Abstract
In this work, we are interested in studying the effect of the addition of three heterocyclic organic compound derived from imidazole, namely 2-(1,4,5-triphenyl-1H-imidazol-2-yl)phenol (IM-OH), 1,4,5-triphenyl-2-(4-metyoxyphenyl)-1H-imidazole (IM-OCH3), and 3-methoxy-4-(1,4,5-triphenyl-1H-imidazol-2-yl)phenol (IM-H) on the corrosion inhibition of mild steel in acidic medium H2SO4 0.5 M. This study was performed using weight loss and electrochemical and theoretical investigations. The obtained results indicate that IM-OH, IM-OCH3, and IM-H act as excellent inhibitors for mild steel in H2SO4 0.5 M. The results obtained from the electrochemical methods show that IM-OH, IM-OCH3, and IM-H imparted high resistance and behave as mixed type inhibitors. Inhibition efficiency (IE %) increases with the increase of inhibitors concentration to attain 97.7%, 98.9%, and 88.9% at 10−3 M of IM-OH, IM-OCH3, and IM-H respectively. EIS data is analyzed to model the inhibition process through appropriate equivalent circuit model. Thermodynamic and kinetic parameters controlling the adsorption process are calculated and discussed. In addition, the surface of the mild steel has been analyzed by the SEM-EDAX. The theoretical results were in good agreement with experimental measurements.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Rbaa M, Galai M, Benhiba F, Obot IB, Oudda H, EbnTouhami M, Zarrouk A (2018) Synthesis and investigation of quinazoline derivatives based on 8-hydroxyquinoline as corrosion inhibitors for mild steel in acidic environment: experimental and theoretical studies. Ionics 2:1–19. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11581-018-2817-7
Shylesh BS, Ventkatesh TV, Praveen BM (2011) Corrosion inhibition studies of mild steel by new inhibitor in different corrosive medium. Res J Chem Sci 1(7):46–50
Tebhji K, Hammouti B, Oudda H, Ramdani A, Benkadour A (2005) The inhibitive effect of bipyrazolic derivatives on the corrosion of steel in hydrochloric acid solution. Appl Surf Sci 252:1378–1385
Fouda AS, Ismail MA, Al-Khamri AA, Abousalem AS (2019) Experimental, quantum chemical and molecular dynamic studies on the action of arylthiophene derivatives as acid corrosion inhibitors. J Mol Liq 290:111178. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.molliq.2019.111178
Moradi Z, Attar MM (2014) An investigation on the inhibitory action of benzazole derivatives as a consequence of sulfur atom induction. Appl Surf Sci 317:657–665
Shivakumar SS, Mohana KN (2012) Cantellaasiatica extracts as green corrosion inhibitors for mild steel in 0.5 M H2SO4. Adv Appl Sci Res 3:3097–3106
Galai M, El Faydy M, El Kacimi Y, Dahmani K, Alaoui K, Touir R, Lakhrissi B, EbnTouhami M (2017) Portugaliae Electrochimica Acta 35:233
Hammouti B, Aouniti A, Taleb M, Brighli M, Kertit S (1995) L-methionine methyl ester hydrochloride as a corrosion inhibitor of iron in acid chloride solution. Corrosion 51:411–416
El-Ouafi A, Hammouti B, Oudda H, Kertit S, Touzani R, Ramdani A (2002) New bipyrazole derivatives as effective inhibitors for the corrosion of mild steel in 1M HCI medium. Anti-Corros Meth Mater 49:199–204
Salghi R, Bazzi L, Hammouti B, Bouchtart A, Kertit S, AitAddi ZA, EL Alami Z (2000) Étude électrochimique de l'inhibition de la corrosion de l'alliage d'aluminium 3003 en milieu bicarbonate par les composés triazolique. Ann Chim Sci Mater 25:187–200
