THE SECOND SURVEY OF THE MOLECULAR CLOUDS IN THE LARGE MAGELLANIC CLOUD BY NANTEN. II. STAR FORMATION

, , , , , , , , , and

Published 2009 August 13 © 2009. The American Astronomical Society. All rights reserved.
, , Citation Akiko Kawamura et al 2009 ApJS 184 1 DOI 10.1088/0067-0049/184/1/1

0067-0049/184/1/1

ABSTRACT

We studied star formation activities in the molecular clouds in the Large Magellanic Cloud. We have utilized the second catalog of 272 molecular clouds obtained by NANTEN to compare the cloud distribution with signatures of massive star formation including stellar clusters, and optical and radio H ii regions. We find that the molecular clouds are classified into three types according to the activities of massive star formation: Type I shows no signature of massive star formation; Type II is associated with relatively small H ii region(s); and Type III with both H ii region(s) and young stellar cluster(s). The radio continuum sources were used to confirm that Type I giant molecular clouds (GMCs) do not host optically hidden H ii regions. These signatures of massive star formation show a good spatial correlation with the molecular clouds in the sense that they are located within ∼100 pc of the molecular clouds. Among possible ideas to explain the GMC types, we favor that the types indicate an evolutionary sequence; i.e., the youngest phase is Type I, followed by Type II, and the last phase is Type III, where the most active star formation takes place leading to cloud dispersal. The number of the three types of GMCs should be proportional to the timescale of each evolutionary stage if a steady state of massive star and cluster formation is a good approximation. By adopting the timescale of the youngest stellar clusters, 10 Myr, we roughly estimate the timescales of Types I, II, and III to be 6 Myr, 13 Myr, and 7 Myr, respectively, corresponding to a lifetime of 20–30 Myr for the GMCs with a mass above the completeness limit, 5 × 104 M.

Export citation and abstract BibTeX RIS

1. INTRODUCTION

The Magellanic Clouds can be observed in more detail than any other extra galaxies at any wavelengths because of the proximity. The relatively face-on location of the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) enables us to obtain a complete sample of astronomical objects with less contamination compared with the Galaxy. Studies of the LMC provide invaluable information on our understanding of the galaxies in various aspects, including the properties of the interstellar medium (ISM), evolution of molecular clouds, and star formation.

The environments, such as metallicity, in the LMC are different from those in the Galaxy (e.g., Z ∼ 1/2 Z; Dufour 1984 and taking into account the revision of the solar abundance by Asplund et al. 2004). Star formation activities are also different. Stellar clusters called "populous clusters," which are self-gravitating like Galactic globular clusters, are found by photometric studies (e.g., Hodge 1961; van den Bergh 1981). Their masses are ∼104–105 M, which are smaller than those of the Galactic globular clusters but larger than those of the Galactic open clusters by an order of magnitude (Kumai et al. 1993; Hunter et al. 2003). It is notable that more than a hundred of the populous clusters are significantly younger, i.e., a few to 100 Myr, than the Galactic globular clusters and some are still forming at present, such as R136 in 30 Dor nebula (e.g., Massey & Hunter 1998). This suggests that the formation process of globular-like rich clusters can be studied through the observations of the young clusters and ISM properties in the LMC. To date, optical indicators of the massive star formation or cluster formation, such as H ii regions and stellar clusters, have been studied in the large area of the LMC (e.g., Henize 1956; Davies et al. 1976, hereafter DEM; Kennicutt & Hodge 1986, hereafter KH; Bica et al. 1996). DEM identified 357 Hα emission nebulae, and KH measured the Hα flux of 240 H ii regions. Regarding the stellar clusters, Bica et al. (1996) cataloged 624 clusters, and classified them into eight types according to their colors.

The first complete map of the molecular gas in the LMC was obtained by Cohen et al. (1988) in 12CO (1–0) with the southern CfA 1.2 m telescope at CTIO. However, the survey was limited by the low spatial resolution, 8farcm8 corresponding to 130 pc at the distance of the LMC. High-resolution CO observations of selected regions, especially toward well known active star-forming regions (e.g., 30 Dor, N11, N159) by the SEST 15 m telescope have been performed in the LMC (e.g., Israel et al. 1986; Johansson et al. 1994; Caldwell & Kutner 1996; Kutner et al. 1997; Johansson et al. 1998; Israel et al. 2003b). These observations revealed detailed structure and properties of the molecular gas of the individual star-forming regions at a linear resolution of less than 10 pc, although they are limited in spatial coverage, about 1 deg2.

Recently, Fukui et al. (2008, hereafter "Paper I") made a second survey of the molecular gas in the LMC by a 4 m telescope, NANTEN, at Las Campanas Observatory, Chile. This survey was carried out in 12CO (1–0) with resolution of 2 arcmin grid spacing with the half-power beam width of 2farcm6 and covered ∼30 deg2 (Fukui et al. 2008). The resolution of the survey was high enough to resolve giant molecular clouds (GMCs) and enabled us to cover a large region efficiently. The molecular clouds with a completeness limit of 5 × 104M in mass are identified in nearly the entire region where the current massive star and cluster formation is on-going, and 272 molecular clouds are cataloged.

In this paper, we present the results from comparisons of the GMCs identified by NANTEN (Paper I) with classical H ii regions and optically identified stellar clusters and discuss cloud evolution. Recent surveys of the Magellanic Clouds by the IR satellites, like Spitzer (e.g., Mexiner et al. 2006, "Surveying the Agents of a Galaxy's Evolution") and AKARI (e.g., Ita et al. 2008; Murakami et al. 2007) have been strong tools to identify younger, and lower mass YSOs (Whitney et al. 2008). Comparisons of these YSOs and the GMCs are found elsewhere (Indebetouw et al. 2008; T. Onishi et al. 2009, in preparation).

