초록

In 1687, a man calling himself Yu Yŏlli was discovered begging from the common people of Chido garrison in Chŏlla Province by pretending to be a Chinese castaway. Although the Chosŏn court eventually established that he was lying, it took a full month to come to this conclusion, despite what seems at times to have been a very flimsily constructed identity on Yu’s part. This article argues that he succeeded because he effectively reproduced the established Ming Loyalist narrative of the Chosŏn court, and also because of his initial location in the unstable and uncertain world of the southwestern islands. His lies, for this reason, are very useful for understanding the ideological presuppositions of late Chosŏn society.

키워드

Chosŏn, Maritime China, Chŏlla, rumour, Ming Loyalism, castaways

참고문헌(51)open

  1. [인터넷자료] Cho Hyŏnmyŏng / Sinbo sugyo chimnok [Newly supplemented collection of royal edicts]. 1743. Kyujanggak #kyu 1158

  2. [단행본] Chōsen Sōtokufu Chūsūin / 1974 / Chosŏn wangjo pŏpchŏn chip [Collected law codes of the Chosŏn dynasty] / Kyŏng’in munhwasa

  3. [인터넷자료] Yi Kyŏngsŏk / Hyojong sillok 1661

  4. [인터넷자료] Kim Suhang / Hyŏnjong kaesu sillok 1683

  5. [인터넷자료] Hŏ Chŏk / Hyŏnjong sillok 1677

  6. [인터넷자료] Kim Chaero / Soktaejŏn [Amended Great Code]. 1746. Kyujanggak #kojo 33

  7. [인터넷자료] / Naju Chidojin chido [Map of Chido Commandery in Naju]. 1872. Kyujanggak # kyu 1049

  8. [단행본] Pak Chiwŏn / 2004 / Yŏrha ilgi [Jehol diary] / Pori

  9. [인터넷자료] / Pibyŏngsa tŭngnok

  10. [인터넷자료] Sŏng Haeŭng / Yŏn’gyŏngjae chŏnjip [Collected works of Yŏn’gyŏngjae]. Kwaeinsabon edition. Undated. Korea National University Rare Books Library # kwi 555, 555A, 555B

  11. [인터넷자료] Song Siyŏl / Songja taejŏn [Grand compendium of the works of Master Song]. Kyujanggak edition of 1787. Kyujanggak # Kyu 3452

  12. [인터넷자료] Kim Ch’angjip / Sukchong sillok 1728

  13. [학술지] Bohnet, Adam / 2011 / Ruling Ideology and Marginal Subjects: Ming Loyalism and Foreign Lineages in Late Chosŏn Korea / Journal of Early Modern History 15 (6) : 477 ~ 505

  14. [학술지] Adam Bohnet / 2012 / Subversie Ming Loyalist Narratives in Late Choson Korea / Seoul Journal of Korean Studies 25 (1) : 1 ~ 30

  15. [단행본] Chin P’a / 2014 / Haeyang kwa tong Asia ŭi munhwa kyoryu / Tosŏ ch’ulp’an kyŏngjin : 174 ~ 209

  16. [단행본] Chŏng Sŏng’il / 2013 / Chŏllado wa Ilbon: Chosŏn sidae haenan sago punsŏk [Chŏlla Province and Japan: Marine accident cases during the Chosŏn period] / Kyŏng’in munhwasa

  17. [단행본] Deuchler, Martina / 1999 / Culture and the State in Late Chosŏn Korea / Harvard University Asia Center : 91 ~ 133

  18. [단행본] Haboush, Jahyun Kim / 2010 / Statecraft and Classical Learning: The Rituals of Zhou in East Asian History / Brill : 309 ~ 329

  19. [단행본] Haboush, Jahyun Kim / 2005 / Time, Temporality and Imperial Transition / Association for Asian Studies and University of Hawai’i Press : 115 ~ 141

  20. [단행본] Hang, Xing / 2015 / Conflict and Commerce in Maritime East Asia: The Zheng Family and the Shaping of the Modern World / Cambridge University Press

  21. [학술지] 허태용 / 2010 / 17·18세기 北伐論의 추이와 北學論의 대두 / 대동문화연구 (69) : 373 ~ 418

  22. [단행본] Hŏ T’aeyong / 2009 / Chosŏn hugi Chunghwaron kwa yŏksa insik [Late Chosŏn discussion of Chunghwa and historical consciousness] / Ak’anet

  23. [학술지] 임완혁 / 2005 / 明.淸 交替期 朝鮮의 對應과 忠烈錄의 의미 / 漢文學報 12 (1) : 179 ~ 217

  24. [학술지] Kang Ch’angnyong / 2004 / 17 segi chungyŏp Chunggugin ŭi Cheju p’yoch’ak—Hyŏnjŏng p’allyŏn (1667) Myŏng nara sangin Im In’gwan irhaeng ŭi Cheju p’yoch’ak ch’ŏri rŭl chungsim ŭro [The arrival of Chinese in Cheju during the mid-seventeenth century: With a focus on the handling of the Ming merchant Lin Yinguan and crew during the eighth year of Hyŏnjong (1667)] / T’amna munhwa 25 : 25 ~ 59

  25. [단행본] Kang Sŏkhwa / 2000 / Chosŏn hugi Hamgyŏngdo wa pukpang yŏngt’o ŭisik [Hamgyŏng Province during the late Chosŏn and consciousness of northern territory] / Kyŏngsewŏn

  26. [단행본] K’alsŭn Andŏsŭ / 2014 / Tong Asia ŭi sahyŏng / Yŏngnam taehakkyo ch’ulp’anbu : 152 ~ 193

  27. [학술지] 김창수 / 2012 / 17세기 후반 朝鮮使臣의 공식보고와 정치적 파장 / 사학연구 (106) : 141 ~ 173

  28. [단행본] Kim Hodong / 2007 / Tokto.Ullŭngdo ŭi yŏksa [The history of Tokto and Ullŭngdo] / Kyŏngin munhwasa

  29. [단행본] Kim Kyŏngok / 2004 / Chosŏn hugi tosŏ yŏn’gu [Research on islands during the Late Chosŏn period] / Hyean

  30. [학술지] 김문식 / 2012 / 成海應이 증보한『丁未傳信錄』 / 진단학보 (115) : 93 ~ 122

  31. [학술지] Kim, Seonmin / 2007 / Ginseng and Border Trespassing Between Qing China and Chosŏn Korea / Late Imperial China 28 (1) : 33 ~ 61

  32. [단행본] Kye Sŭngbŏm / 2009 / Chosŏn sidae haeoe p’abyŏng kwa Han-Jung kwan’gye: Chosŏn chibaech’ŭng ŭi Chung’guk insik [Dispatch of troops abroad during the Chosŏn period and Sino-Korean relations: The concept of China among Chosŏn’s ruling elite] / P’urŭn yŏksa

  33. [단행본] Kye Sŭngbŏm / 2009 / Han-Jung-Il hakkye ŭi Han-Jung kwan’gyesa ŭi yŏn’gu wa chaengjŏm / Tongbuga yŏksa chaedan : 125 ~ 186

  34. [학술지] 계승범 / 2014 / The Altar of Great Gratitude: A Korean Memory of Ming China under Manchu Dominance, 1704–1894 / Journal of Korean Religions 5 (2) : 71 ~ 88

  35. [단행본] Lewis, James B / 2003 / Frontier Contact Between Chosŏn Korea and Tokugawa Japan / Routledge Curzon

  36. [학술지] Lee, Hoon / 2006 / The Repatriation of Castaways in Chosŏn Korea-Japan Relations, 1599–1888 / Korean Studies 30 (1) : 67 ~ 90

  37. [단행본] Matsuura Akira / 2009 / Kaigai jŏhŏ kara miru Higashi Ajia: tŏsen fŭsetsugaki no sekai [East Asia seen through information from abroad: The world of records of rumours from Chinese ships] / Seibundŏ

  38. [학술지] 민덕기 / 2012 / 동아시아 해금정책의 변화와 해양 경계에서의 분쟁 / 한일관계사연구 (42) : 189 ~ 228

  39. [단행본] Miura Kunio / 1985 / The Rise of Neo-Confucianism in Korea / Columbia University Press : 411 ~ 444

  40. [단행본] Pae Usŏng / 2014 / Chosŏn kwa Chunghwa: Chosŏn i kkum kkugo sangsang han segye wa munmyŏng [Chosŏn and Chunghwa: The world and civilization that Chosŏn dreamed and imagined] / Tolbege

  41. [학술지] Pae Usŏng / 1998 / Chosŏn hugi pyŏnjigwan pyŏnhwa wa chiyŏngmin insik [Changes in attitudes toward edge territory during the late Chosŏn and the consciousness of local people] / Yŏksa hakpo 160 : 9 ~ 45

  42. [학술지] Park, Saeyoung / 2014 / Memory, Counternarrative and the Body Politic in Post-Imjin Korea / Journal of Korean Studies 19 (1) : 153 ~ 178

  43. [학술지] Robinson, Kenneth R / 2006 / An Island’s Place in History: Tsushima in Japan and Chosŏn, 1392–1592 / Korean Studies 30 : 38 ~ 64

  44. [학술지] Robinson, Kenneth R / 2000 / Centering the King of Chosŏn: Aspects of Korean Maritime Diplo-macy, 1392–1592 / The Journal of Asian Studies 59 (1) : 109 ~ 125

  45. [단행본] Roux, Pierre-Emmanuel / 2014 / Space and Location in Circulation of Knowledge (1400-1800): Korea and Beyond / Peter Lange : 124 ~ 128

  46. [학술지] 송양섭 / 2005 / 朝鮮後期 羅州諸島의 折受와 設邑論議의 展開 / 대동문화연구 (50) : 377 ~ 419

  47. [학술지] Sun Weiguo / 2007 / Yili yu xianshi de chongtu: Cong dingwei piaoliuren shijian kan Chaoxian wangchao zhi zun Ming bian Qing wenhua xintai [The conflict between orthodox thought and reality: Chosŏn’s pro-Ming/Anti-Qing sentiment as seen in the attitudes to the ninety-five drifting persons from Taiwan in 1667] / Hanxue yanjiu 25 (2) : 187 ~ 210

  48. [단행본] U Kyŏngsŏp / 2013 / Chosŏn Chunghwajuŭi ŭi sŏngnip kwa Tong Asia [East Asia and the establishment of Chosŏn Chunghwa ideology] / Yunisŭt’ori

  49. [학술지] White, Luise / 2000 / Telling More: Lies, Secrets, and History / History and Theory 39 (4) : 11 ~ 22

  50. [학술지] 유미나 / 2011 / 深河戰鬪의 名將 金應河와 "忠烈錄" 판화 / 열린정신 인문학 연구 12 (1) : 97 ~ 147

  51. [단행본] Yun Yusuk / 2016 / Kŭnse Cho-Il kwan’gye wa Ullŭngdo [Ullŭngdo and early modern relations between Chosŏn and Japan ] / Hyean