Abstract
Using MSA-level data over 1994–2014, we study the effect of bank failures on local business dynamics, in the form of net business formation and net job creation. We find that at least one bank failure in the metropolitan statistical area (MSA) with the mean population prevents approximately 475 net businesses from forming in that area, compared with MSAs that experience no bank failures, ceteris paribus. The equivalent effect on net job creation is 16,433 net job losses. Our results are even stronger for small businesses, which are usually more dependent on bank-firm relationships. These effects point to significant welfare losses stemming from bank failures, highlighting an important role for government intervention. We show that the Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP) is effective in reducing the negative effects of bank failures on local business dynamics. This positive effect of TARP is quite uniform across small and large firms.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
The expenses cover unpaid principal amounts deemed unrecoverable and only reflect the costs to taxpayers because of the processes involved in resolving the failures. For example, Kang et al. (2015) estimate that during the S&L crisis the median cost incurred by the FDIC for closing a potentially distressed bank was about $1.2 million.
In additional estimations (reported on request), we examine the effect of both types of bank failures. We find both to reduce local business dynamics. However, there are too few liquidation bank observations to draw strong conclusions.
We treat those MSAs that cover multiple states as part of the state that has the highest population concentration.
Unfortunately, we do not have MSA-level information on whether the employees of the branches of failed banks are part of Net job creation. In any case, this number must be small; more so because in many cases some or all the employees of the failed bank branches are employed by the acquiring bank.
The BDS is a public data set of annual aggregate statistics describing different facets of local entrepreneurship: establishment entries and exits, as well as job creation and destruction by firm size and age at the MSA level.
An establishment is a business entity with multiple stores, outlets, or branch locations.
The pairwise correlation coefficient between the logarithmic value of MSA-level personal income and net business formation is 0.69 and significant at the 95% level. Moreover, when we estimate the effect of MSA-level personal income on net business formation using state-year fixed effects we find a 1% rise in personal income to statistically significantly increase net business formation by 1.03%.
Defined as assets 90 or more days past due and still accruing interest, plus assets that are no longer accruing interest divided by total assets.
If bank balance sheets already deteriorate, then the enforcement action would have been one related to financial safety and soundness.
dy/dFAILURE is computed using the delta method.
The correlation between local economic crisis and bank failures is positive. Although there is some overlap between local economic crisis and bank failures, not all local economic crises coincide with branch failures and not all branch failures occur during local economic crises.
In addition, when we drop observations for MSAs with a local economic crisis, we get similar results with negative and statistically significant coefficients for the interaction term FAILURE x Personal income.
We provide these results in the appendix (table A3).
CAMELS stands for capital adequacy, asset quality, management, earnings, liquidity, and sensitivity to market risk.
As reflected in Fig. 2, bank failures occur in waves. To examine whether year-specific clustering drives our inferences, we additionally report results from double clustering the variables by MSA and year. The statistical significance remains similar to that of baseline Table 4 with interaction terms (results are shown in table A4 in the online appendix).
Commercial real estate loans are for the acquisition, development and construction of business properties like retail malls, shopping centers, office buildings and complexes, and hotels.
To put our results into context, Berger and Roman (2017) find that the TARP creates eight jobs per 1000 people. Our results are not directly comparable because Berger and Roman conduct their analysis by state and do not account for the effect of bank failures. We find a lower effect that is consistent with offsetting the adverse effect of bank failures on local business dynamics.
We also place the cutoff at TARP banks controlling 30% of deposits yielding similar results.
References
Allen, L., Bali, T. G., & Tang, Y. (2012). Does Systemic Risk in the Financial Sector Predict Future Economic Downturns? Review of Financial Studies, 25, 3000–3036.
Anari, A., Kolari, J., & Mason, J. (2005). Bank Asset Liquidation and the Propagation of the U.S. Great Depression. Journal of Money Credit Banking, 37, 753–773.
Ashcraft, A. B. (2005). Are Banks Really Special? New Evidence from the FDIC-Induced Failure of Healthy Banks. American Economic Review, 95, 1712–1730.
Bargeon, L. I., Schlingemann, F. P., Stulz, R. M., & Zutter, C. J. (2017). What is the Shareholder Wealth Impact of Target CEO Retention in Private Equity Deals? Journal of Corporate Finance, 48, 388–404.
Berger, A. N., & Roman, R. A. (2015). Did TARP Banks Get Competitive Advantages? Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 50, 1199–1236.
