Research reportAccelerated time-course of inhibition of return in Huntington's disease
Introduction
Control of automatic visuospatial attention, a stimulus-driven, bottom-up process, has been extensively investigated using cue-target tasks, in which either spatially compatible, or incompatible, cue and target stimuli are presented successively [48]. In such tasks the transient presentation of a cue stimulus appears to promote independent, and conflicting, facilitatory and inhibitory processes [35], [65], representing preparation-for-action evoked by a stimulus driven shift of attention, as well as the active inhibition of this more automatic visuomotor process. These competing processes result in differential effects for short and long delays, or stimulus onset asynchronies (SOA), between cue and target presentation. Short SOAs facilitate responses to targets presented in the same location as the cue, compared to those presented in alternate locations. Longer SOAs result in a relative slowing of response to a target presented in the same location as the previous cue stimulus [49]. The latter phenomenon, known as inhibition of return (IOR), has been the subject of intensive investigation, with various theoretical and neural accounts proposed.
Attentional theories attribute the source of IOR to the orienting of attention towards a particular location, and the subsequent removal of this attention, discouraging re-inspection of an already attended-to location [27], [49], [55]. Conversely, it has also been proposed that IOR is simply a consequence of the activation of the ocular motor system. As such it may result from the inhibitory modulation of a motor program generated towards previously cued locations [61], [62]. However, these accounts are not necessarily mutually exclusive, and may simply represent different manifestations of the same underlying process [54].
Although the exact neural mechanisms underlying IOR are unclear, the involvement of the midbrain structure superior colliculus (SC) [9], [55], [64] is consistent with both sensory-attentional and ocular motor accounts, given that is implicated in both attentional [53] and ocular motor processes [58]. Further, the SC contains cells which are sensitive to a range of different sensory modalities, consistent with the presence of IOR, albeit with differing time courses, over and within a range of motor paradigms [59]. Certainly patients with progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP), a neurodegenerative disorder with predilection for the SC, fail to show inhibition at longer SOAs [51].
However, the associated reduction in facilitatory activity over the SC appears to reflect a signal reduction that has taken place cortically [10], [36], [67]. Notably, neural damage in PSP is not specific to the SC [51]. Ro et al. [54], for example, have demonstrated that the frontal eye fields (FEF), which are heavily interconnected with the SC, play a crucial role in generating IOR. Transcranial magnetic stimulation applied over the FEFs resulted in the elimination of the slowed response to cued targets [54]. This suggests that the inhibitory component of the IOR may emanate from the FEF. Further, it has been proposed that this temporary inhibitory link set up between stimuli at inhibited locations and their responses, may derive from the posterior parietal cortex [15]. Thus IOR may be characterised as the relative precedence of inhibitory activity, versus facilitatory activity, over the SC, which is determined cortically, by structures commonly involved in both eye movement and attention [6], [28].
The basal ganglia (BG) also comprise an important component of both ocular motor and attentional networks, and are primarily concerned with the focusing of neural resources via selectively facilitating or inhibiting neural activity [37]. Crucial for the efficient resolution of response conflict [70], they influence the selection and suppression of competing responses via both direct facilitatory, and indirect inhibitory pathways [56]. Significantly, the SC is normally gated by tonic inhibitory input from the BG output structure substantia nigra pars reticula (SNr) [20], [21]. Thus the BG may well influence the balance of activity over the SC under conditions which promote competing processes, including situations which generate IOR.
Given the anatomical and functional links between the BG and the SC, compromised performance may be anticipated in patients with BG dysfunction. Indeed, altered performance has been revealed in Parkinson's disease (PD), predominantly a BG disorder, although findings are varied and widely discrepant [5], [12], [26], [46], [47], [71]. These discrepancies may well be a function of methodological inconsistencies between the various studies [46], including the predictiveness of cue stimuli and the temporal properties of cue-target presentation. However, in the single study which has addressed IOR in PD within the context of eye movement, an increased magnitude in the IOR was found to correspond with disease stage [5]. These authors attributed this to over-active reflexive attentional processes in PD. As PD manifests in the overactivity of BG inhibitory output to the SC, this finding may alternatively reflect the rapid decay of facilitatory cue-related activity. Conceivably this would be reflected in the relative precedence of cortically modulated inhibitory activity over the SC regions encoding the cue-target location, over time.
Attentional control has received some attention in Huntington's disease (HD), also primarily a disorder of the BG. In the initial stages of the disease, there is preferential degeneration of indirect, inhibitory pathways, resulting in difficulty inhibiting irrelevant responses, as well as perseverative behaviour [19], [66]. Perseveration has been revealed in numerous set-shifting tasks whereby patients persist with a response set no longer appropriate to the task [16], [17], [24], [32], [60]. Whether IOR is altered in HD remains unexplored.
