Reconstruction of fire whirls using scale models
Abstract
This work was motivated from the knowledge of a historical fire whirl accident in which a fire whirl was responsible for 38,000 deaths and serious damage to the environment, all of which happened within 15 minutes. To understand the general features of fire whirls, records of example fire whirls were collected and deduced to be of three different types. Scaling laws were derived using dimensional analysis; three types of scale-models, with scaling ratios of , , and , corresponding to three actual fire whirls (prototypes), were designed in the laboratory. Wind tunnel fire experiments were performed burning methanol as the fire source and by changing the wind velocity to understand conditions under which fire whirls can occur. The model fire whirls reconstructed in the laboratory were visualized with water vapor; and profiles of velocity and temperature were, respectively, measured by a hot wire anemometer and a fine thermocouple. Because the dynamic structure of prototype fire whirls is not known due to lack of direct measurements in actual flows, a large scale-model with scaling ratio of to the prototype was designed to be studied in an open field. This model consisted of 85 circular pans filled with 2.3 m3 of methanol that were distributed in an area of 400 m2. Air movement was visualized by colored smoke. Wind velocity and direction were measured at five different locations and air temperatures at nine different locations. It was found that the visually determined whirl diameter and whirl column height, and the maximum tangential velocity of the whirl can be correlated to the scale model by the proposed scaling laws.
References (38)
- F.A. Williams
Prog. Ener. Combust. Sci.
(1982) - H.W. Emmons et al.
- A. Muraszew et al.
Combust. Flame
(1979) - F.A. Albini
Am. Sci.
(1984) - R.H. Luke et al.
Bushfires in Australia
(1978) - A. Barcilion
J. Atmo. Sci.
(1967) - H.E. Anderson
USDA Forest Service Research Paper INT-56
(1968) - C.M. Countryman
Fire Whirls—Why, When, and Where
(1971) - S. Soma et al.
- Emmons, H. W., personal communication,...
Fire Res. Abst. Rev.
Fire Res. Abst. Rev.
Scale Models in Engineering: The Theory and Its Application
Technol. Human Beings
Fire Tech
Cited by (130)
LES of fire plumes subjected to crosswind inducing vertical vorticity
2024, Fire Safety JournalIn the present work, the structure of several fire plumes from massive fires subjected to moderate crosswinds is numerically investigated by means of large eddy simulations. The fire plume evolution was evaluated by the mean concentration for a range of fireline intensities and inclinations. There is a notorious rise in the fire plume’s vertical extent and inclination upon increasing fireline intensity, whereas a notable asymmetry emerges upon increasing fireline inclination. The well-known coherent flow structures emerging from jets in crossflow were identified, such as the shear-layer vortices, the counter-rotating vortex pair, and the wake vortices. Additionally, fire plumes with high intensities (which require a large entrainment) were found to generate strong vertical structures that resemble dust devils, when vertical vorticity is present in the flow — generated, for example, by a wind gust. For a fireline subjected to a wind gust of , these vertical structures move in the wind direction at with an average increase (decrease) of the maximum vorticity upon increasing height (time). The appearance of these vertical structures is enhanced by the fireline inclination.
An experimental study of the blue whirl: Effect of fuel surface diameter
2024, Combustion and FlameDiameter of liquid fuel surface is generally an important factor for pool fires. This work studies the effect of diameter of liquid fuel surface on the flame dynamics of the blue whirl formed on a concaved smooth metal surface with a 10-degree inclination. The results show that diameter of liquid fuel surface has a significant influence on the formation and evolution of the blue whirl. When the fuel surface diameter is in the range of 25 mm < d < 50 mm, a stable blue whirl can be formed. When d ≥ 50 mm, the blue whirl becomes unstable, that is a yellow whirling flame is generated in the center region of the envelope of the blue whirl, forming a transitional state. As the fuel surface diameter increases, both the circulation and flame width of the blue whirl show a near-linear growth. The liftoff height of the flame edge in the stable state of blue whirl varies linearly with fuel diameter, while remaining almost constant in the transitional state. Whereas the flame precession frequency of blue whirl increases linearly with the increase of circulation, the precession radius keeps nearly constant. The mass burning rate per unit area of the blue whirl decreases with increasing the fuel surface diameter. A radiative heat transfer model for the blue whirl is established based on radiation theory, and the modified burning rate expressions for the stable and transitional states of the blue whirl are obtained using the model and experimental measurements. Further scaling laws, based on dimensional analysis, are proposed for predicting the flame geometric features and flame precession frequency of the blue whirl. This work provides experiments of the flame dynamics at various fuel surface diameters and insights into the physics of the blue whirl.
