Abstract
It has been proposed that, when electricity markets open to retail competition, incumbent distribution utilities should be required to sell to residential customers at wholesale spot market prices. It is argued here that this overestimates the value of spot-price sales to customers, and underestimates the costs and disadvantages of the proposed policy. Experience in San Diego illustrates the problems. But other policies such as “shopping credits” have deficiencies too. An alternative approach, based on transitional maximum price caps, has facilitated the development of a competitive and fully deregulated residential retail market in the United Kingdom.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Berg, S. V. et al. 2001. Manifesto on the California Electricity Crisis. University of California, Berkeley: Institute of Management, Innovation, and Organization (January 26).
Blumstein, C. 1999. “Pricing Electricity for Default Customers: Pass Through or Performance-Based Rates?” Program on Workable Energy Regulation (POWER), University of California Energy Institute (August).
Carere, E. et al. 2001. “The California Crisis and its Lessons for the EU.” The Brattle Group (June).
Caves, D., K. Eakin, and A. Faruqui. 2000. “Mitigating Price Spikes in Wholesale Markets through Market-Based Pricing in Retail Markets.” The Electricity Journal 13 (April 3): 13-23.
Chandley, J. D., S. M. Harvey, and W. W. Hogan. 2000. “Electricity Market Reform in California.” Available at ksgwww.harvard.edu/people/whogan (November 22).
Crew, M., and P. Kleindorfer. 2002. “Regulatory Economics: Twenty Years of Progress?” Journal of Regulatory Economics 21 (January 1): 5-22.
Demsetz, H. 1969. “Information and Efficiency: Another Viewpoint.” Journal of Law and Economics XI (April): 1-22.
Flaim, T. 2000. “The Big Retail 'Bust': What Will It Take to Get True Competition?” The Electricity Journal 13 (March 2): 41-54.
Goldschmid, H. J., H. M. Mann, and J. F. Weston. 1974. Industrial Concentration: The New Learning, Boston and Toronto: Little, Brown and Company.
Goulding, A. J., C. Ruffin, and G. Swinand. 1999. “The Role of Vibrant Retail Electricity Markets in Assuring that Wholesale Power Markets Operate Effectively.” The Electricity Journal 12 (December 10): 61-73.
Green, R. 2001. “Markets for Electricity in Europe.” Oxford Review of Economic Policy 17 (3 Autumn): 329-345.
Hirst, E. and B. Kirby. 2001. “Retail-Load Participation in Competitive Wholesale Electricity Markets”. Edison Electric Institute, Washington, DC, and Project for Sustainable FERC Energy Policy, Alexandria, VA (January).
Hogan, W. W. 1994a. “Comments” on California Public Utilities Commission, Order Instituting Rulemaking and Order Instituting Investigation: on the Commission's Proposed Policy Statement on Restructuring California's Electric Services Industry and Reforming Regulatory Policy R. 94-04-031 and I. 94-04-032, Los Angeles (June 15). (These Orders were filed April 20, 1994 and referred to as the California “Blue Book” proposals.)
Hogan, W. W. 1994b. “Comments on Electric Industry Restructuring” before Energy and Power Subcommittee, Committee on Energy and Commerce, U.S. House of Representatives, Washington, DC (July 14).
Hogan, W. W. 1994c. “Efficient Direct Access: Comments on the California Blue Book Proposal.” The Electricity Journal 7 (September 7): 30-41.
Joskow, P. L. 2000a. “Deregulation and Regulatory Reform in the US Electric Power Sector.” In Deregulation of Network Industries, edited by S. Peltzman, and C. Winston. Washington, DC: AEI-Brookings Joint Center for Regulatory Studies, pp. 113-188.
Joskow, P. L. 2000b. “Why Do We Need Electricity Retailers? Or, Can You Get It Cheaper Wholesale?” Center for Energy and Environmental Policy Research, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, revised discussion draft (January 13).
Joskow, P. L. 2001. “California's Electricity Crisis.” Oxford Review of Economic Policy 17 (3 Autumn): 365-388.
Joskow, P. L., and R. G. Noll. 1999. “The Bell Doctrine: Applications in Telecommunications, Electricity, and Other Network Industries.” Stanford Law Review 51 (May): 1249-1315.
Kahn, A. E. 1999. “Bribing Customers to Leave and Calling it Competition.” Guest Editorial, The Electricity Journal (May 12): 88-90.
Kahn, A. E. 2002. “The Deregulatory Tar Baby: The Precarious Balance Between Regulation and Deregulation, 1970–2000 and Henceforward.” Journal of Regulatory Economics 21 (January 1): 35-56.
Kirzner, I. M. 1973. Competition and Entrepreneurship. Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press.
Littlechild, S. C. 1999. “Promoting Competition in Electricity Supply.” Power UK. 68 (November): 12-19.
Littlechild, S. C. 2000. “Why We Need Electricity Retailers: A Reply to Joskow on Wholesale Spot Price Passthrough”, WP 21/2000, Judge Institute of Management Studies, and WP 0008, Department of Applied Economics, University of Cambridge (August 22).
Littlechild, S. C. 2002a. Regulators, Competition and Transitional Price Controls: A Critique of Price Restraints in Electricity Supply and Mobile Telephones. London: Institute of Economic Affairs. Occasional Paper (February 20). Available at thtp://www.iea.org.uk
Littlechild, S. C. 2002b. “Competition in retail electricity supply.” Journal des Economistes et des Etudes Humaines XII (June/September 2/3): 353-376.
Monopolies and Mergers Commission. 1996. PowerGen plc and Midlands Electricity plc: A Report on the Proposed Merger. Cm 3231, London: HMSO (April).
NVE. (n.d.) Untitled survey paper, Oslo: Norwegian Water Resources and Energy Administration. At one time available at thtp://www.nve.no/english.
NVE. 2000. Market Report 1998–99 Oslo: Norwegian Water Resources and Energy Administration (May 3). Available at thtp://www.nve.no/english
Ofgem. 1999. Reviews of Public Electricity Suppliers 1998 to 2000, Supply Price Control Review, Initial Proposals. London: Office of Gas and Electricity Markets (October).
Ofgem. 2002a. “Review of Domestic Gas and Electricity Comptetition and Supply Price Regulation: Conclusions and Final Proposals” (Ferbruary 16). Available at thtp://www.ofgem.gov.uk/projects/pricereg_index.thm
Ofgem. 2002b.NETA—One year on (March 27). Available at thtp://www.ofgem.gov.uk/pressoffice/project_factsheets.thm
Ruff, L. E. 1999. “Competitive Electricity Markets: One Size Should Fit All.” The Electricity Journal 12 (November 9): 20-35.
Tschamler, T. 2000. “Designing Competitive Electric Markets: The Importance of Default Service and Its Pricing.” The Electricity Journal, 13 (March 2): 75-82.
Wolak, F. A. 1999a. “An Empirical Analysis of the Impact of Hedge Contracts on Bidding Behavior in a Competitive Electricity Market.” (May). Available at thtp://www.stanford.edu./ ~ wolak
Wolak, F. A. (chairman, Market Surveillance Committee). 1999b. Report on Redesign of California Real-Time Energy and Ancillary Services Market, California Independent System Operator (October 18).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Littlechild, S.C. Wholesale Spot Price Pass-Through. Journal of Regulatory Economics 23, 61–91 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1021883431400
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1021883431400