초록

Originally, East Asian intellectuals focused their attention on the philosophy of the Confucian Classics, rarely commenting on their literary aspects. During the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, however, there were three exegetical works that proposed a different approach to the Mengzi: Maengja ch’aŭi (Notes on the meanings of the Mengzi) written by Wi Paekkyu (1727–1798), a Chosŏn scholar, Mengzi lunwen written by Niu Yunzhen (1706–1758) from China, and Doku Mōshi written by Hirose Tansō (1782–1856) in Japan. These exegeses approached the Mengzi through its literary style, and commented on many literary points: rhetorical strategy, grammar, and wording. In this article, these exegetical works are referred to as “rhetorical commentaries” since they emphasized rhetoric to a much greater extent than previous commentaries. The purpose of this article is to show how the rhetorical commentaries are different from ordinary or standard commentaries, such as the works of Zhu Xi and Jiao Xun, but also to point out some differences among the three rhetorical commentaries. In addition, this study evaluates the significance of the appearance in East Asia of rhetorical commentaries in the seventeenth to nineteenth centuries. This will be done by placing them in the context of elevant historical events and changes in literati culture from the middle ages to the early-modern period of East Asia. Thus, this article will be a first step towards an understanding of rhetorically oriented exegeses in East Asia and the relationship between these commentaries, their historical change and their intellectual history.

키워드

East Asia, the Confucian Classics, rhetorical commentaries, Mengzi, exegesis

참고문헌(56)open

  1. [단행본] Hirose Tansō / 1927 / Hirose zenshū (Completed works of Hirose) / Hitagun kyōikukai

  2. [단행본] Hong Sŏkchu / 1984 / Yŏnch’ŏn chŏnsŏ (Completed works of Yŏnch’ŏn) / Osŏngsa

  3. [단행본] Jiao Xun / 1996 / Mengzi zhengyi (Correct meaning of the Mengzi), Vols. 1–2 / Zhonghua shuju

  4. [단행본] Kim Ch’anghyŏp / 1996 / Han’guk munjip ch’onggan (Comprehensive publication of Sino-Korean literary collections in Sino-Korean), Vol. 162 / Minjok munhwa ch’ujinhoe

  5. [단행본] Kong Yingda / 1993 / In Shisanjing zhushu(Thirteen Classics) / Shanghai guji chubanshe

  6. [단행본] Legge, James / 1960 / The Chinese Classics, Vol. 2 / Hong Kong University Press

  7. [단행본] Legge, James / 2015 / The I Ching / Dover Publications

  8. [단행본] Li Zhi / 1995 / Sishu ping (Evaluating the Four Books) / Shanghai guji chubanshe

  9. [기타] Niu Yunzhen / 1803 / Mengzi lunwen (A literary analysis of the Mengzi) / Kongsantang wenji (Collected works of Kongsantang)

  10. [단행본] Niu Yunzhen / 2001 / Shiji pingzhu (Notes and comments on the Record of the Great Historian) / Sanqin chubanshe

  11. [단행본] Ogyū Sorai / 1994 / Rongo chō (Evidence to the Analects) / Heibonsha

  12. [단행본] Wi Paekkyu / 2000 / Han’guk munjip ch’onggan (Comprehensive publication of Sino-Korean literary collections), Vol. 243 / Minjok munwa ch’ujinhoe

  13. [단행본] Wi Paekkyu / 1974 / Chonjae chŏnsŏ (Completed works of Chonjae), Vols. 1–2 / Kyŏngin ch’ulp’ansa

  14. [단행본] Yang Qiyuan / 1620 / Sishu yan (Looking into the Four Books) / Guoli bianyiguan

  15. [단행본] Zhu Xi / 1983 / Sishu zhangju jizhu (Interlinear analysis of and collected commentaries on the Four Books) / Zhonghua shuju

  16. [단행본] Bol, Peter K. / 1994 / This Culture of Ours: Intellectual Transitions in T’ang and Sung China / Stanford University Press

  17. [단행본] Chang Kangisun / 2010 / The Cambridge History of Chinese Literature, vol. 2 / Cambridge University Press

  18. [단행본] Chow, Kaiwing / 1994 / The Rise of Confucian Ritualism in Late Imperial China: Ethics, Classics, and Lineage Discourse / Stanford University Press

  19. [학술지] Chow, Kaiwing / 1996 / Writing for Success: Printing, Examinations, and Intellectual Change in Late Ming China / Late Imperial China 17 : 120 ~ 157

  20. [학술지] 정우봉 / 2006 / 한국 수사학사에 있어 ‘修辭’ 담론과 그 맥락 / 민족문화연구 (45) : 109 ~ 132

  21. [단행본] Denecke, Wiebke / 2010 / The Dynamics of Masters Literature: Early Chinese Thought from Confucius to Han Feizi / Harvard University Press

  22. [단행본] Dong Hongli / 1997 / Mengzi yanjiu (Studies of the Mengzi) / Jiangsu guji chubanshe

  23. [단행본] Elman, Benjamin A. / 2001 / From Philosophy to Philology / UCLA Asian Pacific Monograph Series

  24. [학술지] Elman, Benjamin A. / 1991 / Political, Social, and Cultural Reproduction via Civil Service Examinations in Late Imperial China / Journal of Asian Studies 50 : 7 ~ 28

  25. [단행본] Guo Xiliang / 2010 / Hanzi guyin shouce (Handbook of ancient pronunciations of Chinese characters) / Beijing daxue chubanshe

  26. [학술지] Hou Jiangbo / 2014 / Niu Yunzhen xueshu yuanyuan kaoshu (An analytical description of Niu Yunzhen’s academic origin) / Dezhou xueyan xuebao 30 : 7 ~ 9

