초록

“What is the text? Authority and authenticity in muga.” This question is the essential issue which I intend to elaborate in this article. One of the main issues to consider in translation work is the identification of the author. In the case of muga, the identification of the author or authors is not always easy and obvious. It requires a wider angle of perspective on authorship. Identification of the author can neither be ignored because s/he is a person in power, who retains the authority of the transmission of muga, nor be underestimated because s/he is in possession of the authority of the authenticity of muga even when its meaning differs from person to person (mudang, spiritual daughter, amateur or “minjung ethnographer”, scholar) and changes according to the context or to varieties present in religious language. Thus, the particular issue which I intend to explore in this article is the multiple figure of the author, while identifying the procedures of decontextualization of muga from its context and of its recontextualization in another context. In other words, by analyzing the modality followed by the author/s in the procedure of decontextualizing and recontextualizing pieces of muga within and outside the ritual, this article focuses on how this influences the text which is intended to have a wider significance. Translation of a muga will be defined in accordance with the new meanings of authority, authenticity and text. The ethnographic material on which the research is based is drawn from years of fieldwork and books and articles I have written on the subject.

키워드

authorship, authenticity, authority, intertextuality and co-authors

참고문헌(44)open

  1. [단행본] Akamatsu, Chijo e Akiba. / 1937 / Chosen fuzoku no kenkyu / Osaka yago shoten

  2. [단행본] Bauman,Richard / 1986 / Story, Performance, and Event Contextual Studies of Oral Narrative / Cambridge University Press

  3. [학술지] Bauman, Richard. / 1990 / Poetics and Performance as Critical Perspectives on Language and Social Life / Annual Review of Anthropology (19) : 59 ~ 88

  4. [단행본] Bruno,Antonetta L. / 2002 / The Gate of Words Language in the Rituals of Korean Shamans / Press of the Research School for Asian, African and Amerindian Studies

  5. [단행본] Bruno, Antonetta L. / 2006 / Canti sciamanici coreani Collana Classici delle religioni / Utet

  6. [단행본] Bruno,Antonetta L. / 2007 / Sending away the Smallpox Gods : 259 ~ 283

  7. [단행본] Bruno,Antonetta L. / 2007 / A Shamanistic Ritual for Sending On the Dead : 325 ~ 352

  8. [단행본] Buswell Jr. / 2007 / Religions of Korea in Practice / Princeton University Press

  9. [단행본] Chang Chi-yong. / 1964 / Hong Kilton chon / Chongumsa

  10. [단행본] Chong Ch’ung-kwon / 2001 / P’ansori sasol-ui yonwongwa pyonmo / Toso ch’ulp’an taunsaem

  11. [단행본] Chong Pyong-uk. / 1981 / Han’guk-ui p’ansori / Chimmundang

  12. [단행본] Eco,Umberto. / 1995 / I limiti dell’interpretazione / Bompiani

  13. [단행본] Gennette, Gard. / 1997 / Palinsesti.La letteratura al secondo grado / Einaudi

  14. [단행본] / 1980 / Han’guk kubi munhak taegye / Han’guk chongsin munhwa yon’guwon

  15. [단행본] / 1991 / Han’guk minsok taesajon / Minjok munhwasa

  16. [단행본] Hernadi, Paul. / 1972 / Beyond Genre in New Directions in Literary Classification / University Press

  17. [단행본] Hong, T’ae-han. / 2000 / Sosa muga Tanggumegi yon’gu / Minsokwon

  18. [단행본] Kim, Hon-son. / 1995 / Han’guk kojon munhak chonjip 18 in ilban muga / Koryo Taehakkyo minjok munhwa yon’guso

  19. [단행본] Kim,Kum-hwa / 1995 / Kim Kum-hwa mugajip in komuna tta-e manshin huina paeksong-ui norae / Munumsa toso ch’ulp’an

  20. [학술지] Kim,Pyong-kuk. / 1982 / Kubi sosashi-roso pon p’ansori sasol-ui kusong pangsik / Han’guk hakpo 8 (2) : 120 ~ 149

  21. [단행본] Kim,Tae-kon / 1992 / Han’guk mugajip 4vols / Chimmundang

  22. [단행본] Kim, Yong-il. / 1996 / Han’guk musok shinhwa-ui sosa mohyongnon / Sejong ch’ul p’ansa

  23. [단행본] Kuipers,Joel C. / 1990 / Power in Performance The Creation of Textual Authority in Weyewa Ritual Speech / University of Pennsylvania Press

  24. [단행본] Kungnip munhwajae yon’guso / 1996 / Hwanghae-do P’yongsan sonorum kut / Kungnip munhwajae yon’guso

  25. [단행본] Lindstrom,Lamont. / 1992 / Context Contests in Debatable Truth Statements on Tanna / Vanuatu : 101 ~ 124

  26. [단행본] Linell,Per. / 1998 / Approaching Dialogue in Talk,Interaction and Contexts in Dialogical Perspectives / John Benjamins

  27. [단행본] Marshall R, Phil. / 1994 / The Korean Singer of Tales / Harvard-Yenching Institute

  28. [단행본] McCann,David R. / 2003 / Between Literary and Folk in The Art of Twelve Gasa Songs. In Korean Literature in Its Classical Heritage and Modern Breakthroughs / Korean National Commission for UNESCO

  29. [단행본] Nam Yongshin. / 1999 / Kugo sajon / Seoul:Songandang

  30. [단행본] Park,Byen-sen. / 1973 / Le recit de la"Princesse abandonnee"et les mediums a travers l’histoire de Coree / Yonsei University Museum

  31. [단행본] Pak, Kyong-shin. / 1993 / Tonghaean pyolshin kut muga, 5 vols / Kukhak charyowon

  32. [단행본] Pak,Kyong-shin / 1999 / Han’guk-ui Pyolshin kut muga 5 / Kukhak charyowon

  33. [단행본] Pettid,Michael J. / 1999 / From Abandoned Daughter to Shaman Matriarch in An Analysis of the Pari Kongju, a Korean Shamanistic Song, Ph.D. dissertation / University of Hawaii

  34. [단행본] Plett,Heinrich E / 1991 / Intertextuality / Plett : 3 ~ 27

  35. [단행본] Ricoeur, Paul. / 1977 / Interpretation Theory in Discourse and the Surplus of Meaning / Texas Christian University Press

  36. [단행본] Ricoeur, Paul. / 1977 / The Rule of Metaphor in Multidisciplinary Studies in the Creation of Meaning / University of Toronto Press

  37. [학술지] Schechner, Richard. / 1981 / Performers and Spectators Transported and Transformed / American Ethnologist 12 (4) : 707 ~ 724

  38. [단행본] So,Tae-sok. / 1990 / Ansong muga / Chimmundang

  39. [단행본] So,Tae-sok. / 1997 / Kubi munhak / Haenam

  40. [단행본] So,Tae-sok . / 1974 / Tonghaean muga / Hyongsol : 240 ~ 406

  41. [단행본] Yang, Chong-sung. / 1999 / Han’guk-ui musok in Seoul-Hwanghae-do p’yon / Kungnip minsok pangmulgwan

  42. [단행본] Yang, Chong-sung. / 1999 / Han’guk mushin-ui ch’ejewa ch’egye / Seoul Taehakkyo pigyo munhwa yon’guso

  43. [단행본] Yi,Nunghwa / 1927 / Choson musok ko / Paengnok ch’ulp’ansa

  44. [단행본] Walraven,Boudewijn C.A. / 1994 / Songs of the Shaman in the Ritual Chants of the Korean mudang / Kegan Paul International