Abstract
In the last decade, structural realism has been presented as the most promising strategy for developing a defensible realist view of science. Nevertheless, controversy still continues in relation to the exact meaning of the proposed structuralism. The stronger version of structural realism, the so-called ontic structural realism, has been argued for on the basis of some ideas related to quantum mechanics. In this paper, I will first outline these arguments, mainly developed by Steven French and James Ladyman, then challenge them, putting a particular emphasis on a metaphysical principle (the Principle of the Identity of the Indiscernibles) which, even though it is crucial for the whole argument, hasn't been, in my opinion, clearly stated and examined yet. My overall view will be that a weaker version of the form of realism we are considering is more plausible – namely, epistemic structural realism.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
Adams, R. M.: 1979, 'Primitive Thisness and Primitive Identity', in Journal of Philosophy 76, 5–25.
Auyang, S.: 1995, How is Quantum Field Theory Possible? Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Auyang, S.: 2001, 'Spacetime as a Fundamental and Inalienable Structure of Fields', in Studies in the History and Philosophy of Modern Physic 32(2), 205–215.
Ayer, A. J.: 1954, The Identity of the Indiscernibles, in (Ayer, 1980), Chap. 2.
Ayer, A. J.: 1980, Philosophical Essays, Greenwood Publishing Group, London.
Barnette, R. L.: 1978, Does Quantum Mechanics Disprove the Principle of the Identity of Indiscernibles, in Philos. Sci. 45, 466–470.
Belousek, D. W.: 2000, 'Statistics, Symmetry and (In)Distinguishability in Bohmian Mechanics', in Foundations of Physics 30(1), 153–164.
Black, M.: 1952, 'The Identity of the Indiscernibles', in Mind 61(242), 153–164.
Bohm, D. and B. Hiley: 1993, The Undivided Universe. An Ontological Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics, Routledge, London.
Cao, T. Y.: 2003, 'Can we Dissolve Physical Entities into Mathematical Structures?' in Synthèse 136(1), 57–71.
Castellani, E. and P. Mittelstaedt: 2000, 'Leibniz's Principle, Physics and the Language of Physics', in Foundations of Physics 30(10), 1587–1604.
Chakravartty, A.: 1998, 'Semirealism', in Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science 29(3), 391–408.
Cortes, A.: 1976, 'Leibniz's Principle of the Identity of the Indiscernibles: A False Principle', in Philosophy of Science 45, 466–470.
French, S.: 2000, 'The reasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics: Partial Structures and the Application of Group Theory to Physics', in Synthese 125, 103–120.
French. S.: 2001, 'Symmetry, Structure and the Constitutions of Objects', talk given at the Symmetries in Physics, New Reflections workshop, Oxford, January 2001.
French, S.: 2002, 'Reason, Reference and the Quest for Objects', talk given at the Structural Realism and Newman's Problem conference, London School of Economics, 23 March 2002.
French, S.: 2003, 'Scribbling on the Blank Sheet', in Studies in the History and Philosophy of Modern Physics 34(2), 227–259.
French, S. and J. Ladyman: 2003, 'Remodelling Structural Realism: Quantum Physics and the Metaphysics of Structure', in Synthese 136(1), 31–56.
French, S. and M. Redhead: 1988, 'Quantum Mechanics and the Identity of the Indiscern-ibles', in British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 39, 233–246.
Ginsberg, A.: 1981, 'Quantum Theory and the Identity of the Indiscernibles Revisited', in Philosophy of Science 48(3), 489–491.
Hacking, I.: 1975, 'The Identity of the Indiscernibles', in Journal of Philosophy 72, 249–256.
Hilborn, R. C. and C. L. Yuca: 2002, 'Identical Particles in Quantum Mechanics Revisited', in British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 53, 355–389.
Krause, D.: 1992, 'On a Quasi-Set Theory', in Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic 33, 402–411.
Ladyman, J.: 1998, 'What is Structural Realism?' in Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science 29(3), 409–424.
Leibniz, G. W.: 1686, Discourse on Metaphysics,in R.N.D. Martin and S. Brown (eds., and trans.), Discourse on Metaphysics and Related Writings, Manchester University Press, Manchester.
Loux, M.: 1978, Substance and Attribute, D. Reidel, Dordrecht.
Lowe, E. J.: 1998, The Possibility of Metaphysics, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Mertz, D.: 1996, Moderate Realism and its Logic, Yale University Press, Yale.
Moore, G. E.: 1922, Philosophical Studies, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London.
Poincarè, J. H.: 1902, La Science et l'hypothèse, Flammarion, Paris.
Psillos, S.: 1995, 'Is Structural Realism the Best of Both Worlds?' in Dialectica 49, 15–46.
Psillos, S.: 1999, Scientific Realism: How Science Tracks Truth, Routledge, London.
Redhead, M.: 1988, 'A Philosopher Looks at Quantum Field Theory', in H. Brown and R. Harré, (eds.), Philosophical Foundations of Quantum Field Theory, Clarendon Press, Oxford, pp. 9–23.
Redhead, M.: 2001, 'The Intelligibility of the Universe', in A. O'Hear (ed.), Philosophy at the New Millennium, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 73–90.
Russell, B.: 1940, An Inquiry into Meaning and Truth, Prometheus, London.
Seibt, J.: 2002, 'Quanta, Tropes or Processes: Ontologies for QFT Beyond the Myth of Substance', in M. Kuhlmann, F. Lyre and A. Wayne, A. (eds.), Ontological Aspects of Quantum Field Theory, World Scientific, Singapore, pp. 53–97.
Simons, P.: 2002, 'Candidate General Ontologies for Situating Quantum Field Theory', in Kuhlmann, M., Lyre, F. and Wayne, A. (eds.), in M. Kuhlmann, F. Lyre and A. Wayne, A. (eds.), Ontological Aspects of Quantum Field Theory, World Scientific, Singapore, pp. 33–52.
Teller, P.: 1983, 'Quantum Physics, the Identity of the Indiscernibles and Some Unanswered Questions', in Philosophy of Science 50(2), 309–319.
Teller, P.: 1995, An Interpretive Introduction to Quantum Field Theory, Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey.
Van Fraassen, B. C.: 1991, Quantum Mechanics: an Empiricist View, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Van Fraassen, B. C.: (forthcoming), 'Structure: Its Shadow and Substance', in Ehrlich, P. and Jones, R., Reverberations of the Shaky Game: Essays in Honor of Arthur Fine, University of Chicago Press.
Wiggins, D.: 2001, Sameness and Substance Renewed, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Worrall, J.: 1989, 'Structural Realism: the Best of Both Worlds?' in Dialectica 43, 99–124.
Worrall, J.: 1994, 'How to Remain (Reasonably) Optimistic: Scientific Realism and the “Luminiferous Ether”', in D. Hull, M. Forbes and M. Burian (eds.), PSA1994, Philosophy of Science Association, pp. 334–342.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Morganti, M. On the Preferability of Epistemic Structural Realism. Synthese 142, 81–107 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1023/B:SYNT.0000047712.39407.c3
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/B:SYNT.0000047712.39407.c3