초록

In the first few decades of the Qing Dynasty (1644-1912), Chinese political thinkers engaged in a seminal debate over how to redesign the basic "constitution" of imperial authority. The pivotal figure in this rich argument was Gu Yanwu (1613-1682), who proposed a "mixed model" approach that would combine the strengths and counteract the weaknesses in the two rival systems for constituting political authority-the decentralized fengjian system versus the centralized, bureaucratic junxian system. This article reconstructs the main arguments in that debate, looking at how mixed model advocates differed from fengjian revivalists, focusing on the role and ideas of Gu Yanwu, but also drawing attention to their shared goal of using reform to strengthen the imperial state and the authority of the emperor. The concluding section shows how the consolidation of Qing ideological authority by 1680 brought a close to this constitutional debate, leaving it to be rediscovered during the crisis of the 19th century.

키워드

history of political thought-China, constitutionalism-China, Qing Dynasty, fengjian, jun.xian, Gu Yanwu, Huang Zongxi

참고문헌(48)open

  1. [단행본] 陈山榜 / 2004 / 颜元评传 / Renmin jiaoyu chubanshe

  2. [학술지] Creel, H. G. / 1964 / The Beginnings of Bureaucracy in China: The Origin of the Hsien / The Journal of Asian Studies 23 (2) : 155 ~ 184

  3. [단행본] De Bary, W. T. / 1967 / Chinese Thought and Institutions / University of Chicago Press : 163 ~ 203

  4. [학위논문] Delury, John Patrick / 2007 / Despotism Above and Below: Gu Yanwu’s Record of Daily Learning on Money, Power and Mores

  5. [단행본] Elliott, Mark C. / 2001 / The Manchu Way: The Eight Banners and Ethnic Identity in Late Imperial China / Stanford Univ. Press

  6. [단행본] Elman, Benjamin / 1984 / From Philosophy to Philology: Intellectual and Social Aspects of Change in Late Imperial China / Harvard Univ. Press

  7. [단행본] Faure, David / 2007 / Emperor and Ancestor: State and Lineage in South China / Stanford Univ. Press

  8. [단행본] 冯天瑜 / 2010 / ‘封建’靠论 / Zhongguo shehui kexue chubanshe

  9. [학술지] Fisher, Thomas S. / 1978 / Accommodation and Loyalism: The Life of Lü Liuliang (1629-1683) / Papers on Far Eastern History 107 (45) : 1 ~ 42

  10. [단행본] Gernet, Jacques / 1991 / Écrits d’un sage encore inconnu / Gallimard/Unesco

  11. [단행본] Gernet, Jacques / 1981 / State and Law in East Asia (Festschrift Karl Bünger) / Harrasoowitz : 112 ~ 125

  12. [단행본] 葛榮晉 / 1996 / 陆世仪评传 / Nanjing daxue chubanshe

  13. [단행본] 顧炎武 / 1996 / 日知录集释 / Yuelu shushe

  14. [단행본] 顧炎武 / 1983 / 顧亭林詩文集 / Zhonghua shuju

  15. [단행본] 黃宗羲 / 1993 / Waiting for the Dawn: A Plan for the Prince: Huang Tsunghsi’s Ming-i tai-fang lu / Columbia Univ. Press

  16. [단행본] 黃宗羲 / 2002 / 黃宗羲全集 / Zhejiang guji chubanshe

  17. [단행본] Hymes, Robert / 1989 / Neo-Confucian Education: The Formative Stage / University of California Press : 440 ~ 451

  18. [단행본] Jiang Qing / 2012 / A Confucian Constitutional Order: How China’s Ancient Past Can Shape Its Political Future / Princeton Univ. Press

  19. [단행본] Kuhn, Philip / 2002 / Origins of the Modern Chinese State / Stanford Univ. Press

  20. [학술지] Li Feng / 2003 / ‘Feudalism’ and Western Zhou China: A Criticism / Harvard Journal of Asiatic Studies 63 (1) : 115 ~ 144

  21. [단행본] Li Feng / 2009 / Landscape and Power in Early China: The Crisis and Fall of the Western Zhou 1045-771 BC / Cambridge Univ. Press