2. MOLECULAR CLOUDS, H ii REGIONS, AND YOUNG CLUSTERS

2.1. Molecular Clouds Identified by the Second NANTEN Survey

A survey of the molecular clouds was carried out in 12CO (J = 1–0) by NANTEN, a 4 m radio telescope of Nagoya University at Las Campanas Observatory, Chile (Paper I). The observed region is about 30 deg2 and covers the region where the CO emission was detected by the NANTEN first survey (e.g., Fukui et al. 1999; Mizuno et al. 2001). The observed grid spacing was 2', corresponding to ∼30 pc at a distance of the LMC, 50 kpc, with a 2farcm6 half-power beam width at 115 GHz. The spectral intensities were calibrated by employing the standard room-temperature chopper wheel technique (Kutner & Ulich 1981). An absolute intensity calibration was made by observing Orion-KL (R.A. (B1950) = 5h32m47fs0, decl. (B1950) = −5°24'21'') by assuming its absolute temperature, T*R, to be 65 K. The rms noise fluctuations were about 0.07 K at a velocity resolution of 0.65 km s−1 with about 3 minutes' integration for an on-position. The typical 3σ noise level of the velocity-integrated intensity was about 1.2 K km s−1 (Figure 1).

Figure 1.

Figure 1. Distribution of the CO emission (Paper I) superposed on the Hα image (Kim et al. 1999). The red contours show the velocity-integrated intensity of the CO (1–0) line obtained by NANTEN; the contours are from 1.2 K km s−1 (3σ noise level) with 2.4 K km s−1 intervals. The white lines show the observed area.

Standard image High-resolution image

Fukui et al. (2008) identified 272 molecular clouds of which 230 are detected at more than two observing positions (hereafter "GMCs," in this paper) by using cloud identifying algorithm, cprops (Rosolowsky & Leroy 2006). The radius and virial mass of the clouds range from 10 to 220 pc, and 9 × 103 to 9 × 106M, respectively. The CO luminosity and virial mass of the GMCs show a good correlation, and a conversion factor, XCO, from a CO intensity to an H2 column density was derived to be (7 ±2) ×1020 cm−2 (K km s−1)−1 by assuming virial equilibrium. The sensitivity in N(H2), then, corresponds to N(H2) = 8 × 1020 cm−2 and the range of mass of the GMCs is 2 × 104M to 7 × 106M, respectively. The details of the observations and the method to identify the GMCs are found in Paper I and Rosolowsky & Leroy (2006).

2.2. Young Astronomical Objects Associated with the Molecular Clouds

In order to identify the current massive star and cluster forming molecular clouds, H ii regions and young stellar clusters were searched for in the published catalogs. The association of these objects and the molecular clouds were determined.

Henize (1956) and Davies et al. (1976) cataloged more than 300 Hα emission nebulae in the LMC. The estimated diameters of the H ii regions range from ∼10 pc to ∼400 pc. In addition, an extensive Hα photometry of the 240 H ii regions was carried out by Kennicutt & Hodge (1986). Figure 2 shows luminosity distribution of these H ii regions, indicating that the current sample of H ii regions includes those with Hα luminosities as faint as ∼1036 erg s−1 at the faint end. This shows that the sensitivity of the survey is high enough to detect the Orion nebula, ∼4 × 1036 erg s−1, (Gebel 1968) at the distance of the LMC. The Orion Nebula is ionized primarily by a single O7 star together with at least B0.5, B3, and B0.5 (O9.5) stars (Goudis 1982). This faint end of the luminosities is comparable to those of small Galactic H ii regions that can be ionized by a single O9 star (e.g., Panagia & Ranieri 1973). Detailed studies of several faint H ii regions in the LMC show that most of the H ii regions are ionized primarily by a star as massive as B0 accompanied by several other massive but cooler stars, except for two ionized by a single mid-O star and B0 star (Wilcots 1994). It is also suggested that the faint H ii regions in the catalogs are ionized by a single O star and those luminous ones (L ≳ 5 × 1037 erg s−1) are by OB associations (Kennicutt & Hodge 1986).

Figure 2.

Figure 2. Distribution of the luminosities of the H ii regions in the LMC from Kennicutt & Hodge (1986). The arrow shows the luminosity of the Orion nebula, L ∼ 4 × 1036 erg s−1 (Gebel 1968).

Standard image High-resolution image

A mosaic image of the 1.4 GHz continuum emission observed with the Parkes Telescope (Filipovic et al. 1995) and the ATCA are combined to present the thermal and nonthermal radio emission of the LMC covering 10fdg8 × 12fdg3 (e.g., Filipovic & Staveley-Smith 1998; Hughes et al. 2007). This image was also used to determine if there are any H ii regions escaped from optical identification due to the extinction by molecular clouds. The angular resolution of the data is 40'', corresponding to ∼10 pc at a distance of the LMC. Thus one should keep in mind that a size of the H ii regions of this study is larger than ∼10 pc.

The LMC has more than 6500 stellar clusters and OB associations (Bica et al. 1999). Photometric properties of about 10% of the brightest ones were measured to derive their masses and ages (Bica et al. 1996). In this paper, we use these clusters with known properties to study the formation of cluster and OB association in the molecular clouds. These 120 OB associations and 504 stellar clusters are classified into 10 types of different ages (SWB0–VII; Bica et al. 1996) from their UB and BV indices. In Table 1, the numbers of these objects according to their ages in the area covered with the second NANTEN survey are shown. We shall call these objects "clusters" throughout this paper and we should note that this includes both clusters and OB associations.

Table 1. Number of Clusters and OB Associations

SWB Typea Agea (Myr) Number of Clustersa,b Number of Clustersb in Observed Area
SWB 0 <10 137 137
SWB I 10–30 130 122
SWB II 30–70  65  56
SWB III 70–200  87  71
SWB IVA 200–400  62  45
SWB IVB 400–800  33  23
SWB V 800–2000  41  16
SWB VI 2000–5000  30  11
SWB VII 5000–16000  38  17

Notes. aFrom Bica et al. (1996). bIncluding both clusters and OB associations.

