Abstract
The analytical hierarchy process (AHP) is one of the most effective methods for criteria ranking/weighting to have been successfully incorporated into GIS analyses. We present a new method for optimizing pairwise comparison decision-making matrices in AHP method, which has been developed on the basis of an interval pairwise comparison matrix (IPCM) derived from expert knowledge. The method has been used for criteria ranking in land subsidence susceptibility mapping (LSSM) as a practical test case, for which an interval matrix was generated by pairwise comparison. To compare the capability of the AHP method (a traditional approach) with that of the proposed IPCM method (a novel approach), 11 creations of LSSM were ranked using each approach in turn. The criteria weightings obtained were then used to produce LSSM maps based on each of these approaches. The results were tested against a data set of known land subsidence occurrences, indicating an improvement in accuracy of about 14% in the LSSM map that was developed using the IPCM method. This improvement was achieved by minimizing the uncertainty associated with criteria ranking/weighting in a traditional AHP and could form a basis for future research into minimizing the uncertainty in weightings derived using the AHP method. Our results will be of considerable importance for researchers involved in GIS-based multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) and those dealing with GIS-based spatial decision-making methods.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Ahmadi SH, Sedghamiz A (2007) Geostatistical analysis of spatial and temporal variations of groundwater level. Environ Monit Assess 129(1–3):277–294
Brunelli M (2014) Introduction to the analytic hierarchy process. Springer, Berlin
Cabrera-Barona P, Ghorbanzadeh O (2018) Comparing classic and interval analytical hierarchy process methodologies for measuring area-level deprivation to analyze health inequalities. Int J Environ Res Public Health 15(1):140
Carmone FJ, Kara A, Zanakis SH (1997) A Monte Carlo investigation of incomplete pairwise comparison matrices in AHP. Eur J Oper Res 102:538–553
Carver SJ (1991) Integrating multi-criteria evaluation with geographical information systems. Int J Geogr Inf Syst 5:321–339
Chai JC, Shen SL, Zhu HH, Zhang XL (2004) Land subsidence due to groundwater drawdown in Shanghai. Geotech 54(2):143–147
Chen J, Zhu Q (2010) Uncertainty and decision strategy analysis of GIS-based ordered weighted averaging method. In: Information networking and automation (ICINA), int conference on 2010 Oct 18, vol 1. IEEE, pp V1–375
Chen Y, Khan S, Paydar Z (2010) To retire or expand? A fuzzy GIS-based spatial multi-criteria evaluation framework for irrigated agriculture. Irrig Drain 59:174–188
Chen VY, Lien HP, Liu CH, Liou JJ, Tzeng GH, Yang LS (2011) Fuzzy MCDM approach for selecting the best environment-watershed plan. Appl Soft Comput 11:265–275
Dehghani M, Rastegarfar M, Ashrafi RA, Ghazipour N, Khorramrooz HR (2014) Interferometric SAR and geospatial techniques used for subsidence study in the Rafsanjan plain. Am J Environ Eng 4:32–40
Deng H (1999) Multicriteria analysis with fuzzy pairwise comparison. Int J Approx Reason 21:215–231
Eastman JR, Toledano J, Jin W, Kyem PA (1993) Participatory multi-objective decision-making in GIS. In: Autocarto-conference. ASPRS American society for photogrammetry, pp 33–33
Fakhri MS, Moghaddam AA, Najib MO, Barzegar R (2015) Investigation of nitrate concentrations in groundwater resources of Marand plain and groundwater vulnerability assessment using AVI and gods methods. J Environ Stud 41(1):15
Fawcett T (2006) An introduction to ROC analysis. Pattern Recognit Lett 27:861–874
Feizizadeh B, Blaschke T (2011) Landslide risk assessment based on GIS multi-criteria evaluation: a case study in Bostan-Abad County, Iran. J Earth Sci Eng 1:1
