Case reportVolar dislocation of the second and third carpometacarpal joints – the Lisfranc injury of the hand?Luxation palmaire des deuxième et troisième articulations carpo-métacarpiennes : traumatisme de Lisfranc de la main ?
Introduction
Hand fractures make up a large proportion of those attending the emergency department (ED), accounting for 1.5% of all ED admissions in the US [1]. Carpometacarpal dislocations account for a much lower proportion of hand injuries [2], with the vast majority of them being described in the literature as small case series and case reports.
Although there are many case reports and series describing the dorsal dislocations of the CMC joints [3], descriptions of volar dislocations in the literature appear to be much rarer. Despite the scarcity of these injuries, Buchholz et al. were keen to illustrate that these dislocations particularly at this CMC level have to be monitored closely to prevent suboptimal future outcomes associated with high energy injury and prolonged swelling [4]. With the exception of a few case reports of volar CMC dislocations of the relatively mobile thumb [5], only small numbers of CMC dislocations have been described from second to fifth fingers [6], [7]. To date there has only been a couple of other case reports involving only the volar dislocation of the 2nd and 3rd CMC joints including that described by Harwin et al. [8]. These authors highlighted the importance of the firm soft tissue attachments in terms of capsule and ligament which is thought to contribute to the infrequency of this injury pattern. Harwin et al. went on to describe the joint articulations and the rigid central pillar of the hand formed by the 2nd and 3rd metacarpals [8] – this was later confirmed through kinematic analysis analyzing differences in movements arcs of the 2nd and 3rd CMC joints [9].
This case report is presented to highlight the importance of rare injuries that can potentially present to any clinician treating hand injuries. This report also presents a case for further cross-sectional imaging essential in delineating the injury pattern whilst also guiding operative management.
Section snippets
Case report and mechanism of injury
This 18-year-old right hand dominant male presented to our emergency department with right hand swelling and discomfort following a rugby injury. He gave a clear history of his injury mechanism which began as he fell onto his outstretched hand. After landing with his hand effectively planted in the ground, he remembered his metacarpophalangeal joints hyperextended, his wrist in neutral and the elbow extended. At this point another player landed over his shoulder, effectively transmitting an
Discussion
The precise anatomical relationships of the CMC joints are required for normal function of the hand. Buchholz et al. clearly demonstrate that with disruption and dislocation of CMC joints can result in persistent swelling with poor outcomes [4]. They described the importance of nearby soft tissue structures with the deep branch of ulnar nerve closely related with the volar surface of the 5th CMC joint, with the deep palmar arch closely related to the 3rd CMC joint. Therefore, the importance of
Conclusion
Isolated volar dislocation of the 2nd and 3rd CMC joints is a rare injury. We present this method of fixation to clarify early assessment and management. This is a similar mechanism of a Lisfranc injury in the foot [14] and highlights again the importance of recognizing clearly the mechanism of the injury, which will guide the appropriate radiographic assessment.
The injury described is likely to occur at a relatively similar frequency to other potentially debilitating hand injuries such as
Disclosure of interest
The authors declare that they have no competing interest.
References (14)
- et al.
The frequency and epidemiology of hand and forearm fractures in the United States
J Hand Surg Am
(2001) Carpometacarpal dislocations: report of five cases and review of the literature
J Hand Surg Am
(1986)- et al.
Three-dimensional kinematic analysis of the second through fifth carpometacarpal joints
J Hand Surg Am
(2001) - et al.
The ligament and skeletal anatomy of the second through fifth carpometacarpal joints and adjacent structures
J Hand Surg Am
(2001) - et al.
Dorsal dislocations of the second to fifth carpometacarpal joints: a case report
Hand Surg
(2008) - et al.(2010)
- et al.
Volar dislocation of the index carpometacarpal joint in association with a Bennett's fracture of the thumb: a rare injury pattern
Emerg Med J
(2006)
Cited by (3)
Pure divergent dislocation of the index and middle finger carpometacarpal joints: A rare case
2019, Trauma Case ReportsCitation Excerpt :Therefore, the divergent dislocation is very complicate to produce, they need multiple forces to the hand including deceleration and rotation, even more enough forces to dislocate the keystone of the hand corresponding to the third CMC joint [8]. Gunther suspected a torsional force pushing the carpus to rotate on a fixed metacarpal base with the hand firmly fixed on the motorbike handle [7]. Anteroposterior radiographs showed apparent shortening of metacarpals and loss of parallelism between metacarpal bases and carpal bones, but CMC dislocation can be concealed by overlapping of the joints.
Early Recognition and Treatment of Carpometacarpal Fractures and Dislocations
2021, Revista Brasileira de OrtopediaCombined Fracture of Carpal and Volar Divergent Dislocation of the Second to Fifth Carpometacarpal Joints
2021, Acta Chirurgiae Orthopaedicae et Traumatologiae Cechoslovaca