Substitutional doping of WO3 for Ca-ion based supercapacitor
Introduction
Societal development and advancement are mainly dependent on energy. Our dependency on limited fossil fuels is a major cause for concern along with the environmental damage caused due to the burning of fossil fuels. We have realized the importance of clean and renewable energy in our survival as well as that of the planet. Incessant emission of greenhouse gases, the resulting global warming, and climate change threaten the balance of the planet itself.[1] As the awareness about clean and renewable energy inspires us towards impactful change, the problem of energy storage becomes more critical. Harvesting energy from renewable sources to powering electric vehicles, energy storage is garnering the attention of researchers and governments alike.[2] Li-ion battery has been dominating as an energy storage device for a couple of decades. However, as technology advances the shortcomings of Li-ion batteries become more apparent. Li-ion batteries have relatively lower power density. New technology is more demanding. There are also concerns over the availability of raw material, toxicity, safety, and environmental impact and thus different options are being investigated.[3]
Tungsten oxide (WO3) is a multi-functional material with good performance in applications such as gas sensing, electrochromism, photo-catalysis, energy storage, etc.[4], [5], [6], [7], [8] WO3 exhibits pseudocapacitive behavior due to multiple oxidation states, fast surface reactions, and suitable crystal structure for intercalation of electrolyte ions. WO3 based supercapacitors have been extensively studied and widely reported.[9], [10], [11], [12], [13], [14], [15] Huang et al. [16] reported Csp of 524F g−1 for tungsten oxide nanosheets arrays with 84% capacitance retention after 4000 cycles in 0.5 M H2SO4. He et.al[17] achieved Csp of 488F g−1 and 84% capacitance retention after 10,000 cycles in 2 M H2SO4 electrolyte for 0.6 V potential window. Kim et al. [18] tested the performance of WO3 in 1 M LiClO4 + PC between − 0.9 and 0.5 V (vs. SCE) and achieved Csp of 139 Fg−1 for pristine WO3. After 2000 cycles 75% capacitance retention was observed. The performance of WO3 increased after embedding a metallic nanofilament array (NFA). The capacitance and its retention both increased due to the inclusion of conductive NFA. Santhosha et al. [19] demonstrated the synthesis of WO3 nanoparticles with a high specific capacity of 927 mAh g−1 in the first cycle. However, the capacity retention was very poor and it decreased to 100 mAh g−1 for the second discharge cycle. With successive discharge cycles, the capacity continued to decrease. Garcia et. al[20] also encountered a similar problem. In their report, WO3 electrode showed a discharge capacity of 120 mAh g−1 for the initial cycles but with poor stability. Capacity retention is a major issue with WO3 electrodes in sodium-ion electrolytes.
The performance of WO3 in neutral aqueous electrolytes (Li+ and Na+ ions) is nowhere near that of H2SO4. Major factors affecting the performance is the reaction kinetics of the material, electronic conductivity, movement of electrolyte ion and their interaction with the metal centers. [21] Options other than Li and Na ion containing electrolyte can prove more suitable.[22] Cheaper and abundant elements like calcium and aluminum further bring down the cost while improving the performance of the electrode material.[23], [24]
Utilizing composite electrode has many advantages. The performance of WO3 was increases significantly with the incorporation of carbon nanotubes, conducting polymers, graphene, and graphene oxide.[21] The choice of materials for the preparation of composite electrodes is dependent on the synergy of materials. Carbon-based materials, in general, have higher electronic conductivity, power density, and surface area than metal oxides. However, the energy density and specific capacitance are lower than metal oxides. [25] Combining two suitable materials brings the best out of them. Another approach to augment and alter the properties is doping of metal oxide with a different metal. Substitutional doping is an effective strategy to tailor the electrochemical, structural, and optical properties of WO3. Substitutional doping results in modulation of band energies, crystal structure, charge transportation capabilities, and material electrolyte interface. WO3 has been doped with different metals to improve its performance as a photo-catalyst in photoelectrochemical water splitting and electrochromism.[26], [27], [28], [29], [30], [31], [32] Doping with isovalent elements like molybdenum or chromium will not result in charge mismatching and thus reducing the defects and vacancies. However, doping with non-isovalent elements will create oxygen vacancies and other defects.[33] The size of the dopant element is also important along with its valency. The movement of electrolyte ions in and out of the crystal and the ease with which this happens is determined by the crystal structure of the active material and the electrolyte’s ionic size. Systematic substitutional doping can facilitate crystal structure modification according to application requirements.
In this report, we focus on substitutional doping of different valence metals (Bi3+, Hf4+, and Nb5+) in WO3 and its effect on electrochemical charge storage. The electrochemical performance of pristine WO3 is compared with doped (Bi, Hf, and Nb) WO3. The results are further analyzed in conjunction with the data from different characterization techniques such as XRD, XPS, Raman, and TEM as well as theoretically with density functional theory (DFT) calculations. The enhancement in electrochemical performance is ascribed to the crystal structure and lattice parameter modifications due to the result of substitutional doping. Further, the doped samples were tested in different aqueous electrolytes (H, Li, Na, Ca, and Al) to analyze their electrochemical performance. Aqueous electrolytes have numerous advantages over organic electrolytes. Aqueous electrolytes have high-ionic conductivity, low cost, non-flammability, non-corrosiveness, safety, and convenient assembly in air, compared to organic electrolytes. To evaluate the performance of doped samples, electrolytes with different ionic sizes and valencies were used. The most commonly used electrolyte for WO3 is 1 M H2SO4. Due to the corrosive nature of the acid electrolyte, mild, neutral aqueous electrolytes are the preferred option. Li-ion is widely studied and the most commonly used electrolyte commercially. The demand for Li and its limited availability is slowly driving up its prices. To further explorer the options Na, Ca, and Al was also selected. These materials are easy to access, abundant and cheap. An asymmetric device was fabricated using the best combination of electrode material and electrolyte.
