The decay of quantum systems with a small number of open channels
Introduction
Decay phenomena take place whenever a quantum system is coupled to its environment. Typical examples range from highly excited nuclei over mesoscopic or macroscopic cavities with attached wave guides to the overall interaction of (quantum) systems with the cosmic background radiation responsible for de-coherence phenomena. These systems are open in the sense that the (originally) bound states can be populated by a pulse coming, via some channels, from the “outside”. Vice versa, an initial population of bound states can decay into these channels.
The theoretical description of decay phenomena dates back to the early 1930s. In the pioneering work of Weisskopf and Wigner [1] it has been shown that an individual state generically dissolves at an exponential rate into the continuum of unbound states coupled to it. Later, a detailed investigation of decay properties of quantum systems has been performed in the context of nuclear reaction theory, see the classical textbook by Mahaux and Weidenmüller [2] and its precursors [3], [4], [5], [6], [7], as well as in the field of quantum chemistry [8].
In recent years, decaying quantum systems have been studied from the point of view of scattering on systems with (infinitely) high potential walls. Such systems can be realized in the form of “billiards” or microwave cavities, which allow for a detailed investigation both experimentally and theoretically. One can show that the scattering properties of such billiards are closely related to the spectral properties of the corresponding closed system [9], [10], [11]. Nowadays, one of the most active fields in quantum physics is the analysis (and design) of mesoscopic structures. Here, the openness is realized by attaching leads to a restricted area of low-dimensional electron gas, which gives rise to a variety of quantum transport phenomena, see the recent report by Beenakker [12].
Open systems allow for a dual description: on the one hand, they can be considered from the “inside” point of view, treating the coupling to the environment as a — not necessarily small — perturbation. From this point of view, one can study the (discrete) eigenvalues of the system, the widths of resonances and the resulting decay properties. On the other hand, open systems allow to take the “outside” point of view, considering the system as a perturbation of the environment. The typical quantity to be investigated from this point of view is the scattering matrix (S-matrix), i.e. the amplitude for passing from a given incoming channel to a certain outgoing channel as a function of energy.
The duality between the inside and the outside points of view has been used in order to investigate properties belonging to the system by doing scattering experiments on it. For billiard systems, a detailed study of the relation between the eigenphases of the S-matrix and the spectrum of the bound system has been initiated by the work of Smilansky et al. [13], [14]. These studies show that (under certain smoothness conditions for the boundary of the billiard) there is a one-to-one correspondence between the spectrum of the bound system and that of eigenphases of the S-matrix: Whenever the system is (at a given energy E) “transparent”, i.e. the S-matrix has an eigenvalue equal to 1, the closed system has a bound state, and vice versa [15], [16], [17].
There is a second reflection of this inside–outside duality, leading to a direct connection between the S-matrix and the decay function, i.e. the probability to find the system in a bound state after it has been excited by a pulse from the outside [18]. This connection can be used, e.g., in order to interpret experimental observations on super-conducting microwave cavities [19] in terms of quantum decay.
The results presented in this review will be derived mostly for a model which has turned out to be most appropriate for describing open quantum systems in terms of Random Matrix Theory (RMT). Its formulation starts from the assumption that the Hamiltonian describing the quantum system itself plus its environment can be decomposed into a part relevant for the system, another part describing the structure of the decay channels themselves and a third one responsible for the interaction. A comprehensive discussion of this approach can be found in the book by Mahaux and Weidenmüller [2]; for a systematic overview see the recent review by Guhr et al. [20].
The application of RMT has allowed to obtain a large number of powerful and general results both for the description of closed and of open quantum systems. Prominent examples are the derivation of analytical expressions for many statistical properties of spectra like nearest-neighbor spacing distributions and number variances [21], [22], [23], two-point correlation functions [24] or the amplitudes of wave functions [25]. For open systems, the distributions of decay and transition amplitudes have been obtained in certain limiting cases [26], [27], [28].
Random Matrix Models turn out to successfully describe the properties of quantum systems the classical counterpart of which is chaotic [29], [30], [31]; for an excellent overview, see [32]. Moreover, during the past decade the development of RMT has largely profited from the broad application of super-symmetric methods. Starting from the pioneering work of Verbaarschot, Weidenmüller and Zirnbauer [24] a huge amount of new results has been obtained; for a contemporary review on this subject see Ref. [20].
