Formation of cheddar cheese analogues using canola oil and ultrasonication – A comparison between single and double emulsion systems
Introduction
Developing reduced-fat cheeses with sensory attributes comparable with those of full-fat cheese is challenging, but has considerable commercial potential. One promising approach is the use of double emulsions (Garti, 1997), in which emulsion droplets themselves contain an inner emulsion of the opposite phase. For reduced fat cheeses, a water-in-oil-in-water type emulsion (W1/O/W2) can be used to displace some of the fat present in cheese with water. In such a system, water droplets can be emulsified within emulsified fat droplets that are themselves surrounded by the aqueous phase of the cheese.
Simply reducing the fat content by omission detrimentally affects texture, making the cheese firmer. By including water within the fat droplets, double emulsions can potentially reduce fat without significantly altering cheese structure. A double emulsion droplet can effectively occupy the same volume as a fat droplet in a regular emulsion, but with the calorific content reduced due to displacement of the oil with internalised water droplets. Double emulsions have been proposed to reduce the fat content of various food products including salad dressings (Gaonkar, 1994), Gouda cheese (Felfoul, Bornaz, Baccouche, Sahli, & Attia, 2015) and white fresh cheeses (Lobato-Calleros et al., 2006, Lobato-Calleros et al., 2007, Lobato-Calleros et al., 2008). However, achieving stability is a key challenge in the development of double emulsion products. The need for large amounts of surfactant to stabilise both the inner and outer phases (Matsumoto, Kita, & Yonezawa, 1976) has restricted the use of double emulsions in the dairy industry due to the cost and the use of non-dairy emulsifiers such as Span 80, Tween 80 (Felfoul et al., 2015), and DATEM (Lobato-Calleros et al., 2008). There are ongoing efforts, however, to use natural emulsifiers like proteins and polysaccharides as replacements for synthetic surfactants (Benichou et al., 2002, Shanmugam and Ashokkumar, 2014).
Recently, an approach that reduces the amount of synthetic emulsifier needed for stable double emulsions was reported by Leong, Zhou, Kukan, Ashokkumar, and Martin (2017) where double emulsions were prepared using sunflower oil, in which the internal water droplets were stabilised by small amounts of lipophilic emulsifier and the outer oil droplets were stabilised by proteins in the skim milk. As the bulk aqueous phase in these preparations is skim milk, this ingredient has potential to be readily transformed into cheese-like products. In principle, these emulsions could be produced with droplets of similar size to fat globules in cheese milk. This modified milk stream could then be used to create a cheese microstructure similar to that of full-fat cheese, but with the fat content reduced by the skim milk entrapped in the internal phase.
Ultrasonication is an effective method to create double emulsions with an efficiency comparable with that of conventional homogenisation and rotor stator type devices (Walstra, 1993). An advantage of ultrasound is that the applied energy density can be readily tuned to tailor the droplet size and enable a high yield of encapsulation in the double emulsions (Tang and Sivakumar, 2012, Tang et al., 2013). The ability to control droplet size could also help improve the sensory quality of reduced-fat products (Goudédranche, Fauquant, & Maubois, 2000). The ability to produce small double emulsion droplets at high yield with a high displaced volume of fat would provide complementary benefits due to the increased effective fat volume and increased surface area. Ultrasonication can also provide synergistic effects, such as partial denaturation of proteins that can help improve emulsion stability (Shanmugam & Ashokkumar, 2014). The effects of ultrasonication on protein denaturation (Chandrapala and Leong, 2015, Stathopulos et al., 2004) and/or lipid oxidation (Chemat et al., 2004, Juliano et al., 2014), however, need to be characterised further in the context of finished cheese products, as these factors can potentially affect cheese functionality and flavour development.
Double emulsions can be used to displace fat in cheese and also to replace dairy fat with less expensive oils of plant and vegetable origin. For example, canola oil is less expensive than milk fat and has a higher proportion of healthy polyunsaturated and ω-3 fatty acids. The use of non-dairy liquid oils in cheese production has to date been limited. So far, olive oil (Felfoul et al., 2015) has been used for the production of Gouda cheese, while canola oil has been evaluated in the production of soft white cheese (Lobato-Calleros et al., 2007). No study has yet evaluated the use of ultrasonically prepared double emulsions for the creation of Cheddar-cheese analogues. Furthermore, there are, to our knowledge, no prior studies that have evaluated the use of ultrasonication to produce simple emulsions formulated with liquid vegetable oils that can be converted into hard cheese-like products.