Download table as:  ASCIITypeset image

3. MOLECULAR CLOUDS AND ASSOCIATION WITH H ii REGIONS AND YOUNG CLUSTERS

3.1. Overall Distribution of the Molecular Clouds, H ii Regions, and Clusters

Figures 1, 3(a), and (b) show the distribution of the Hα emission (Kim et al. 1999), young clusters (younger than 10 Myr), and clusters older than 10 Myr together with the molecular clouds, respectively.

Figure 3.

Figure 3. Distribution of the clusters (Bica et al. 1996) and molecular clouds detected by NANTEN (Paper I). The contours show the velocity-integrated intensity of the CO (1–0) line obtained by NANTEN from 1.2 K km s−1 (3σ noise level) with 2.4 K km s−1 intervals. The thin lines show the observed area. The positions of the supergiant shells, LMC 3 and LMC 4, are shown by circles with dashed lines. The coordinates and the size are taken from Meaburn (1980). (a) Red crosses show the position of young clusters identified as SWB type 0 (τ≲ 10 Myr) by Bica et al. (1996). (b) Blue and green crosses show the positions of clusters identified as SWB type I (10 Myr ≲τ≲ 30 Myr) and SWB type II to VII (30 Myr ≲τ), respectively.

Standard image High-resolution image

Figure 1 shows that the overall distribution of the Hα local peaks and GMCs are well coincident to each other, while the extent of the individual Hα emitting regions and the size of the GMCs are different. Almost all the luminous H ii regions with high flux densities, like 30 Dor to N 159, N 11, N 63/N 64 complexes, N 44 and N 206 are associated with GMCs, while fainter and diffuse extended Hα emission show less degrees of association. Some luminous H ii regions, like N 51, are associated with only small molecular clouds, which may indicate molecular gas dissipation after formation of massive H ii regions. It is also noted that there are several GMCs not associated with Hα emission (see also Section 4.1)

Figure 3(a) shows that young clusters are often found at, or near the peak of the GMCs. Some of the young clusters associated with GMCs are forming groups with a few to ten clusters. These active cluster forming regions, such as N 159, N 11, and N 44, are found especially toward bright H ii regions. Note that a number of clusters in the northeastern region in the LMC and some in the west of 30 Dor are isolated from molecular clouds. These groups of clusters are located inside large cavities of Hα emission (see also Figure 1), two of the supergiant shells, LMC 4 and LMC 3, respectively (Meaburn 1980).

Compared with the youngest group of clusters, the older clusters have less degree of association with the GMCs (Figure 3(b)). The second youngest group of clusters, SWB I, is presented in blue crosses in Figure 3(b), showing that the correlation with the molecular clouds is low. Nevertheless there are several regions where the number of SWB I clusters is enhanced, for example, inside a supergiant shell, LMC 4, and the south of 30 Dor. It is interesting to note that the SWB 0 clusters are also gathered in these regions, suggesting that the distribution of SWB 0 and I clusters still retain the information of their formation sites. On the other hand, the older clusters, SWB II–VII, are distributed more uniformly over the galaxy showing no trend of association with the GMCs. It is to be noted here that the older clusters are distributed more widely over the galaxy compared with the region where the current star formation is observed (Bica et al. 1996)

The overall distribution of H ii regions, young clusters, and older clusters indicates that the GMCs are the sites of current massive star formation and of cluster formation. To show the associated object more clearly, we present close-up views of the GMCs and the young objects in Figures 4 and 5(a)–(f) (Figure 4 as a guide). These panels confirm that the H ii regions and young clusters are often associated with molecular clouds well, while the older clusters are distributed randomly.

Figure 4.

Figure 4. Velocity-integrated intensity map of the molecular clouds observed by NANTEN (Paper I). The contours are from 1.2 K km s−1 (3σ noise level) with 1.2 K km s−1 intervals. The boxes indicate the regions presented in Figures 5(a)–(f).

Standard image High-resolution image
Figure 5.
Standard image High-resolution image
Figure 5.
Standard image High-resolution image
Figure 5.
Standard image High-resolution image
Figure 5.
Standard image High-resolution image
Figure 5.
Standard image High-resolution image
Figure 5.

Figure 5. Upper panels and left panels of Figures 5(a), (c)–(e), and 5(b), (f), respectively: distribution of the molecular clouds (Paper I) superposed on the Hα image (Kim et al. 1999); the contours are from 1.2 K km s−1 (3σ noise level) with 2.4 K km s−1 intervals. The white lines present the observed area. Lower panels and right panels of Figures 5(a), (c)–(e), and 5(b), (f), respectively: distribution of the molecular clouds (Paper I, contours), H ii regions by Henize (1956, yellow circles) and by Davies et al. (1976, red circles), youngest clusters identified as SWB type 0 (red crosses), SWB type I clusters (blue crosses), and SWB type II clusters (Bica et al. 1996, green crosses), respectively. The contours in red are from 1.2 K km s−1 with 1.2 K km s−1 intervals. The dashed lines present the observed area.

Standard image High-resolution image

In the following, we report some individual active star-forming regions in detail. In the N 11 (DEM 41) region, the young clusters are found in a bright, large complex of H ii regions, while they are not exactly found toward the GMCs (Figure 5(a)). Only small clouds are found at the outer edge of N 11 nebulae with young clusters near the edge of the molecular clouds. The cluster at the center of N 11, LH 9, is neither associated with Hα emission peaks nor molecular clouds. This suggests that the parent cloud of LH 9 has been dissipated, and that triggered star formation occurred at the outer region as discussed by, for example, Israel et al. (2003a). A group of H ii regions are found near the western edge of the bar in the N 79/N 83 region (Figure 5(b)). In contrast with the N 11 region, young clusters associated with the GMCs and bright Hα emission are found near the peak of the GMCs in this region, and the young clusters without a bright H ii region are at the center of diffuse shell-like Hα emission. In Figure 5(b), there are a few GMCs hosting no H ii regions, one of which is at the western end of the N79/N 83 region.

