Turbulent advances of a breaking bore: Preliminary physical experiments

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.expthermflusci.2014.12.002Get rights and content

Highlights

  • The propagation of breaking bore roller toe was investigated in laboratory.

  • The toe perimeter shape fluctuated rapidly with transverse distance and time.

  • Large fluctuations in bore celerity were observed in terms of both time and space.

  • Instantaneous longitudinal roller profiles showed temporal and spatial fluctuations.

  • Distinctive air bubble entrainment was measured at the toe of the roller.

Abstract

In an estuary, a tidal bore may be generated at the leading edge of the flood tidal wave during the early flood tide under spring tide conditions into a narrow funnelled channel. For Froude numbers greater than 1.4–1.6, the leading edge of the bore is characterised by a breaking roller. The roller is characterised by a sudden increase in water depth, a highly turbulent flow with large-scale vortical structures, some kinetic energy dissipation, a two-phase air–water flow region and strong turbulence interactions. New experiments were conducted in a large canal with a focus on breaking bore roller propagation. The upstream propagation of the roller toe was highly turbulent. The toe perimeter shape fluctuated rapidly with transverse distance and time. The celerity of the roller toe changed rapidly with time and space, although in a quasi-two-dimensional manner on average. The instantaneous longitudinal free-surface profile of the roller showed significant temporal and spatial fluctuations. New air–water flow measurements highlighted some distinctive air bubble entrainment at the toe of the roller. Bubbles with larger chord times were detected at higher vertical elevations in a more intermittent manner. Overall the study demonstrated that the propagation of breaking bore is a very turbulent, three-dimensional process.

Introduction

A sudden increase in flow depth in an open channel induces a positive surge [13], [3], [19]. In an estuary, a positive surge of tidal origin is called a tidal bore which may be generated by the early flood tide propagating upstream into a narrow funnelled channel under a large tidal range [34], [8]. After formation, the bore may be analysed as a hydraulic jump in translation [30], [20]. The shape of the surge front is a function of its Froude number Fr1 [25], [9]. For a rectangular channel, Fr1 equals:Fr1=V1+Ug×d1where V1 is the initial flow velocity positive downstream, U is the mean bore celerity positive upstream, g is the gravity acceleration, d1 is the initial flow depth (Fig. 1A). For Fr1 > 1.4–1.6, the leading edge of the bore is characterised by a breaking roller. Fig. 1B presents a photograph of a large breaking tidal bore in China. The bore roller is characterised by a sudden increase in water depth, a highly turbulent flow with large-scale vortical structures, some kinetic energy dissipation, a two-phase air–water flow region and strong turbulence interactions with the free surface associated with splashes and droplet ejections.

In this contribution, a physical investigation was conducted in laboratory with a focus on the bore roller properties. Detailed measurements were performed in a relatively large facility. The observations included a series of video observations of propagating breaking bores to characterise the roller toe perimeter, the bore front celerity and their fluctuations, as well as some preliminary unsteady air entrainment measurements in the bore roller using a dual-tip phase-detection probe. It is the purpose of this contribution to study thoroughly the upstream roller propagation and its turbulent fluctuations.

Section snippets

Experimental facility and instrumentation

New experiments were conducted in a 19 m long 0.7 m wide tilting channel, made of glass sidewalls and smooth PVC bed (Fig. 2). The bed slope was horizontal (So = 0) and the channel ended with a free overfall. The initially steady flow was supplied by a constant head reservoir, delivered into an upstream intake channel and led to the glass sidewalled test section through a series of flow straighteners followed by a smooth bed and sidewall convergent. A fast-closing Tainter gate was located next to

Roller toe perimeter

In hydraulic jumps and breaking bores, the roller toe is a flow singularity where air is entrapped and vorticity is generated [14]. It is also called breaker foot [2] and corresponds to the position for base of a breaker, at the boundary between smooth and turbulent flow at the water surface, see the examples in Figs. 1B and 2. View in elevation, the roller toe formed a continuous line, herein called the roller toe perimeter (Fig. 1A). The shape of the roller toe perimeter and its evolution

Discussion: unsteady air bubble entrainment in the roller

The instantaneous void fraction c is defined as 0 in the water and 1 in the air. Fig. 7 presents the time variations of instantaneous void fraction c at different vertical elevation z/d1, where ttoe is the time of passage of the bore roller toe. In Fig. 7, the black lines correspond to the leading tip probe signal and the red lines to the trailing sensor signal. The data showed consistently that a substantial number of bubbles were entrapped between 1.25 < z/d1 < 1.5. No bubble was detected for z/d1

Conclusion

New experiments were conducted in a large flume to investigate breaking bores and the bore roller propagation. The results demonstrated several outcomes.

  • (1)

    The propagation of breaking bore roller toe was a highly turbulent process. Although the transverse shape of the roller toe perimeter was quasi two-dimensional on average, the toe perimeter shape fluctuated rapidly with transverse distance and time.

  • (2)

    The sidewalls had little effect on the upstream propagation of the breaking bore roller, within

Acknowledgments

The authors thank Dr Frédéric MURZYN (ESTACA Laval, France) and Dr Hubert BRANGER (University of Aix-Marseille, France) for their detailed review of the report and very valuable comments. They also thank Professor Pierre LUBIN (University of Bordeaux, France) for his personal involvement, contribution and comments to the research project. They thank further both reviewers for their constructive and helpful comments. The authors acknowledge the technical assistance of Jason VAN DER GEVEL and

References (38)

  • H. Chanson

    Tidal Bores, Aegir, Eagre, Mascaret, Pororoca: Theory and Observations

    (2011)
  • H. Chanson

    Momentum considerations in hydraulic jumps and bores

    J. Irrigation Drainage Eng. ASCE

    (2012)
  • H. Chanson, Y.H. Toi, Physical modelling of breaking tidal bores: comparison with prototype data, J. Hydraulic Res....
  • R. Cointe, A theory of breakers and breaking waves, Ph.D. thesis, University of California, Santa Barbara, USA, 1987,...
  • N.J. Docherty et al.

    Physical modelling of unsteady turbulence in breaking tidal bores

    J. Hydraulic Eng., ASCE

    (2012)
  • F.M. Henderson

    Open Channel Flow

    (1966)
  • H.G. Hornung et al.

    The flow field downstream of a hydraulic jump

    J. Fluid Mech.

    (1995)
  • J.W. Hoyt et al.

    Hydraulic jump as ‘Mixing Layer’

    J. Hyd. Eng., ASCE

    (1989)
  • C. Koch et al.

    Turbulence measurements in positive surges and bores

    J. Hydraulic Res., IAHR

    (2009)
  • Cited by (26)

    • On optical flow techniques applied to breaking surges

      2020, Flow Measurement and Instrumentation
    • Physical study of the 3-dimensional characteristics and free-surface properties of a breaking roller in bores and surges

      2020, Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science
      Citation Excerpt :

      More details on scale effects in bores and positive surges are provided by Leng and Chanson [22]. Based on previous results by Leng and Chanson [20,21], repetitions varied between R = 8 for the side view to R = 25 for the top view data sets. Channel slopes ranged between 0 and 1.25%, generating flows with different hydrodynamic properties and bores with various Froude numbers Fr1 (Eq. (1)).

    • Air-water interaction and characteristics in breaking bores

      2019, International Journal of Multiphase Flow
      Citation Excerpt :

      The test section was made of glass side walls and smooth PVC bed. The same channel was previously used by Leng and Chanson (2015a, 2016). The initially steady flow was supplied by an upstream intake tank equipped with flow calming devices and flow straighteners, leading to the 19 m long glass-sidewall test section through a smooth three-dimensional convergent.

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text