Feizizadeh B, Blaschke T (2012) Uncertainty analysis of GIS-based ordered weighted averaging method for landslide susceptibility mapping in Urmia Lake Basin, Iran. In: Proceedings of GIScience
Feizizadeh B, Blaschke T (2013a) Land suitability analysis for Tabriz County, Iran: a multi-criteria evaluation approach using GIS. J Environ Plann Man 56:1–23
Feizizadeh B, Blaschke T (2013b) GIS-multicriteria decision analysis for landslide susceptibility mapping: comparing three methods for the Urmia lake basin, Iran. Nat Hazards 65:2105–2128
Feizizadeh B, Blaschke T (2014) An uncertainty and sensitivity analysis approach for GIS-based multicriteria landslide susceptibility mapping. Int J Geogr Inf Sci 28:610–638
Feizizadeh B, Ghorbanzadeh O (2017) GIS-based interval pairwise comparison matrices as a novel approach for optimizing an analytical hierarchy process and multiple criteria weighting. GI_Forum 1: 27–35
Feizizadeh B, Kienberger S (2017) Spatially explicit sensitivity and uncertainty analysis for multicriteria-based vulnerability assessment. J Environ Plann Man 1:1–23
Feizizadeh B, Roodposhti MS, Jankowski P, Blaschke T (2014a) A GIS-based extended fuzzy multi-criteria evaluation for landslide susceptibility mapping. Comput Geosci 73:208–221
Feizizadeh B, Jankowski P, Blaschke T (2014b) A GIS based spatially-explicit sensitivity and uncertainty analysis approach for multi-criteria decision analysis. Comput Geosci 64:81–95
Feizizadeh B, Kienberger S, Kamran KV (2015) Sensitivity and uncertainty analysis approach for GIS-MCDA based economic vulnerability assessment. GI_Forum 2015:81–89
Feizizadeh B, Roodposhti MS, Blaschke T, Aryal J (2017) Comparing GIS-based support vector machine kernel functions for landslide susceptibility mapping. Arab J Geosci 10:122
Ganguli M (2011) Groundwater withdrawal and land subsidence: a study of Singur Block, West Bengal, India. Int J Geomat Geosci 2:465
Gaspar JL, Goulart C, Queiroz G, Silveira D, Gomes A (2004) Dynamic structure and data sets of a GIS database for geological risk analysis in the Azores volcanic islands. Nat Hazards Earth Syst Sci 4:233–242
Ghorbanzadeh O, Feizizadeh B, Blaschke T (2017) Multi-criteria risk evaluation by integrating an analytical network process approach into GIS-based sensitivity and uncertainty analyses. Geomat Nat Hazards Risk 1:25
Goodwin P, Wright G (2009) Decision analysis for management judgment. Wiley, New York
Gorsevski PV, Gessler PE, Foltz RB, Elliot WJ (2006) Spatial prediction of landslide hazard using logistic regression and ROC analysis. Trans GIS 10:395–415
Gorsevski PV, Donevska KR, Mitrovski CD, Frizado JP (2012) Integrating multi-criteria evaluation techniques with geographic information systems for landfill site selection: a case study using ordered weighted average. Waste Manag 32:287–296
Greene R, Devillers R, Luther JE, Eddy BG (2011) GIS-Based Multiple-Criteria Decision Analysis. Geography Compass 5:412–432
Hu RL, Yue ZQ, Wang LU, Wang SJ (2004) Review on current status and challenging issues of land subsidence in China. Eng Geol 76(1–2):65–77
Huang B (2017) Comprehensive geographic information systems. Elsevier, Amsterdam
Iranian Census Centre (2016) Iranian cities population [online]. http://www.amar.org.ir
Ishizaka A, Balkenborg D, Kaplan T (2011) Does AHP help us make a choice? An experimental evaluation. J Oper Res Soc 62:1801–1812
Jadidi MR, Sabouhi Sabouni M, Homayounifar M, Mohammadi A (2012) Assessment of energy use pattern for tomato production in Iran: a case study from the Marand region. Res Agric Eng 58(2):50–56
Jahanshahloo G, Hoseinzadeh F, Barzegarinegad A, Hatamaian H (2012) Weight gain for interval pairwise matrices in the AHP with area of confidence by DEA method. In: Proceedings of the 4th national conference of data envelopment analysis, vol 1. University of Mazandaran, Sari, p 3
Kaleyski N (2014) Eigenvalues of symmetric interval matrices. BC. Thesis, Charles University, Prague, p 71
