Role of dispersants in kinetics and energetics of stirred ball mill grinding

doi:10.1016/0301-7516(96)00003-8

International Journal of Mineral Processing

Volume 47, Issues 1–2, June 1996, Pages 141-152

https://doi.org/10.1016/0301-7516(96)00003-8 Get rights and content

Abstract

Rheology of suspensions plays an important role in fine grinding of solids in stirred ball mills which exhibit superior performance in the sub-sieve grinding range than the conventional ball mills, in terms of both throughput and energy consumption. Addition of suitable dispersants to the slurry feed can result in a drastic reduction or even elimination of yield stress and permits higher solid loadings of the pulp. This investigation shows that size distributions of the comminuted products collapse onto essentially identical self-similar or self-preserving curves when particle size is rescaled by the median size, irrespective of the presence or absence of dispersants. The median size therefore is a consistent one parameter index of fineness that drives the size spectrum on its grinding trajectory which remains invariant of solid loadings and dispersant levels. The rate of change cf this characteristic length with the expenditure of specific grinding energy does not seem to vary with the addition of a dispersant. It is therefore inferred that dispersants do not effect the grinding mechanisms operating in the mill and the “speed” of grinding, that is, the inherent efficiency of the mill. However, since the rate of production of fines is directly proportional to the amount of solids present in the grinding charge, dispersants can under favourable conditions enhance the productivity or throughput of the mill significantly. A lumped parameters G-H model of grinding, when formulated in energy expended rather than in grinding time, can accurately simulate the kinetics of grinding in the stirred mill.

References (10)

D.W. Fuerstenau et al.
A multi-torque model for the effects of dispersants and slurry viscosity on ball milling
Int. J. Miner. Process.
(1990)
M. Gao et al.
A study on the effect of parameters in stirred ball milling
Int. J. Miner. Process.
(1993)
P.C. Kapur
Self-preserving size spectra of comminuted particles
Chem. Eng. Sci.
(1972)
M. Gao et al.
The influence of slurry theology on ultra-fine grinding in a stirred ball mill
M. Gao et al.
Fine grinding in mineral processing using stirred ball trills
Chem. Eng. Aust.
(1993)

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (38)