Bentiss F, Traisnel M, Gengembre L, Lagrene’e M (1999) A new triazole derivative as inhibitor of the acid corrosion of mild steel: electrochemical studies, weight loss determination, SEM and XPS. Appl Surf Sci 152:237–249
Alaoui K, Touir R, Galai M, Serrar H, Ouakki M, Kaya S, Tüzün B, Boukhris S, EbnTouhami M, El Kacimi Y (2018) Electrochemical and computational studies of some triazepine carboxylate compounds as acid corrosion inhibitors for mild steel. Journal of Bio- and Tribo-Corrosion 4:37
Alaoui K, Ouakki M, Abousalem AS, Serrar H, Galai M, Derbali S, Nouneh K, Boukhris S, EbnTouhami M, El Kacimi Y (2019) Molecular dynamics, Monte-Carlo simulations and atomic force microscopy to study the interfacial adsorption behaviour of some triazepine carboxylate compounds as corrosion inhibitors in acid medium. Journal of Bio- and Tribo-Corrosion 5:1
Kertit S, Essouffi H, Hammouti B, Benkaddour M (1998) 1-phenyl-5-mercapto-1,2,3,4-tétrazole (PMT): un nouvel inhibiteur de corrosion de l’alliage Cu-Zn efficace à très faible concentration. J Chim Phys 95:2072
Ech-chihbi E, Salim R, Oudda H, Elaatiaoui A, Rais Z, Oussaid A, El Hajjaji F, Hammouti B, Elmsellem H, Taleb M (2016) Effect of some imidazopyridine compounds on carbon steel corrosion in hydrochloric acid solution. Der Pharma Chemica 8(13):214–230
Ech-chihbi E, Belghiti ME, Salim R, Oudda H, Taleb M, Benchat N, Hammouti B, El-Hajjaji F (2017) Experimental and computational studies on the inhibition performance of the organic compound “2-phenylimidazo [1,2-a]pyrimidine-3-carbaldehyde” against the corrosion of carbon steel in 1.0 M HCl solution. J Surf Interfaces 9:206–217
Galai M, Rbaa M, El Kacimi Y, Ouakki M, Dkhirech N, Touir R, Lakhrissi B, EbnTouhami M (2016) Anal Bioanal Electrochem 9:80
Rbaa M, Galai M, El Kacimi Y, Ouakki M, Touir R, Lakhrissi B, EbnTouhami M (2017) PortugaliaeElectrochimica Acta 35(6):323–338
Ouakki M, Rbaa M, Galai M, Lakhrissi B, Rifi EH, Cherkaoui M (2018) Experimental and quantum chemical investigation of imidazole derivatives as corrosion inhibitors on mild steel in 1.0 M hydrochloric acid. Journal of Bio-and Tribo-Corrosion 4:35
Ouakki M, Galai M, Rbaa M, Abousalem AS, Lakhrissi B, Rifi EH, Cherkaoui M (2019) Quantum chemical and experimental evaluation of the inhibitory action of two imidazole derivatives on mild steel corrosion in sulphuric acid medium. Heliyon 5:e02759
Matjaz F, Jennifer J (2014) Application of corrosion inhibitors for steels in acidic media for the oil and gas industry: a review, Corros. Sci 86:17–41
Salim R, Elaatiaoui A, Benchat N, Ech-chihbi E, Rais Z, Oudda H, El Hajjaji F, El Aoufir Y, Taleb M (2017) Corrosion behavior of a smart inhibitor in hydrochloric acid molar: experimental and theoretical studies. JMES 8(10):3747–3758
Gupta NK, Verma C, Quraishi MA, Mukherjee AK (2016) Schiff's bases derived from l-lysine and aromatic aldehydes as green corrosion inhibitors for mild steel: experimental and theoretical studies. J Mol Liq 215:47–57
EmregülKC, Atakol O (2003) Mater. Chem. Phys 82: 188–193
ASTM G-81, (1995) Annual book of ASTM standards
Dhanapala A, Boopathy SR, Balasubramanian V (2012) Influence of pH value, chloride ion concentration and immersion time on corrosion rate of friction stir welded AZ61A magnesium alloy weldments. J Alloys Compd 523:49–60
Scendo M (2008) Inhibition of copper corrosion in sodium nitrate solutions with nontoxic inhibitors. Corros Sci 50:1584–1592
Hermas AA, Morad MS (2008) Corros. Sci 50 (9):2710–2717
Liu FG, Du M, Zhang J, Qiu M (2009) Corros. Sci 51 (1) :102–109