Small groups of young clusters are found near the peak of a massive GMC in N 44 (DEM158, 160, 166, 167, 169) as well as small GMCs along the supergiant shell LMC 4 (Figure 5(c)). On the other hand, only one or two clusters are associated with a GMC near the LMC bar (Figure 5(d)). One may speculate that clusters are formed in groups in the massive GMCs of M ∼ 106M or near a supergiant shell. It is also noted that a bright H ii region, the N 51 complex, is associated with a very small molecular cloud, maybe a remnant of the parent cloud of this bright H ii region.

Figure 5(f) shows the 30 Dor (DEM 263) region to the molecular ridge including active star-forming site, N 159 (DEM 271, 272), and the Arc region. The most remarkable feature in Hα emission is a bright complex of H ii regions in 30 Dor, while massive molecular clouds are found not exactly toward 30 Dor but extending to the south as already noted by several authors (e.g. Cohen et al. 1988; Indebetouw et al. 2008; Paper I). Most of the youngest clusters of τ< 10 Myr are associated with the GMCs or found near the GMCs. On the other hand, the clusters of 10 <τ< 30 Myr are away from the GMCs and mostly found between 30 Dor and N 159 where the bright Hα emission from 30 Dor is extended but only small molecular clouds are detected. The most active current star formation site in this figure is a well known region, N 159, where young clusters as well as a number of H ii regions are found at or near the peaks of the molecular ridge. The detailed studies of star formation activities and molecular clouds are carried out by several authors (e.g., Johansson et al. 1998; Minamidani et al. 2008; Indebetouw et al. 2008; Mizuno et al. 2009). In the south of N159, only smaller H ii regions are associated with the molecular ridge. These results indicate that the southern region may be younger than the north.

There are several other regions with active star formation in Figure 5(f), N 148, N 180, N 206, and N 214, where groups of H ii regions, some of which contain a young cluster, are associated with GMCs. It is interesting to note that these groups of H ii regions are mostly found off from the peak of the GMCs. It should be noted that the NANTEN beam is not capable of resolving the individual local peaks of the GMC and the parent core of the group of H ii regions may have escaped from detection. Nevertheless, the positional offset of the peak of the GMC and the group of H ii regions indicate the dissipation of the molecular gas by active star formation. It is also to be noted that there are several GMCs, especially at southern edge of this figure without significant Hα emission or clusters.

Figure 6 shows the distribution of the projected separations of H ii regions and stellar clusters from the nearest CO emission with an integrated intensity above 1.2 K km s−1 (3σ noise level). The lines in Figure 6 represent the frequency distribution expected if the same number of the H ii regions or clusters are distributed at random in the observed area. It is clearly shown by eye that the distribution of the youngest clusters with an age smaller than 10 Myr, i.e., SWB 0 (Bica et al. 1996), and the H ii regions are sharply peaked within 100 pc of CO emission exhibiting strong spatial correlations. On the other hand, the older clusters, SWB I (τ>10 Myr) or older, show much weaker or no correlation. This figure again indicates that the H ii regions and SWB 0 clusters are well associated with molecular clouds as well as that rapid cloud dissipation after cluster formation.

Figure 6.

Figure 6. Frequency distribution of the projected distances of (a) the H ii regions, (b) SWB 0 clusters (τ≲ 10 Myr), (b) SWB I clusters (10 Myr ≲τ≲ 30 Myr) and SWB type II to VII clusters (30 Myr ≲τ, Bica et al. 1996) from the nearest molecular cloud (Paper I), respectively. Lines show the frequency distribution of the distance when the H ii regions and clusters are distributed randomly.

Standard image High-resolution image

Hereafter, we will focus on the H ii regions and SWB 0 clusters in the discussion and call SWB 0 cluster as "young cluster" unless otherwise stated.

3.2. Determination of Association of Individual Molecular Clouds With H ii Regions and Young Clusters

3.2.1. Determination of association of the H ii regions and young clusters

We have determined the association of individual H ii regions and young clusters with the molecular clouds by the following criteria: (1) for clusters, if the extent of a cluster is overlapped with the boundary of a molecular cloud; and (2) for the H ii regions, if the Hα-emitting region is overlapped with the boundary of a molecular cloud.

In total, 97 out of 137 young clusters are found to be associated with the molecular clouds. In addition, those clusters are all associated with H ii regions. These confirms that the clusters associated with the molecular clouds are young and contain massive stars. For reference, we have also determined the association of the SWB I clusters and the molecular clouds. As a result, only 15 out of 122 clusters are found to be associated with the molecular clouds in the survey area of NANTEN. This result suggests that the molecular clouds start to be dissipated while the clusters are still in the SWB 0 phase. This scenario is consistent with the result from Fukui et al. (1999) and Yamaguchi et al. (2001b).

3.2.2. Determination of Association of Radio Continuum Sources toward the Molecular Clouds without Optically Identified H ii regions

As presented in the previous sections, there are a number of molecular clouds without H ii regions or young clusters. Clusters and H ii regions may be hidden behind the molecular clouds by chance. For the H ii regions, we have also compared the distribution of the molecular clouds and the point sources from the ATCA+Parkes combined continuum emission (Filipovic et al. 1995; Dickel et al. 2005; Hughes et al. 2007) to search for such hidden H ii regions. If an H ii region is behind a GMC, the H ii region cannot be seen optically due to extinction, but should be observed as a radio source.

A mosaic image of the 1.4 GHz continuum emission observed with the Parkes Telescope (Filipovic et al. 1995) and the ATCA are combined to present the thermal and nonthermal radio emission of the LMC covering 10fdg8 × 12fdg3 (e.g., Filipovic & Staveley-Smith 1998; Hughes et al. 2007). A catalog of sources identified from this image will be presented elsewhere (M. D. Filipovic et al. 2009, in preparation). In this work, first, 1.4 GHz continuum emission was examined carefully toward the molecular clouds without optical H ii region. Then if we see any point sources at 1.4 GHz, we searched for corresponding 4.8 and 8.6 GHz sources (Dickel et al. 2005). We found about seventy 1.4 GHz both point-like and extended sources toward the 72 molecular clouds; ring-like artifacts seen in the 1.4 GHz image near 30 Dor made it difficult to determine the emission toward four molecular clouds. Among these 1.4 GHz sources, only one 1.4 GHz source, ATCA J054308 − 710409, was also seen at 4.8 GHz and 8.6 GHz, indicating that most of the 1.4 GHz sources in these molecular clouds are background sources or supernova remnants (SNRs).

