Calorimetric method for determining the thermochemical energy storage capacities of redox metal oxides
Introduction
As renewable power generation increases worldwide, the need for advanced energy storage methods continues to grow. Solar energy in particular requires the development of efficient storage systems in order to overcome its intermittent nature and meet daily energy demands [1]. One such method of interest is thermochemical energy storage (TCES). These systems are highly attractive: they provide higher energy densities and improved thermal efficiencies through higher operating temperatures relative to existing sensible or latent energy storage systems, and can be implemented for peak-production storage across a wide variety of power generation methods [2]− [3].
The current focus in this field is the development of materials that are reactively stable and exhibit high energy storage capacities at high temperatures [3]. Transition metal oxides have been shown to be good candidates for TCES via reduction/oxidation reactions at high temperatures. Dizaji et al. [2] and Wu et al. [3] performed comprehensive reviews of the current literature on both pure and mixed metal oxide redox TCES systems under study, finding that in general, these systems show promise for their high operating temperatures (≥ 700 °C), long energy storage durations, high storage capacities due to high reaction enthalpies, and the ability to be oxidized in air, avoiding complex gas storage systems. Of the variety of metal oxides considered, manganese oxides appear to be an attractive candidate for their low toxicity and low costs relative to other systems, such as Co3O4 and BaO2 [3]. Studies on the pure Mn2O3/Mn3O4 redox couple have all identified very poor oxidation kinetics as the main drawback of pure manganese oxides [[4], [5], [6], [7], [8], [9]]. Subsequent studies have attempted to enhance oxidation kinetics by mixing manganese oxides with a variety of other transition metal oxides, to varying degrees of success [1,2,5,[10], [11], [12], [13], [14], [15]].
To improve the viability of manganese-oxide-based TCES, Randhir et al. [16] mixed magnesium oxide and manganese oxide to form a magnesium-manganese oxide redox material that exhibits the following reversible reaction at high temperatures,Here, x is the ratio of Mg/Mn, and y1 and y2 are the excess oxygen contained within the material lattice for oxidized and reduced materials, respectively. It should be noted that Eq. 1 is a simplified version of the chemical reaction, and a comprehensive discussion on the reaction evolution can be found in Randhir et al. [16]. In summary, the material functions as a storage medium by decomposing from a spinel structure to a monoxide structure as the temperature is increased from 1000 to 1500 °C, releasing oxygen gas in the process. The work of Randhir et al. with magnesium-manganese oxides demonstrated both reactive stability and enhanced speed of oxidation while operating between 1000 and 1500 °C for materials with Mn/Mg molar ratios of 2/1, 1/1, and 2/3, known hereon as 2/1 MM, 1/1 MM, and 2/3 MM, respectively [16].
The purpose of this study is to measure the enthalpy of magnesium-manganese oxides in order to compute their energy storage capacities for a specified redox cycle. To do so, a combination of drop calorimetry and acid-solution calorimetry are utilized to measure the total enthalpies and the standard enthalpies of formation of compounds that form at temperatures of interest for thermochemical energy storage applications. Both techniques have been successfully utilized in the literature. Drop calorimetry has been employed quite commonly for measuring enthalpy of metal oxides at high temperatures. For example, Frederick et al. [17] measured the enthalpy of uranium dioxide up to 1227 °C. Popa et al. [18] measured the thermodynamic properties of monazite from 177 to 1227 °C. Takahashi et al. [19] measured the enthalpy and specific heat of gadolinia-doped uranium dioxide between 127–727 °C. Ritchet et al. [20] measured the thermodynamic properties of several silicon dioxide phases between 727–1527 °C. Acid-solution calorimetry has also been shown to be a successful technique. Brink and Holley [21] used this technique to calculate the standard enthalpy of formation of strontium (II) oxide by dissolving it and pure strontium metal in aqueous 1 M hydrochloric acid solution (HCl). Matskevich et. al. [22] successfully calculated the standard enthalpy of formation of SrCeO3 perovskite doped with lutetium (III) oxide by dissolving samples in a solution of 1 M HCl. Tsvetkov et al. [23] calculated the standard enthalpy of formation of double perovskites GdBaCo2−xMxO6-δ (M = Fe, Mn; x = 0, 0.2) by dissolving constituent metal-oxides in 200 mL of 4 M HCl solution.