Kaliraj S, Chandrasekar N, Magesh NS (2014) Identification of potential groundwater recharge zones in Vaigai upper basin, Tamil Nadu, using GIS-based analytical hierarchical process (AHP) technique. Arab J Geosci 7(4):1385–1401
Kavzoglu T, Sahin EK, Colkesen I (2014) Landslide susceptibility mapping using GIS-based multi-criteria decision analysis, support vector machines, and logistic regression. Landslides 11(3):425–439
Khan S, Faisal MN (2008) An analytic network process model for municipal solid waste disposal options. Waste management 28:1500–1508
Khandan R (2011) Analysis acceptable consistency of interval comparison matrices and obtaining their weights. M.Sc. Thesis, University of Qom, Qom, p 67
Khorrami B (2016) Assessment of groundwater withdrawal applying GIS [M.Sc. thesis]. University of Tabriz, Tabriz, p 110
Kritikos TR, Davies TR (2011) GIS-based multi-criteria decision analysis for landslide susceptibility mapping at northern Evia, Greece [GIS-basierte multikriterielle Entscheidungsanalysen zur Kartierung von Massenverlagerungspotenzialen im nördlichen Evia, Griechenland.]. Zeitschrift der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Geowissenschaften 162:421–434
Kułakowski K (2015) Notes on order preservation and consistency in AHP. Eur J Oper Res 245:333–337
Lai SK (1995) A preference-based interpretation of AHP. Omega 23:453–462
Lan J, Lin J, Cao L (2009) An information mining method for deriving weights from an interval comparison matrix. Math Comput Model 50:393–400
Lashkaripour GR, Asghari-Moghaddam A, Allaf-Najib M (2005) The effects of water table decline on the groundwater quality in Marand Plain, Northwest Iran. Iran Int J Sci 6(1):47–60
Lee S, Park I, Choi JK (2012) Spatial prediction of ground subsidence susceptibility using an artificial neural network. J Environ Manag 49(2):347–358
Li X, Cheng G, Lu L (2000) Comparison of spatial interpolation methods. Adv Earth Sci 3:003
Liu F (2009) Acceptable consistency analysis of interval reciprocal comparison matrices. Fuzzy Sets Syst 160:2686–2700
Malczewski J (1999) GIS and multicriteria decision analysis. Wiley, New York
Malczewski J (2004) GIS-based land-use suitability analysis: a critical overview. Progr Plann 62(1):3–65
Malczewski J (2006) GIS-based multicriteria decision analysis: a survey of the literature. Int J Geogr Inf Sci 20:703–726
Malczewski J, Rinner C (2015) Multicriteria decision analysis in geographic information science. Springer, Berlin
Mendoza GA, Martins H (2006) Multi-criteria decision analysis in natural resource management: a critical review of methods and new modelling paradigms. For Ecol Manag 230(1–3):1–22
Mikhailov L (2003) Deriving priorities from fuzzy pairwise comparison judgements. Fuzzy Sets Syst 134:365–385</Bib>
Mikhailov L (2004) Group prioritization in the AHP by fuzzy preference programming method. Comput Oper Res 31:293–301
Motagh M, Walter TR, Sharifi MA, Fielding E, Schenk A, Anderssohn J, Zschau J (2008) Land subsidence in Iran caused by widespread water reservoir overexploitation. Geophys Res Lett 35(16):1–5
Nandi A, Shakoor A (2010) A GIS-based landslide susceptibility evaluation using bivariate and multivariate statistical analyses. Eng Geol 110:11–20
Nekhay O, Arriaza M, Guzmán-Álvarez JR (2009) Spatial analysis of the suitability of olive plantations for wildlife habitat restoration. Comput Electron Agric 65:49–64
Özcan T, Çelebi N, Esnaf Ş (2011) Comparative analysis of multi-criteria decision making methodologies and implementation of a warehouse location selection problem. Expert Syst Appl 38(8):9773–9779
Pirnazar M, Zand Karimi A, Feizizadeh B, Ostad-Ali-Askari K, Eslamian S, Hasheminasab H, Ghorbanzadeh O, Haeri Hamedani M (2017) Assessing flood hazard using GIS based multi-criteria decision making approach; study area: East Azerbaijan province (Kaleibar Chay basin). J Flood Eng 8(2):203–223