The 1.4 GHz source, ATCA J054308 − 710409, is found just at the edge of the GMC 224 and coincides with a radio source, LMC B0543 − 7105, identified at 4.75, 4.85, and 8.85 GHz by Filipovic et al. (1995). Because it lies at the edge of the GMC, the absence of Hα emission toward the source is not perhaps due to the extinction by the molecular cloud. We estimated a spectral index of this source, α, defined as Sν ∼ να, where Sν is the integrated flux density at frequency, ν, to be α ∼ −0.4. Filipovic et al. (1998) studied the spectral index of radio sources detected with the Parkes telescope and found that the known H ii regions have rather flat spectra with a spectral index of α = −0.15 ± 0.31, and the SNRs and background sources have steeper spectra, α = −0.43 ± 0.19 and α = −0.59 ± 0.48, respectively. These results show that ATCA J054308 − 710409 is also unlikely to be a hidden H ii region and is more likely to be an SNR.

This comparison of the ATCA 1.4 GHz and the molecular clouds indicates that hidden H ii regions of this size are unlikely to exist. Since all the young clusters found in the molecular clouds are associated with the H ii regions, these results suggest that the hidden clusters are also unlikely to exist.

3.3. Molecular Cloud Types

It was shown in Fukui et al. (1999) that the GMCs can be classified into three groups based on a sample of 55 GMCs with a mass ranging from 2 × 105M to 3 × 106M: (1) starless GMCs; (2) those with small H ii regions whose Hα luminosity is less than 1037 erg s−1; and (3) those with stellar clusters and large H ii regions of Hα luminosity greater than 1037 erg s−1.

The current comparison of the molecular clouds with the clusters and H ii regions gives a consistent result. Here we classify the molecular clouds into three types according to the association with massive star formation activities:

  • 1.  
    starless molecular clouds in the sense that they are not associated with H ii regions or young clusters (Type I);
  • 2.  
    molecular clouds with H ii regions (Type II); and
  • 3.  
    molecular clouds with H ii regions and young clusters (Type III).

It should be noted that "starless" here means without star-forming activities with stars more massive than early O star capable of ionizing H ii regions, and it does not exclude the possibility of associated young low-mass stars. Comparisons of the GMCs with young, low or intermediate mass stars are now possible by using recent results by the IR satellites, like Spitzer (e.g., Mexiner et al. 2006, "Surveying the Agents of a Galaxy's Evolution") and AKARI (e.g., Ita et al. 2008; Murakami et al. 2007). Comparisons of these YSOs (Whitney et al. 2008) and the GMCs are found elsewhere (Indebetouw et al. 2008; T. Onishi et al. 2009, in preparation).

Table 2 lists the associated H ii regions and young clusters for each molecular cloud. Out of 272 molecular clouds, 72, 142, and 58 are found to be Type I, II, and III, respectively (see also Table 3). Figures 79 present the examples of the molecular clouds of each type. Examples are chosen from the most massive clouds from each type. It is interesting to note that the most massive Type I molecular clouds have similar size and mass to those of Type II, while the number of massive Type I is less. To study the physical properties of the molecular clouds, one has to keep in mind that the completeness limit of the NANTEN survey of MCO = 5 × 104M. Table 3 also summarizes a number of GMCs with MCO > 5 × 104M for each type. Out of 191 GMCs, 46, 96, and 49 GMCs are found to be Type I, II, III, showing that about a half of them are Type II, and a quarter is Type I and Type III, respectively.

Figure 7.

Figure 7. Examples of GMCs without massive star formation (GMC Type I). The eight most massive GMCs are shown in contours superposed on the DSS2 images. The contours are from 1.2 K km s−1 with 1.2 K km s−1 intervals. The crosses indicate the position of the GMCs as in Table 1 of Paper I.

Standard image High-resolution image
Figure 8.

Figure 8. Examples of the molecular clouds associated with H ii regions but not with young clusters (GMC Type II). The six most massive GMCs are shown in contours superposed on the DSS2 images. The contours are from 1.2 K km s−1 with 1.2 K km s−1 intervals except for (a) GMC 216; the contours are from 1.2 K km s−1 with 2.4 K km s−1 intervals for (a). The crosses indicate the positions of the GMCs as in Table 1 of Paper I.

Standard image High-resolution image
Figure 9.
Standard image High-resolution image
Figure 9.

Figure 9. Examples of the molecular clouds associated with H ii regions and young clusters (GMC Type III) in (a) the N 11 region, (b) the N 44 and N 51 regions, (c) the N 206 region observed, and (d) the 30 Dor and N 159 regions. Left panels: distribution of the molecular clouds by NANTEN (Paper I) is superposed on the Hα image (Kim et al. 1999). Right panels: distribution of the NANTEN molecular clouds (Paper I, contours), H ii regions (yellow circles by Henize 1956 and red circles by Davies et al. 1976), and youngest clusters identified as SWB type 0 (Bica et al. 1996, crosses), respectively. The contours shown are from 1.2 K km s−1 with 1.2 K km s−1 intervals.