This study sought to determine the nature and extent of deficits in HD with respect to the allocation and control of automatic visuospatial attention over a range of SOAs, including those expected to elicit IOR. Given the intimate functional and anatomical relationship between visuospatial attention and oculomotor processes [2], we chose a saccadic paradigm similar to that of Briand et al. [5]. Cost/benefit analyses of cue presentation were ascertained by comparing latencies of valid and invalidly cued saccades with latencies of un-cued saccades. Whilst latencies following neutral cues are more conventionally used for this type of analysis, we attempted to ascertain the ‘absolute’ temporal effects of non-informative spatial cues on subsequent responses. It was considered that because response conflict is inherent in the presentation of two competing visual stimuli (i.e., discrete modulation of activity over a range of ocular motor structures) they may be inappropriate as a baseline measure of performance for patients who exhibit deficient conflict resolution. However, we do acknowledge a degree of scepticism about the appropriateness of either measure as representative of baseline performance.
Ocular motor deficits in HD parallel deficits found for other motor systems, resulting not only in difficulty initiating voluntarily saccades, but in distractibility (erroneous movement) when presented with novel stimuli [34], especially during gaze fixation tasks which require a spatially unrelated response (anti-saccade) [30], [31], [34], [66]. Thus distractibility, or poor fixation, was anticipated in HD. Accordingly, the premature release of SC activity representing the location of a cue was anticipated, resulting in a relative precedence of cortical inhibition. HD patients might therefore exhibit either increased IOR, similar to PD patients [5], or early onset of IOR. Similarly, perseverative activity, also a consequence of the reduced inhibitory output of the BG, may result in the persistence of suppressed cue-related activity, and earlier onset of IOR. Thus it was anticipated that the temporal exploration of spatial cueing in HD, might help elucidate both the impact and time-course of both facilitatory and inhibitory processes. This in turn may lead to a greater understanding of the IOR phenomenon and of the range of deficits found in HD.
Section snippets
Participants
All participants gave their informed consent prior to inclusion in the study, in accordance with the Helsinki declaration. Ten patients with mild to moderate HD participated voluntarily in this study. Data for two of these patients were deemed unsuitable for analysis, with saccadic intrusions corrupting an unacceptable number of trials (greater than 50%). The remaining eight patients were aged between 41 and 63 years (M = 50.87, S.D. = 7.31). All were clinically diagnosed with HD by a neurologist
Saccadic intrusions
A significantly larger proportion of trials were corrupted by anticipations or saccadic intrusions by HD patients (7.1%) compared to control subjects (1.3%), χ2 (1, n = 4013) = 88.96, p < 0.001.
Erroneous responses to cue
HD patients generated a similar proportion of erroneous responses to the cue (8.4%), as control subjects (7.3%). Given the potential bias resulting from the presentation of relatively fewer catch trials (one third as many trials), these were removed from ANOVA of error distribution. Notably, although HD
Discussion
This study utilised a non-predictive peripheral cueing paradigm to evaluate the nature and extent of attentional deficits in symptomatic HD patients. Specifically, it sought to investigate the effect of attentional manipulation on saccadic behaviour, presenting spatially valid and invalid visual cues with a range of stimulus onset asynchronies between cue and target. Results reveal abnormally early onset of IOR in HD, as anticipated, although appropriate suppression of a ‘reflexive’ response to
Acknowledgements
We gratefully acknowledge the help and cooperation of all subjects who so willingly participated in this study. This research was supported, in part, by a Jean Gilmore bursary, awarded to J. Fielding by the AFWU-SA Inc. Trust Fund.
References (71)
- et al.
A parametric fMRI study of overt and covert shifts of visuospatial attention
NeuroImage
(2001) - et al.
Automatic orienting of visuospatial attention in Parkinson's disease
Neuropsychologia
(2001) - et al.
A common network of functional areas for attention and eye movements
Neuron
(1998) - et al.
Inhibitory tagging of locations in the blind field of hemianopic patients
Conscious Cogn
(1997) - et al.
Mini-Mental State. A practical method for grading the cognitive state of patients for the clinician
J Psychiatr Res
(1975) - et al.
The effect of Huntington's disease and Gilles de la Tourette's syndrome on the ability to hold and shift attention
Neuropsychologia
(1996) - et al.
Ocular motor abnormalities in Huntington's disease
Vision Res
(1997) - et al.
Facilitation and inhibition arising from the exogenous orienting of attention depends on the temporal properties of spatial cues and targets
Neuropsychologia
(1999) The physiological basis of clinical deficits in Parkinson's disease
Prog Neurobiol
(2003)- et al.