Fouda AS, Ismail MA, GY EL-e, Abousalem AS (2017) Evaluation of 4-amidinophenyl-2, 2′-bithiophene and its aza-analogue as novel corrosion inhibitors for CS in acidic media: experimental and theoretical study. J Mol Liq 240:372–388
Abousalem AS, Ismail MA, Fouda AS (2018) A complementary experimental and in silico studies on the action of fluorophenyl-2,2′-bichalcophenes as ecofriendly corrosion inhibitors and biocide agents. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.molliq.2018.11.125
El Belghiti M, Karzazi Y, Dafali A, Hammouti B, Bentiss F, Obot IB, Bahadur I, Ebenso EE (2016) Experimental, quantum chemical and Monte Carlo simulation studies of 3,5-disubstituted-4-amino-1,2,4-triazoles as corrosion inhibitors on mild steel in acidic medium. J Mol Liq 218:281–293
Frisch A (2009) Gaussian 09W, Wallingford USA 25
Rahmani H, IsmailyAlaoui K, Emran KM, El Hallaoui A, Taleb M, El Hajji S, Labriti B, Ech-chihbi E, Hammouti B, El-Hajjaji F (2019) Experimental and DFT investigation on the corrosion inhibition of mild steel by 1, 2, 3- triazole regioisomers in 1M hydrochloric acid solution, Int. J Electrochem Sci 14:985–998
Elemike Elias E, Nwankwo Henry U, Onwudiwe Damian C, Hosten Eric C (2017) Synthesis, crystal structures, quantum chemical studies and corrosion inhibition potentials of 4-(((4 ethylphenyl)imino)methyl)phenol and (E)-4-((naphthalen-2- ylimino) methyl) phenol Schiff bases. J Mol Struct 1147:252–265
Yadav DK, Quraishi MA (2012) Electrochemical investigation of substituted pyranopyrazoles adsorption on mild steel in acid solution. Ind Eng Chem Res 51:8194–82100
Hmamou DB, Salghi R, Zarrouk A, Aouad MR, Benali O, Zarrok H, Messali M, Hammouti B, Kabanda M, Bouachrine M, Ebenso EE (2013) Weight loss, electrochemical, quantum chemical calculation, and molecular dynamics simulation studies on 2-(Benzylthio)-1,4,5-triphenyl-1H-imidazole as an inhibitor for carbon steel corrosion in hydrochloric acid. Ind Eng Chem Res 52:14315–14327
Obot B, Obi-Egbedi NO (2011) Anti-corrosive properties of xanthone on mild steel corrosion in sulphuric acid: experimental and theoretical investigations. Curr Appl Phys 11:382–392
Popova A, Christov M, Raicheva S, Sokolova E (2004) Corros. Sci 46:1333–1350
Ahamad I, Quraishi MA (2010) Corros. Sci 52:651–656
Dkhireche N, MouhsineGalai YEK, Rbaa M, Ouakki M, BrahimLakhrissi MET (2018) New Quinoline derivatives as sulfuric acid inhibitor’s for mild steel. Anal Bioanal Electrochem 10(1):111–135
Hegazy MA, Hasan AM, Emara MM, Bakr MF, Youssef AH (2012) Corros. Sci 65:67–76
Ashassi-Sarkhadi, Asghri E (2008). Electrochim. Acta 54:162
Abbas A, Fazakas É, Török T (2018) Corrosion studies of steel rebar samples in neu- tral sodium chloride solution also in the presence of a bio-based (green) in- hibitor. Int J Corros Scale Inhib 7:38–47
Kalaiselvi K, Chung I-M, Kim S-H, Prabakaran M (2018) Corrosion resistance of mild steel in sulphuric acid solution by Coreopsis tinctoria extract: electrochemical and surface studies. Anti Corros Methods Mater 65(4):408–416
Fidrusli A, Mahmood M (2018) Ginger extract as green corrosion inhibitor of mild steel in hydrochloric acid solution. In: Proceedings of the IOP conference series: materials science and engineering, IOP Publishing 290: 012087
Dehghani A, Bahlakeh G, Ramezanzadeh B, Ramezanzadeh M (2019) Detailed macro−/micro-scale exploration of the excellent active corrosion inhibition of a novel environmentally friendly green inhibitor for carbon steel in acidic environments. J Taiwan Inst Chem Eng 100:239–261
