Causes of Distrust and Conflict in the ROK-US Alliance: With a Focus on the Roh Moohyun Era

@article{ART002135629},
author={ 손병권 and 김민아 },
title={Causes of Distrust and Conflict in the ROK-US Alliance: With a Focus on the Roh Moohyun Era},
journal={분쟁해결연구},
issn={1738-365X},
year={2016},
volume={14},
number={2},
pages={263-286},
doi={10.16958/drsr.2016.14.2.263},
url={http://dx.doi.org/10.16958/drsr.2016.14.2.263}

TY - JOUR
AU - 손병권
AU - 김민아
TI - Causes of Distrust and Conflict in the ROK-US Alliance: With a Focus on the Roh Moohyun Era
T2 - 분쟁해결연구
PY - 2016
VL - 14
IS - 2
PB - 단국대학교 분쟁해결연구센터
SP - 263-286
SN - 1738-365X
AB - Given a widespread consensus that the ROK-US alliance had weakened during the Roh Moohyun years, this paper proposed four explanations on trust depletion and conflict escalation between the two nations: explanations based on “core belief divergence,” “motivated bargaining tactic,” “mutual communication mismanagement,” and “political institutional difference” respectively. Among other things, the core belief explanation was right in pointing out the distrust and conflict arising from preference differences of two nations’ foreign policy elites. The motivated bargaining tactic model also has merits in that it emphasizes political elites’ incentive to bargain in an advantaged position, and to take advantage of threat from outside to solidify domestic support. The mutual communication mismanagement explanation, in its turn, well captures one of the important situations where two allies begin to engage with each other without enough information about each other’s counterpart. Finally, the political institutional model is remotely related to the distrust and tension problem. Among the four explanations mentioned above, the first and fourth ones are exogenously given when a new Korean administration starts in the context of the Korean political structure, while the second and third ones focus on the processional context.
KW - the ROK-US alliance, President Roh Moohyun, core belief, bargaining tactic, communication mismanagement, political institution
DO - 10.16958/drsr.2016.14.2.263
UR - http://dx.doi.org/10.16958/drsr.2016.14.2.263
ER -

손병권 and 김민아 (2016). Causes of Distrust and Conflict in the ROK-US Alliance: With a Focus on the Roh Moohyun Era. 분쟁해결연구, 14( 2), 263- 286.

손병권 and 김민아 . 2016, “Causes of Distrust and Conflict in the ROK-US Alliance: With a Focus on the Roh Moohyun Era”, 분쟁해결연구, vol. 14, no. 2, pp. 263-286. Available from: doi:10.16958/drsr.2016.14.2.263

손병권 김민아 et al. “Causes of Distrust and Conflict in the ROK-US Alliance: With a Focus on the Roh Moohyun Era” 분쟁해결연구 14.2 pp. 263-286 (2016): 263.

손병권 , 김민아 . Causes of Distrust and Conflict in the ROK-US Alliance: With a Focus on the Roh Moohyun Era 분쟁해결연구 [Internet]. 2016; 14( 2), : 263-286. Available from: doi:10.16958/drsr.2016.14.2.263

손병권 and 김민아 . “Causes of Distrust and Conflict in the ROK-US Alliance: With a Focus on the Roh Moohyun Era” 분쟁해결연구 14, no.2 (2016): 263-286. doi: 10.16958/drsr.2016.14.2.263

홈 권호 목록 논문 목록 논문 상세

Causes of Distrust and Conflict in the ROK-US Alliance: With a Focus on the Roh Moohyun Era