Section snippets
Formation and growth mechanism of WO3
Adding WCl6 to ethanol results in the formation of chloride alkoxides along with HCl. Acidic conditions are necessary for the formation of a precipitate. The solution first turns orange and then to yellow as WCl6 dissolves in ethanol. In this stage, the HCl is being formed, and the amount continues to increase as the dissolution process reaches completion. After complete dissolution of WCl6, the solution of intermediate chloride alkoxides in the presence of HCl (acidic condition) slowly turns
Materials
Tungsten Hexachloride (WCl6, Sigma Aldrich), Niobium Pentachloride (NbCl5, Sigma Aldrich), Hafnium Chloride (HfCl4, Sigma Aldrich), Bismuth Chloride (BiCl3, Sigma Aldrich) were used. Ethanol was used as a solvent. Carbon cloth (CC) was used as substrate.
Synthesis of WO3 and (Bi, Hf and Nb) doped WO3
In a typical synthesis of pristine tungsten oxide, 0.6 g of WCl6 was dissolved in 50 ml ethanol by magnetic stirring for 10 min at room temperature. This solution along with carbon cloth substrate (3*3 cm) was transferred into a Teflon liner
Declaration of Competing Interest
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
Acknowledgement
We gratefully acknowledge the financial support from the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) funded by the Ministry of Education under Grant No. 2018R1D1A1B07048610.
References (56)
- et al.
Van Truong, Electrochromic properties of sol–gel prepared hybrid transition metal oxides – A short review
J. Sci. Adv. Mater. Devices.
(2017) - et al.
Enhanced charge storage by optimization of pore structure in nanocomposite between ordered mesoporous carbon and nanosized WO3-x
J. Power Sources.
(2013) - et al.
Facile synthesis of reduced graphene oxide/tungsten disulfide/tungsten oxide nanohybrids for high performance supercapacitor with excellent rate capability
Appl. Surf. Sci.
(2019) - et al.
Dispersing WO3 in carbon aerogel makes an outstanding supercapacitor electrode material
Carbon N. Y.
(2014) - et al.
Tunable stable operating potential window for high-voltage aqueous supercapacitors
Nano Energy
(2019) - et al.
Facile preparation of W5O14 nanosheet arrays with large crystal channels as high-performance negative electrode for supercapacitor
Electrochim. Acta.
(2020) - et al.
Sodium ion storage performance of magnetron sputtered WO3 thin films
Electrochim. Acta.
(2019) - et al.
WO3 quantum-dots electrochromism
Nano Energy
(2020) - et al.
Supercapacitive composite metal oxide electrodes formed with carbon, metal oxides and conducting polymers
J. Alloys Compd.
(2016) - et al.
Bi-functional Mo-doped WO3 nanowire array electrochromism-plus electrochemical energy storage
J. Colloid Interface Sci.
(2016)
Tuning electronic configuration of WP2 nanosheet arrays via nickel doping for high-efficiency hydrogen evolution reaction
J. Energy Chem.
Switching electrochromic performance improvement enabled by highly developed mesopores and oxygen vacancy defects of Fe-doped WO 3 films
Appl. Surf. Sci.
Modification of the redox behaviour of CeO2 induced by structural doping with ZrO2
J. Catal.
Effect of doping on the performance of high-crystalline SrMnO3 perovskite nanofibers as a supercapacitor electrode
Ceram. Int.
Intercalation pseudo-capacitive TiNb2O7@carbon electrode for high-performance lithium ion hybrid electrochemical supercapacitors with ultrahigh energy density
Nano Energy
Sulfur-doped cobalt phosphide nanotube arrays for highly stable hybrid supercapacitor
Nano Energy
Nanocomposite Materials for the Sodium-Ion Battery: A Review
Small.
Sodium ion batteries: A newer electrochemical storage Wiley Interdiscip
Rev. Energy Environ.
Progress in the Development of Sodium-Ion Solid Electrolytes
Small Methods.
Recent progress in tungsten oxides based memristors and their neuromorphological applications
Electron. Mater. Lett.
Flexible electrochromic supercapacitor hybrid electrodes based on tungsten oxide films and silver nanowires
Chem. Commun.
A New Facile Synthesis of Tungsten Oxide from Tungsten Disulfide: Structure Dependent Supercapacitor and Negative Differential Resistance Properties
Small.
Fabry-Perot Cavity-Type Electrochromic Supercapacitors with Exceptionally Versatile Color Tunability
Nano Lett.
Supercapacitor electrodes based on layered tungsten disulfide-reduced graphene oxide hybrids synthesized by a facile hydrothermal method
ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces.
Synthesis of Three-Dimensional Hierarchical Urchinlike Tungsten Trioxide Microspheres for High-Performance Supercapacitor Electrode
Crystals.
Nanofilament array embedded tungsten oxide for highly efficient electrochromic supercapacitor electrodes
J. Mater. Chem. A.
Cited by (30)
Alternative inner filling and outer surface coating of BNNT by Tungsten(VI) oxide for supercapacitor electrode
2024, Composites Part B: EngineeringHigh-performance VO<inf>2</inf>/CNT@PANI with core–shell construction enable printable in-planar symmetric supercapacitors
2024, Journal of Colloid and Interface ScienceTungsten trioxide based high-performance supercapacitor for application in electric vehicles
2024, Journal of Energy StorageHigh load, long cycle and flexible zinc-ion hybrid supercapacitors
2024, Journal of Energy StorageHigh pseudocapacitance electrode enabled by heterovalent doping and surface coating for rapid charge storage
2024, Surface and Coatings Technology