Fig. 1 illustrates how these two techniques are applied to determine the energy storage capacities of magnesium-manganese oxides. When operating at high temperatures and a constant oxygen partial pressure, the energy stored by magnesium-manganese oxides is separated into two components: that stored as chemical reaction energy, and that stored as sensible and latent energy. Cooling the material under an inert gas allows for the latent and sensible heat to be released while preventing heat release due to oxidation. By preventing oxidation, the enthalpy at temperatures of interest can be measured using drop calorimetry for both the reduced and oxidized material states. This allows us to isolate the energy stored as sensible and latent heat as the temperature is increased. The energy released due to oxidation can then be calculated as the difference between the standard enthalpies of formation of the reduced and oxidized materials, measured using acid-solution calorimetry. The total energy storage capacity for a specified temperature cycle is then computed by,ΔHS = (ΔHDrop, RED – ΔHDrop, OX) + ΔHRxnwhere ΔHDrop, RED is the enthalpy difference between 1500 and 25 °C for reduced materials, ΔHDrop, OX is the enthalpy difference between 1000 and 25 °C for oxidized materials, and ΔHRxn is the chemical energy stored during thermal reduction measured using acid-solution calorimetry.
The novelty of our method has two facets. The combined use of drop and acid-solution calorimetry allows the change in enthalpy due to chemical reaction and that due to sensible heat (and phase change if present) to be distinctly isolated. In addition, to obtain accurate measurements using acid-solution calorimetry, the material under study must dissolve quickly within the acid. When the material takes a long time (order of hours) to dissolve, the concurrent heat loss from the system severely reduces the accuracy of the calorimetry data. Many metal oxides, in particular, dissolve very slowly in strong acid solutions. However, by adding the right catalyst to the acid, the rate of dissolution of the material of interest can be enhanced significantly, enabling accurate solution calorimetry measurements to be taken. To facilitate this, an acid-solution calorimetry method was developed by adding tin (II) chloride (SnCl2) to aqueous hydrochloric acid solution to enhance the rate of dissolution of magnesium-manganese oxides sufficiently for calorimetry.
In the proposed method, we’ve combined catalytic dissolution enhancement for acid solution calorimetry with drop calorimetry to develop a methodology to study reactive metal oxides. The method delineates the energy stored due to chemical reaction and that stored due to sensible heat change (also phase change if present). We will show that this method is very useful for measuring the energy storage capacity for reactive metal oxides. Further, we believe this method offers an accurate, simple, and low cost alternative to differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) commonly used in the study of high temperature thermochemistry. DSC is the most common technique employed for studying the energy storage capacity of TCES redox metal oxides, as the vast majority of studies compiled by Dizaji et al. [2] and Wu et al. [3] utilized DSC in their analyses. However, it has some significant drawbacks when applied to high temperature TCES metal oxides. Jacob et al. [24] examined the accuracy and reproducibility of specific heat measurements using DSC at high temperatures (> 700 °C), finding that results at temperatures ≥ 800 °C were highly variable with variations in sample mass, mass of the calibration standard, heating rate, and flow rate of the purge gas. Saeed et al. [25] studied the uncertainties associated with the enthalpy of melting and transition temperature measurements of phase change materials taken using DSC, finding that using high heating rates and/or large sample masses resulted in shifts towards results of higher magnitude. The low thermal conductivities and high energy storage densities of phase change materials create a noticeable temperature gradient within the sample, resulting in a higher temperature measured by the DSC thermocouple than the actual average sample temperature, thus creating a biased measurement. Small sample mass and heating rate reduce the thermal gradient bias, but widen the range of uncertainty due to a low observable heat flux [25]. These two studies hold relevance for TCES metal oxides at high temperatures (≥ 800 °C). The first implies that the low accuracy and reproducibility above 800 °C will greatly increase the uncertainty in enthalpy measurements collected using DSC at temperatures of interest (1000–1500 °C) for TCES purposes. In addition, redox metal oxides have high energy storage densities and low thermal conductivities (when subjected to high temperatures). Therefore, the temperature bias caused by the required fast heating rate and inherent temperature gradient make it very difficult to accurately measure reaction enthalpies of redox metal oxides at high temperature using DSC. We initially attempted magnesium-manganese oxide energy storage capacity measurements using DSC but were not satisfied with the accuracy due to the measurement issues described above.
The method we propose utilizes a simple, accurate, and inexpensive means of measuring standard enthalpy of formation for compounds that form at high temperature (≥ 1000 °C). The ability to analyze several grams (compared with mg samples for DSC) of sample at once reduces the potential for material non-uniformity error. Utilization of a large tube furnace ensures precise temperature control of the sample during the heating step, as well as significant cost savings over a thermogravimetric/DSC analyzer. Additionally, this method facilitates the computation of enthalpy differences between the standard state and the temperature of interest for redox metal oxides. These measurements can then be used to compute the total energy stored between two temperatures of interest for a thermochemical process, providing a clear distinction between the contribution from chemical reaction and that from sensible and latent heat change. Overall, we believe this approach towards measuring enthalpy change of unstudied metal oxide materials can be a very useful tool for thermochemistry research involving metal oxides.
