Abstract
It is generally accepted by demographers that cohort-component projection models which incorporate directional migration are conceptually preferable to those using net migration. Yet net migration cohort-component models, and other simplified variations, remain in common use by both academics and practitioners because of their simplicity and low data requirements. While many arguments have been presented in favour of using one or other type of model, surprisingly little analysis has been undertaken to assess which tend to give the most accurate forecasts. This paper evaluates five cohort-component models which differ in the way they handle migration, four of which are well known, with one—a composite net migration model—being proposed here for the first time. The paper evaluates the performance of these five models in their unconstrained form, and then in a constrained form in which age–sex-specific forecasts are constrained to independent total populations from an extrapolative model shown to produce accurate forecasts in earlier research. Retrospective forecasts for 67 local government areas of New South Wales were produced for the period 1991–2011 and then compared to population estimates. Assessments of both total and age-specific population forecasts were made. The results demonstrate the superior performance of the forecasts constrained to total populations from the extrapolative model, with the constrained bi-regional model giving the lowest errors. The findings should be of use to practitioners in selecting appropriate models for local area population forecasts.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
ABS (1995). Projections of the populations of Australia, States and Territories, 1993 to 2041. Catalogue No. 3222.0. Canberra: ABS.
ABS (2009). Population estimates: Concepts, sources and methods, 2009. Catalogue No. 3228.0.55.001. Canberra: ABS. Accessed May 29, 2015, from http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/mf/3228.0.55.001.
ABS (2010). Effect of delayed birth registrations in Australia. In ABS Births, Australia, 2009 (pp. 37–48). Catalogue No. 3301.0. Canberra: ABS.
ABS (2012a). Technical note: Effect of previously unprocessed New South Wales births. In ABS Births, Australia, 2011. Catalogue No. 3301.0. Canberra: ABS. Accessed May 29, 2015, from http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/Lookup/3301.0Technical+Note12011.
ABS (2012b). Census of population and housing: Details of undercount. Catalogue No. 2940.0. Canberra: ABS.
ABS (2015). Migration, Australia, 2013-14 [Regional Internal Migration Estimates dataset] Catalogue No. 3412.0. Canberra: ABS.
ABC News (2015). ABS confirms census under review amid concern it may be axed to cut costs, sparking outrage from demographers. ABC News website, 19 February 2015. Accessed May 29, 2015, from www.abc.net.au/news/2015-02-19/concerns-national-census-may-be-axed/6145052.
Ahlburg, D. A. (1995). Simple versus complex models: Evaluation, accuracy and combining. Mathematical Population Studies, 5, 281–290.
Ahlburg, D. A., Lutz, W., & Vaupel, J. W. (1999). Ways to improve population forecasting: What should be done differently in the future? In W. Lutz, J. W. Vaupel, & D. A. Alhburg (Eds.), Frontiers of population forecasting (pp. 191–198). New York: Population Council.
Armstrong, J. S. (2001). Combining forecasts. In J. S. Armstrong (Ed.), Principles of forecasting (pp. 417–439). Kluwer Boston: Academic Press.
Bell, M. (1997). Small area forecasting for infrastructure planning: Towards better practice. Canberra: Department of Industry, Science and Tourism.
Brisbane Times. (2015). Federal budget 2015: Census saved, $250 m investment in Bureau of Statistics. Brisbane Times website, 7 May 2015. Accessed May 7, 2015, from http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/business/federal-budget/federal-budget-2015-census-saved-250m-investment-in-bureau-of-statistics-20150507-ggvdrp.
Dion, P. (2015). Projection of interprovincial migration. In N. Bohnert, J. Chagnon, S. Coulombe, P. Dion & L. Martel Population projections for Canada (2013 to 2063), Provinces and Territories (2013 to 2038): Technical Report on Methodology and Assumptions (pp. 73–80). Ottawa: Statistics Canada.
Feeney, G. (1973). Two models for multiregional population dynamics. Environment and Planning, 5, 31–43.
Hamilton, C., & Perry, J. (1962). A short method for projecting population by age from one decennial census to another. Social Forces, 41, 163–170.
Isserman, A. M. (1993). The right people, the right rates: Making population estimates and forecasts with an interregional cohort-component model. Journal of the American Planning Association, 59, 45–64.
Murdock, S. H., Leistritz, F. L., Hamm, R. R., Hwang, S., & Parpia, B. (1984). An assessment of the accuracy of a regional economic-demographic projection model. Demography, 21, 383–404.
ONS. (2008). Subnational Population Projections Accuracy Report. London: Office for National Statistics.
Preston, S. H., Heuveline, P., & Guillot, M. (2001). Demography: Measuring and modeling population processes. Oxford: Blackwell.
Rayer, S. (2008). Population forecast errors: A primer for planners. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 27, 417–430.
Rayer, S., & Smith, S. K. (2010). Factors affecting the accuracy of subcounty population forecasts. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 30, 147–161.