Heterogeneity of cingulate contributions to spatial attention
NeuroImage
(2001)
Saccadic eye movements: overview of neural circuitry
Prog Brain Res
Location and function of the human frontal eye-field: a selective review
Neuropsychologia
The posterior cingulate and medial prefrontal cortex mediate the anticipatory allocation of spatial attention
NeuroImage
Distribution in the visual field of the costs of voluntarily allocated attention and of the inhibitory after-effects of covert orienting
Neuropsycholgia
Visual attention in Huntington's disease: the effect of cuing on saccade latencies and manual reaction times
Neuropsychologia
The generality of parietal involvement in visual attention
Neuron
Activation of conflicting responses in Parkinson's disease: evidence for degrading and facilitating effects on response time
Neuropsychologia
Oculomotor disorders in Huntington's chorea
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry
An inventory for measuring depression
Arch Gen Psychiatry
The Beck Depression Inventory (Manual)
Voluntary orienting is dissociated from target detection in human posterior parietal cortex
Nat Neurosci
Control of goal-directed and stimulus-driven attention in the brain
Nat Rev Neurosci
Contribution of the primate superior colliculus to inhibition of return
J Cogn Neurosci
Comparison of the discharge characteristics of brainstem omnipause neurons and superior colliculus fixation neurons in monkey: implications for control of fixation and saccade behavior
J Neurophysiol
An examination of the nature of attentional deficits in patients with Parkinson's disease: evidence from a spatial orienting task
J Int Neuropsychol Soc
Spatial attention deficits in humans: a comparison of superior parietal and temporo-parietal junction lesions
Neuropsychology
Inhibitory processing in the attentional networks
The Simon effect and attention deficits in Gilles de la Tourette's syndrome and Huntington's disease
Brain
A large-scale distributed network for covert spatial attention: further anatomical delineation based on stringent behavioural and cognitive controls
Brain
Cognitive flexibility and complex integration in Parkinson's disease, Huntington's disease and schizophrenia
J Int Neuropsychol Soc
Role of basal ganglia in initiation and suppression of saccadic eye movements
Role of the basal ganglia in the control of purposive saccadic eye movements
Physiol Rev
The neural mechanisms of top-down attentional control
Nat Neurosci
Unified Huntington's disease rating scale: reliability and consistency
Mov Disord
Development of neuropsychological deficits in Huntington's disease
Arch Neurol
Cited by (18)
The role of primary motor cortex in manual inhibition of return: A transcranial magnetic stimulation study
2023, Behavioural Brain ResearchTranscranial magnetic stimulation as a tool for understanding neurophysiology in Huntington's disease: A review
2013, Neuroscience and Biobehavioral ReviewsCitation Excerpt :Psychomotor speed has also been shown to be sensitive to disease progression (Bechtel et al., 2010; Harrington et al., 2012; Lemiere et al., 2004; Rosenberg et al., 1995; Rowe et al., 2010; Rupp et al., 2010; Snowden et al., 2002; Solomon et al., 2008; Stout et al., 2011; Tabrizi et al., 2009, 2012, 2011) and has been found to correlate with neuroimaging measures, such as striatal atrophy, extrastriatal WM and cortical thickness in both pre-HD and symp-HD (Bamford et al., 1995; Bechtel et al., 2010; Paulsen et al., 2008). Several studies have shown a reliable deficit in inhibitory control in pre-HD and symp-HD, thought to be related to degeneration of the indirect inhibitory BG circuitry (Aron et al., 2003; Farrow et al., 2007; Fielding et al., 2006; Lawrence et al., 1998a; Swerdlow et al., 1995). There are also consistent reports of slowed processing speed and reaction times, which emerge in pre-HD and significantly worsen with disease progression, and are associated with BG degeneration (Beste et al., 2006; Duff et al., 2010; Georgiou et al., 1995, 1997; Joel, 2001; Kirkwood et al., 2000a,b; Lehéricy et al., 2006; Saint-Cyr, 2003; Schneider et al., 2010; Ward et al., 2006).
Oculomotor deficits affect neuropsychological performance in oculomotor apraxia type 2
2013, CortexCitation Excerpt :SI are common in the normal population (Abadi and Gowen, 2004). Abnormal SI have reported in several neurological diseases (Fielding et al., 2006; Rascol et al., 1991) but have never been described in AOA2 (Le Ber et al., 2004). In this study, both siblings experienced increased frequencies of SI.
Electrophysiological measures as potential biomarkers in Huntington's disease: Review and future directions
2010, Brain Research ReviewsCitation Excerpt :The Nogo-N2 is thought to be associated with pre-motor inhibitory processes (Falkenstein et al., 1999) or conflict processes (Nieuwenhuis et al., 2003) and the Nogo-P3 is likely to be related to evaluation of the inhibitory processes (Band and van Boxtel, 1999; Roche et al., 2005). In line with other behavioral studies (Aron et al., 2003; Fielding et al., 2006), Beste et al. (2008c) found HD participants to be significantly impaired in their ability to inhibit responses compared to controls. Corresponding electrophysiological data indicate there was a strong selective attenuation of the Nogo-P3, but not the Nogo-N2, in HD compared to controls.
Confirmation for a delayed inhibition of return by systematic sampling in schizophrenia
2010, Psychiatry ResearchCitation Excerpt :IOR mechanisms are narrowly determined by anatomical structures commonly involved in both eye movement and attention like the superior colliculus (Sapir et al., 1999; Dorris et al., 2002). Also the basal ganglia markedly influences the generation of IOR (Fielding et al., 2006). A number of studies reported altered IOR in schizophrenia patients with a reduction of its amplitude (Huey and Wexler, 1994; Carter et al., 1994; Sapir et al., 2001; Gouzoulis-Mayfrank et al., 2004, 2006, for a review see Kebir et al., 2008).
Space-based but not object-based inhibition of return is impaired in Parkinson's disease
2009, Neuropsychologia