Berger, A., & Roman, R. (2017). Did Saving Wall Street Really Save Main Street? The Real Effects of TARP on Local Economic Conditions. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 52, 1827–1867.
Berger, A., Saunders, A., Scalise, J., & Udell, G. (1998). The effects of bank mergers and acquisitions on small business lending. Journal of Financial Economics, 50, 187–229.
Berger, A., Miller, N., Petersen, M., Rajan, R., & Stein, J. (2005). Does function follow organizational form? Evidence from the lending practices of large and small banks. Journal of Financial Economics, 76(2), 237–269.
Berger, A., Roman, R., Sedunov, J. (2017). Did TARP Reduce or Increase Systemic Risk? The Effects of TARP on Financial System Stability. Working Paper, University of South Carolina.
Bersch, J., Degryse, H., Kick, T., & Stein, I. (2017). The Real Effects of Bank Distress: Evidence from Bank Bailouts in Germany. DNB Working Paper.
Braun, M., & Larraín, B. (2005). Finance and the business cycle: International, inter-industry evidence. Journal of Finance, 60(3), 1097–1127.
Calomiris, C. W., & Mason, J. (2003a). Consequences of Bank Distress during the Great Depression. American Economic Review, 93, 937–947.
Calomiris, C. W., & Mason, J. (2003b). Fundamentals, Panics, and Bank Distress during the Depression. American Economic Review, 93, 1615–1647.
Calomiris, C. W., Hubbard, G., & Stock, J. H. (1986). The Farm Debt Crisis and Public Policy. Brookings Paper on Economic Activity, 2, 441–479.
Carlson, M., & Mitchener, K. J. (2009). Branch Banking as a Device for Discipline: Competition and Bank Survivorship during the Great Depression. Journal of Political Economy, 117(2), 165–210.
Chodorow-Reich, G. (2014). The Employment Effects of Credit Market Disruptions: Firm-Level Evidence from the 2008-9 Financial Crisis. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 129, 1–59.
Clair, R. T., O’Driscoll, G. P., & Yeats, K. J. (1994). Is Banking Different? A Reexamination of the Case for Regulation. CATO Journal, 13, 345–353.
Covi, G., Gorpe, M., & Kok, C. (2021). CoMap: Mapping Contagion in the Euro Area Banking Sector. Journal of Financial Stability, 53, 100814.
Degryse, H., Masschelein, N., & Mitchell, J. (2011). Staying, dropping, or switching: the impacts of bank mergers on small firms. Review of Financial Studies, 24, 1102–1140.
Deli, Y., & Hasan, I. (2017). Real Effects of Bank Regulation: Global Evidence. Journal of Banking and Finance, 82, 217–228.
Delis, M., Staikouras, P., & Thomas, C. (2017). Formal Enforcement Actions and Bank Behavior. Management Science, 63, 959–987.
Dell’Ariccia, G., Detragiache, E., & Rajan, R. (2008). The Real Effect of Banking Crises. Journal of Financial Intermediation, 17, 89–112.
Drexler, A., & Schoar, A. (2014). Do Relationships Matter? Evidence from Loan Officer Turnover. Management Science, 60, 2722–2736.
Duarte, F. D., Gama, A. P. M., & Gulamhussen, M. A. (2018). Defaults in bank loans to SMEs during the financial crisis. Small Business Economics, 51, 591–608.
Duchin, R., & Sosyura, D. (2014). Safer Ratios, Riskier Portfolios: Banks’ Response to Government Aid. Journal of Financial Economics, 113, 1–28.
Fan, Y., Huang, Y., Jiang, Y., & Liu, F. H. (2020). Watch out for Bailout: TARP and Bank Earnings Management. Journal of Financial Stability, 51, 100785.
Federal Reserve Board. (2016). Consumers and Mobile Financial Services. Accessed at http://www.federalreserve.gov/econresdata/consumers-and-mobile- financial-services- report- 201603.pdf
Gilbert, A., & Kochin, L. (1989). Local Economic Effects of Bank Failures. Journal of Financial. Services Research, 14(3), 333–345.
Gormley, T., & Matsa, D. (2014). Common errors: How to (and not to) control for Unobserved Heterogeneity. Review of Financial Studies, 27(2), 617–661.
Huang, R. (2008). Evaluating the real effect of bank branching deregulation: Comparing contiguous counties across US state border. Journal of Financial Economics, 87(3), 678–705.
Imai, M., & Takarabe, S. (2011). Bank Integration and Transmission of Financial Shocks: Evidence from Japan. American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics, 3(1), 155–183.
