초록

The descendants of Ming loyalists who had migrated to Chosŏn with Prince Pongnim in 1645 were an integral part of the Ming loyalist ideology advocated by the Chosŏn court during the eighteenth century. The significance of their presence in Chosŏn, however, waned with the weakening of this ideology and the rise of Northern Learning in the nineteenth century. Under these adverse circumstances, the Ming loyalist families in the early nineteenth century employed various strategies to re-emphasize Ming loyalism and consolidate their Ming loyalist identity; an initiative they viewed as critical in justifying their presence in Chosŏn society. This article traces the variety of these identity-reinforcing efforts by the Ming loyalist families, ranging from shrine-building and compilation efforts to intermarriage. It focuses on the ritual structures built in Chojong’am by these descendants and analyzes how the symbols of Ming loyalism embedded in this place by the Chosŏn literati in the seventeenth century were manipulated by Ming descendants in the early nineteenth century. Through these initiatives, the descendants asserted a new version of Ming loyalism that not only potentially undermined the claims of the Chosŏn court/literati to be the inheritors of Ming culture but strengthened the symbolic significance of the Ming loyalist families. This study illuminates this implicit tension and disjuncture between the positions of the two parties, which is significant for understanding developments, rather than seeing the Ming loyalists’ activities as an outcome of ongoing cooperative interactions between the Chosŏn court and the Ming families nourished during the eighteenth century.

키워드

Ming loyalism, Chojong’am, Taet’ong haengmyo, Ming loyalist families, Chosŏn Korea

참고문헌(64)open

  1. [단행본] / 1985 / Chonju hwip’yŏn [Collected texts on honoring the Zhou] / Yŏgang ch’ulp’ansa

  2. [인터넷자료] / Chosŏn wangjo sillok 朝鮮王朝實錄 [Veritable records of the Chosŏn dynasty]

  3. [기타] / 1998 / Hwangmyŏng yumin Chenam Wangssi chokpo 皇明遺民濟南王氏族譜 [Genealogy of the Chenam Wang family, loyalist subjects of the August Ming] / Hwangmyŏng yumin Chenam Wangssi taejongjunghoe

  4. [단행본] Kim Chonghu / 1999 / Han’guk munjip ch’onggan Vol. 237 / Minjok munhwa ch’ujinhoe

  5. [단행본] Kim P’yŏngmuk / 2003 / Han’guk munjip ch’onggan Vol. 320 / Minjok munhwa ch’ujinhoe

  6. [단행본] Kim Yŏngnok / 1878 / Chojong’am chi [Records of Chojong’am] / Kyujanggak Institute for Korean Studies

  7. [기타] / 1981 / Nangya Chŏngssi chokpo 瑯琊鄭氏族譜 [Genealogy of the Nangya Chŏng family] / Held at the Taet’ongmyo, Kap’yŏng County, Kyŏnggi Province

  8. [인터넷자료] P’ung Hakcho / Hwangdan ch’amban yusin chegarok [Records of the families of the Ming loyalist ministers attending the rituals at Taebodan]

  9. [단행본] P’ung Hakcho / 1828 / Hwangjo yumin segye wŏllyubo [Genealogy of the loyalist subjects of the August Dynasty] / Academy of Korean Studies

  10. [인터넷자료] P’ung Hŏnjo / Sangsaenggong nyŏnbo [A chronicle of our licentiate ancestor]

  11. [단행본] P’ung Yŏngsŏp / 1973 / Imgu P’ungssi chokpo 臨胊馮氏族譜 [Genealogy of the Imgu P’ungs] / Tongmunsa

  12. [단행본] P’ung Yŏngsŏp / 1977 / Chojong’am munhŏllok [Collection of literature related to Chojong’am] / Chojong’am chaegŏnch’ujinhoe

  13. [단행본] Song Naehŭi / 1994 / Han’guk yŏktae munjip ch’ongsŏ Vol. 763 / Kyŏngin munhwasa

  14. [단행본] Song Siyŏl / 1993 / Han’guk munjip ch’onggan Vols. 108–116 / Minjok munhwa ch’ujinhoe

  15. [단행본] Sŏng Haeŭng / 2001 / Han’guk munjip ch’onggan Vol. 276 / Minjok munhwa ch’ujinhoe

  16. [인터넷자료] / Sŭngjŏngwŏn ilgi 承政院日記 [Daily records of the Royal Secretariat]

  17. [단행본] / 1704 / Taebodansa yŏnsŏl 大報壇事筵說 [Discussions of matters concerning Taebodan during royal lectures] / Kyujanggak Institute for Korean Studies

  18. [단행본] Wang Tŏgil / 1822 / Sangsaenggong nyŏnbo [A chronicle of our licentiate ancestor] / Kyujanggak Institute for Korean Studies