  27. [단행본] Im Chong’uk / 2010 / Chungguk yŏktae inmyŏng sajŏn (Biographical dictionary of China through the ages) / Ihoe munwasa

  28. [학술지] Indraccolo, Lisa / 2014 / What is Rhetoric Anyway? Briared in Words in Early China / Asiatische Studien 68 (1) : 331 ~ 341

  29. [학위논문] Jing Dongyan / 2007 / Niu Yunzhen zhuanlue (A biographical sketch of Niu Yunzhen)

  30. [단행본] Kim Sŏkhoe / 1995 / Chonjae Wi Paekkyu munhak yŏn’gu (A study of Chonjae Wi Paekkyu’s literary works) / Ihoe munwasa

  31. [단행본] Kim Sŏngjung / 2002 / Sinjin munch’ŏl (Literature and philosophy of new scholars) / Wŏrin : 215 ~ 232

  32. [학술대회] Kim Hŏn [Kim Heon] / 2004 / Reto’rik’e nŭn susahak in’ga? (Is the concept of rhêtorikê same with the concept of susahak?) / Han’guk susa hakhoe haksul taehoe 5 : 1 ~ 11

  33. [단행본] Koyasu Nobukuni / 2001 / Nihon shisōshi jiten (Dictionary of Japanese intellectual history) / Perikansha

  34. [단행본] Li Changran / 2011 / Qingdai Mengzi xueshi dagang (Outline of the history of Mengzi studies in the Qing dynasty) / Beijing daxue chubanshe

  35. [단행본] Li, Waiyee / 2007 / The Readability of the Past in Early Chinese Historiography / Harvard University Press

  36. [단행본] Lipson, Carol S. / 2004 / Rhetoric Before and Beyond the Greeks / SUNY Press

  37. [단행본] Lu, Xing / 1998 / Rhetoric in Ancient China, Fifth to Third Century, B.C.E.: A Comparison with Classical Greek Rhetoric / University of South Carolina Press

  38. [단행본] Mair, Victor H. / 2012 / The Columbia History of Chinese Literature / Columbia University Press

  39. [단행본] Maruyama Masao / 1958 / Nihon seiji shisōshi kenkyū (Studies in the intellectual history of Tokugawa Japan) / Tōkyō daigaku shuppankai

  40. [학술지] Misawa Katsumi / 1986 / Hirose Tansō no gakutō to Doku Rongo (Hirose Tansō’s academic lineage and his book Doku Rongo [Reading the Analects]) / Kokushigaku 129 : 26 ~ 51

  41. [학위논문] Ren Xiaoyang / 2002 / Mengzi lunwen yanjiu (A study of Mengzi lunwen [A literary analysis of the Mengzi])

  42. [기타] Sejong taewang kinyŏ m saŏ phoe / 2001 / Han’guk kojŏn yongŏ sajŏn (Dictionary of terms in Korean classics) / Sejong taewang kinyŏ m saŏ phoe

  43. [단행본] Seki Kiyichirō / 1925 / Sisho chūsaku zensho (Collections of commentaries by Japanese scholars on the Four Books). Vol. 8 / Bunken shokyoku

  44. [단행본] Song Hyŏkki / 2007 / Chosŏn hugi hanmun sanmun ŭi iron kwa pip’yŏng (Theory and criticism of late–Chosŏn sinographic prose) / Wŏrin

  45. [단행본] Tanaka Kayo / 1993 / Hirose Tansō no kenkyū(A biographical study of Hirose Tansō) / Perikansha

  46. [단행본] Usui Katsumi / 2001 / Nihon kingendai jinmei jiten (Biographical dictionary of modern and contemporary Japanese) / Yoshikawa kōbunkan

  47. [단행본] Van Zoeren, Steven / 2007 / Poetry and Personality: Reading, Exegesis, and Hermeneutics in Traditional China / Stanford University Press

  48. [학술지] Wang Jianjun / 2014 / Niu Yunzhen Mengzi lunwen tanxi (In-depth analysis of Niu Yunzhen’s A literary analysis of the Mengzi) / Yangzhou daxue xuebao 18 : 73 ~ 81

  49. [단행본] Wang Li / 2002 / Hanyu shiluxue (Prosody of Chinese) / Shanghai shiji chuban jituan

  50. [학술지] Weber, Ralph / 2014 / On Comparative Approaches to Rhetoric in Ancient China / Asiatische Studien 68 (4) : 925 ~ 935

  51. [단행본] Xinzhong, Yao / 2003 / RoutledgeCurzon Encyclopedia of Confucianism. Vol. 2 / Routledge Curzon

  52. [학술지] Yan Shiju / 2000 / Niu Yunzhen he tade xuexu sixiang ji chubanye (Niu Yunzhen’s academic thought and his contribution to the publishing business) / Sandong tushuguan jikan 3 : 53 ~ 54

  53. [학위논문] Yi Haejun / 1979 / Chonjae Wi Paekkyu ŭi sahoe kaesŏllon (Chonjae Wi Paekkyu’s meliorism)

  54. [학술지] 이영호 / 2008 / 이탁오의 논어학과 명말 새로운 경학의 등장 / 한국학 31 (4) : 301 ~ 326

  55. [단행본] Yoshikawa Kōjirō / 2001 / Jinsai, Sorai, Norinaga (Three classical philologists of mid-Tokugawa Japan) / Iwanami shoten

  56. [학술지] 유민정 / 2018 / 위백규의 수사학적 경전해석 - 孟子箚義를 중심으로 / 퇴계학보 (143) : 137 ~ 175