1821–1846 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11069-013-0979-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11069-013-0979-1