Section snippets
Drop calorimeter construction
A schematic diagram of the drop calorimeter used in this work is shown in Fig. 2. The system consists of a 44.45 mm OD stainless steel tube with height 152.4 mm and closed at one end, placed inside a plastic Styrofoam-lined thermos. SS 316 stainless steel was used to prevent reaction of the container with dropped samples. Copper fins are attached to the exterior of the tube to enhance the heat transfer to the surrounding fluid. The thermos is filled with 780 mL of distilled water (specific heat
Measurements of energy storage capacities of magnesium-manganese oxides
The methodology detailed in Sec. 3.3 was applied to the novel magnesium-manganese oxide TCES material developed by Randhir et al. [16], examining 2/1 MM, 1/1 MM, and 2/3 MM. The total energy stored for this temperature cycle is calculated using Eq. 2. Because the samples were contained within alumina crucibles during the drop calorimetry process, the enthalpy change of Al2O3 was calculated for each temperature tested using thermodynamic data [28] and was then subtracted from the total enthalpy
Summary and conclusions
A novel high temperature calorimetric method for measuring enthalpy content of TCES redox metal oxide materials was developed. A drop calorimeter was constructed and calibrated using well-documented, non-reactive materials in order to measure the total enthalpy content of a material at any temperature. An acid-solution calorimeter was developed and calibrated using well-documented materials in order to measure the standard enthalpy of formation of compounds that only form at high temperatures.
References (32)
- et al.
Techno-economic assessment of solid–gas thermochemical energy storage systems for solar thermal power applications
Energy
(2018) - et al.
A review of material screening in pure and mixed-metal oxide thermochemical energy storage (TCES) systems for concentrated solar power (CSP) applications
Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev.
(2018) - et al.
A review on high-temperature thermochemical energy storage based on metal oxides redox cycle
Energy Convers. Manage.
(2018) - et al.
Monolithic ceramic redox materials for thermochemical heat storage applications in CSP plants
Energy Procedia
(2014) - et al.
Thermochemical energy storage at high temperature via redox cycles of Mn and Co oxides: pure oxides versus mixed ones
Sol. Energy Mater. Sol. Cells
(2014) - et al.
Exploitation of thermochemical cycles based on solid oxide redox systems for thermochemical storage of solar heat. Part 5: testing of porous ceramic honeycomb and foam cascades based on cobalt and manganese oxides for hybrid sensible/thermochemical heat storage
Sol. Energy
(2016) - et al.
Combining in-situ X-ray diffraction with thermogravimetry and differential scanning calorimetry–an investigation of Co3O4, MnO2 and PbO2 for thermochemical energy storage
Sol. Energy
(2017) - et al.
Investigations on thermochemical energy storage based on technical grade manganese-iron oxide in a lab-scale packed bed reactor
Sol. Energy
(2017) - et al.
High-temperature thermochemical energy storage based on redox reactions using Co-Fe and Mn-Fe mixed metal oxides
J. Solid State Chem.
(2017) - et al.
Thermochemical heat storage at high temperatures using Mn2O3/Mn3O4 system: narrowing the redox hysteresis by metal co-doping
Energy Procedia
(2015)
Lithium manganese oxides as high-temperature thermal energy storage system
Thermochim. Acta
Metal oxides for thermochemical energy storage: a comparison of several metal oxide systems
Sol. Energy
Magnesium-manganese oxides for high temperature thermochemical energy storage
J. Energy Storage
Enthalpy of uranium dioxide and sapphire to 1500 K by drop calorimetry
J. Chem. Thermodyn.
The high-temperature heat capacity of LnPO 4 (Ln= La, Ce, Gd) by drop calorimetry
J. Chem. Thermodyn.
High-temperature heat-capacity measurements on (U, Gd) O2 by drop calorimetry and DSC
J. Nucl. Mater.
Cited by (24)
Particle-based high-temperature thermochemical energy storage reactors
2024, Progress in Energy and Combustion ScienceAl- and Cr-doped Co<inf>3</inf>O<inf>4</inf>/CoO redox materials for thermochemical energy storage in concentrated solar power plants
2023, Solar Energy Materials and Solar CellsChemical equilibrium of the magnesium manganese oxide redox system for thermochemical energy storage
2022, Chemical Engineering Science