The Effect of Fin Pitch on Fluid Elastic Instability of Tube Arrays Subjected to Cross Flow of Water

Abstract

Failure of tubes in shell and tube exchangers is attributed to flow induced vibrations of such tubes. There are different excitations mechanisms due to which flow induced vibration occurs and among such mechanisms, fluid elastic instability is the most prominent one as it causes the most violent vibrations and may lead to rapid tube failures within short time. Fluid elastic instability is the fluid–structure interaction phenomenon which occurs when energy input by the fluid force exceeds energy expended in damping. This point is referred as instability threshold and corresponding velocity is referred as critical velocity. Once flow velocity exceeds critical flow velocity, the vibration amplitude increases very rapidly with flow velocity. An experimental program is carried out to determine the critical velocity at instability for plain and finned tube arrays subjected to cross flow of water. The tube array geometry is parallel triangular with cantilever end condition and pitch ratios considered are 2.6 and 2.1. The objective of research is to determine the effect of increase in pitch ratio on instability threshold for plain tube arrays and to assess the effect of addition of fins as well as increase in fin density on instability threshold for finned tube arrays. Plain tube array with two different pitch ratios; 2.1 and 2.6 and finned tube arrays with same pitch ratio; 2.6 but with two different fin pitches; such as fine (10 fpi) and coarse (4 fpi) are considered for the experimentation. Connors’ equation that relates critical velocity at instability to different parameters, on which instability depends, has been used as the basis for analysis and the concept of effective diameter is used for the present investigation. The modal parameters are first suitably modified using natural frequency reduction setup that is already designed and developed to reduce natural frequency and hence to achieve experimental simulation of fluid elastic instability within the limited flow capacity of the pump. The tests are carried out first on plain tube arrays to establish the same as the datum case and results are compared to known results of plain tube arrays and hence the quality of the test rig is also assessed. The fluid elastic vibration tests are then carried out on finned tube arrays with coarse and fine fin pitches and effects of fins and fin pitch on instability threshold are shown. The vibration response of the tube is recorded for each gradually increasing flow rates of water till instability point is reached. The parameters at the instability are then presented in terms of dimensionless parameters to compare them with published results. It is concluded that, arrays with higher pitch ratios are unstable at comparatively higher flow velocities and instability threshold for finned tube arrays is delayed due to addition of the fins. Further, it is concluded that, instability threshold for finned tube arrays with fine fin pitch is delayed compared to coarse fin pitch and hence for increased fin density, instability threshold is delayed. The experimental results in terms of critical velocities obtained for different tube arrays subjected to water cross flow will serve as the base flow rates for air–water cross flow experiments to be conducted in the next phase.