Pourghasemi HR, Pradhan B, Gokceoglu C (2012) Application of fuzzy logic and analytical hierarchy process (AHP) to landslide susceptibility mapping at Haraz watershed, Iran. Nat Hazards 63:965–996
Pradeep GS, Krishnan MN, Vijith H (2015) Identification of critical soil erosion prone areas and annual average soil loss in an upland agricultural watershed of Western Ghats, using analytical hierarchy process (AHP) and RUSLE techniques. Arab J Geosci 8(6):3697–3711
Rahmati O, Samani AN, Mahdavi M, Pourghasemi HR, Zeinivand H (2015) Groundwater potential mapping at Kurdistan region of Iran using analytic hierarchy process and GIS. Arab J Geosci 8(9):7059–7071
Rahmati O, Zeinivand H, Besharat M (2016) Flood hazard zoning in Yasooj region, Iran, using GIS and multi-criteria decision analysis. Geomat Nat Hazards Risk 7(3):1000–1017
Razandi Y, Pourghasemi HR, Neisani NS, Rahmati O (2015) Application of analytical hierarchy process, frequency ratio, and certainty factor models for groundwater potential mapping using GIS. Earth Sci Inf 8(4):867–883
Saaty TL (1980) The analytical hierarchy process, planning, priority. Resource allocation. RWS Publications, New York
Saaty TL (1990) Decision making for leaders: the analytic hierarchy process for decisions in a complex world. RWS Publications, New York
Saaty TL, Vargas LG (1984) Inconsistency and rank preservation. J Math Psychol 28:205–214
Saaty TL, Vargas LG (1991) Prediction, projection and forecasting. Springer, Netherlands
Sarkis J (1998) Evaluating environmentally conscious business practices. Eur J Oper Res 107:159–174
Sarmento P, Carrão H, Caetano M (2008) A fuzzy synthetic evaluation approach for land cover cartography accuracy assessment. In: Proceedings of the 8th international symposium on spatial accuracy assessment in nat res environ sci, pp 348–355
Schmidt DA, Bürgmann R (2003) Time-dependent land uplift and subsidence in the Santa Clara valley, California, from a large interferometric synthetic aperture radar data set. J Geophys Res B Solid Earth. https://doi.org/10.1029/2002JB00226
Sousa T, Silva A, Neves A (2004) Particle swarm based data mining algorithms for classification tasks. Parallel Comput 30:767–783
Suh J, Choi Y, Park HD, Yoon SH, Go WR (2013) Subsidence hazard assessment at the Samcheok coalfield, South Korea: a case study using GIS. Environ Eng Geosci 19(1):69–83
Sun Y, Kang S, Li F, Zhang L (2009) Comparison of interpolation methods for depth to groundwater and its temporal and spatial variations in the Minqin oasis of northwest China. Environ Modell Softw 24(10):1163–1170
Tenerelli P, Carver S (2012) Multi-criteria, multi-objective and uncertainty analysis for agro-energy spatial modelling. Appl Geogr 32:724–736
Thill JC (1999) Spatial multicriteria decision making and analysis: a geographic information sciences approach. Ashgate, Brookfield
Tiwari DN, Loof R, Paudyal GN (1999) Environmental—economic decision-making in lowland irrigated agriculture using multi-criteria analysis techniques. Agric Syst 60:99–112
Vaezinejad SM, Tofigh MM, Marandi SM (2011) Zonation and prediction of land subsidence (case study-Kerman, Iran). Int J Geosci 2:102
Zhang RD (2005) Theory and application of spatial variation. Am J Comput Math 2(1)
Acknowledgements
This research was partly funded by the Austrian Science Fund (FWF) through the GIScience Doctoral College (DK W 1237-N23). We would like to thank Ministry of Water Resource for East Azerbaijan Province (MWREP) and Mr. Behnam Khorrami (Ph.D. candidate in Department of Geographic Information Systems, Dokuz Eylul University) for support and help.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Ghorbanzadeh, O., Feizizadeh, B. & Blaschke, T. An interval matrix method used to optimize the decision matrix in AHP technique for land subsidence susceptibility mapping. Environ Earth Sci 77, 584 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12665-018-7758-y
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12665-018-7758-y