Invited ReviewResearch on warehouse design and performance evaluation: A comprehensive review
Introduction
This survey and a companion paper (Gu et al., 2007) present a comprehensive review of the state-of-art of warehouse research. Whereas the latter focuses on warehouse operation problems related to the four major warehouse functions, i.e., receiving, storage, order picking, and shipping, this paper concentrates on warehouse design, performance evaluation, case studies, and computational support tools. The objectives are to provide an all-inclusive overview of the available methodologies and tools for improving warehouse design practices and to identify potential future research directions.
Warehouse design involves five major decisions as illustrated in Fig. 1: determining the overall warehouse structure; sizing and dimensioning the warehouse and its departments; determining the detailed layout within each department; selecting warehouse equipment; and selecting operational strategies. The overall structure (or conceptual design) determines the material flow pattern within the warehouse, the specification of functional departments, and the flow relationships between departments. The sizing and dimensioning decisions determine the size and dimension of the warehouse as well as the space allocation among various warehouse departments. Department layout is the detailed configuration within a warehouse department, for example, aisle configuration in the retrieval area, pallet block-stacking pattern in the reserve storage area, and configuration of an Automated Storage/Retrieval System (AS/RS). The equipment selection decisions determine an appropriate automation level for the warehouse, and identify equipment types for storage, transportation, order picking, and sorting. The selection of the operation strategy determines how the warehouse will be operated, for example, with regards to storage and order picking. Operation strategies refer to those decisions about operations that have global effects on other design decisions, and therefore need to be considered in the design phase. Examples of such operation strategies include the choice between randomized storage or dedicated storage, whether or not to do zone picking, and the choice between sort-while-pick or sort-after-pick. Detailed operational policies, such as how to batch and route the order picking tour, are not considered design problems and therefore are discussed in Gu et al. (2007).
It should be emphasized that warehouse design decisions are strongly coupled and it is difficult to define a sharp boundary between them. Therefore, our proposed classification should not be regarded as unique, nor does it imply that any of the decisions should be made independently. Furthermore, one should not ignore operational performance measures in the design phase since operational efficiency is strongly affected by the design decisions, but it can be very expensive or impossible to change the design decisions once the warehouse is actually built.
Performance evaluation is important for both warehouse design and operation. Assessing the performance of a warehouse in terms of cost, throughput, space utilization, and service provides feedback about how a specific design or operational policy performs compared with the requirements, and how it can be improved. Furthermore, a good performance evaluation model can help the designer to quickly evaluate many design alternatives and narrow down the design space during the early design stage. Performance evaluation methods include benchmarking, analytical models, and simulation models. This review will mainly focus on the former two since simulation results depend greatly on the implementation details and are less amenable to generalization. However, this should not obscure the fact that simulation is still the most widely used technique for warehouse performance evaluation in the academic literature as well as in practice.
Some case studies and computational systems are also discussed in this paper. Research in these two directions is very limited. However, it is our belief that more case studies and computational tools for warehouse design and operation will help to bridge the significant gap between academic research and practical application, and therefore, represent a key need for the future.
The study presented in this paper and its companion paper on operations, Gu et al. (2007), complements previous surveys on warehouse research, for example, Cormier, 2005, Cormier and Gunn, 1992, van den Berg, 1999, Rowenhorst et al., 2000. Over 250 papers are included within our classification scheme. To our knowledge, it is the most comprehensive review of existing research results on warehousing. However, we make no claim that it includes all the literature on warehousing. The scope of this survey has been mainly focused on results published in available English-language research journals.
The topic of warehouse location, which is part of the larger area of distribution system design, is not addressed in this current review. A recent survey on warehouse location is provided by Daskin et al. (2005).
The next four sections will discuss the literature on warehouse design, performance evaluation, case studies, and computational systems, respectively. The final section gives conclusions and future research directions.
Section snippets
Overall structure
The overall structure (or conceptual design) of a warehouse determines the functional departments, e.g., how many storage departments, employing what technologies, and how orders will be assembled. At this stage of design, the issues are to meet storage and throughput requirements, and to minimize costs, which may be the discounted value of investment and future operating costs. We can identify only three published papers addressing overall structural design.
Park and Webster (1989) assume the
Performance evaluation
Performance evaluation provides feedback on the quality of a proposed design and/or operational policy, and more importantly, on how to improve it. There are different approaches for performance evaluation: benchmarking, analytic models, and simulations. This section will only discuss benchmarking and analytic models.
Case studies
There are some published industrial case studies, which not only provide applications of the various design and operation methods in practical contexts, but more importantly, also identify possible future research challenges from the industrial point of view. Table 3 lists these case studies, identifying the problems and the types of warehouse they investigated. It is difficult to generalize from such a small set of specific cases, but one conclusion is that substantial benefits can achieved by
Computational systems
There are numerous commercial Warehouse Management Systems (WMS) available in the market, which basically help the warehouse manager to keep track of the products, orders, space, equipment, and human resources in a warehouse, and provide rules/algorithms for storage location assignment, order batching, pick routing, etc. Detailed review of these systems is beyond the scope of this paper. Instead, we focus on the academic research addressing computational systems for warehouse design. As
Conclusions and discussion
We have attempted a thorough examination of the published research related to warehouse design, and classified papers based on the main issues addressed. Fig. 1 shows the numbers of papers in each category; there were 50 papers directly addressing warehouse design decisions. There were an additional 50 papers on various analytic models of travel time or performance for specific storage systems or aggregates of storage systems. Benchmarking, case studies and other surveys account for 18 more
References (130)
- et al.
