Abstract
Rock and ice climbing are widely considered to be ‘high-risk’ sporting activities that are associated with a high incidence of severe injury and even death, compared with more mainstream sports. However, objective scientific data to support this perception are questionable. Accordingly, >400 sport-specific injury studies were analysed and compared by quantifying the injury incidence and objectively grading the injury severity (using the National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics score) per 1000 hours of sporting participation. Fatalities were also analysed. The analysis revealed that fatalities occurred in all sports, but it was not always clear whether the sport itself or pre-existing health conditions contributed or caused the deaths. Bouldering (ropeless climbing to low heights), sport climbing (mostly bolt protected lead climbing with little objective danger) and indoor climbing (climbing indoors on artificial rock structures), showed a small injury rate, minor injury severity and few fatalities. As more objective/external dangers exist for alpine and ice climbing, the injury rate, injury severity and fatality were all higher. Overall, climbing sports had a lower injury incidence and severity score than many popular sports, including basketball, sailing or soccer; indoor climbing ranked the lowest in terms of injuries of all sports assessed. Nevertheless, a fatality risk remains, especially in alpine and ice climbing. In the absence of a standard definition for a ‘high-risk’ sport, categorizing climbing as a high-risk sport was found to be either subjective or dependent on the definition used. In conclusion, this analysis showed that retrospective data on sport-specific injuries and fatalities are not reported in a standardized manner. To improve preventative injury measures for climbing sports, it is recommended that a standardized, robust and comprehensive sport-specific scoring model should be developed to report and fully evaluate the injury risk, severity of injuries and fatality risk in climbing sports.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Schöffl V, Schöffl I, Schwarz U, et al. Injury-risk evaluation in water ice climbing. Med Sport 2009; 2 (1-2): E32–8
Union International des Associations d’Alpinisme 2008 [online]. Available from URL: http://ww.uiaa.ch [Accessed2009 Jan 5]
International Federation of Sport Climbing [online]. Available from URL: http://www.ifsc-climbing.org [Accessed2009 Jan 5]
Hochholzer T, Schöffl V. One move too many. 2nd ed. Ebenhausen: Lochner Verlag, 2006
Schöffl V, Küpper T. Injuries at the 2005 World Championships in rock climbing. Wilderness Environ Med 2006; 17: 187–90
Morrison AB, Schoffl VR. Review of the physiological responses to rock climbing in young climbers. Br J Sports Med 2007; 41 (12): 852–61
The British Mountaineering Council 2009 [online]. Available from URL: http://www.thebmc.co.uk [Accessed 2009 Jan 5]
Schöffl V, Winkelmann HP. Accident statistics at ‘indoor climbing walls’ [in German]. Sportverletz Sportschaden 1999 Mar; 13 (1): 14–6
Schöffl VR, Harrer J, Kupper T. Biceps tendon ruptures in rock climbers. Clin J Sport Med 2006 Sep; 16 (5): 426–7
Wright DM, Royle TJ, Marshall T. Indoor rock climbing: who gets injured? Br J Sports Med 2001 Jun; 35 (3): 181–5
Schöffl V, Kupper T. Rope tangling injuries: how should a climber fall? Wilderness Environ Med 2008 Summer; 19 (2): 146–9
Smith LO. Alpine climbing: injuries and illness. Phys Med Rehabil Clin N Am 2006 Aug; 17 (3): 633–44
Schöffl VR, Hochholzer T, Imhoff AB, et al. Radiographic adaptations to the stress of high-level rock climbing injunior athletes: a 5-year longitudinal study of the Germanjunior national team and a group of recreational climbers. Am J Sports Med 2007 Jan; 35 (1): 86–92
Schöffl V, Hochholzer T, Imhoff A. Radiographic changes in the hands and fingers of young, high-level climbers. AmJ Sports Med 2004 Oct; 32 (7): 1688–94
