책임 분야 개정방안

@article{ART001331068},
author={ 한상훈 and 천진호 },
title={책임 분야 개정방안},
journal={형사법연구},
issn={1598-0979},
year={2009},
volume={21},
number={1},
pages={79-114},
doi={10.21795/kcla.2009.21.1.79},
url={http://dx.doi.org/10.21795/kcla.2009.21.1.79}

TY - JOUR
AU - 한상훈
AU - 천진호
TI - 책임 분야 개정방안
T2 - 형사법연구
PY - 2009
VL - 21
IS - 1
PB - 한국형사법학회
SP - 79-114
SN - 1598-0979
AB - This paper suggests a bill to amend and reform the criminal responsibility provisions of the Criminal Act of Korea, and explains the purpose of the reform. This reform bill is a part of a one-year project conducted by a group of law professors. The current criminal act was enacted in 1953 and its general part remained intact ever since. So it is thought that amendments are inevitable to introduce new theories and court decisions in the field of criminal law. On the question of the criminal immaturity excluding the criminal responsibility, the authors accepted the current provision which excludes the criminal punishments of a person, where he is less then 14 years of age at the time of an offence(Article 9). A recent amendment to the Juvenile Act authorised protective measures to a person between 10 and 19 years of age. About a mental disorder the authors considered recent developments in the psychiatrics. The effect of diminished capacity or partial capacity is needed to be changed. The current regulation provides that "for the conduct of a person who, because of mental disorder, is deficient in the abilities mentioned in the preceding paragraph, the punishment shall be mitigated." The principle of responsibility requires that the punishment shall be proportionate to the responsibility of a person. Under the current article 10 paragraph 2 a punishment shall be mitigated, where a perpetrator was however diminished in the capacity provided for in Article 10. This kind of lenient punishments do not seem to comport with the justice principle. So this bill gives a discretionary effect of the partial capacity. The self-induced intoxication has been in the middle of dabate in last 10 years. The new provision gives a clear ground for the negligent self-induced intoxication and knowingly induced intoxication(so called actio libera in causa, Article 10 para. 3). On the mistake of law(art. 16), the courts have been of the opinion that the art. 16 does not apply to the case of ignorance of law, while the academics interpret the provision to the contrary. The new bill places explicitly the ignorance of law under the same theory of the mistake of law, by which a person shall not be punishable if the mistake is based on justifiable grounds.
KW - 형법개정, 책임능력, 법률의 착오, 원인에 있어서 자유로운 행위
DO - 10.21795/kcla.2009.21.1.79
UR - http://dx.doi.org/10.21795/kcla.2009.21.1.79
ER -

한상훈 and 천진호 (2009). 책임 분야 개정방안. 형사법연구, 21( 1), 79- 114.

한상훈 and 천진호 . 2009, “책임 분야 개정방안”, 형사법연구, vol. 21, no. 1, pp. 79-114. Available from: doi:10.21795/kcla.2009.21.1.79

한상훈 천진호 et al. “책임 분야 개정방안” 형사법연구 21.1 pp. 79-114 (2009): 79.

한상훈 , 천진호 . 책임 분야 개정방안 형사법연구 [Internet]. 2009; 21( 1), : 79-114. Available from: doi:10.21795/kcla.2009.21.1.79

한상훈 and 천진호 . “책임 분야 개정방안” 형사법연구 21, no.1 (2009): 79-114. doi: 10.21795/kcla.2009.21.1.79

홈 권호 목록 논문 목록 논문 상세

책임 분야 개정방안

형사법연구

약어 : -

2009, vol.21, no.1, pp.79 - 114

DOI : 10.21795/kcla.2009.21.1.79

발행기관 : 한국형사법학회

연구분야 : 법학

한상훈¹ , 천진호²

¹연세대학교

²동아대학교

인용한 논문 수 : 18 서지 간략 보기

초록

This paper suggests a bill to amend and reform the criminal responsibility provisions of the Criminal Act of Korea, and explains the purpose of the reform. This reform bill is a part of a one-year project conducted by a group of law professors. The current criminal act was enacted in 1953 and its general part remained intact ever since. So it is thought that amendments are inevitable to introduce new theories and court decisions in the field of criminal law. On the question of the criminal immaturity excluding the criminal responsibility, the authors accepted the current provision which excludes the criminal punishments of a person, where he is less then 14 years of age at the time of an offence(Article 9). A recent amendment to the Juvenile Act authorised protective measures to a person between 10 and 19 years of age. About a mental disorder the authors considered recent developments in the psychiatrics. The effect of diminished capacity or partial capacity is needed to be changed. The current regulation provides that "for the conduct of a person who, because of mental disorder, is deficient in the abilities mentioned in the preceding paragraph, the punishment shall be mitigated." The principle of responsibility requires that the punishment shall be proportionate to the responsibility of a person. Under the current article 10 paragraph 2 a punishment shall be mitigated, where a perpetrator was however diminished in the capacity provided for in Article 10. This kind of lenient punishments do not seem to comport with the justice principle. So this bill gives a discretionary effect of the partial capacity. The self-induced intoxication has been in the middle of dabate in last 10 years. The new provision gives a clear ground for the negligent self-induced intoxication and knowingly induced intoxication(so called actio libera in causa, Article 10 para. 3). On the mistake of law(art. 16), the courts have been of the opinion that the art. 16 does not apply to the case of ignorance of law, while the academics interpret the provision to the contrary. The new bill places explicitly the ignorance of law under the same theory of the mistake of law, by which a person shall not be punishable if the mistake is based on justifiable grounds.

키워드

형법개정, 책임능력, 법률의 착오, 원인에 있어서 자유로운 행위

참고문헌(17)

[기타] 김봉태 / 1985 / 형법개정의 기본방향 / 형사법개정특별심의위원회, 형사법개정자료(Ⅱ) : 18
[기타] 김진환 / 정신장애 범죄자의 책임과 처우에 관한 연구 : 42
[기타] 법무부 / 1986 / 형사법개정특별심의위원회 회의록, 제2권 / 제14차 소위원회 : 189
[학술지] 오영근 / 1999 / 원인에 있어서 자유로운 행위와 그 유형 : 과실에 의한 원인에 있어서 자유로운 행위를 중심으로 / 형사정책연구 (여름) : 88
[기타] 윤용규 / 1998 / 법정고시 : 118
[학위논문] 정규원 / 1997 / 형법상 책임능력에 관한 연구
[학술지] 차용석,고시계 / 1986 / 6,189면
[학위논문] 한상훈 / 2000 / 원인에 있어서 자유로운 행위와 책임귀속에 관한 연구
[학술지] 형사법연구 제4권,한국형사법학회 / 1991 / 12,262면
[기타] 형사정책연구원 / 형법제정자료집 : 202
[단행본] 황산덕 / 1986 / 형법개정의 문제점 / 방문사 : 27
[기타] / Neugefasst durch Bek. v. 14.12.2006 I 3134
[기타] / Zuletzt geändert durch Art. 3 Abs. 3 G v. 31.10.2008 I 2149
[기타] Riklin / 2007 / Schweizerisches Strafrecht / AT 1
[기타] Smith / 2003 / Criminal Law : 218
[기타] Stratenwerth / 2007 / Schweizerisches Strafgesetzbuch Handkommentar / Art. 19 Rn. 1
[기타] Stratenwerth / Schweizerisches Strafgesetzbuch Handkommentar / Art. 19 Rn. 2