Warehouse design optimization
European Journal of Operational Research
(1985) - et al.
Modelling the service process in a multi-address warehousing system
Applied Mathematical Modelling
(1989) - et al.
Design and performance of kitting and order picking systems
International Journal of Production Economics
(1995) - et al.
Travel time analysis for general item location assignment in a rectangular warehouse
European Journal of Operational Research
(1999) - et al.
A review of warehouse models
European Journal of Operational Research
(1992) - et al.
Conceptual design of a warehouse for just-in-time operations in a bakery
Computers and Industrial Engineering
(1995) Performance approximation of pick-to-belt orderpicking systems
European Journal of Operational Research
(1994)- et al.
Design and operation of an order-consolidation warehouse: models and applications
European Journal of Operational Research
(1992) - et al.
Research on warehouse operation: A comprehensive review
European Journal of Operational Research
(2007) - et al.
Class-based storage assignment policy in carousel system
Computers and Industrial Engineering
(1994)
Economic sizing of warehouses – A linear programming approach
Computers and Operations Research
A performance estimating model for AS/RS by M/G/1 queuing system
Computers and Industrial Engineering
Cycle time models for single/double carousel system
International Journal of Production Economics
Sequencing picking operations and travel time models for man-on-board storage and retrieval warehousing system
International Journal of Production Economics
Performance analysis of carousel systems with double shuttle
Computers and Industrial Engineering
The impacts of acceleration/deceleration on travel time models for carousel systems
Computers and Industrial Engineering
A framework for the exact evaluation of expected cycle times in automated storage systems with full-turnover item allocation and random service requests
Computers and Industrial Engineering
Travel time model for the warehousing system with a tower crane S/R machine
Computers and Industrial Engineering
The procedure of determining the order picking strategies in distribution center
International Journal of Production Economics
An expert system framework for automated storage and retrieval system control
Computers and Industrial Engineering
An integrated storage system evaluation model
Applied Mathematical Modelling
Design optimization models for storage and retrieval systems using rail-guided vehicles
Applied Mathematical Modelling
An integrated performance model for order picking systems with randomized storage
Applied Mathematical Modelling
Journal of Manufacturing Systems
Warehouse logistics systems – A CAD model
Engineering Costs and Production Economics
A microcomputer-based optimization model for the design of automated warehouses
International Journal of Production Research
A geometrical approach to computing expected cycle times for zone-based storage layouts in AS/RS
International Journal of Production Research
Maximizing of the throughput of a computerized automated warehousing system under system constraints
International Journal of Production Research
Optimum allocation of resources between the random access and rack storage spaces in an automated warehousing system
International Journal of Production Research
Performance of bucket brigades when work is stochastic
Operations Research
Internal layout design of a warehouse
AIIE Transactions
Elements of warehouse layout
International Journal of Production Research
Travel-time models for automated storage/retrieval systems
IIE Transactions
Design and performance models for end-of-aisle order picking systems
Management Science
A generalized design and performance analysis models for end-of-aisle order-picking systems
IIE Transactions
Vehicle routing in an automated warehouse: Analysis and optimization
Annals of Operations Research
Routing policies and COI-based storage policies in picker-to-part systems
International Journal of Production Research
Optimal layout in low-level picker-to-part systems
International Journal of Production Research
The impact of rack configuration on the speed profile of the storage and retrieval machine
IIE Transactions
The impact of acceleration/deceleration on travel-time models for automated storage/retrieval systems
IIE Transactions
An analysis of automated storage and retrieval systems in manufacturing assembly lines
IIE Transactions
Operational research methods for efficient warehousing
On coordinating warehouse sizing, leasing and inventory policy
IIE Transactions
Modelling and analysis for capacity expansion planning in warehousing
Journal of the Operational Research Society
Facility location in supply chain design
Improving order-picking response time at Ankor’s warehouse
Interfaces
Establishing zones in single-command class-based rectangular AS/RS
IIE Transactions
Analytical results for miniload throughput and the distribution of dual command travel time
IIE Transactions
Cited by (474)
Improving order picking efficiency through storage assignment optimization in robotic mobile fulfillment systems
2024, European Journal of Operational ResearchAutomated storage and retrieval system design with variant lane depths
2024, European Journal of Operational Research50 years of warehousing research—An operations research perspective
2024, European Journal of Operational ResearchRanking model to measure energy efficiency for warehouse operations sustainability
2023, Journal of Cleaner ProductionA classification approach to order picking systems and policies: Integrating automation and optimization for future research
2023, Results in Control and OptimizationReorganization of inventory to improve kitting efficiency and maximize space utilization
2023, Manufacturing Letters