Jimenez, G., Ongena, S., Peydro, J., & Saurina, J. (2014). Hazardous Times for Monetary Policy: What Do Twenty-Three Million Bank Loans Say About the Effects of Monetary Policy on Credit Risk-Taking? Econometrica, 82(2), 463–505.
Kang, A., Lowery, R., & Wardlaw, M. (2015). The Costs of Failed Banks: A Structural Estimation of Regulatory Incentives. Review of Financial Studies, 28(4), 1060–1102.
Karceski, J., Ongena, S., & Smith, D. C. (2005). The Impact of Bank Consolidation on Commercial Borrower Welfare. Journal of Finance, 60, 2043–2082.
Khwaja, A., & Mian, A. (2008). Tracing the Impact of Bank Liquidity Shocks: Evidence from an Emerging Market. American Economic Review, 98(4), 1413–1442.
Kishan, R., & Opiela, T. (2000). Bank Size, Bank Capital and the Bank Lending Channel. Journal of Money Credit and Banking., 32(1), 121–141.
Koetter, M., & Noth, F. (2015). Did TARP Distort Competition among Sound Unsupported Banks? Economic Inquiry, 54, 994–1020.
Li, L. (2013). TARP Funds Distribution and Bank Loan Supply. Journal of Banking and Finance, 37, 4777–4792.
Nigro, P. J., & Jacques, K. (2000). Financial turmoil, failed bank acquisitions, and bank business lending behavior. Journal of Financial. Services Research, 17(2), 149–164.
Pagano, M., & Pica, G. (2012). Finance and Employment. Economic Policy. Economic Policy, 27, 5–55.
Peek, J., & Rosengren, E. (1998). Bank consolidation and small business lending: it’s not just bank size that matters. Journal of Banking and Finance, 22, 799–819.
Peek, J., & Rosengren, E. (2000). Collateral Damage: Effects of the Japanese Bank Crisis on Real Economic Activity in the United States. American Economic Review, 90, 30–45.
Popov, A., & Zaharia, S. (2019). Credit market competition and the gender gap in labor force participation: Evidence from local markets. European Economic Review, 115(C), 25–59.
Ramirez, C., & Shively, P. (2012). The Effect of Bank Failures on Economic Activity: Evidence for the U.S. States in the Early 20th Century. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 44(2–3), 433–455.
Richardson, G., & Troost, W. (2009). Monetary Intervention Mitigated Banking Panics during the Great Depression: Quasi-Experimental Evidence from a Federal Reserve District Border, 1929-1933. Journal of Political Economy, 117(6), 1031–1073.
Ruhm, C. (2016). Health Effects of Economic Crises. Health Economics, 25(2), 6–24.
Sapienza, P. (2002). The Effects of Banking Mergers on Loan contracts. Journal of Finance, 57, 329–367.
Saunders, A., & Wilson, B. (1996). Contagious Bank Runs: Evidence from the 1929-1933 Period. Journal of Financial Intermediation, 5, 409–423.
U.S. Treasury. (2017). United States Department of the Treasury Office of Financial Stability, Troubled Asset Relief Program, Fiscal Year 2017 Citizen’s Report. https://www.treasury.gov/initiatives/financialstability/reports/Documents/FY2017%20OFS%20Citizens%20Report.pdf. (last visited on 1 September 2018).
Uchida, H., Udell, G., & Yamori, N. (2012). Loan officers and relationship lending to SMEs. Journal of Financial Intermediation, 21, 97–122.
Varum, C. A., & Rocha, V. C. (2013). Employment and SMEs during crises. Small Business Economics, 40, 9–25.
Vermoesen, V., Deloof, M., & Laveren, E. (2013). Long-term debt maturity and financing constraints of SMEs during the Global Financial Crisis. Small Business Economics, 41, 433–448.
Ziebarth, N. L. (2013). Identifying the Effects of Bank Failures from a Natural Experiment in Mississippi during the Great Depression. American Economic Journal Macroeconomics, 5, 81–101.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary information
ESM 1
(DOCX 372 kb)
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Contreras, S., Delis, M.D., Ghosh, A. et al. Bank failures, local business dynamics, and government policy. Small Bus Econ 58, 1823–1851 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11187-021-00478-5
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11187-021-00478-5
Keywords
- Bank failures
- Bank-business relationships
- Net business formation
- Net job creation
- Metropolitan statistical area
- Panel estimation methods
- TARP funds