DIAGRAM REASONING AND PARACONSISTENT THINKING: HIEROMONK HIEROTHEOS, HIS ANCESTRY, AND LEGACY
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24193/subbto.2022.2.03Keywords:
Byzantine theology, Trinitarian theology, triadology, Eustratius of Nicaea, Nicetas “of Maroneia,” Nicephorus Blemmydes, Theodore II Laskaris, hieromonk Hierotheos, Theophanes of Nicaea, Joseph Bryennios, Arsenites, Arsenite movement, logical diagrams, FilioqueAbstract
The article is dedicated to the use of logical diagrams in Byzantine Trinitarian theology. Logical diagrams are a kind of logical computation that is often considered to originate with Euler and Leibniz, but they were, in fact, used by Byzantine theologians since at least the ninth century. Nevertheless, logical diagrams were never so widely accepted as they began to be from the late thirteenth century to the early fifteenth century. The diagrams seem to have been introduced into Trinitarian theology by Eustratius of Nicaea (an authoritative philosopher who did not fare as well as a theologian) in his anti-Latin polemics dating to ca. 1112. From there, the use of diagrams was reclaimed in about the 1140s by the Latinophrone Nicetas of Maroneia and rejected in 1256 by the anti-Latin theologian Emperor Theodore II Laskaris. Nevertheless, beginning in the 1270s, their popularity and variability exploded. Eventually, triadological diagrams were canonized as the legacy of St. Hierotheos of Athens, the teacher of Dionysius the Areopagite, by Joseph Bryennios in the early fifteenth century. Even the internal opponent of Palamite theology, Theophanes of Nicaea, resorted to diagrams in defending his own triadology. The figure who rendered diagrams critical for the Hesychast theologians was, in the 1270s, hieromonk Hierotheos. He was able to express with diagrams the inconsistency of the mainstream Byzantine understanding of the Trinity. Nevertheless, his own name would come, in the fourteenth century, under a kind of damnatio memoriae, so that his main ideas circulated rather under the name of Hierotheos of Athens. This article argues that hieromonk Hierotheos passed from the Church of Patriarch Joseph to the Church of Patriarch Arsenius (or the Arsenites). Some of the highly authoritative teachers of the Palamites were in disagreement with the Great Church on the Arsenite issue, refusing to accept the act of 1410, where the Great Church had declared the Arsenites to be on the right side of the conflict. This fact could have affected the memory of hieromonk Hierotheos in the milieu where his works were most in demand.
References
“Le hiéromoine Hiérothée, théologien du Saint-Esprit.” Κληρονομία 13 (1981): 299–330.
Ὁ Ἱερομόναχος Ἱερόθεος (ΙΓ΄ αι.) καὶ τό ἀνέκδοτο συγγραφικό ἔργο του. Κριτική ἔκδοση. 3rd edn. Athens: Κυριακίδη, 2009.
“A Logical Scheme and Paraconsistent Topological Separation in Byzantium: Inter-Trinitarian Relations according to Hieromonk Hierotheos and Joseph Bryennios.” In Relations. Ontology and Philosophy of Religion, edited by Daniele Bertini and Damiano Migliorini, 283–299. Milan: Mimesis International, 2018.
“Beyond Books: The Diagrammatic Mode in Byzantium.” In Illuminations. Studies Presented to Lioba Theis, edited by Galina Fingarova, Fani Gargova, and Margaret Mullet, 93–104. Vienna: Phoibos Verlag, 2022.
“Byzantine Diagrams.” In The Diagram as Paradigm, 13–32.
“Damian of Alexandria.” In Encyclopaedia Aethiopica. Vol. 2. Edited by Siegbert Uhlig, 77–78. Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz, 2005.
“Eustratius of Nicaea, a Theologian: About the Recent Publications of Alexei Barmin.” Scrinium 16 (2020): 344–358.
“Leontius of Byzantium and His “Theory of Graphs” against John Philoponus.” In The Ways of Byzantine Philosophy, edited by Mikonja Knežević, 143–170. Alhambra, CA: Sebastian Press, 2015.
“Nicephorus Blemmydes on the Holy Trinity and the Paraconsistent Notion of Numbers: A Logical Analysis of a Byzantine Approach to the Filioque.” Studia Humana 5 (2016): 40–54.
