초록

The expanded role of courts in arbitral procedures is said to have certain detrimental effects on the cost-effective approach to arbitration. This is the case when the court is appointing an arbitrator, pursuant to the specific domestic legal regime. The danger of decisions, especially those with expanded role of courts can create delays and hurdles. Even with contradictory viewpoints, the role of the court should complement the arbitral tribunal and not impede the functioning of arbitration independent of the judicial system. In this paper, two recent cases in Korean Supreme Court are reviewed, trying to find the proper implications on further arbitration practices especially in the stage of arbitrator appointment. Even though the proper appointment of arbitrators is essential to the existence of valid arbitration proceedings, appointment of arbitrators by the courts should constitute an administrative power, and not a judicial power. The cases reviewed make clear that the court must play a facilitative role in international commercial arbitration by assisting the parties in appointing the arbitral tribunal, the court intervention must be kept to a minimum.

키워드

중재판정부, 중재인 선정, 중재법 제12조, 항고

참고문헌(19)open

  1. [단행본] 목영준 / 2000 / 상사중재법론 / 박영사

  2. [단행본] 양병회 / 2005 / 주석 중재법 / 대한상사중재원

  3. [단행본] 장문철 / 2000 / 현대 중재법의 이해 / 세창출판사

  4. [기타] / 2009 / 대법원 2009년 4월 15일 선고, 2007그154 결정

  5. [기타] / 2009 / 대법원 2009년 10월 14일 선고, 2009마1395 결정

  6. [학술지] 강수미 / 2008 / 다수당사자중재에 있어서 중재인 선정방법 / 중재연구 18 (2) : 79 ~ 102

  7. [학술지] 김용일 / 2006 / 국제상사중재에서 중재인 선정에 관한 비교연구 / 통상정보연구 8 (3) : 215 ~ 235

  8. [학술지] 오원석 / 2007 / ICC仲裁에서 仲裁人 選定과 確認에관한 硏究 / 중재연구 17 (2) : 23 ~ 41

  9. [학술지] 오창석 / 2006 / 상사중재에 있어서의 중재인에 대한 시피사유와 중재인의 고지의무 / 상사판례연구 19 (1) : 353 ~ 388

  10. [학술지] 이주원 / 2008 / 남북상사중재에 있어 중재인선정방식에 관한 연구 / 중재연구 18 (1) : 147 ~ 165

  11. [학술지] 조정곤 / 1993 / 상사중재에서의 중재인선정과 전략게임 / 중재학회지 3 (1)

  12. [학술지] 최혁준 / 2006 / 중재판정부 구성에 관한 비교연구-외국중재규칙을 중심으로 - / 중재연구 16 (1) : 187 ~ 217

  13. [학술지] Iguchi, Naoki / 2009 / ADR Client Strategies in Asia Leading Lawyers on Navigating the Negotiation Process, Advising Multinational Clients, and Understanding the Key Laws Governing ADR in this Region / Arbitration Laws and Trends in Japan

  14. [학술지] Okekeifere, Andrew I. / 1999 / Appointment and Challenge of Arbitrators under the UNICITRAL Model Law : Part 1: Agenda for Improvement / International Arbitration Law Review 2 (5)

  15. [학술지] Sen, Aniruddha / 2006 / The Role of the Court in the Appointment of Arbitrators - an Analysis with Reference to the Supreme Court of India's Decision in S.B.P. v. Patel Engineering / Vindobona Journal of International Commercial Law & Arbitration 10

  16. [단행본] Stone, Katherine V.W. / 2003 / Arbitration Law / Foundation Press New York

  17. [기타] United Nations Commission on International Trade Law / 2006 / UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration 1985 With amendments as adopted in 2006, United Nations, Vienna

  18. [기타] 近藤昌昭 / 2004 / 仲裁法 コンメンタール

  19. [단행본] 小島武司 / 2007 / 注釋と論点 仲裁法 / 靑林書院