Schöffl V, Hochholzer T, Winkelmann HP, et al. Pulley injuries in rock climbers. Wilderness Environ Med 2003 Summer; 14 (2): 94–100
Gerdes EM, Hafner JW, Aldag JC. Injury patterns and safety practices of rock climbers. J Trauma 2006 Dec; 61 (6): 1517–25
Rooks MD. Rock climbing injuries. Sports Med 1997 Apr; 23 (4): 261–70
Rooks MD, Johnston 3rd RB, Ensor CD, et al. Injury patterns in recreational rock climbers. Am J Sports Med 1995 Nov-Dec; 23 (6): 683–5
Paige TE, Fiore DC, Houston JD. Injury in traditional and sport rock climbing. Wilderness Environ Med 1998; 9 (1): 2–7
Schussmann LC, Lutz LJ, Shaw RR, et al. The epidemiology of mountaineering and rock climbing accidents. Wilderness Environ Med 1990; 1: 235–48
Bowie WS, Hunt TK, Allen Jr HA. Rock-climbing injuries in Yosemite National Park. West J Med 1988 Aug; 149 (2): 172–7
Addiss DG, Baker SP. Mountaineering and rock-climbing injuries in US national parks. Ann Emerg Med 1989 Sep; 18 (9): 975–9
Limb D. Injuries on British climbing walls. Br J Sports Med 1995 Sep; 29 (3): 168–70
Bannister P, Foster P. Upper limb injuries associated with rock climbing [abstract]. Br J Sports Med 1986 Jun; 20 (2): 55
Haas JC, Meyers MC. Rock climbing injuries. Sports Med 1995 Sep; 20 (3): 199–205
Jebson JL, Steyers CM. Hand injuries in rock climbing: reaching the right treatment. Physician Sportsmed 1997; 25 (5): 1–7
Killian RB, Nishimoto GS, Page JC. Foot and ankle injuries related to rock climbing: the role of footwear. J Am Podiatr Med Assoc 1998 Aug; 88 (8): 365–74
Largiader U, Oelz O. An analysis of overstrain injuries in rock climbing. Schweiz Z Sportmed 1993 Sep; 41 (3): 107–14
Logan AJ, Makwana N, Mason G, et al. Acute hand and wrist injuries in experienced rock climbers. Br J Sports Med 2004 Oct; 38 (5): 545–8
Rane A, Leal C. Injuries in sport climbing. In: Dubas F, Valloton J, editors. A colour atlas of mountain medicine. London: Wolfe Publishing, 1991: 176–82
Rohrbough JT, Mudge MK, Schilling RC. Overuse injuries in the elite rock climber. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2000 Aug; 32 (8): 1369–72
Schafer J, Gaulrapp H, Pforringer W. Acute and chronicoveruse injuries in extreme sport-climbing. Sportverletz Sportschaden 1998 Mar; 12 (1): 21–5
Wyatt JP, McNaughton GW, Grant PT. A prospective study of rock climbing injuries. Br J Sports Med 1996 Jun; 30 (2): 148–50
Pfeifer C, Messner K, Scherer R, et al. Injury pattern and overuse stress syndrome in young sport climbers. Wien Klin Wochenschr 2000 Nov 24; 112 (22): 965–72
Holtzhausen LM, Noakes TD. Elbow, forearm, wrist, and hand injuries among sport rock climbers. Clin J Sport Med 1996 Jul; 6 (3): 196–203
Stelzle FD, Gaulrapp H, Pforringer W. Injuries and overuse syndromes due to rock climbing on artificial walls. Sportverletz Sportschaden 2000 Dec; 14 (4): 128–33
Hochholzer T, Schöffl VR. Epiphyseal fractures of the finger middle joints in young sport climbers. Wilderness Environ Med 2005 Fall; 16 (3): 139–42
Schöffl V, Hochholzer T, Winkelmann HP, et al. Differential diagnosis of finger pain in sport climbers [inGerman]. D Z Sportmed 2003; 54: 38–43
Schöffl VR, Schoffl I. Finger pain in rock climbers: reaching the right differential diagnosis and therapy. J Sports Med Phys Fitness 2007 Mar; 47 (1): 70–8
Taro K, Dowell W, Rawe J, et al. Why we take risks. Time Magazine (US ed.) 1999 Sep; 6: 1–6
Greenfeld KT, Dowell W, Rawe J, et al. Life on the edge. Time Magazine (US ed) 1999 Sep; 6: 1–7
UK Health and Safety Executive 2009 [online]. Available from URL: http://www.hse.gov.uk/education/statistics.htm [Accessed 2009 Feb 7]
Valuri G, Stevenson M, Finch C, et al. The validity of a four week self-recall of sports injuries. Injury Prev 2005; 11: 135–7
Veldman A, Fischer D, Brand J, et al. Proposal for a new scoring system in international interhospital air transport. J Travel Med 2001; 8: 154–7
Mosimann U. Notfälle beim Eisklettern. Bergundsteigen 2006; 1 (4): 70–3