분쟁해결연구

약어 : drsr

2016, vol.14, no.2, pp.263 - 286

DOI : 10.16958/drsr.2016.14.2.263

발행기관 : 단국대학교 분쟁해결연구센터

연구분야 : 사회과학일반

손병권¹ , 김민아²

¹중앙대학교

²중앙대학교

인용한 논문 수 : - 서지 간략 보기

초록

Given a widespread consensus that the ROK-US alliance had weakened during the Roh Moohyun years, this paper proposed four explanations on trust depletion and conflict escalation between the two nations: explanations based on “core belief divergence,” “motivated bargaining tactic,” “mutual communication mismanagement,” and “political institutional difference” respectively. Among other things, the core belief explanation was right in pointing out the distrust and conflict arising from preference differences of two nations’ foreign policy elites. The motivated bargaining tactic model also has merits in that it emphasizes political elites’ incentive to bargain in an advantaged position, and to take advantage of threat from outside to solidify domestic support. The mutual communication mismanagement explanation, in its turn, well captures one of the important situations where two allies begin to engage with each other without enough information about each other’s counterpart. Finally, the political institutional model is remotely related to the distrust and tension problem. Among the four explanations mentioned above, the first and fourth ones are exogenously given when a new Korean administration starts in the context of the Korean political structure, while the second and third ones focus on the processional context.

키워드

the ROK-US alliance, President Roh Moohyun, core belief, bargaining tactic, communication mismanagement, political institution

참고문헌(22)

[단행본] Daalder, Ivo H. / 2003 / The George W. Bush Presidency: An Early Assessment / The Johns Hopkins University Press
[단행본] Evans, Peter B / 1993 / Double-Edged Diplomacy: International Bargaining and Domestic Politics / University of California Press
[학술지] George, Alexander L. / 1969 / The Operational Code: A Neglected Approach to the Study of Political Leaders and Decision Making / International Studies 13 (2) : 190 ~ 222
[학술지] Gourevitch, Peter / 1978 / Second Image Reversed: The International Sources of Domestic Politics / International Organization 32 (4) : 881 ~ 912
[단행본] Hermann, Margaret G. / 1983 / Perspectives on American Foreign Policy: Selected Readings / St. Martin Press
[학술지] Jervis, Robert / 1968 / Hypotheses on Perception / World Politics 20 (3)
[학술지] 정하용 / 2012 / 단극 체계와 한미동맹의 변화 / 한국정치연구 21 (1) : 231 ~ 254
[단행본] Kegley, Charles W / 1979 / American Foreign Policy: Pattern and Process / St. Martin Press
[학술지] 이기완 / 2011 / 1990년 이후 한국의 정치동학과 한미동맹 / 국제관계연구 16 (1) : 5 ~ 29
[기타] Lee, Mi Sook / 2008 / Foreign/Security Policies – Fives Years Dominated by 386 / Munhwa Daily : 8
[학술지] Levy, Jack S. / 1988 / Domestic Politics and War / Journal of Interdisciplinary History 18 : 653 ~ 673
[학술지] Miller, R. A. / 1995 / Domestic Structures and the Diversionary Use of Force / American Political Science Review 39 (3) : 760 ~ 785
[학술지] 문정인 / 2008 / Diplomacy of Defiance and Facilitation: The Six Party Talks and the Roh Moo Hyun Government / Asian Perspective 32 (4) : 71 ~ 105
[단행본] Moravscik, Andrew / 1993 / Double-Edged Diplomacy: International Bargaining and Domestic Politics / University of California Press
[학술지] Morgan, Clifton T. / 1992 / Domestic Discontent and the External Use of Force / Journal of Conflict Resolution 36 : 25 ~ 52
[학술지] Ostrom, Charles W / 1986 / The President and the Political Use of Force / American Political Science Review 80 : 541 ~ 566
[학술지] Patrick, James / 1991 / The Influences of Domestic and International Politics on the President’s Use of Force / Journal of Conflict Resolution 35 (2) : 307 ~ 332
[학술지] Putnam, Robert / 1988 / Diplomacy and Domestic Politics: The Logic of Two-Level Games / International Organization 42 (3) : 427 ~ 460
[학술지] Schoppa, Leonard J. / 1993 / Two-Level Games and Bargaining Outcome: Why gaiatsu Succeed in Japan in Some Cases but Not Others / International Organization 47 (3) : 353 ~ 386
[단행본] Waltz, Kenneth / 1959 / Man, the State and War / Columbia University Press
[학술지] 우정엽 / 2015 / 한국 국민의 한미 동맹에 대한 지지 변화에 대한 연구 / 국제.지역연구 24 (3) : 41 ~ 65
[학술지] 윤종빈 / 2004 / 17대 초선의원들의 사회·경제적 배경 / 의정연구 10 (2) : 59 ~ 83