  19. [단행본] Wang Tŏgil / 1873 / Panch’ŏn yugo 盤川遺稿 [Remaining manuscripts of Wang Tŏgil] / Kyujanggak Institute for Korean Studies

  20. [단행본] Wang Tŏkku / 1818 / Hwangjo yuminrok [Records of the loyalist subjects of the August Dynasty] / Kyujanggak Institute for Korean Studies

  21. [단행본] Wang Tŏkku / 1888 / Ch’anghaejip 滄海集 [Literary collection of Wang Tŏkku] / Kyujanggak Institute for Korean Studies

  22. [단행본] Yu Chunggyo / 2004 / Han’guk munjip ch’onggan Vol. 324 / Minjok munhwa ch’ujinhoe

  23. [단행본] Yun Haengim / 2002 / Han’guk munjip ch’onggan Vol. 287 / Minjok munhwa ch’ujinhoe

  24. [학술지] DON BAKER / 2010 / PRACTICAL ETHICS AND PRACTICAL LEARNING: TASAN’S APPROACH TO MORAL CULTIVATION / Acta Koreana 13 (2) : 47 ~ 61

  25. [학위논문] Bohnet, Adam / 2008 / Migrant and Border Subjects in Late Chosŏn Korea

  26. [학술지] Bohnet, Adam / 2011 / Ruling Ideology and Marginal Subjects: Ming Loyalism and Foreign Lineages in Late Chosŏn Korea / Journal of Early Modern History 15 : 477 ~ 505

  27. [학술지] Adam Clarence Bohnet / 2012 / From Liaodongese Refugee to Ming Loyalist: The Historiography of the Sanggok Ma, a Ming Migrant Descent Group in Late Joseon Korea / The Review of Korean Studies 15 (1) : 109 ~ 139

  28. [학술지] 조성산 / 2009 / 18세기 후반～19세기 전반 對淸認識의 변화와 새로운 中華 관념의 형성 / 한국사연구 (145) : 67 ~ 113

  29. [학술지] Chŏn Yongu / 1990 / Hwayang sŏwŏn kwa Mandongmyo e taehan ilyŏn’gu[A study of the Hwayang Academy and Mandongmyo] / Hosŏ sahak 18 : 135 ~ 176

  30. [단행본] Chŏng Okcha / 1998 / Chosŏn hugi Chosŏn Chunghwa sasang yŏn’gu [A study of Chosŏn’s Chunghwa ideology in the late Chosŏn period] / Ilchisa

  31. [학술지] Duncan, John B. / 2000 / Hyanghwain: Migration and Assimilation in Chosŏn Korea / Acta Koreana 3 : 99 ~ 113

  32. [단행본] Haboush, Jahyun Kim / 1988 / The Confucian Kingship in Korea: Yŏngjo and the Politics of Sagacity / Columbia University Press

  33. [단행본] Haboush, Jahyun Kim / 1999 / Culture and the State in Late Chosŏn Korea / Harvard University Asia Center : 46 ~ 90

  34. [단행본] Haboush, Jahyun Kim / 2005 / Time, Temporality, and Imperial Transition / University of Hawai‘i Press : 115 ~ 141

  35. [학술지] 한경구 / 2007 / The Archaeology of the Ethnically Homogeneous Nation-State and Multiculturalism in Korea / Korea Journal 47 (4) : 8 ~ 32

  36. [단행본] Han Myung-gi / 2015 / The East Asian War, 1592–1598: International Relations, Violence, and Memory / Routledge : 277 ~ 293

  37. [학술지] 김호 / 2003 / 英祖의 大報壇 증수와 明 三皇의 享社 / 한국문화 (32) : 181 ~ 215

  38. [단행본] Kim Kŏnt’ae / 2016 / Han’guk yŏksa in’guhak yŏn’gu ŭi kanŭngsŏng / Sŏnggyun’gwan taehakkyo ch’ulp’anbu : 171 ~ 199

  39. [학술지] 김대식 / 2016 / 고종대 만동묘(萬東廟)와 서원(書院) 훼철 논의의 전개 / 교육사상연구 30 (1) : 47 ~ 72

  40. [학술지] 김두헌 / 2010 / 『姓源錄』을 통해서 본 서울 중인 가계 연구 - 중인 가계의 유형과 규모 및 정체성 - / 서울학연구 (39) : 41 ~ 77

  41. [학술지] Kye Sŭngbŏm / 2004 / The Posthumous Image and Role of Ming Taizu in Korean Politics / Ming Studies 50 : 107 ~ 130

  42. [단행본] Kye Sŭngbŏm / 2011 / Chŏngji toen sigan: Chosŏn ŭi Taebodan kwa kŭndae ŭi munt’ŏk [Suspended time: Chosŏn’s Taebodan and the threshold of modernity] / Sŏgang taehakkyo ch’ulp’anbu