Bein T. Scores-Hilfsmittel zur Risikoeinschätzung. In: Madler C, Jauch K, Werdan K, et al., editors. Das NAW Buch: Akutmedizin der ersten 24 Stunden. 3rd ed. München, Jena: Elvesier, Urban & Fischer, 2005: 193–9
öGAN. Scoring systeme im rettungsdienst 2008 [online]. Available from URL: http://www.oegan.at [Accessed2008 Jan 8]
Schöffl V, Klee S, Strecker W. Evaluation of physiological standard pressures of the forearm flexor muscles duringsport specific ergometry in sport climbers. Br J Sports Med 2004 Aug; 38 (4): 422–5
Jakus PM, Shaw WD. An empirical analysis of rock climbers’ response to hazard warnings. Risk Anal 1996 Aug; 16 (4): 581–6
DAV. Bergunfallstatistik 2004–2005. München: German Alpine Club, 2006
Josephsen G, Shinneman S, Tamayo-Sarver J, et al. Injuries in bouldering: a prospective study. Wilderness Environ Med 2007 Winter; 18 (4): 271–80
Jones G, Asghar A, Llewellyn DJ. The epidemiology of rock climbing injuries. Br J Sports Med 2007; 42: 773–8
Nelson NG, McKenzie LB. Rock climbing injuries treated in emergency departments in the US, 1990-2007. Am JPrev Med 2009 Sep; 37 (3): 195–200
American Alpine Club. Accidents in North American mountaineering [letter]. Am Alpine Club 2006; 9 (1): 59
Canadian Alpine Club. Accidents in North American mountaineering: Canadian Alpine Club, 2005. Available from URL: http://www.alpineclub-edm.org/accidents/type.asp?type=Ice+Climbing [Accessed 2007 Dec 30]
Malcom M. Mountaineering fatalities in Mt Cook National Park. N Z Med J 2001; 114 (1127): 78–80
Stephens BD, Diekema DS, Klein EJ. Recreational injuries in Washington State National Parks. Wilderness Environ Med 2005; 16 (4): 192–7
Monasterio ME. Accident and fatality characteristics in a population of mountain climbers in New Zealand [abstract]. N Z Med J 2005 Jan 28; 118 (1208): U1249
Firth PG, Zheng H, Windsor JS, et al. Mortality on Mount Everest, 1921-2006: descriptive study [abstract]. BMJ 2008; 337: a2654
Hearns ST, Fraser MH, Allan DB, et al. Spinal injuries in Scottish mountaineers. Wilderness Environ Med 2006 Fall; 17 (3): 191–4
McIntosh SE, Leemon D, Visitacion J, et al. Medical incidents and evacuations on wilderness expeditions. Wilderness Environ Med 2007; 18: 298–304
McIntosh SE, Campbell AD, Dow J, et al. Mountaineering fatalities on Denali. High Alt Med Biol 2008 Spring; 9 (1): 89–95
McLennan JG, Ungersma J. Mountaineering accidents in the Sierra Nevada. Am J Sports Med 1982; 11: 160–3
Schöffl V. Sportklettern. In: Engelhardt M, editor. Sportverletzungen: Elsevier, Urban & Fischer, 2006: 455–60
Hochholzer T, Schöffl V. One move too many. Ebenhausen: Lochner Verlag, 2003
Carmeli E, Wertheim M. Handverletzungen bei jugendlichen und erwachsenen sportkletterern: hand injuriesin young and old wall climbers. Dtsch Z Sportmed 2001; 52 (10): 285–8
Bollen SR. Upper limb injuries in elite rock climbers. J R Coll Surg Edinb 1990 Dec; 35 (6 Suppl.): S18–20
Bollen SR. Injury to the A2 pulley in rock climbers. J Hand Surg [Br] 1990 May; 15 (2): 268–70
Bollen SR, Gunson CK. Hand injuries in competition climbers. Br J Sports Med 1990 Mar; 24 (1): 16–8
Kubiak EN, Klugman JA, Bosco JA. Hand injuries in rock climbers. Bull NYU Hosp Joint Dis 2006; 64 (3-4): 172–7
Schöffl V. Handverletzungen beim klettern: hand injuries in rock climbing. Dtsch Z Sportmed 2008; 59 (4): 85–90
Schöffl V, Schöffl I. Finger pain in rock climbers-reaching the right differential diagnosis. J Sports Med Phys Fitness 2007; 47 (1): 70–8
Schöffl V, Winkelmann HP. FuXdeformitäten bei sportkletterern: foot deformations in sportclimbers. Dtsch ZSportmed 1999; 50: 73–6
Watson DS, Mehan TJ, Smith GA, et al. Golf cart-related injuries in the US. Am J Prev Med 2008 Jul; 35 (1): 55–9
Ferris BG. Mountain-climbing accidents in the United States. N Engl J Med 1963; 268: 430–1
Hubicka E. Rock climbing injuries sustained at the training centre in Cesky Raj (author’s transl) [article in Czech]. Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech 1977 Feb; 44 (1): 78–82
Chitnavis JP, Gibbons CL, Hirigoyen M, et al. Accidentswith horses: what has changed in 20 years? Injury 1996 Mar; 27 (2): 103–5
Gabbett TJ. Incidence of injury in amateur rugby league sevens. Br J Sports Med 2002 Feb; 36 (1): 23–6
Gissane C, Jennings D, Kerr K, et al. Injury rates in rugby league football: impact of change in playing season. Am JSports Med 2003 Nov-Dec; 31 (6): 954–8
Molsa J, Kujala U, Nasman O, et al. Injury profile in ice hockey from the 1970s through the 1990s in Finland. AmJ Sports Med 2000 May-Jun; 28 (3): 322–7
Gabbett TJ. Incidence of injury in junior rugby league players over four competitive seasons. J Sci Med Sport 2008; 11 (3): 323–8
Wedderkopp N, Kaltoft M, Lundgaard B, et al. Prevention of injuries in young female players in European teamhandball: a prospective intervention study. Scand J Med Sci Sports 1999 Feb; 9 (1): 41–7
Ekstrand J, Walden M, Walden M. Risk for injury when playing in a national football team. Scand J Med Sci Sports 2004 Feb; 14 (1): 34–8
Tomida Y, Hirata H, Fukuda A, et al. Injuries in elite motorcycle racing in Japan. Br J Sports Med 2005 Aug; 39 (8): 508–11
Baltzer AW, Ghadamgahi PD. American football injuries in theGerman Federal League: risk of injuries and patternof injuries. Unfallchirurgie 1998 Apr; 24 (2): 60–5
Seil R, Rupp S, Tempelhof S, et al. Sports injuries in team handball: a one-year prospective study of sixteen men’ssenior teams of a superior nonprofessional level. Am JSports Med 1998 Sep-Oct; 26 (5): 681–7
Cumps ED, Verhagen E, Annemans L. Injury risk and socio- economic costs resulting from sports injuries in Flanders. Data derived from Sports Insurance Statistics 2003. Br J Sports Med 2007; 42 (9): 767–2
Neville VJ, Molloy J, Brooks JH, et al. Epidemiology of injuries and illnesses in America’s Cup yacht racing. Br JSports Med 2006 Apr; 40 (4): 304–11; discussion 11-2
Costa-Paz M, Aponte-Tinao L, Muscolo DL. Injuries to polo riders: a prospective evaluation. Br J Sports Med 1999 Oct; 33 (5): 329–31; discussion 31-2
Nickel C, Zernial O, Musahl V, et al. A prospective study of kitesurfing injuries. Am J Sports Med 2004; 32 (4): 921–7
Backx FJG, Beijer HJM, Bol E, et al. Injuries in high-risk persons and high-risk sports. Am J Sports Med 1991; 19: 124–30
Becker A. Verletzungen im FrauenfuXball. Homburg/Saar: Homburg, 2006
Burns J, Keenan A, Redmond A. Factors associated with traithlon-related overuse injuries. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther 2003; 33: 177–84
Zazryn T, Cameron P, McCrory P. A prospective cohort study of injury in amateur and professional boxing. Br JSports Med 2006 Aug; 40 (8): 670–4
Gaulrapp H, Weber A, Rosemeyer B. Injuries in mountain biking. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 2001; 9 (1): 48–53
Aschauer E, Ritter E, Resch H, et al. Injuries and injury risk in skiing and snowboarding. Unfallchirurg 2007 Apr; 110 (4): 301–6
Knobloch K, Vogt PM. Nordic pole walking injuries: nordic walking thumb as novel injury entity. Sportverletz Sportschaden 2006 Sep; 20 (3): 137–42
Dau I, Dingerkurs ML, Lorenz S. Verletzungsmuster beim wellenreiten: injury patterns in surfing. Dtsch Z Sportmed 2005; 56 (12): 410–4
Schindera ST, Triller J, Steinbach LS, et al. Spectrum of injuries from glacial sports. Wilderness Environ Med 2005 Spring; 16 (1): 33–7
Patterson R. On thin ice: a rather personal look at the hazards of winter climbing. CMAJ 1992 Mar 15; 146 (6): 1041–7
Berghold F. Sportmedizinische Aspekte desWanderns und Bergsteigens im Hochgebirge. Schweiz Z Sportmed 1982; 30: 5–12
Bunting CJ, Little MJ, Tolson H, et al. Physical fitness and eustress in the adventure activities of rock climbing andrappelling. J Sports Med Phys Fitness 1986 Mar; 26 (1): 11–20
Burdick TE, Brozen R. Wilderness event medicine. Wilderness Environ Med 2003 Winter; 14 (4): 236–9
Hartsock LA, Feagin Jr JA, Ogilvie BC. Climbing and the older athlete. Clin Sports Med 1991 Apr; 10 (2): 257–67
