Abstract
GS 341 is one of the most familiar of Nietzsche’s writings. This article proposes a new reading that stands in contrast with most English-language Nietzsche scholarship. The text presents a communication and its reception. A ‘demon’ makes an announcement, and a hearer responds in one way or another. But there is also another narrative altogether, whose conceptual vocabulary comes from a dynamic world-view. In this an interaction of forces leads to a new situation. If the hearer is not crushed by the ‘greatest weight’, there must be an inner force that counteracts its impact. I argue that what Nietzsche calls amor fati is a state that allows our drives to achieve full expression, and so makes possible a collective strength able to withstand the greatest impact. The final sentence refers to a “confirmation and sealing”. What happens is that the demon’s message makes an impression on the receptive hearer. For Nietzsche this is a working metaphor, not a turn of phrase. In a draft from this period he writes: “Let us stamp the image of eternity on our life!” That sudden and forceful act, embodying an evaluative judgement, is the event that GS 341 is all about.
Bibliography
Abel, Günter: Die Dynamik der Willen zur Macht und die ewige Wiederkehr, 2nd edn., Berlin 199810.1515/9783110827873Search in Google Scholar
Anderson, R. Lanier: “Nietzsche on Truth, Illusion, and Redemption”, European Journal of Philosophy 13.2 (2005), 185–22510.1111/j.0966-8373.2005.00227.xSearch in Google Scholar
Ansell-Pearson, Keith: “Living the Eternal Return as an Event: Nietzsche with Deleuze”, Journal of Nietzsche Studies 14 (1997), 64–97Search in Google Scholar
Ansell-Pearson, Keith: Nietzsche Contra Rousseau: A Study of Nietzsche’s Moral and Political Thought, Cambridge 1996Search in Google Scholar
Bois, Henri: “Le ‘Retour éternel’ de Nietzsche”, L’Année philosophique 24 (1913), 145–184Search in Google Scholar
Clark, Maudemarie: Nietzsche on Truth and Philosophy, Cambridge 199010.1017/CBO9780511624728Search in Google Scholar
Frege, Gottlob: “The Thought: A Logical Enquiry”, Mind 65 (1956), 289–311, first published as “Der Gedanke: Eine logische Untersuchung”, Beiträge zur Philosophie der deutschen Idealismus 1 (1918/19), 58–77Search in Google Scholar
Gooding-Williams, Robert: Zarathustra’s Dionysian Modernism, Stanford, CA 200110.1515/9780804780193Search in Google Scholar
Han-Pile, Béatrice: “Nietzsche and Amor Fati”, European Journal of Philosophy 19.2 (2009), 224–26110.1111/j.1468-0378.2009.00380.xSearch in Google Scholar
Hatab, Lawrence J.: Nietzsche’s Life Sentence: Coming to Terms with Eternal Recurrence, New York 2005Search in Google Scholar
Higgins, Kathleen M.: Comic Relief: Nietzsche’s Gay Science, New York 2000Search in Google Scholar
Kain, Philip J.: Nietzsche and the Horror of Existence, Lanham, MD 200910.1080/09608780802548416Search in Google Scholar
Langer, Monika M.: Nietzsche’s Gay Science: Dancing Coherence, Basingstoke 201010.1057/9780230281769Search in Google Scholar
Lemm, Vanessa: Nietzsche’s Animal Philosophy: Culture, Politics, and the Animality of the Human Being, New York 200910.2307/j.ctt13x024mSearch in Google Scholar
Loeb, Paul S.: “The Colossal Moment in Nietzsche’s Gay Science § 341”, in Paul Katsafanas (ed.), The Nietzschean Mind, London 2018, 428–44710.4324/9781315146317-28Search in Google Scholar
Loeb, Paul S.: The Death of Nietzsche’s Zarathustra, Cambridge 201010.1017/CBO9780511770821Search in Google Scholar
Magnus, Bernd: Nietzsche’s Existential Imperative, Bloomington, IN 1978Search in Google Scholar
Magnus, Bernd / Higgins, Kathleen M.: “Nietzsche’s Works and Their Themes”, in Bernd Magnus / Kathleen M. Higgins (ed.), The Cambridge Companion to Nietzsche, Cambridge 1996, 21–6810.1017/CCOL0521365864.002Search in Google Scholar
Magnus, Bernd: “Perfectibility and Attitude in Nietzsche’s Übermensch”, Review of Metaphysics 36 (1983), 633–659Search in Google Scholar
Mittasch, Alwin: Nietzsche, Stuttgart 1952Search in Google Scholar
Nehamas, Alexander: Nietzsche: Life As Literature, Cambridge 1985Search in Google Scholar
Oddy, Andrew: “Assaying in Antiquity”, Gold Bulletin 16.2 (1983), 52–5910.1007/BF03214624Search in Google Scholar
Oger, Eric: “The Eternal Return as Crucial Test”, Journal of Nietzsche Studies 14 (1997), 7–15Search in Google Scholar
Ridley, Aaron: “Nietzsche’s Greatest Weight”, Journal of Nietzsche Studies 14 (1997), 19–25Search in Google Scholar
Rynhold, David / Harris, Michael J.: Nietzsche, Soloveitchik, and Contemporary Jewish Philosophy, Cambridge 201810.1017/9781316266212Search in Google Scholar
Salaquarda, Jörg: “Der ungeheure Augenblick”, Nietzsche-Studien 18 (1989), 317–33710.1515/9783112418680-021Search in Google Scholar
Schacht, Richard: Nietzsche, London 1983Search in Google Scholar
Simmel, Georg: Schopenhauer and Nietzsche, trans. Helmut Loiskandl, Deena Weinstein and Michael Weinstein, Amherst, MA 1986Search in Google Scholar
Small, Robin: Time and Becoming in Nietzsche’s Thought, London 2010Search in Google Scholar
Soll, Ivan: “Reflections on Recurrence: A Re-Examination of Nietzsche’s Doctrine, die Ewige Wiederkehr des Gleichen”, in Robert C. Solomon (ed.), Nietzsche: A Collection of Critical Essays, Garden City, NY 1973, 322–342Search in Google Scholar
Stack, George J.: Lange and Nietzsche, Berlin 198310.1515/9783110854664Search in Google Scholar
Ure, Michael: Nietzsche’s The Gay Science: An Introduction, Cambridge 201910.1017/9781139019354Search in Google Scholar
Williams, Linda L.: Nietzsche’s Mirror: The World as Will to Power, Lanham, MD 2001Search in Google Scholar
Wood, David C.: Time After Time, Bloomington, IN 2007Search in Google Scholar
© 2020 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston
