초록

The only significant part of North Korean propaganda that is uncritically accepted in the foreign research community is the regime’s claim to be guided in its policy-making by Kim Il Sung’s Juche Thought. Oddly enough the Western consensus regarding Juche’s crucial importance to Pyongyang has never been accompanied by much research into the doctrine. Usually it is described in a sentence or two as a cult-like ideology of self-reliance. The following article sets out to show that the conventional wisdom is mistaken: Juche Thought exists to be praised and not read, let alone implemented. The little paraphrasable sense that can be extracted from the official sources is not only distinct from, but in many respects incompatible with, the paranoid, race-based nationalism that has always constituted North Korea’s true dominant ideology. In addition, the article seeks to explain how it was that the outside world accepted the Juche myth no less readily than did the North Korean people themselves.

키워드

juche, Hwang Changyŏp, Kim Il Sung, Kim Jong Il, North Korean ideology, North Korean studies, self-reliance, nationalism, propaganda, race theory

참고문헌(54)open

  1. [단행본] Ajami, Chaouki / 1978 / Juche in Theory and Application / Pyongyang

  2. [단행본] Alford, C. Fred. / 1999 / Think No Evil in Korean Values in the Age of Globalization / Cornell University Press

  3. [단행본] Belke, Thomas J. / 1999 / Juche: A Christian Study of North Korea’s State Religion / Living Sacrifice Book Co.

  4. [단행본] Bratzke, Mike. / 2003 / Kita Chosen ‘rakuen’ no zangai / Soshisha

  5. [단행본] Bright,Arthur. / 2006 / Defectors in No Kim Jong Il Would Mean No Nuclear Threat / The Christian Science Monitor

  6. [단행본] Burns,John F. / 1985 / The Kim Dynasty’s North Korea in A Nation Centered on One Family / New York Times

  7. [단행본] Ch’oi Kangsuk / 2006 / Kangje tongwon chonbom omyong posotta / Soul sinmun

  8. [단행본] Chong Ki-jong / 1997 / Ryoksa ui taeha / yesul ch’ulp’ansa

  9. [단행본] / 1999 / Choson taebaekkwa sajon / Kwahak paekkwa sajon ch’ulp’ansa

  10. [단행본] Cumings, Bruce. / 1993 / The Corporate State in North Korea. In State and Society in Contemporary Korea / Ithaca and London : 197 ~ 230

  11. [단행본] Cumings, Bruce. / 1990 / Origins of the Korean War in The Roaring of the Cataract 1947 1950 / Princeton University Press

  12. [단행본] Demick,Barbara. / 2005 / North Korea Seeks End to U.N.Aid / The Los Angeles Times

  13. [단행본] Dower, John W. / 1986 / War Without Mercy in Race and Power in the Pacific War / Pantheon Books

  14. [단행본] Eckert, Carter / 1996 / Offspring of Empire in The Koch’ang Kims and the Colonial Origins of Korean Capitalism, 1876 1945 / University of Washington Press

  15. [단행본] Gourevitch,Philip. / 2003 / Letter from North Korea in Alone in the Dark / The New Yorker

  16. [단행본] Haggard, Stephen. / 2007 / Famine in North Korea in Markets, Aid and Reform / Aid and Reform.Columbia University Press

  17. [단행본] Hwang Changyop / 2006 / Hoegorok / Sidaechongsin

  18. [인터넷자료] / Interview on the Charlie Rose Show:Christopher R.Hill,Assistant Secretary for East Asian and Pacific Affairs / U.S. State Department’s website

  19. [단행본] Im Chongguk / 1966 / Ch’inil munhangnon

  20. [단행본] Jones, Maggie. / 2006 / Shutting Themselves I / The New York Times

  21. [단행본] Kim Il Sung / 1968 / Choson minjujuui inmin konghwaguk eso ui sahoejuui konsol kwa Namchoson hyongmyong e taehayo / Choson rodongdang ch’ulp’ansa : 195 ~ 240

  22. [단행본] Kim Il Sung / 1968 / Choson rodongdang che 4 ch’a taehoe eso han chungang wiwonhoe saop ch’onghwa pogo, 1961 nyon 9 wol 11 il / Choson rodongdang ch’ulp’ansa : 60 ~ 203

  23. [단행본] Kim Il Sung. / 1968 / Kangsogun tangsaopchido eso odun kyohun e taehayo / Choson rodongdang ch’ulp’ansa : 505 ~ 542

  24. [단행본] Kim Il Sung. / 1967 / Sahoejuui hyongmyong ui hyondangye e issoso tang mit’ kukka saop ui myot kaji munje tul e taehayo / Choson rodongdang ch’ulp’ansa : 532 ~ 559

  25. [단행본] Kim Il Sung. / 1967 / Sasang saop eso kyojojuui wa hyongsikchuu i rul t’oech’i hago chuch’e rul hwangnip halte taehayo / Choson rodongdang ch’ulp’ansa : 560 ~ 585

  26. [학술지] Kim Il Sung. / 1984 / Uri tang ui chuch’e sasang gwa konghwaguk chongbu ui taenaeoe chongch’aek ui myot’kaji munje e taehayo / Kim Ilsong chojakjip (27) : 390 ~ 402

  27. [단행본] Kim Jong Il / 1992 / Chuch’e munhangnon / Pyongyang

  28. [단행본] Kim Pyongno. / 2000 / Pukhan sahoe ui chonggyosong in chuch’e sasanggwa kidokkyo ui chonggyo yangsik pigyo / T’ongil yon’guwon

  29. [단행본] Kimura, Mitsuhiko. / 2006 / Pasijum eso kongsanjuui ro.” In Haebang chonhusa ui chaeinsik / Ch’aeksesang : 737 ~ 764

  30. [단행본] Lankov, Andrei. / 2004 / Crisis in North Korea in The Failure of De-Stalinization 1956 / University of Hawaii Press

  31. [단행본] Lankov, Andrei. / 2002 / From Stalin to Kim Il Sung in The Formation of North Korea, 1945 1960 / Rutgers University Press

  32. [기타] Lee,Sunny. / 2007 / God Forbid, Religion in North Korea / Asia Times

  33. [단행본] Mao Zedong. / 1967 / We Must Learn to Do Economic Work In Selected Works of Mao Tse-tung / Foreign Languages Press

  34. [단행본] Martin, Bradley. / 2004 / Under the Loving Care of the Fatherly Leader in North Korea and the Kim Dynasty / Thomas Dunne Books

  35. [단행본] Moore, Malcolm. / 2008 / Kim Jong Il, North Korea’s Dear Leader in Profile / Daily Telegraph (UK)

  36. [보고서] Myers, Brian / 1994 / Han Sorya and North Korean Literature

  37. [단행본] Myers, Brian. / 2004 / Mother of All Mothers in The Leadership Secrets of Kim Jong Il / The Atlantic Monthly

  38. [학술지] Myers,Brian. / 1955 / The Watershed that Wasn’t: Re-Evaluating Kim Il Sung’s ‘Juche Speech’ of 1955 / Acta Koreana 9 (1) : 89 ~ 115

  39. [단행본] Oberdorfer, Don. / 2002 / The Two Koreas in A Contemporary History / Basic Books

  40. [단행본] Oh, Kongdan. / 2000 / North Korea Through the Looking Glass / Brookings Institution Press

  41. [단행본] Paige, Glenn D. / 1963 / The Post-War Politics of Communist Korea North Korea Today / Praeger Inc : 17 ~ 29

  42. [단행본] Pak Chihyang / 2006 / Haebang chonhusa ui chaeinsik / Ch’aeksesang

  43. [단행본] Park.Han S. / 1996 / The Nature and Evolution of Juche Ideology. In North Korea Ideology, Politics, Economy / Prentice Hall : 9 ~ 18

  44. [단행본] Pfabigan, Alfred. / 1986 / Schlaflos in Pjgjang / Verlag Christian Brandstter

  45. [단행본] Pocha,Jehangir S. / 2005 / Choreographing Success in North Korea / The Boston Globe

  46. [단행본] Saccone, Richard. / 2003 / Negotiating With North Korea / Hollym

  47. [보고서] Schafer, Bernd. / 1972 / North Korean ‘Adventurism’ and China’s Long Shadow, 1966 1972.

  48. [보고서] Schafer, Bernd. / 1989 / Weathering the Sino-Soviet Conflict in The GDR and North Korea, 1949 1989 : 25 ~ 38

  49. [단행본] Schurmann, Franz. / 1968 / and Organization in Modern China / University of California Press

  50. [단행본] Szalontai, Balazs. / 2005 / Kim Il Sung in the Khrushchev Era in Soviet-DPRK Relations and the Roots of North Korean Despotism, 1953 1964 / Woodrow Wilson Center Press

  51. [학술대회] Szalontai, Balazs. / 2003 / You Have No Political Line of Your Own’ in Kim Il Sung and the Soviets, 1953-1964 / Cold War International History Project Bulletin : 87 ~ 103

  52. [단행본] / 1959 / Taejung chongchi yong’o sajon / Pyongyang

  53. [단행본] Yang, Key P. / 1963 / The North Korean Educational System in 1945 to Present. North Korea Today / Praeger Inc

  54. [단행본] Zagoria, David S. / 1963 / Some Comparisons Between the Russian and the Chinese Models. In Communist Strategies in Asia in A Comparative Analysis of Governments and Parties / Frederick A. Praeger. : 11 ~ 33