Standard image High-resolution image

Table 2. Associated H ii Regions, OB Associations, and Young Clusters

    Young Objects    
Molecular Cloudsa   H ii Regionsb Young Clustersc GMC Type Notes
1 LMC N J0447 − 6910       I  
2 LMC N J0447 − 6713       I 1
3 LMC N J0448 − 6920 N 79 DEM 6   II  
4 LMC N J0449 − 6910 N 77 DEM 2, DEM 4, DEM 5 IC 2105 III  
5 LMC N J0449 − 6826 N 76 DEM 3   II  
6 LMC N J0449 − 6806       I  
7 LMC N J0449 − 6652       I  
8 LMC N J0450 − 6910 N 77 DEM 4   II  
9 LMC N J0450 − 6930 N 78, N 79 DEM 6   II  
10 LMC N J0450 − 6919 N 79 DEM 6, DEM 10   II  
11 LMC N J0451 − 6858       I  
12 LMC N J0451 − 6704 N 4, N 5 DEM 8, DEM 11, DEM 12 NGC 1714, SL 69 III  
      DEM 18      
13 LMC N J0451 − 6729       I  
14 LMC N J0451 − 6922 N 79 DEM 10, DEM 15 BRHT 1a, IC 2111, NGC 1727 III  
15 LMC N J0452-6750       I  

Notes. (1) Hα source is seen at the peak of the cloud. (2) Hα source is seen within the cloud. (3) Diffuse Hα emission, a part of the LMC 4, is seen across the cloud. (4) Hα source, possibly an OB star (FAUST 840; UV emission source) is seen within the cloud. aCloud identified in Paper I. The number and name of the clouds are from Tables 1 and 2 of Paper I. bH ii regions associated with the clouds; "N" for Henize (1956), and "DEM" for Davies et al. (1976). cYoung clusters and associations associated with the clouds. Clusters are SWB 0 clusters and associations by Bica et al. (1996)

Only a portion of this table is shown here to demonstrate its form and content. A machine-readable version of the full table is available.

Download table as:  DataTypeset image

Table 3. GMC Type and Evolution of the GMCs

    Number of Clouds    
GMC Type Observed Signature all clouds GMCsa Timescale a (Myr) Star Formation Activities
I No H ii regions or young clusters  72 46(24%)  6 Without massive star formation
II With H ii region(s) 142 96(50%) 13 Massive star formation
III With H ii region(s) and SWB 0 cluster(s)  58 49(26%)  7 Cluster formation
  young cluster only ... ...  3 Dissipation of clouds

Notes. Timescale of the GMCs at each evolutionary stage is estimated by assuming the formation of the molecular clouds (MCO > 5 × 104M) and clusters to be constant, and the timescale is proportional to the number of the sample. aMolecular clouds with MCO > 5 × 104 M.

Download table as:  ASCIITypeset image

3.4. Distribution of the Molecular Clouds

Figures 10(a)–(f) show the radial distribution of CO emission; the number and the surface density, Σ, of the molecular clouds with Types I, II, and III, respectively. The surface density, Σ, is derived by integrating the CO luminosity within annuli spaced by 4' and then divided by an area of the annuli. The center used is α(J2000) = 5h17fm6, δ(J2000) = −69°2' determined from the kinematics of the H i observations by Kim et al. (1998). To see the angular distribution of the CO emission, the distribution of the clouds and the surface density, Σ, for each molecular cloud type are also presented in Figures 11(a)–(f). Here, the surface density, Σ, is derived by integrating CO luminosity over a sector with a 20° width and then divided by an observed area of the sector. The CO luminosity to mass conversion is carried out by assuming a conversion factor, XCO of 7 × 1020 cm−2 (K km s−1)−1 (Paper I) for both Figures 10 and 11.

Figure 10.

Figure 10. (a), (c), and (e): Frequency distribution of the cloud distances from the center α(J2000) = 5h17fm6, δ(J2000) = −69°2' determined from the kinematics of the H i (Kim et al. 1998). (b), (d), and (f): Distribution of the surface mass density along the distances from the center α(J2000) = 5h17fm6, δ(J2000) = −69°2'. (a) and (b), (c) and (d), and (e) and (f) present those of the GMC Type I, Type II, and Type III, respectively. Dashed lines (red in electric version) present those of the GMCs without small clouds. The region within 1.7 kpc from the center (dotted lines) is completely covered (Paper I).

Standard image High-resolution image
Figure 11.

Figure 11. (a), (c), and (e): frequency distribution of the position angle of the clouds with respect to the center α(J2000) = 5h17fm6, δ(J2000) = −69°2' determined from the kinematics of the H i (Kim et al. 1998). The angle starts from the north to the east in counter clock-wise direction. (b), (d), and (f): distribution of the surface mass density along the position angle of the clouds with respect to the center α(J2000) = 5h17fm6, δ(J2000) = −69°2'. (a) and (b), (c) and (d), and (e) and (f) present those of the GMC Type I,  II, and III, respectively. Dashed lines (red in electric version) present those of the GMCs without small clouds. The region within 1.7 kpc from the center (dotted lines) is completely covered (Paper I).

Standard image High-resolution image

Figure 10 shows that the radial profile of the surface density decreases moderately along the galactocentric distance for Type II as is also seen in the nearby spiral galaxies (e.g., Wong & Blitz 2002), while those for Types II and III are rather flat with respect to the radial distance. It is interesting to note that the number distribution and surface density show different radial profiles for Type I; the number increases at large radial distances but the surface density is relatively constant. This indicates that the more massive Type I GMCs are found at the large radial distances. It is also notable that there is a sharp enhancement of the number of the clouds around 1.5 kpc for Types II and III. This enhancement is due to the molecular ridge, N11, and N44. This enhancement is also seen in the angular distribution, especially at about 120° due to the molecular ridge.

3.5. Physical Properties of the GMCs

Cluster forming clouds provide us with precious information on understanding physical processes of cluster formation. We shall examine the physical properties of the GMC types. In this section, only the GMCs with mass MCO > 5 × 104M are considered. Figure 12 shows the distribution of the line width, size, and mass of the GMCs, respectively. The upper panels are the GMCs not associated with the H ii regions and the clusters, i.e., those with no sign of massive star formation (Type I). The middle ones are the GMCs associated only with the H ii regions, i.e., those showing massive star formation but no cluster formation (Type II). The lower are the GMCs associated with the H ii regions and clusters, i.e., those actively forming stars and clusters (Type III). Table 4 summarizes a mean and standard deviation of the line widths, sizes, and masses of each GMC type.

Figure 12.