Recently, strong support for the development of RMT and its relevance for the description of chaotic quantum systems resulted from experiments on microwave cavities [10], [11], [33], [34], [35]; for a review see Ref. [36]. Taking into account the equivalence between the time-independent Schrödinger equation and the Helmholtz equation, describing the behavior of electromagnetic fields in conducting cavities, one can use such (macroscopic) experiments in order to study the properties of purely quantum systems.
A central point in the presented review will be the discussion of systems with overlapping resonances, i.e. with resonances having (on average) a separation in energy which is small compared to their typical width. Historically, this situation has been discussed first for the case of many decay channels where the widths of resonances are large because they can decay via many different decay paths. This picture describes the typical behavior of strongly interacting many-body systems [2]. As an immediate consequence of such a large resonance overlap characteristic signatures (Ericson fluctuations [37], [38]) in the cross section have been recognized.
Only recently, it has been proven rigorously [27], [28] that overlapping resonances can occur, as well, if the number of open channels is small. This is due to the fact that, quantum mechanically, the “openness” is a two-dimensional quantity: it can be enlarged either by increasing the number of open channels or by enhancing the (average) coupling strength between bound states and a given decay channel.
Note, that the case of a large number of channels corresponds to the quasi-classical regime. A good illustration for this fact provide systems with leads. In this case, each decay channel corresponds to a transverse mode in the wave guide. Obviously, in the semiclassical limit, ℏ→0, the number of open transverse modes goes to infinity, for any given diameter of the lead, and for any given energy of the wave propagating through the lead. On the other hand, the few-channel case corresponds to the deep quantum region. In the present review, we shall concentrate just on this situation omitting almost completely the presentation of semiclassical methods for the description of open quantum systems; from the broad spectrum of excellent books and review articles on this subject the works of Berry [39], Gutzwiller [40] and Smilansky [41] can be recommended.
This review is organized as follows. In Section 2 the Hilbert space description of open quantum systems is introduced. A generic Hamiltonian for a system with N bound states coupled to M decay channels is provided. A formal solution of the corresponding Schrödinger equation is obtained and an intuitive scheme for deriving the corresponding scattering matrix is given. For pedagogical reasons, two simple cases corresponding to systems with one and two resonances are considered. On the basis of these studies, a first expectation concerning the effect of overlap of different resonances is formulated.
Using the results of the previous section, in Section 3 the decay properties of quantum systems are derived. After establishing a general relation between the decay function and the S-matrix, the decay of chaotic systems is studied in detail. Using the results of Ref. [24] for the S-matrix correlation function, the decay law for an arbitrary number of open channels and for arbitrary coupling strength between bound states and continua is presented. In particular, the generically non-exponential character of quantum decay is pointed out.
In Section 4 the properties of decaying quantum systems are discussed under the assumption that the degree of overlap can be made arbitrarily large without enlarging the number of open decay channels. This corresponds to the regime of strong coupling. It is shown that this assumption leads to a separation of scales of resonance widths and, correspondingly, to a separation of time scales in the decay of the system. Analytical expressions are obtained for the pole structure of the S-matrix and for its averaged value. The differences between regular and chaotic systems in the regime of strong coupling are indicated, and results for the distribution of decay widths and other statistical quantities are presented.
Section 5 collects results on a class of dynamical systems illustrating the conclusions obtained so far. For this purpose, scattering systems with leads are analyzed in detail. As a starting point, the scattering on quasi-one-dimensional systems (“graphs”) is investigated. An explicit expression for the S-matrix of such systems is given. On its basis, the coupling matrix elements between the bound system and the decay channels are derived analytically. In order to illustrate the effect of strong coupling in such systems, we investigate periodic quasi-one-dimensional structures permitting locally an arbitrarily large degree of resonance overlap. The discussion of microwave experiments verifying the decay law derived in Section 3 concludes this section.
In Section 6, the results of the preceeding sections are discussed from a different point of view. Namely, it is pointed out, that the distribution of resonances, as obtained by diagonalizing the effective Hamiltonian, is favorable for the system in the sense of realizing its slowest possible decay. A corresponding extremum principle for quantum decay is formulated, and a numerical illustration for the case of one open channel is presented.
Finally, Section 7 contains a summary of the presented results and indicates some possible further experimental verifications.
Section snippets
A general Hamiltonian
In the present section we introduce a Hamiltonian describing a generic scattering problem. On its basis, an expression for the scattering matrix of open systems will be derived. In Section 3, this expression will be used in order to obtain a general expression for the decay law.
Our starting point is the assumption that, for a broad class of scattering problems, the scattering event is confined to a certain compact part of the available space [28]. This region constitutes the so-called
Peculiarities of quantum decay: a heuristic consideration
In Section 2, the solution of the Schrödinger equation (2.2) for Hamiltonian (2.1) has been derived within the framework of Random Matrix Theory. In particular, we showed, that the scattering matrix essentially depends on the number of decay channels and on the coupling strength between bound states and continua.
In the present section, we discuss the decay law of a system desribed by the Hamiltonian (2.1). For this purpose, in Section 3.2 a general relation between the decay function and the
The spectrum of the effective Hamiltonian
In the previous sections, at different places the redistribution of decay widths has been mentioned which is expected to take place if the coupling strength between bound states and continua exceeds some critical value. For example, in Section 3.6 we noticed that the decay law for stochastic systems depends on the transmission coefficients Tc≡4xc/(1+xc)2 rather than on the coupling constant xc directly. As a consequence, the lifetime of the compound system becomes large if the coupling
Scattering systems with leads
In the preceeding sections, we discussed different aspects of open quantum systems. We started from the assumptions of Random Matrix Theory and considered systems described by the model Hamiltonian (2.1). In the following, we demonstrate that two crucial phenomena derived in these sections, namely the non-exponential decay of systems with a small number of open channels, and the redistribution of resonance widths in the region of overlapping resonances are present in real dynamical systems, as
Motivation
In the previous sections the decay of quantum systems has been discussed from different points of view. In particular, in Section 3, an equation has been derived, expressing the decay function in terms of the two-point correlation function of the corresponding scattering matrix, Eq. (3.24)
We recall that in this expression p(t) is the probability to find the system at time t in a bound state assuming it was excited by an
Summary
In the present review, the decay of open quantum systems has been studied. As a generic model, a scattering system has been considered which allows for a set of N metastable or compound states coupled to a set of M open channels. Although the formation and decay of compound systems were originally studied in the context of nuclear physics, the present considerations are applicable also to the many-body scattering problem of atomic, molecular and solid state physics as well as to the scattering
Note added in proof
Recently, a direct confirmation of the resonance behavior described in Section 5.4 has been given in a microwave experiment [178]. A particularly instructive discussion of a quasi-one-dimensional system illustrating analytically both the close connection between graphs and quantum chaos and the non-exponential decay of such systems can be found in [179], [180].
Acknowledgements
Most of this work has been accomplished at the Institute for Nuclear and Hadronic Physics of the Forschungszentrum Rossendorf, at the Max-Planck-Institute for Physics of Complex Systems, Dresden, and at the Institute for Theoretical Physics of the Technical University Dresden. It would have been impossible without the good working conditions created there. Especially, I am grateful to Prof. G. Soff from the Institute of Theoretical Physics at the Technical University Dresden for his continuous
References (180)
A unified theory of nuclear reactions I
Ann. Phys. (New York)
(1958)A unified theory of nuclear reactions II
Ann. Phys. (New York)
(1962)- et al.
Random-matrix theories in quantum physics, common concepts
Phys. Rep.
(1998) - et al.
Grassman integration in stochastic quantum physics: the case of compound-nucleus scattering
Phys. Rep.
(1985) - et al.
Stochastic vs. semiclassical approach to quantum-mechanical chaotic scattering
Ann. Phys. (New York)
(1991) - et al.
Chaotic Scattering and Transmission Fluctuations
Physica D
(1991) A theory of fluctuations in nuclear cross sections
Ann. Phys.
(1963)- et al.
Compound-nucleus scattering in the presence of direct reactions
Phys. Lett. B
(1985) - et al.
