General models for the distributions of electric field gradients in disordered solids

Hyperfine studies of disordered materials often yield the distribution of the electric field gradient (EFG) or related quadrupole splitting (QS). The question of the structural information that may be extracted from such distributions has been considered for more than fifteen years. Experimentally most studies have been performed using Mössbauer spectroscopy, especially on . However, NMR, NQR, EPR and PAC methods have also received some attention. The EFG distribution for a random distribution of electric charges was for instance first investigated by Czjzek et al [1] and a general functional form was derived for the joint (bivariate) distribution of the principal EFG tensor component and the asymmetry parameter . The importance of the Gauss distribution for such rotationally invariant structural models was thus evidenced. Extensions of that model which are based on degenerate multivariate Gauss distributions for the elements of the EFG tensor were proposed by Czjzek. The latter extensions have been used since that time, more particularly in Mössbauer spectroscopy, under the name `shell models'. The mathematical foundations of all the previous models are presented and critically discussed as they are evidenced by simple calculations in the case of the EFG tensor. The present article only focuses on those aspects of the EFG distribution in disordered solids which can be discussed without explicitly looking at particular physical mechanisms. We present studies of three different model systems. A reference model directly related to the first model of Czjzek, called the Gaussian isotropic model (GIM), is shown to be the limiting case for many different models with a large number of independent contributions to the EFG tensor and not restricted to a point-charge model. The extended validity of the marginal distribution of in the GIM model is discussed. It is also shown that the second model based on degenerate multivariate normal distributions for the EFG components yields questionable results and has been exaggeratedly used in experimental studies. The latter models are further discussed in the light of new results. The problems raised by these extensions are due to the fact that the consequences of the statistical invariance by rotation of the EFG tensor have not been sufficiently taken into account. Further difficulties arise because the structural degrees of freedom of the disordered solid under consideration have been confused with the degrees of freedom of QS distributions. The relations which are derived and discussed are further illustrated by the case of the EFG tensor distribution created at the centre of a sphere by m charges randomly distributed on its surface. The third model, a simple extension of the GIM, considers the case of an EFG tensor which is the sum of a fixed part and of a random part with variable weights. The bivariate distribution is calculated exactly in the most symmetric case and the effect of the random part is investigated as a function of its weight. The various models are more particularly discussed in connection with short-range order in disordered solids. An ambiguity problem which arises in the evaluation of bivariate distributions of centre lineshift (isomer shift) and quadrupole splitting from Mössbauer spectra is finally quantitatively considered.