This study investigated the properties of pressed Cheddar cheese analogues created from single and double emulsions of canola oil formed using ultrasonication. The cheese analogues were compared with an established Cheddar cheese model using milk fat from cream. The effects of the ultrasonic treatment on the protein and fat content of the milk used to make cheese, the cheese itself and the whey were assessed. The microstructure and functional properties of the cheeses, including melting capability and texture were analysed. This study provides information that will be useful for developing new cheese products with a reduced and modified fat content.
Section snippets
Materials
Canola oil (Woolworths, Bella Vista, Australia) was used in the single and double emulsions. Polyglycerol polyricinoleate (PGPR), sourced from a confectionary company in Australia, was used at a fixed loading of 2 wt% of the oil phase to stabilise the inner W1/O emulsion of the double emulsion (Leong, Zhou, Zhou, Ashokkumar, & Martin, 2018). Pasteurised and homogenised skim milk (Pauls Dairy, Lactalis, South Brisbane, Australia) containing <0.1% (w/v) fat was used as the bulk phase of the
Cheese appearance, composition and yield
The three cheeses (CONCH, SECH and DECH) behaved similarly during production, with no notable differences in the milk ripening, renneting or cooking steps. During cheddaring, the cooked curds of the emulsion (DECH and SECH) cheeses initially appeared to undergo less complete matting, as also occurs when Cheddar cheese is made with homogenised milk, where the fat differs in structure from unhomogenised milk (Peters, 1956). After pressing, however, the curds of the emulsion cheeses adhered
Conclusions
This study illustrates how the fat/oil type and method of emulsification affects the distribution of fat within the cheese microstructure, and in turn the physical properties of the resulting analogue cheeses produced, both immediately after pressing and upon maturation. The double emulsion (DECH) cheeses had a distinct microstructure with a skim milk phase encapsulated within the emulsified oil droplets. Small skim milk droplets remained dispersed within double emulsion droplets, even after 7
Acknowledgements
Philip Wilcox and Dr Ronald Halim are acknowledged for their assistance in the set-up of gas chromatography protocols used for the fatty acid profiling. Confocal microscopes were accessed within the Bio21 Advanced Microscopy Facility. This research was supported under Australian Research Council’s Industrial Transformation Research Program (ITRP) funding scheme (project number IH120100005). The ARC Dairy Innovation Hub is a collaboration between The University of Melbourne, The University of
References (39)
- et al.
Effects of ultrasound on the thermal and structural characteristics of proteins in reconstituted whey protein concentrate
Ultrasonics Sonochemistry
(2011) - et al.
High power ultrasound effects on lipid oxidation of refined sunflower oil
Ultrasonics Sonochemistry
(2004) - et al.
Some features of breakdown in water-in-oil-in-water multiple emulsions
Journal of Colloid and Interface Science
(1981) Double emulsions—scope, limitations and new achievements
Colloids and Surfaces A: Physicochemical and Engineering Aspects
(1997)- et al.
Application of exopolysaccharide-producing cultures in reduced-fat Cheddar cheese: Cryo-scanning electron microscopy observations
Journal of Dairy Science
(2005) - et al.
Lipid oxidation volatiles absent in milk after selected ultrasound processing
Ultrasonics Sonochemistry
(2014) - et al.
Preparation of water-in-oil-in-water emulsions by low frequency ultrasound using skim milk and sunflower oil
Food Hydrocolloids
(2017) - et al.
The formation of double emulsions in skim milk using minimal food-grade emulsifiers–A comparison between ultrasonic and high pressure homogenisation efficiencies
Journal of Food Engineering
(2018) - et al.
Ultrasound improves the renneting properties of milk
Ultrasonics Sonochemistry
(2014) - et al.