  22. [단행본] 陸世儀 / 1985 / 陸桴亭思辨錄輯要 / Zhonghua shuju

  23. [단행본] 呂留良 / 1995 / 續修四庫全書 / Shanghai guji chubanshe

  24. [학술지] Meyer-Fong, Tobie / 2004 / Packaging the Men of Our Times: Literary Anthologies, Friendship Networks, and Political Accommodation in the Early Qing / Harvard Journal of Asiatic Studies 64 (1) : 5 ~ 56

  25. [단행본] Pocock, J. G. A. / 1973 / Politics, Language, and Time: Essays on Political Thought and History / Atheneum : 3 ~ 41

  26. [단행본] Pocock, J. G. A. / 1975 / The Machiavellian Moment: Florentine Political Thought and the Atlantic Republican Tradition / Princeton Univ. Press

  27. [학술지] Rowe, William T. / 1998 / Ancestral Rites and Political Authority in Late Imperial China:Chen Hongmou in Jiangxi / Modern China 24 (4) : 378 ~ 407

  28. [단행본] Rowe, William T. / 2001 / Saving the World: Chen Hongmou and Elite Consciousness in 18th Century China / Stanford Univ. Press

  29. [학술지] Rowe, William T / 2012 / Rewriting the Qing Constitution: Bao Shichen’s ‘On Wealth’(Shuochu) / T’oung Pao 98 : 178 ~ 216

  30. [단행본] Ryan, Alan / 2012 / On Politics: A History of Political Thought / W. W. Norton

  31. [단행본] Schrecker, John E. / 2004 / The Chinese Revolution in Historical Perspective / Praeger

  32. [학술지] Song, Jaeyoon / 2011 / Redefining Good Government: Shifting Paradigms in Song Dynasty (960-1270) Discourse on ‘Fengjian’ / T’oung Pao 97 : 301 ~ 343

  33. [단행본] Spence, Jonathan D. / 1999 / The Search for Modern China / W. W. Norton

  34. [학술지] Struve, Lynn A. / 1982 / The Hsü Brothers and Semiofficial Patronage of Scholars in the K’ang-hsi Period / Harvard Journal of Asiatic Studies 42 (1) : 231 ~ 266

  35. [단행본] Szonyi, Michael / 2002 / Practicing Kinship: Lineage and Descent in Late Imperial China / Stanford Univ. Press

  36. [단행본] 唐甄 / 1963 / 潛書 / Zhonghua shuju

  37. [단행본] Wakeman, Frederic / 1985 / The Great Enterprise: The Manchu Reconstruction of Imperial Order in 17th Century China / University of California Press

  38. [단행본] 汪晖 / 2004 / 现代中国思想的兴起 / Sanlian shudian

  39. [학술지] Whitbeck, Judith / 1983 / Kung Tzu-chen and the Redirection of Literati Commitment in Early 19th Century China / Qing shi wen-ti 4 (10) : 1 ~ 32

  40. [학술지] Wiens, Mi Chu / 1976 / Changes in the Fiscal and Rural Control Systems in the 14th and 15th Centuries / Ming Studies 3 (Fall) : 53 ~ 69

  41. [학술지] Wilson, Thomas A. / 1994 / Confucian Sectarianism and the Compilation of the Ming History / Late Imperial China 15 (2) : 53 ~ 84

  42. [단행본] 蕭公權 / 1980 / 中國政治思想史 / Zhongguo wenhua daxue chubanbu

  43. [학술지] 夏晓虹 / 1999 / 并世人物 缘悭一面—顾, 黄, 王三家交游考 / Huinei tongxun 6 : 115

  44. [단행본] 许苏民 / 2006 / 顾炎武评传 / Nanjing daxue chubanshe

  45. [단행본] 顏元 / 1987 / 顏元集 / Zhonghua shuju

  46. [단행본] Zarrow, Peter / 1924 / After Empire: The Conceptual Transformation of the Chinese State, 1885-1924 / Stanford Univ. Press

  47. [학술지] 赵刚 / 1985 / 顾炎武与黄太冲书新证 / Lanzhou daxue xuebao, shehui kexue 34 (4) : 17 ~ 18

  48. [단행본] 朱端强 / 2004 / 万斯同与明史修纂纪年 / Zhonghua shuju