Optimization of operating conditions on ultra-fine coal grinding through kinetic stirred milling and numerical modeling
2022, Powder Technology
This study investigated ultra-fine coal grinding performance of four low- to moderate-cost grinding media in a laboratory stirred mill. Kinetic grinding tests showed that silica beads generated the finest product size with a P₈₀ of 5.9 μm from a feed size of 24.4 μm while having a specific energy (SE) input of 309 kWh/ton. Nonetheless, the least energy consumption of 109 kWh/ton was achieved by alumina beads; however, yielding a coarser product size of 15.5 μm. In addition, test results indicate that optimizing media sizes, solids concentration, and using viscosity modifiers enhance coal ultra-fine grinding performance. Under the optimized testing conditions, a P₈₀ of 2.7 μm was produced with a corresponding SE input of 270 kWh/ton using silica beads ranging from 420 to 850 μm and a dispersant dosage of 14 kg/ton. Moreover, the mathematical models generated based on population balance modeling provided an accurate forecast of the particle-size distribution.
Role of sodium hexametaphosphate in ultra-fine grinding of alumina-doped titanium dioxide
2022, Powder Technology
In wet stirred milling of Al-doped TiO₂, sodium hexametaphosphate (SHMP) is used as a small molecule dispersant to improve milling performance. In both acidic and basic conditions, SHMP interacts strongly with Al-doped TiO₂ and remains stable during milling. Considering the apparent and true particle breakage performance, at pH 10.3, the optimal dosing concentration was 0.16 wt% (0.33θ, sub-monolayer coverage), which is consistent for both dilute (5 vol%) and concentrated (≥ 19.1 vol%) suspensions. At higher SHMP concentration (0.77θ), the increased solution conductivity compromised milling performance by weakly destabilizing the Al-doped TiO₂ particles. At the optimal dose concentration of 0.33θ SHMP, particle dispersion is maintained through electrostatic and steric forces which contribute to moderating changes in suspension viscosity (~10% increase) as the particle size is reduced.
Impacts of process and design conditions of dry stirred milling on the shape of product size distribution
2021, Minerals Engineering
Citation Excerpt :
However, due to the impacts of the operating conditions as well as the response of the ground material, plotting of the self-similarities was also considered. Self-similarity approach requires to normalize the sizes with their d50 values and, hence, all of the size distributions have a pivot point that enables observation of the changes in their slopes more explicitly (Kapur et al., 1996; Rao and Datta, 2006). The impacts of the bead size including the mixture was investigated at varied median product sizes.
A grinding technology should consider the physical properties of the material, i.e., size, shape, which have effects on the product specifications, i.e., quality, strength or overall process efficiency. In this respect, this study aimed at evaluating the variations in the shape of product size distribution of a stirred media mill as the attention on this technology has been growing in the recent years. Within the scope of the research, series of grinding tests were performed at different operating conditions, i.e. bead size, bead type, tip speed, feed rate and mill design, with a laboratory scale continuously operated horizontal stirred media mill. The investigations proved that the use of coarser and denser beads as well as adjusting higher tip speeds resulted in obtaining narrower product size distribution for the same mean size. For a better understanding of the process, the stress energy and mean residence time evaluations were also undertaken. It was found that the stress energy and its normalization with the mean residence time are directly proportional to the slope of the distributions. As a conclusion, the dry stirred media mill is able to adjust the shape of the distribution, which may be beneficial regarding to the mechanical properties of the end products (cement manufacturing) or efficiency of the mineral beneficiation processes.
Recovery of magnetite from waste ferrous sulfate using polyethylene glycol (PEG) as a dispersant
2018, Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China (English Edition)
The effect of PEG dispersant on the magnetic separation of magnetite (Fe₃O₄) synthesized from ferrous sulfate solution via co-precipitation method with calcium hydroxide as the precipitant was investigated. The results indicated that a PEG dispersant could significantly affect Fe₃O₄ recovery. Adding PEG during the preparation of Fe₃O₄ was unfavorable for Fe₃O₄ recovery. When the PEG-6000 concentration was increased from 0 to 8 g/L, the iron grade and median particle size of the Fe₃O₄ product decreased from 65.58% and 2.35 μm to 57.79% and 1.35 μm, respectively. However, adding PEG during the wet milling of the mixed product promoted the subsequent recovery of Fe₃O₄. When the amount of PEG-200 increased from 0% to 4% of the powder mass, the grade of iron in the Fe₃O₄ product increased from 65.58% to 68.32%. While the relative molecular mass of PEG at an amount of 4% of the powder mass increased from 200 to 20000, the grade of iron was reduced from 68.32% to 66.70%.
Optimisation and analysis of bead milling process for preparation of highly viscous, binder-free dispersions of carbon black pigment
2018, Progress in Organic Coatings
Lab scale milling equipment is often employed to prepare dispersion formulations that possess considerably different characteristics from each other. The viscosity of a pre-mixed dispersion is one of the main parameters to consider when selecting a particular milling equipment for grinding of pigment. Generally, high viscosity dispersions are not easy to grind using a lab-scale re-circulating bead mill. There are numerous factors that can potentially result in changes in the starting point formulations. It is therefore crucial to assess any variations in the pigment loading occurring during milling for extended time periods. In this study, rheological characterisation, thermogravimetric analyses and surface resistivity measurements have been carried out on multiple dispersion formulations and it is shown that pigment loading after milling can be different from that in the starting point formulation.
The effect of prolonged mechanical activation duration on the reactivity of Portland cement: Effect of particle size and crystallinity changes
2017, Construction and Building Materials
Citation Excerpt :
This later becomes significantly smaller in size but occupy a larger volume fraction [27–29]. While smaller size of media provides larger contact surface between the media and material being ground, higher agitator speed gives rise to a greater kinetic energy of the media [25,26]. During the milling process, powder undergoes a severe plastic deformation, which introduces a number of defects (dislocations, grain boundaries, vacancies, and interstitials) into the material.
The present study investigates the preparation of Portland cement powders with various particle sizes and degrees of crystallinity, prepared by High Energy Ball Milling, and their use as a binder material addition.
The structural, the microstructural and the morphological transformations of the processed powders during the milling process were studied.
The electrical conductivity and the ion concentrations of the pore solution of cement pastes prepared with the processed cement were measured to understand how prolonging milling duration affects the early stage of setting reaction.
The effect of using the activated cement powders as a binder material addition on mechanical properties of the resulting cement pastes was studied. Results have shown that for an addition percentage up to 10%, the flexural strength, and the young modulus were improved as a function of the milling duration of the addition materials. Results have suggested that, besides of the particle size reduction, the formation of the amorphous fraction within the processed cement contributes to the acceleration of the early stage of hydration and improves the mechanical properties of the cement paste.

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

Research paperRole of dispersants in kinetics and energetics of stirred ball mill grinding

Abstract

Int. J. Miner. Process.

Int. J. Miner. Process.

Chem. Eng. Sci.

The influence of slurry theology on ultra-fine grinding in a stirred ball mill

Fine grinding in mineral processing using stirred ball trills

Chem. Eng. Aust.

Research paper
Role of dispersants in kinetics and energetics of stirred ball mill grinding