Microstructure and texture of white fresh cheese made with canola oil and whey protein concentrate in partial or total replacement of milk fat
Food Research International
(2007)
Reduced-fat white fresh cheese-like products obtained from W 1/O/W 2 multiple emulsions: Viscoelastic and high-resolution image analyses
Food Research International
Structural and textural characteristics of reduced-fat cheese-like products made from W 1/O/W 2 emulsions and skim milk
LWT-Food Science and Technology
Lipid rafts in the bovine milk fat globule membrane revealed by the lateral segregation of phospholipids and heterogeneous distribution of glycoproteins
Food Chemistry
An attempt at preparing water-in-oil-in-water multiple-phase emulsions
Journal of Colloid and Interface Science
The effect of pH at renneting on the microstructure, composition and texture of Cheddar cheese
Food Research International
The effect of calcium chloride addition on the microstructure and composition of Cheddar cheese
International Dairy Journal
Proteolysis and lipolysis of goat milk cheese
Journal of Dairy Science
Cheddar cheese made from pasteurized milk homogenized at various pressures
Journal of Dairy Science
Ultrasonic preparation of stable flax seed oil emulsions in dairy systems–physicochemical characterization
Food Hydrocolloids
Cited by (9)
Fabrication of double emulsion gel using monoacylglycerol and whey protein concentrate: The effects of primary emulsion gel fraction and particle size
2023, Journal of Food EngineeringCitation Excerpt :Our previous research on the bigel (hydrogel-in-oleogel) system showed that the reduction of hydrogel particle size, irrespective of the utilised hydrocolloid type, reinforced the final gel structure (Habibi et al., 2022). HIU has been used as an emulsification method in various emulsion systems such as PE (Silva et al., 2021b; Taha et al., 2020; Zhou et al., 2021) and DE (W/O/W) (Leong et al., 2018, 2020; Silva et al., 2020; Silva and Chandrapala, 2021). HIU has a significant role in producing small and narrow droplet size distribution of emulsion because of shear force, high pressure, microjets, shock waves, and acoustic streaming derived from acoustic cavitation (Zhou et al., 2021).
Protein fortification of model cheese matrices using whey protein-enriched double emulsions
2023, Food HydrocolloidsCitation Excerpt :Put simply, a double emulsion is an emulsion in which the emulsion droplets contain an inner emulsion of the opposite phase (Leong, Zhou, Kukan, Ashokkumar, & Martin, 2017). The inclusion of water-in-oil-in-water (W/O/W) double emulsions in cheese making is a relatively new idea, which has so far been used to reduce the fat content (Felfoul, Bornaz, Baccouche, Sahli, & Attia, 2015; Leong et al., 2020; Lobato-Calleros et al., 2007; Lobato-Calleros et al., 2008; Lobato-Calleros, Rodriguez, Sandoval-Castilla, Vernon-Carter, & Alvarez-Ramirez, 2006) or to encapsulate nutrients such as vitamin B-12 into cheese (Giroux et al., 2013). In addition, the use of double emulsions allows substitution of anhydrous milk fat (rich in saturated fatty acids (Chouinard, Girard, & Brisson, 1998; DiNicolantonio & O’Keefe, 2017)) with less expensive and potentially healthier fat alternatives such as sunflower, canola or olive oil, which are rich in poly-unsaturated fatty acids (including ω-3 and ω-6) (Chouinard et al., 1998; Ramos, Fernández, Casas, Rodríguez, & Pérez, 2009), further improving the nutritional value of cheese analogues.
Recent trends in the development of healthy and functional cheese analogues-a review
2022, LWTCitation Excerpt :As already discussed, the development of CAs requires the formation of emulsions (Fig. 2). Leong et al. (2020) attempted to develop Cheddar CAs with canola oil and ultrasonication by forming single emulsion (O|W) and double emulsion (W|O|W) systems. The O|W emulsion was softer and showed more coalescence.
Recent Advances in the Formation, Stability, and Emerging Food Application of Water-in-Oil-in-Water Double Emulsion Carriers
2024, Food and Bioprocess TechnologyNatural ingredients and probiotics for lowering cholesterol and saturated fat in dairy products: an updated review
2023, Quality Assurance and Safety of Crops and FoodsUltrasonic Emulsification of Milk Proteins Stabilized Primary and Double Emulsions: A Review
2023, Food Reviews International