Abstract
Most community banks face relatively high levels of diversifiable credit risk because they have relatively few loan customers (idiosyncratic risk) and are not geographically diversified (local market risk). We simulate mergers among community banks to quantify the relative contributions of idiosyncratic risk and local market risk to the default risk assumed by community banks. We find that the greatest risk-reduction benefits are achieved by increasing a community bank’s size, regardless of where the expansion takes place. We interpret this result as evidence that idiosyncratic risk dominates local market risk, especially at rural banks. Community banks face enormous pressure to grow, yet the pressure to geographically diversify is limited. As a consequence, larger community banks are likely to replace smaller community banks, but their focus on relationship lending will not disappear.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Allen, Linda, and Julapa Jagtiani. “The Risk Effects of Combining Banking, Securities, and Insurance Activities.” Journal of Economics and Business 52 (November–December 2000), 485–497.
Berger, Allen N. “The Efficiency Effects of Bank Mergers and Acquisitions: A Preliminary Look at the 1990s Data.” In: Yakov Amihud, and Geoffrey Miller, eds., Bank Mergers and Acquisitions. Boston: Kluwer. 1998, 79–112.
Berger, Allen N., Rebecca S. Demsetz, and Philip E. Strahan. “The Consolidation of the Financial Services Industry: Causes, Consequences, and Implications for the Future.” Journal of Banking and Finance 23 (February 1999), 135–194.
Berger, Allen N., and Robert DeYoung. “The Effects of Geographic Expansion on Bank Efficiency.” Journal of Financial Services Research 19 (April 2001), 163–184.
Berger, Allen N., and Robert DeYoung. “Technological Progress and the Geographic Expansion of the Banking Industry.” Working paper WP 2002–07, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, June 2002.
Boyd, John H., and David E. Runkle. “Size and Performance of Banking Firms: Testing the Predictions of Theory.” Journal of Monetary Economics 31 (February 1993), 47–67.
Boyd, John H., and Mark Gertler. “The Role of Large Banks in the Recent U.S. Banking Crisis.” Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis Quarterly Review 18 (Winter 1994), 2–21.
Boyd, John H., and Stanley L. Graham. “Consolidation in U.S. Banking: Implications for Efficiency and Risk.” In: Yakov Amihud, and Geoffrey Miller eds., Bank Mergers and Acquisitions. Boston: Kluwer, 1998, 113–136.
Boyd, John H., Stanley L. Graham, and R. Shawn Hewitt. “Bank Holding Company Mergers with Nonbank Financial Firms: Effects on the Risk of Failure.” Journal of Banking and Finance 17 (February 1993), 43–63.
Bureau of Labor Statistics. “Labor Market Areas,” U.S. Department of Labor, Washington, D.C., 2001.
Carlton Jim. “Wells Fargo Discovers Getting Together is Hard to Do–Efforts to Merge Operations with Fist Interstate Result in Alienated Customers.” The Wall Street Journal (July 21, 1997), B4.
Cornett, Marcia M., and Hassan Tehranian. “Changes in Corporate Performance Associated with Bank Acquisitions.” Journal of Financial Economics 31 (April 1992), 211–234.
Craig, Ben, and Joao Cabral dos Santos. “The Risk Effects of Bank Acquisitions.” Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland Economic Review (Second Quarter 1997), 25–35.
Demsetz, Rebecca S., and Philip E. Strahan. “Diversification, Size, and Risk at Bank Holding Companies.” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 29 (August 1997), 300–313.
Diamond, Douglas W. “Financial Intermediation and Delegated Monitoring.” Review of Economic Studies 51 (July 1984), 393–414.
Evanoff, Douglass D., and Evern Ors. “Local Market Consolidation and Bank Productive Efficiency.” Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, Working paper, 2002–25, 2002.
Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. History of the 1980s, Lessons for the Future, 1997.
Gilbert, R. Alton, Andrew P. Meyer, and Mark D. Vaughan. “Could a CAMELS Downgrade Model Improve Off-Site Surveillance?” Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review 85 (January/February 2002), 47–63.
Gunther, Jeffery W., and Kenneth J. Robinson. “Industry Mix and Lending Environment Variability: What Does the Average Bank Face?” Economic and Financial Review, Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas (Second Quarter 1999), 24–31.
Hadlock, Charles, Joel Houston, and Michael Ryngaert. “The Role of Managerial Incentives in Bank Acquisitions.” Journal of Banking and Finance 23 (February 1999), 221–249.
Hughes, Joseph P., William W. Lang, Loretta J. Mester, and Choon-Geol Moon. “The Dollars and Sense of Bank Consolidation.” Journal of Banking and Finance 23 (February 1999), 291–324.
Laderman, Elizabeth S. “The Potential Diversification and Failure Reduction Benefits of Bank Expansion into Nonbanking Activities.” Working paper 2000–01, Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, October 1999.
Levonian, Mark. “Interstate Banking and Risk.” Weekly Letter, Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, 92–26, July 1994.
Liang, Nellie, and Stephen A. Rhoades. “Geographic Diversification and Risk in Banking.” Journal of Economics and Business 40 (November 1988), 271–284.
Meyer, Andrew P., and Timothy J. Yeager. “Are Small Rural Banks Vulnerable to Local Economic Downturns?” Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review 83 (March/April 2001), 25–38.
Neely, Michelle Clark, and David C. Wheelock. “Why Does Bank Performance Vary Across States?” Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review 79 (March/April 1997), 27–40.
Rivard, Richard J., and Christopher R. Thomas. “The Effect of Interstate Banking on Large Bank Holding Company Profitability and Risk.” Journal of Economics and Business 49 (February 1997), 61–76.
Rose, John T., and John D. Wolken. “Geographic Diversification in Banking, Market Share Changes, and the Viability of Small Independent Banks.” Journal of Financial Services Research 4 (March 1990), 5–20.
Rose, Peter S. “The Diversification and Cost Effects of Interstate Banking.” Financial Review 31 (May 1996), 431–452.
Whalen, Gary. “The Impact of the Growth of Large, Multistate Banking Organizations on Community Bank Profitability.” Working paper WP2001–5, Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, December 2001.
Wheelock, David C., and Paul W. Wilson. “New Evidence on Returns to Scale and Product Mix Among U.S. Commercial Banks.” Journal of Monetary Economics 47 (June 2001), 653–674.
Yeager, Timothy J. “The Demise of Community Banks? Local Economic Shocks Aren't to Blame.” Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (forthcoming).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Emmons, W.R., Gilbert, R.A. & Yeager, T.J. Reducing the Risk at Small Community Banks: Is it Size or Geographic Diversification that Matters?*. Journal of Financial Services Research 25, 259–281 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1023/B:FINA.0000020665.54596.f6
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/B:FINA.0000020665.54596.f6