Radiative characteristics of large-scale fire whirl: An experimental study
2024, International Journal of Thermal SciencesFlame radiative characteristics, depending on the flame type, flame scale, and fuel type, are key parameters that determine fire spread and thermal hazards. Accurate prediction of flame radiation in large-scale natural fires requires detailed information on radiative characteristics. This paper presented an experimental study on the radiative properties of large-scale fire whirls with RP-5 aviation fuel. The maximum flame height and mean width reached 21.40 m and 3.60 m, respectively. Unlike large-scale free pool fires, the radial stabilization effect of the fire whirl suppressed the unstable toroidal vortex structures and the smoke production significantly. Most of the flame was high-temperature and high-emissive power areas in the large-scale fire whirl, and the emissive power exceeded 100 kW/m2 on about 60 % flame area. The flame temperature and emissive power first increased with height, then stabilized and decreased in the upper part of the fire whirl. The peak flame temperature, mean flame temperature, and mean emissive power all increased with an increase in the flame width. The mean emissive power ranged from 93.06 to 157.47 kW/m2, 2.3–3.9 times the values in free pool fires of the same scale. The solid flame radiation model could effectively predict the instantaneous radiative heat fluxes from large-scale fire whirls to distant external targets with the corrections of atmospheric transmissivity. The semi-empirical correlation of the radiative fraction based on the turbulent dissipation showed that neither the flame size nor heat release rate affects the radiative fraction, consistent with the our and other researchers’ experimental data from medium to large-scale fire whirls.
Effect of initial generating eddy height on temperature, velocity and air entrainment of fire whirl
2024, Combustion and FlameIn this paper, we present an experimental effort to reveal the effect of the initially generated eddy height on the thermal, velocity, and air entrainment properties of the fire vortex plume. Experiments were performed by a fixed-frame facility with variable channel wall height (h), using propane as the fuel (20 cm in burner exit diameter, 50.0–100.0 kW in heat release rate). Results show that the growth rates of centerline excess temperature and axial velocity tend to increase with h in the continuous flame below h. It is found that the radial distribution of excess temperature is always of hump-type and little affected by h at lower levels, while the radial profile of axial velocity changes from the plateau-type into the hump-type as h is increased. In the upper continuous and intermittent flames, the radial profile of excess temperature evolves from the hump type into the unimodal type, and that of axial velocity develops into the unimodal type from the plateau type as h is increased. The growth rates of excess temperature radius and axial velocity radius with the normalized height decrease with h for the continuous and intermittent flames. The axial position corresponding to the significant increase in the growth rate moves upstream with the increase of the heat release rate (). Under small h, the tangential velocity within the vortex core decreases with height, suggesting that the rotational strength becomes weakened. It is found that the air entrainment is weak at the flame bottom within the initial generating eddy height, and the entrained air is insufficient for complete combustion. The axial mass flow rate increases obviously as the channel wall disappears. With the increase of h, turbulence suppression is enhanced, and its role in flame elongation becomes more significant. The reduction of flame height is probably attributed to the greater turbulent mixing length under lower initial generating eddy height.
A model to predict maximum tangential wind velocity in laboratory-scale fire whirls without flames in a crosswind
2024, Fire Safety JournalFire whirls cause strong wind damage in large outdoor fires such as wildland fires and urban fires. A model to predict the maximum tangential wind velocity in laboratory-scale fire whirls without flames in a crosswind is developed based on a generation mechanism and the properties of the fire whirls. The model also predicts the radii of the fire whirls and the crosswind speed when they occur. The fire whirls modeled are those with large circulation and large radii, that is, large intense fire whirls. These fire whirls occur and remain downwind of a fire line placed perpendicular to the crosswind under a low crosswind speed and a high heat release rate (HRR). The model agrees well with the experimental results.
Turbulent cylindrical fire whirl
2023, Combustion and FlameThe cylindrical fire whirl, characterized by nearly constant flame width in the axial direction and open flame tip, is a unique flame pattern of the buoyant diffusion flame under strong imposed rotation. This paper presents a combined experimental and analytical study to investigate the formation and flame geometry of turbulent cylindrical fire whirls. A medium-scale rotating screen facility (diameter: 2.0 m, height: 10.0 m) was utilized for experiments with independently controlled and finely regulated imposed circulation (Γ) and heat release rate (=15–250 kW), by using propane as the fuel. It was found that the formation of cylindrical fire whirl is accompanied by the downward movement of the unstable flame bulge, and the propagation velocity agreed well with the predictions of the classical vortex breakdown theory. The physical analysis showed that the onsets of cylindrical fire whirls would occur at specific critical values of , where Re and B are the dimensionless imposed circulation and the dimensionless fire buoyancy flux, respectively. The analytical results agree well with data from small to medium-scale experiments and field observation, with m = 1/4 and 1/3 for laminar and turbulent fire whirls, respectively. Contrary to the general fire whirl, the mean flame height decreases, and the mean flame width increases steadily with Γ in the cylindrical fire whirl. A flame height correlation is derived from the radially-integrated momentum and mixture fraction equations, and a flame width correlation is developed based on the concept of equal axial convection and radial diffusion times for the turbulent cylindrical fire whirl. The two models both couple the heat release rate and the imposed circulation, and agree well with the experimental data of this work. The enhanced turbulence level induced by the flow instability of vortex breakdown is suggested to be the dominant mechanism for flame height reduction and flame width increase in the turbulent cylindrical fire whirl.
- ∗
Current address: College of Engineering, Seikei University, Kichijoji, Musashino, Tokyo 180, Japan.