Time evolution of chaotic quantum systems
Ann. Phys. (New York)
(1992) - et al.
Resonances of a superconducting microwave cavity: A test of the Breit–Wigner formula over a large dynamic range
Nucl. Phys. A
(1993)
Statistical model cross sections for overlapping resonances
Nucl. Phys. B
On collision duration in the presence of strong overlapping resonance levels
Phys. Lett. B
The α + α → 8Be Double Resonances at the 16.6 and 16.9 MeV levels
Nucl. Phys. A
Two-photon ionisation: interference and population trapping
Phys. Lett. A
Trapping in the coherent radiationless decay of degenerate states
Phys. Lett. A
On statistical theory of overlapping resonances
Phys. Lett. B
Dynamics and statistics of unstable quantum states
Nucl. Phys. A
N levels and one continuum: bound states in continuum and dependence of resonance parameters on the coupling strength
Phys. Lett. A
On the generalization of the level repulsion theorem to resonances
Phys. Lett. B
Energy repulsion and width attraction in a system of two interacting resonances in 8Be
Phys. Lett. B
Trapping in competitive decay of degenerate states
Phys. Lett. A
Quantum interference effects in decay rate of metastable systems
Phys. Lett. A
Chaotic behaviour of scattering induced by strong external coupling
Phys. Lett. A
Average level repulsion for N narrow resonances and its application to 53Cr
Phys. Lett. B
Collective dynamics of unstable quantum states
Ann. Phys. (New York)
Energy attraction and width repulsion due to external mixing and an application to 8Be
Nucl. Phys. A
Evidence for trapping and collectivization of resonances at strong coupling
Nucl. Phys. A
The 2+ doublet in 8Be: an example of accidental resonance degeneracy
Phys. Lett. B
Time delay correlations in chaotic scattering: random matrix approach
Physica D
Berechnung der natürlichen Linienbreiten auf Grund der Diracschen Lichttheorie
Z. Phys.
Shell-Model Approach to Nuclear Reactions
Higher angular momentum and long range interaction in resonance reactions
Phys. Rev.
On a class of analytic functions from the quantum theory of collisions
Ann. Math.
On the connection between the distribution of poles and residues for an R function and its invariant derivative
Ann. Math.
Interference effects in the radiative decay of closely spaced levels
Molec. Phys.
Experimental demonstration of chaotic scattering of microwaves
Phys. Rev. Lett.
Experimental observation of scarred eigenfunctions of chaotic microwave cavities
Phys. Rev. Lett.
Distribution of eigenmodes in a superconducting stadium billiard with chaotic dynamics
Phys. Rev. Lett.
Random-matrix theory of quantum transport
Rev. Mod. Phys.
Chaotic Spectroscopy
Phys. Rev. Lett.
Semiclassical quantization of chaotic billiards – a scattering theory approach
Nonlinearity
A scattering approach to the quantization of billiards – the inside-outside duality
Chaos
Evanescent and real waves in quantum billiards and Gaussian beams
J. Phys. A
Spectral duality for planar billiards
Commun. Math. Phys.
Nonexponential decay of a stochastic one-channel system
Phys. Rev.
Gaussian orthogonal ensemble statistics in a microwave stadium billiard with chaotic dynamics: Porter–Thomas distributions and algebraic decay of time correlations
Phys. Rev. Lett.
Statistical theory of the energy levels of complex systems I
J. Math. Phys.
Statistical theory of the energy levels of complex systems II
J. Math. Phys.
Statistical theory of the energy levels of complex systems III
J. Math. Phys.
Basic Features of Efetov's Supersymmetry Approach
Cited by (200)
Observing Relative Homotopic Degeneracy Conversions with Circuit Metamaterials
2024, Physical Review LettersRealistic prediction and engineering of high-Q modes to implement stable Fano resonances in acoustic devices
2023, Nature CommunicationsHigh Q-factor reconfigurable microresonators induced in side-coupled optical fibres
2023, Light: Science and ApplicationsExceptional points in periodic array of silicon rods
2023, Applied Physics LettersIntensity statistics inside an open wave-chaotic cavity with broken time-reversal invariance
2023, Physical Review E