Figure 12. Histograms of ΔV ((a), (d), and (g)), R ((b), (e), and (h)), and MCO ((c), (f), and (i)) of the GMCs. (a)–(c), (d)–(f), and (c)–(i) show the properties of the GMC Type I, Type II, and Type III, respectively. Dashed lines indicate the completeness limit of the R, Rcompleteness = 20 pc, and MCO, MCO,completeness = 5 × 104M. Note that R is derived for 164 GMCs out of 230 because the size cannot be derived for those with minor axis less than the NANTEN beam (see Paper I)

Standard image High-resolution image

Table 4. Physical properties of the GMCs

    Line Width Size Mass
GMC Type Number of Clouds 〈ΔV〉 (km s−1) σΔV (km s−1) R〉 (pc) σR (pc) MCO〉 (105 M) $\sigma _{M_{\rm CO}}$ (105 M)
I 46(24%) 5.9 2.5 40 15 2  2
II 96(50%) 5.5 2.2 36 19 3  4
III 49(26%) 7.0 3.0 46 30 6 20

Notes. Properties of the GMCs with mass, MCO > 5 × 104M. The average values of line width, size, and mass for each type are shown in 〈 〉. The average and σ of the size are derived for 164 GMCs with minor axis more than the NANTEN beam (see also Paper I).

Download table as:  ASCIITypeset image

Figure 12 and Table 4 indicate that a significant difference is not seen in the line width and size among the three types, while the mass distribution shows a slight difference. The frequency distribution of mass of Types I and II shows a peak at MCO ∼ 105M and then decreases as the mass becomes large, while that of Type III is rather flat and the average mass of Type III is larger than that of Types I and II. The small difference in the physical properties among three types suggests that the integrated properties of the GMCs at a scale of 30–100 pc are not so sensitive to the local star formation activities until the last stage of cloud dissipation.

4. DISCUSSION

4.1. GMC Type I: GMCs Without Massive Star Formation

Almost all the GMCs in the solar vicinity are forming massive stars actively as indicated by associated H ii regions and/or OB associations in addition to a number of young low-mass stars (Dame et al. 1987; Blitz 1993 and references therein). There are only two GMCs which show no signs of massive star formation in the solar neighborhood among ∼20 GMCs; the Maddalena's cloud (Maddalena & Thaddeus 1985) and ON-1 cloud complex (Israel & Wootten 1983). The reason for not forming massive stars may be either it is at a very young stage prior to massive star formation (Maddalena & Thaddeus 1985; Israel & Wootten 1983) or that it is in a late stage after active star formation (Lee et al. 1994).

A large number of starless GMCs in the LMC suggests that the timescale in star formation is significantly longer in the LMC than in the Galaxy. The ionization degree in a molecular cloud is likely determined by the far-ultraviolet (FUV) photons of stellar radiation fields (McKee 1989; Nozawa et al. 1991). In the LMC, the FUV flux is several times higher (Israel et al. 1986) and the dust extinction is smaller by a factor of 3–4 for a given gaseous column density (Koornneef 1982). Since the timescale of the diffusion of magnetic field is proportional to the ionization degree (Spitzer 1978), the contraction of cloud may be slowed down by the magnetic field. In addition, the cooling rate via molecular and dust emission is expected to be smaller in the LMC than in the Galaxy, helping star formation activity to slow down. Higher ionization degree and smaller cooling rate are basically the consequences of lower metallicity in the LMC (Dufour 1984) and are both likely to support for the retarded star formation.

An alternative idea to explain starless GMCs is that the GMCs in the LMC are of very recent formation, a situation possibly similar to the Maddalena's clouds and ON-1 cloud complex. It is well known that the LMC has a number of supershells expanding to accumulate the interstellar matter (Meaburn 1980; Oey 1996; Kim et al. 1999). Yamaguchi et al. (2001a) investigated the possible correlation between GMCs and supergiant shells and concluded that one third of GMCs may be located toward the shell boundaries, suggesting that a significant number of GMCs may have been formed under the triggering by expanding shells. The spatial distribution of the starless GMCs is however fairly random, showing little correlation with supergiant shells. It seems therefore the retarded star formation in the LMC is not due to some local environment or dynamical activities.

Finally, we shall comment on a possible link between Type I GMCs and the formation of populous stellar clusters. It is tempting to speculate that there is a link between populous clusters and the Type I GMCs. A possible explanation is that a longer timescale of star formation allows the formation of protocluster molecular condensations as massive as 105M, which can lead to form populous clusters. This will never happen in the Galaxy because of the star formation immediately after formation of protocluster condensations having mass of 103M.

4.2. Evolution of the GMCs

The molecular clouds are considered to be formed in neutral gas, and as they evolve, they form stars and clusters, being dissipated by stellar winds or UV radiation from the massive stars or supernova explosions. At the end of their life, the newly formed stars and clusters remain. The process is, however, still unclear quantitatively, because we need a complete data set of molecular clouds to estimate the evolutionary timescale statistically. In our Galaxy, it is difficult to obtain such a complete sample due to the heavy contamination toward the Galactic plane. On the other hand, a face-on galaxy like the LMC is suitable for collecting a complete sample, which enables us to investigate the evolutionary process more quantitatively. By using the complete data set of the GMCs for a whole galaxy, we shall estimate their evolutionary timescale. In this section, only the GMCs with mass MCO > 5 × 104M are considered.

The evolutionary sequence of the GMCs is schematically drawn in Figure 13 together with examples of the GMCs corresponding to each stage. In the first stage, the GMC Type I, the GMCs show no sign of massive star formation. The second stage, the GMC Type II, is the GMCs associated only with H ii regions. They are forming massive stars, but clusters have not appeared yet. The third, the GMC Type III, is the GMCs associated with both H ii regions and clusters. They are actively forming clusters. Molecular gas around newly formed clusters is partly dissipated, but the GMCs are still massive as is seen in Figure 12. The last is when the GMCs have been completely dissipated and only the young clusters and/or SNRs are found.

Figure 13.

Figure 13. Evolutionary sequence of the molecular clouds. The left panels are examples of GMC Type I (GMC 215, LMC N J0544 − 7127 in Table 1), Type II (GMC 135, LMC N J0525-6609), and Type III (the northern part of GMC 197, LMC N J0540 − 7008) from the top panel, respectively. Each panel presents Hα images from Kim et al. (1999) with GMCs identified by NANTEN (Paper I) in contours: The contour levels are from 1.2 K km s−1 with 1.2 K km s−1 intervals. Open circles indicate the position of young clusters (Bica et al. 1996). The middle panels are illustration for each evolutionary stage. Open circles and filled circles in red represent young clusters and H ii regions, respectively.

Standard image High-resolution image

If we assume that the GMCs and clusters in the LMC are being formed nearly steadily, we can estimate each evolutionary timescale according to the above classification. First, we shall estimate the timescale of the cloud dissipation. We found that ∼66% of the youngest clusters of τ< 10 Myr are associated with the GMCs (see Section 3.2). If we assume that the clusters in the LMC are being formed nearly steadily in the past 10 Myr, this result means the GMCs can survive during ∼66% of the cluster age, 10 Myr, and are dissipated in a few Myr after formation of clusters due to the UV photons from the clusters. The timescale for the GMC Type III is thus considered to be ∼7 Myr. If we further assume that the massive star formation and cluster formation occur nearly steadily, the timescale for each stage is proportional to the number of the GMCs. Accordingly, the timescales for the GMC Type I and II are estimated to be 6 Myr and 13 Myr, respectively. As a result, the typical lifetime of the GMCs, corresponding to the total lifetime of the GMC from Type I to III, is roughly ∼30 Myr.

Fukui et al. (1999) and Yamaguchi et al. (2001b) made a comparison of 55 GMCs with mass above 2 × 105M from the NANTEN first survey with the young objects. Their result shows that 6 GMCs show no sign of massive star formation, 9 are associated with H ii regions, and 28 with young clusters, indicating that the population of Type III GMCs is the highest, 50%, and Type II and I are 21% and 14%, respectively. The higher sensitivity of the second survey made us possible to obtain a sample of the GMCs with mass as small as 5 × 104M. This provides us with a complete sample of the GMCs, which are massive enough to produce massive stars. The numbers of Type I and Type II GMCs are increased in the current work compare to the first survey more than that of the Type III, because the mass of the Type I and Type II are smaller than the mass of the Type III, and thus, the higher sensitivity of the survey increased the number of Type I and Type II more. As a consequence of it, the estimated timescale of the a GMC now becomes longer from the previous result.

We summarize the evolutionary timescale of the GMCs in Table 3. The GMCs form massive stars, and H ii regions appear after ∼6 Myr from their birth. After 13 Myr, clusters start to be formed, then also start dissipating the surrounding molecular gas. The GMCs continue to form clusters actively, being dissipated by the UV photons and stellar winds from the clusters. After ∼7 Myr, the GMCs have been almost dissipated by the newly formed clusters, and eventually, by supernova explosions. The above time estimation should include an error. The age determination for the clusters contains uncertainty, but this changes only the absolute timescale for each stage. Other errors are possible due to a simple assumption of the constant formation rate for the clusters and the GMCs. Our estimation, nevertheless, shows a typical evolutionary sequence of the GMCs. Further quantitative detailed studies, such as a comparison with Hα flux, determining the age and mass of the clusters, and observations at higher resolution, will lead us to better understandings of star formation processes and the cloud dissipation in the LMC. Furthermore, detailed comparisons of the molecular clouds with H i give us a clue to understand the molecular clouds formation. These studies are found in elsewhere (e.g., Wong et al. 2009; Fukui et al. 2009)

5. SUMMARY

We summarize our results obtained by comparing the molecular clouds from the second NANTEN survey (Paper I) with the young stellar clusters and H ii regions.

  • 1.  
    We made a positional comparison of the molecular clouds with classical H ii regions and clusters. It is indicated that the youngest group of the clusters, SWB 0 type, with an age of τ < 10 Myr and H ii regions show a significant correlation with the GMCs, while the clusters older than 10 Myr show little or no correlation.
  • 2.  
    The molecular clouds are classified into three types; Type I shows no signature of star formation, Type II is associated with relatively small H ii region(s), and Type III with both H ii region(s) and young stellar cluster(s). Out of 272 molecular clouds, 72, 142, and 58 are found to be Types I, II, and III, respectively. The radio continuum sources were used to confirm that Type I molecular clouds do not host optically hidden H ii regions.
  • 3.  
    It is found that there is no significant difference in the distribution of the line widths and sizes of the GMCs among the three types for those with a mass above the completeness limit, 5 × 104 M, while the mass distribution of the Type III GMCs is different from those of Type I and II. The mass distribution of Type I and II shows a peak at MCO ∼ 105M, while that of the Type III is rather flat.
  • 4.  
    We interpret that these Types represent the evolutionary sequence; i.e., the youngest phase is Type I followed by Type II and the last phase is Type III where most active star formation takes place leading to cloud dispersal. The number of the three types of GMCs should be proportional to the timescale of each evolutionary stage if a steady state is a good approximation. By adopting the timescale of the youngest stellar clusters, 10 Myr, we roughly estimate the timescales of Types I, II, and III to be 6 Myr, 13 Myr, and 7 Myr, respectively, for those with a mass above the completeness limit, 5 × 104 M. This corresponds to a lifetime of the GMC of 20–30 Myr.

The NANTEN project is based on a mutual agreement between Nagoya University and the Carnegie Institution of Washington (CIW). We greatly appreciate the hospitality of all the staff members of the Las Campanas Observatory of CIW. We are thankful to many Japanese public donors and companies who contributed to the realization of the project. This study has made use of SIMBAD Astronomical Database and NASA's Astrophysics Data System Bibliographic Services. This work is financially supported in part by a Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research from the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology of Japan (No. 15071203), from JSPS (No. 14102003, No. 18684003, and core-to-core program 17004), and the Mitsubishi Foundation. A.K. is financially supported by the 21st century COE program.

Please wait… references are loading.
10.1088/0067-0049/184/1/1