  43. [학술지] Liu Ranran / 2010 / Mingmo fu Chao Shandong yimin Zheng Xianjia ji qihouyi yanjiu[A study of Chŏng Sŏngap from Shandong who migrated to Chosŏn in the late Ming and his progeny] / Jinan xuebao (Zhexue shehui kexueban) 3 : 228 ~ 233

  44. [학술지] Mason, David A. / 1991 / The Sam Hwangje Paehyang (Sacrificial Ceremony for Three Emperors): Korea’s Link to the Ming Dynasty / Korea Journal 31 (3) : 117 ~ 136

  45. [학술지] 노혜경 / 2009 / 英祖代 皇朝人 대한 인식 / 동양고전연구 (37) : 127 ~ 159

  46. [학술지] No Taehwan / 1994 / 19 segi chŏnban chisigin ŭi tae Ch’ŏng wigi insik kwa pukhangnon[Intellectuals’ perceptions of the crises in the Qing during the first half of the nineteenth century and Northern Learning] / Han’guk hakpo 20 (3) : 23 ~ 51

  47. [학술지] O Yŏngsŏp / 1994 / Wijŏng ch’ŏksa ŭi sangjingmul Chojong’am[Chojong’am, the symbol of “Defend orthodoxy, reject heterodoxy” thought] / T’aedong kojŏn yŏn’gu 11 : 61 ~ 99

  48. [단행본] Pak Hŭibyŏng / 2013 / Pŏm’ae wa p’yŏngdŭng: Hong Taeyong ŭi sahoe sasang [Universal love and equality: The social thought of Hong Taeyong] / Tolbegae

  49. [단행본] Park, Eugene Y. / 2014 / A Family of No Prominence: The Descendants of Pak Tŏkhwa and the Birth of Modern Korea / Stanford University Press

  50. [학술지] Park Saeyoung / 2014 / Memory, Counternarrative, and the Body Politic in Post-Imjin War Chosŏn Korea / Journal of Korean Studies 19 (1) : 153 ~ 178

  51. [학술지] 노영구 / 2004 / Yi Sun-shin, an Admiral Who Became a Myth / The Review of Korean Studies 7 (3) : 15 ~ 36

  52. [학술지] Pierre-Emmanuel Roux / 2016 / THE CATHOLIC EXPERIENCE OF CHOSŎN ENVOYS IN BEIJING: A CONTACT ZONE AND THE CIRCULATION OF RELIGIOUS KNOWLEDGE IN THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY / Acta Koreana 19 (1) : 9 ~ 44

  53. [학술지] 석소영 / 2013 / 论朝鲜士林与朝宗岩思明文化的关系 / 한중인문학연구 (41) : 307 ~ 332

  54. [단행본] Strassberg, Richard E. / 1994 / Inscribed Landscapes: Travel Writings from Imperial China / University of California Press

  55. [단행본] Sun Weiguo / 2007 / Daming qihao yu xiaozhonghua yishi: Chaoxian wangchao zunzhou sixiang wenti yanjjiu (1637–1800) [Banner of the Great Ming and the Small-China Consciousness: A study of Chosŏn’s ideology of honoring the Zhou] / Shangwu yinshuguan

  56. [단행본] U Kyŏngsŏp / 2013 / Chosŏn Chunghwa chuŭi ŭi sŏngnip kwa Tong Asia [Formation of Chosŏn Chunghwa ideology and East Asia] / Yunisŭt’ori

  57. [학술지] 우경섭 / 2013 / 조선후기 지식인들의 南明王朝 인식 / 한국문화 (61) : 133 ~ 155

  58. [학술지] 우경섭 / 2015 / 조선후기 大明遺民의 罔僕之義 -濟南 王氏 가문의 사례- / 한국학연구 (36) : 179 ~ 206

  59. [학술지] Walraven, Boudewijn / 2000 / Religion and the City: Seoul in the Nineteenth Century / The Review of Korean Studies 3 (1) : 178 ~ 206

  60. [단행본] Yi Kŭnho / 2003 / Chosŏn sidae ŭi chŏngch’i wa chedo, edited by Chŏng Manjo / Chimmundang : 471 ~ 492

  61. [학술지] 이남희 / 2010 / 조선 후기 醫科八世譜의 자료적 특성과 의미 — 현전 자료와 그 수록 년대를 중심으로 — / 조선시대사학보 (52) : 231 ~ 262

  62. [학술지] 이욱 / 2006 / 조선후기 전쟁의 기억과 대보단(大報壇) 제향 / 종교연구 42 : 127 ~ 163

  63. [학술지] 이완우 / 2007 / 華陽洞과 尤庵事蹟 / 藏書閣 (18) : 89 ~ 162

  64. [단행본] Yu Ponghak / 1995 / Yŏn’am ilp’a pukhak sasang yŏn’gu [A study of the Northern Learning thought of Pak Chiwŏn and his close associates] / Ilchisa