Tang Y, Yang X, Yang W, Wan R, Chen Y, Yin X (2010) A preliminary investigation of corrosion inhibition of mild steel in 0.5 M H2SO4 by 2-amino-5-(n-pyridyl)-1,3,4- thiadiazole: polarization, EIS and molecular dynamics simulations. Corros Sci 52:1801–1808
Saleh MM, Atia AA (2006) Effects of structure of the ionic head of cationic surfactant on its inhibition of acid corrosion of mild steel. J Appl Electrochem 36:899–905
Solomon MM, Umoren SA (2016) In-situ preparation, characterization and anticorrosion property of polypropylene glycol/silver nanoparticles composite for mild steel corrosion in acid solution. J Colloid Interface Sci 462:29–41
Ferreira ES, Giancomelli C, Spinelli A (2004) Evaluation of the inhibitor effect of 1-ascorbic acid on the corrosion of mild steel. Mater Chem Phys 1:129–134
Li X, Deng S, Hui F (2011) Corros. Sci 53 :302–309
Deng S, Li X, Hui F (2011) Corros. Sci 53:3596–3602
Naseri E, Hajisafari M, Kosari A, Talari M, Hosseinpour S, Davoodi A (2018) In- hibitive effect of clopidogrel as a green corrosion inhibitor for mild steel; statistical modeling and quantum Monte Carlo simulation studies. J Mol Liq 269:193–202
Srivastava M, Tiwari P, Srivastava S, Kumar A, Ji G, Prakash R (2018) Low cost aque- ous extract of Pisum sativum peels for inhibition of mild steel corrosion. J Mol Liq 254:357–368
Asan A, Soylu S, Kıyak T, Yıldırım F, Oztas SG, Ancın N, Kabasakaloğlu M (2006) Corros. Sci 48:3933
El Mehdi B, Mernari B, Traisnel M, Bentiss F, Lagrenee M (2003) Synthesis and comparative study of the inhibitive effect of some new triazole derivatives towards corrosion of mild steel in hydrochloric acid solution. Mater Chem Phys 77:489–496
Moussa Ouakki, MouhsineGalai, Mohammed Cherkaoui, El-HousseineRifi, Zineb Hatim (2018) Anal. Bioanal. Electrochem 10(7):943–960
Singh AK, Quraishi MA (2009) Corros. Sci 51:2752
Kadiri L, Galai M, Ouakki M, Essaadaoui Y, Ouass A, Cherkaoui M, Rifi EH, Lebkiri A (2018) Anal. Bioanal. Electrochem 10 :249
Ouakki M, Galai M, Cherkaoui M, Rifi EH, Hatim Z (2020) J Chem Technol Metall 55(2): 436–448
Singh AK, Quraishi MA (2010) The effect of some bis-thiadiazole derivatives on the corrosion of mild steel in hydrochloric acid. Corros Sci 52:1373–1385
M'hanni N, Galai M, Anik T, EbnTouhami M, Rifi EH, Asfari Z, Touir R (2017) Surface CoatingsTechnol 310: 8
Galai M, Ouassir J, EbnTouhami M, Nassali H, Benqlilou H, Belhaj T, Berrami K, Mansouri I, Oauki B (2017) α-Brass and (α+ β) brass degradation processes in Azrou soil medium used in plumbing devices. Journal of Bio-and Tribo-Corrosion 3:30
Zheng X, Zhang S, Li W, Yin L, He J, Wua J (2014) Corros. Sci 80:383
Hegazy MA, Abdallah M, Awad MK, Rezk M (2014) Three novel di-quaternary ammonium salts as corrosion inhibitors for API X65 steel pipeline in acidic solution. Part I: experimental results. Corros Sci 81:54–64
El-TaibHeakal F, Fouda A S, Radwan MS (2011) Int J Electrochem Sci 6:3140
MayakrishnanPrabakaran S-HK, NithiyanandhamMugila VH, Parameswari K, Chitra S, Chung I-M (2017) Aster koraiensis as nontoxic corrosion inhibitor for mild steel in sulfuric acid. J Ind Eng Chem 52:235–242
Sherif EM, Erasmus RM, Comins JD (2008) Corros. Sci 50:3439
AshassiSorkhabi H, Seifzadeh D, Hosseini M G (2008) Corros. Sci 50: 3363
Tao Z, Zhang S, Li W, Hou B (2009) Corros. Sci 51: 2588