Huey RB, Eguskitza X. Limits to human performance: elevated risks on high mountains. J Exper Biol 2001 Sep; 204 (Pt18): 3115–9
Madorsky JG, Kiley DP. Wheelchair mountaineering. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1984 Aug; 65 (8): 490–2
Malcolm M. Mountaineering fatalities in Mt Cook National Park. N Z Med J 2001 Mar 9; 114 (1127): 78–80
Patscheider H. Morphologic findings in fatal mountainclimbing accidents. Schweiz Z Sportmed 1971; 19 (4): 7–27
Rettig A. Mountain climbing accidents: measures and problems in first aid. Osterr Schwesternztg 1973 Jul-Aug; 26 (8): 174–7
Townes DA. Wilderness medicine. Prim Care 2002 Dec; 29 (4): 1027–48
Wilson R, Mills Jr WJ, Rodgers DR, et al. Death on Denali. West J Med 1978 Jun; 128 (6): 471–6
Zafren K, Durrer B, Herry JP, et al. Lightning injuries: prevention and on-site treatment in mountains andremote areas: official guidelines of the International Commission for Mountain Emergency Medicine and the Medical Commission of the International Mountaineering and Climbing Federation (ICAR and UIAA MEDCOM). Resuscitation 2005 Jun; 65 (3): 369–72
Shlim DR, Houston R. Helicopter rescues and deaths among trekkers in Nepal. JAMA 1989; 261: 1017–9
Avery JG, Harper P, Ackroyd S. Do we pay too dearly for our sport and leisure activities? An investigation intofatalities as a result of sporting ane leisure activities inEngland and Wales. Public Health 1990; 104: 417–23
Pollard A, Clarke C. Deaths during mountaineering at extreme altitude [abstract]. Lancet 1988; I: 1277
Küpper T, Huber N, Netzer N, et al. Rehabilitation and recovery training after snowboard accidents. Med Sport 2009; 13 (1): 1–4
Wedderkopp N, Kaltoft M, Lundgaard B, et al. Injuries in young female players in European teamhandball. ScandJ Med Sci Sports 1997 Dec; 7 (6): 342–7
Renstrom P, Ljungqvist A, Arendt E, et al. Non-contact ACL injuries in female athletes: an International Olympic Committee current concepts statement. Br J Sports Med 2008 Jun; 42 (6): 394–412
Küpper T, Patig G, Hotz S, et al. Secondary prevention of accidents in school sports: does the teacher’s education fitwith the demands at school? Med Sport 2008; 12 (4): 155–9
Baltzer AW, Ghadamgahi PD, Granrath M, et al. American football injuries in Germany: first results from Bundesligafootball. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 1997; 5 (1): 46–9
Spinks AB, McClure RJ. Quantifying the risk of sports injury: a systematic review of activity-specific rates for childrenunder 16 years of age. Br J Sports Med 2007; 41: 548–57
Turk EE. Natural and traumatic sports-related fatalities. Br J Sports Med 2008; 42 (7): 604–8
Fuller CW, Ekstrand J, Junge A, et al. Consensus statement of injury definitions and data collection proceduresin studies of football (soccer) injuries. Scand J Med Sci Sports 2006; 16: 83–92
Meyers. Meyers Lexikon Online 2.0. 2008 [online]. Available from URL: http://www.lexikon.meyers.de/meyers/extremsport [Accessed 2008 Jan 16]
Kajtna T, Tusak M. Some psychological studies of high risk sports. Kinesiol Slovenica 2004; 10 (1): 96–105
Young CC. Extreme sports: injuries and medical coverage. Curr Sports Med Rep 2002 Oct; 1 (5): 306–11
Henke T, Glaser H. Die Risikobewertung der verschiedenen Sportarten-Epidemiologie von Sportverletzungen. In: Bergler R, editor. Irrationalität und Risiko Gesundheitliche Risikofaktoren und deren naturwissenschaftliche und psychologische Bewertung. Köln: Kölner Universitätsverlag, 2000: 300–18
Acknowledgements
No sources of funding were used to assist in the preparation of this review. The authors have no conflicts of interest that are directly relevant to the content of this review.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Schöffl, V., Morrison, A., Schwarz, U. et al. Evaluation of Injury and Fatality Risk in Rock and Ice Climbing. Sports Med 40, 657–679 (2010). https://doi.org/10.2165/11533690-000000000-00000
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2165/11533690-000000000-00000