Rees, P. (1980). Multistate demographic accounts: Measurement and estimation procedures. Environment and Planning A, 12, 499–531.
Rees, P. (1990). Manual on subnational population projections. Unpublished textbook, School of Geography, University of Leeds.
Rees, P. (1994). Key issues in subnational projection models. Working Paper 94/8, School of Geography, University of Leeds.
Rees, P. (2002). New models for projecting UK populations by ethnic group at national and subnational scales. In J. Haskey (Ed.), Population projections by ethnic group: A feasibility study (pp. 27–42). London: Office for National Statistics.
Renski, H., & Strate, S. (2013). Evaluating alternative migration estimation techniques for population estimates and projections. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 33, 325–335.
Rogers, A. (1990). Requiem for the net migrant. Geographical Analysis, 22, 283–300.
Rogers, A. (1995). Multiregional demography: Principles, methods and extensions. Chichester: Wiley.
Rogers, A., Little, J., & Raymer, J. (2010). The indirect estimation of migration. Dordrecht: Springer.
Rowland, D. T. (2003). Demographic methods and concepts. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Smith, S. K. (1986). Accounting for migration in cohort-component projections of State and local populations. Demography, 23, 127–135.
Smith, S. K. (1987). Tests of forecast accuracy and bias for county population projections. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 82, 991–1003.
Smith, S. K., & Swanson, D. A. (1998). In defense of the net migrant. Journal of Economic and Social Measurement, 24, 249–264.
Smith, S. K., & Tayman, J. (2003). An evaluation of population projections by age. Demography, 40, 741–757.
Smith, S. K., Tayman, J., & Swanson, D. A. (2013). A practitioner’s guide to state and local population projections. Dordrecht: Springer.
Statistics New Zealand. (2008). How Accurate are population projections? An evaluation of statistics New Zealand population projections, 1991–2006. Wellington: Statistics New Zealand.
Stigler, S. M. (1997). Regression towards the mean, historically considered. Statistical Methods in Medical Research, 6, 103–114.
Swanson, D. A., Schlottmann, A., & Schmidt, B. (2010). Forecasting the population of census tracts by age and sex: An example of the Hamilton-Perry method in action. Population Research and Policy Review, 29, 47–63.
Tayman, J. (1996). The accuracy of small-area population forecasts based on a spatial interaction land-use modelling system. Journal of the American Planning Association, 62, 85–98.
Tayman, J. (2011). Assessing uncertainty in small area forecasts: state of the practice and implementation strategy. Population Research and Policy Review, 30, 781–800.
Tye, R. (1994). Local authority estimates and projections: How are they used and how accurate do they need to be? Working Paper 9, Estimating with Confidence project. Department of Social Statistics, University of Southampton.
United Nations/Speare, A. (1992). Preparing migration data for subnational population projections. New York: United Nations.
Werscheler, T., & Nault, F. (1996). Projecting interregional migration balances within a multiregional cohort-component framework. Environment and Planning A, 28, 769–782.
Wilson, T. (2011). A review of sub-regional population projection methods. Report to the Office of Economic and Statistical Research. Queensland Centre for Population Research, School of Geography, Planning and Environmental Management, The University of Queensland: Brisbane.
Wilson, T. (2012). Forecast accuracy and uncertainty of Australian Bureau of Statistics state and territory population projections. International Journal of Population Research, 2012.
Wilson, T. (2013). Quantifying the uncertainty of regional demographic forecasts. Applied Geography, 42, 108–115.
Wilson, T. (2014a). New evaluations of simple models for small area population forecasts. Population, Space and Place,. doi:10.1002/psp.1847.
Wilson, T. (2014b). Simplifying local area population and household projections with POPART. In N. Hoque & L. Potter (Eds.), Emerging techniques in applied demography (pp. 25–38). Dordrecht: Springer.
Wilson, T., & Bell, M. (2004). Comparative empirical evaluations of internal migration models in subnational population projections. Journal of Population Research, 21, 127–160.
Wilson, T., & Bell, M. (2011). Editorial: Advances in local and small-area demographic modelling. Journal of Population Research, 28, 103–107.
Wilson, T., & Rees, P. (2005). Recent developments in population projection methodology: A review. Population, Space and Place, 11, 337–360.
Wilson, T., & Rowe, F. (2011). The forecast accuracy of local government area population projections: A case study of Queensland. Australasian Journal of Regional Studies, 17, 204–243.
Zotteri, G., Kalchschmidt, M., & Saccani, N. (2014). Forecasting by cross-sectional aggregation. Foresight, 35, 35–41.
Acknowledgments
The author is most grateful to the reviewers for their careful reading of the original paper and very helpful suggestions.
Funding
Australian Research Council funding for Discovery Project DP150103343 ‘Improving Subnational Population Forecasts’ is gratefully acknowledged.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Wilson, T. Evaluation of Alternative Cohort-Component Models for Local Area Population Forecasts. Popul Res Policy Rev 35, 241–261 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11113-015-9380-y
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11113-015-9380-y