Verma C, Olasunkanmi LO, Obot IB, Ebensob Eno E, Quraishi MA (2016) 5-Arylpyrimido-[4,5-b]quinoline-diones as new and sustainable corrosion inhibitors for mild steel in 1 M HCl: a combined experimental and theoretical approach. RSC Adv 6:15639–15654
Hu Z, Meng Y, Ma X, Zhu H, Li J, Li C, Cao D (2016) Experimental and theoretical studies of benzothiazole derivatives as corrosion inhibitors for carbon steel in 1 M HCl. Corros Sci 112:563–575
Zarrouk A, Hammouti B, Lakhlifi T, Traisnel M, Vezin H, Bentiss F (2015) New 1 H-pyrrole-2,5-dione derivatives as efficient organic inhibitors of carbon steel corrosion in hydrochloric acid medium: electrochemical, XPS and DFT studies. Corros Sci 90:572–584
Kalman E, Varhegi B, Bako I, Felhosi I, Karman FH, Shaban A (1994) Corrosion inhibition by 1-hydroxy-ethane-1, 1-diphosphonic acid an electrochemical impedance spectroscopy study. J Electrochem Soc 141:3357–3360
Abdel-Gaber A, Abd-El-Nabey B, Sidahmed I, El-Zayady A, Saadawy M (2006) Corros. Sci 48 (9):2765–2779
Do D (1998) Adsorption analysis: equilibria and kinetics. Imperial College Press, London
Bockris O’M, KhanS U M (1993) Surface electrochemistry-a molecular level approach New York, Plenum 1014
Langmuir I (1916) The constitution and fundamental properties of solids and liquids. J Am Chem Soc 38(11):2221–2295
Tempkin MI, Pyzhev V (1940) Kinetics of ammonia synthesis on promoted iron catalyst. Acta Phys Chim USSR 12:327–356
Freundlich HMF (1906) Over the adsorption in solution. J Phys Chem 57:385–471
Frumkin AN (1925) Z Phys Chem 116:466
Horsfall M, Spiff AI (2005) Equilibrium sorption study of Al3+, Co2+ and Ag2+ in aqueous solutions by fluted pumpkin (Telfairiaoccidentalis HOOK) waste biomass. Acta Chim Slov 52:174–181
Kastening B, Holleck L (1965) Talanta 12:1259
El-Awady AA, Abd-El-Nabey BA, Aziz SG (1992) Kinetic-thermodynamic and adsorption isotherms analyses for the inhibition of the acid corrosion of steel by cyclic and open-chain amines. J Electrochem Soc 139:2149
Flis J, Zakroczymski T (1996) Impedance study of reinforcing steel in simulated pore solution with tannin. J Electrochem Soc 143:2458
Khadom A A, Yaro A S; Abdul A H (2010) J Chilean Chem Soc 55:150–152
Boumhara K, Tabyaoui M, Jama C, Bentiss F (2015) Artemisia Mesatlantica essential oil as green inhibitor for carbon steel corrosion in 1M HCl solution: electrochemical and XPS investigations. J Ind Eng Chem 29:146–155
Halambek J, Berkovic K, Vorkapic-Furac J (2010) The influence of Lavandula angustifolia L. oil on corrosion of Al-3Mg alloy. Corros Sci 52:3978–3983
Behpour M, Ghoreishi SM, Mohammadi N, Soltani N, Salavati-Niasari M (2010) Investigation of some Schiff base compounds containing disulfide bond as HCl corrosion inhibitors for mild steel. Corros Sci 52:4046–4057
Eteram A N, Aisha A H (2008) Mater Chem Phys 110:145
Singh AK, Quraishi MA (2011) Investigation of the effect of disulfiram on corrosion of mild steel in hydrochloric acid solution. Corros Sci 53:1288–1297
Nesic S (2007) Key issues related to modelling of internal corrosion of oil and gas pipelines-a review. Corros Sci 49:4308–4338
Shaban SM, Abd-Elaal AA, Tawfik SM (2016) Gravimetric and electrochemical evaluation of three nonionic dithiol surfactants as corrosion inhibitors for mild steel in 1 M HCl solution. J Mol Liq 216:392–400
Ali SA, El-Shareef AM, Al-Ghamdi RF, Saeed MT (2005) The isoxazolidines: the effects of steric factor and hydrophobic chain length on the corrosion inhibition of mild steel in acidic medium. Corros Sci 47:2659–2678
Khrifou R, Galai M, El Bakri H, Larhzil H, Touir R, Ebn Touhami M, Ramli Y (2019) Corrosion inhibition of brass in phosphoric acid solution by 2-(5-methyl-2-nitro-1H-imidazol-1-yl)ethyl benzoate. Chem Data Collect 24:100303
Yadav M, Kumar S, Tiwari N, Bahadur I, Ebenso EE (2015) Experimental and quantum chemical studies of synthesized triazine derivatives as an efficient corrosion inhibitor for N80 steel in acidic medium. J Mol Liq 212:151–167
Martinez S, Stern I (2002) Thermodynamic characterization of metal dissolution and inhibitor adsorption processes in the low carbon steel/mimosa tannin/sulfuric acid system. Appl Surf Sci 199:83–89
Elachouri M, Hajji MS, Salem M, Kertit S, Aride J, Coudert R, Essassi E (1996) Corros52: 103
Olasunkanmi LO, Obot IB, Kabanda MM, Ebenso EE (2015) Some Quinoxalin-6-yl derivatives as corrosion inhibitors for mild steel in hydrochloric acid: experimental and theoretical studies. J Phys Chem C 119(28):16004–16019
Yadav M, Kumar S, Sinha RR, Bahadur I, Ebenso EE (2015) New pyrimidine derivatives as efficient organic inhibitors on mild steel corrosion in acidic medium: electrochemical, SEM, EDX, AFM and DFT studies. J Mol Liq 211:135–145
Verma C, Quraishi MA, Obot IB, Ebenso EE (2019) Effect of substituent dependent molecular structure on anti-corrosive behavior of one-pot multicomponent synthesized pyrimido [2,1-B] benzothiazoles: computer modelling supported experimental studies. J Mol Liq 287:110972
Marvin Sketch Software, Version: 18.22, Chem Axon Ltd., 2018
Raja G, Saravanan K, Sivakumar S (2015) Quantum chemical investigations on benzene derivative: a DFT study. Rasayan J Chem 8(1):37–41
Migahed MA, El-Rabiei MM, Nady H, Elgendy A, Zaki EG, Abdou MI, Noamy ES (2017) Novel ionic liquid compound act as sweet corrosion inhibitors for X-65 carbon tubing steel: experimental and theoretical studies. J Bio-Tribo Corros 3:31
Allam NK (2007) Thermodynamic and quantum chemistry characterization of the adsorption of triazole derivatives during Muntz corrosion in acidic and neutral solutions. Appl Surf Sci 253:4570–4577
Ibeji CU, Adejoro IA, Adeleke BB (2015) A benchmark study on the properties of unsubstituted and some substituted polypyrroles. J Phys Chem Biophys 5(6):193/1–193/11
Elmsellem H, Elyoussfi A, Steli H, Sebbar NK, Essassi EM, Dahmani M, El Ouadi Y, Aouniti A, El Mahi B, Hammouti B (2016) Der Pharma Chem 8 (1): 248–256
Fouda AS, Ismail MA, Abousalem AS, Elewady GY (2017) Experimental and theoretical studies on corrosion inhibition of 4-amidinophenyl-2, 2′-bifuran and its analogues in acidic media. RSC Adv 7(73):46414–46430
Verma C, Lgaz H, Verma DK, Ebenso EE, Bahadur I, Quraishi MA (2018) Molecular dynamics and Monte Carlo simulations as powerful tools for study of interfacial adsorption behavior of corrosion inhibitors in aqueous phase: a review. J Mol Liq 260:99–120
Fouda AS, Ismail MA, Mostafa A, Abousalem AS (2019) Comprehensive investigations on the action of cationic terthiophene and bithiophene as corrosion inhibitors: experimental and theoretical studies. New J Chem 43:768–789
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Ouakki, M., Galai, M., Rbaa, M. et al. Investigation of imidazole derivatives as corrosion inhibitors for mild steel in sulfuric acidic environment: experimental and theoretical studies. Ionics 26, 5251–5272 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11581-020-03643-0
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11581-020-03643-0