“The Refutation of Petrus Grossolanus: The Λόγοι ἀντιῤῥητικοί by Eustratius of Nicaea.” In Contra Latinos et Adversus Graecos: The Separation between Rome and Constantinople from the Ninth to the Fifteenth Century, edited by Alessandra Bucossi and Anna Calia, 199–215. OLA 286. Bibliothèque de Byzantion 22. Leuven: Peeters, 2020.
“Theodore the Studite’s Christology against Its Logical Background.” Studia Humana 8 (2019): 99–113.
“What Means ‘Tri-’ in ‘Trinity’? An Eastern Patristic Approach to the ‘Quasi-Ordinals’.” Journal of Applied Logic 6 (2019): 1093–1107.
Epistulae et Amphilochia. Vol. 5. Edited by Leendert G. Westerink. Leipzig: Teubner, 1986.
Œuvres théologiques. 2 vols. Edited and translated by Michel Stavrou. SC 517, 558. Paris: Cerf, 2007, 2013.
Полемика и схизма. История греко-латинских споров IX–XII веков [Polemics and Schism: History of the Greek-Latin Discussions in the 9th–12th Centuries]. Moscow: Институт философии, теологии и истории св. Фомы, 2006.
Allatius, Leo. De Ecclesiae Occidentalis atque Orientalis perpetua consensione, libri tres. Cologne: Apud Jodocum Kalcovium, 1648.
Andreeva, Maria Aleksandrovna. Полемика Ѳеодора II. Ласкаря съ Никифоромъ Влеммидомъ [Polemics of Theodore II Laskaris with Nicephoros Blemmydes]. Věstník Královské české společnosti nauk. Třída filosoficko-historicko-filologická (1929): 1–36. Prague: Královská česká společnost nauk, 1930.
Andronikos Kamateros. Sacrum Armamentarium. Pars prima. Edited by Alessandra Bucossi. CCSG 75. Turnhout: Brepols, 2014.
Angelov, Dimiter. The Byzantine Hellene: The Life of Emperor Theodore Laskaris and Byzantium in the Thirteenth Century. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2019.
Barmin, Alexei. “Une source méconnue des Dialogues de Nicétas de Maronée.” REB 58 (2000): 231–243.
Bazini, Hélène. “Une première édition des oeuvres de Joseph Bryennios: les Traités adressés aux Crétois.” REB 62 (2004): 83–132.
Blanchet, Marie-Hélène. Georges-Gennadios Scholarios (vers 1400–vers 1472). Un intellectuel orthodoxe face à la disparition de l’Empire Byzantin. Paris: Institut français d’études byzantines, 2008.
Boojamra, John L. Church Reform in the Late Byzantine Empire: A Study for the Patriarchate of Athanasios of Constantinople. Ἀνάλεκτα Βλατάδων 35. Thessaloniki: Πατριαρχικὸν Ἵδρυμα Πατερικῶν Μελετῶν, 1982.
Carnielli, Walter, and Marcelo Esteban Coniglio. Paraconsistent Logic: Consistency, Contradiction and Negation. New York: Springer, 2016.
Constas, Nicholas. “Mark Eugenikos.” In La théologie byzantine et sa tradition. Vol. 2: (XIIIe–XIXe s.), edited by Carmelo Giuseppe Conticello and Vassa Conticello, 411–475. Turnhout: Brepols, 2002.
Corpus Dionysiacum I: Pseudo-Dionysius Areopagita. De Divinis Nominibus. Edited by Beate R. Suchla. Berlin: de Gruyter, 1990.
Corpus Dionysiacum IV/1: Ioannis Scythopolitani Prologus et Scholia in Dionysii Areopagitae Librum De Divinis Nominibus cum Additamentis Interpretum Aliorum. Edited by Beate R. Suchla. Berlin: de Gruyter, 2011.
Darrouzès, Jean. “Les documents byzantins du XIIe siècle sur la primauté romaine.” REB 23 (1965): 42–88.
De Groot, Jean. Aristotle’s Empiricism: Experience and Mechanics in the Fourth Century BC. Las Vegas: Parmenides Publishing, 2014.
De Risi, Vincenzo. Geometry and Monadology. Leibniz’s “Analysis Situs” and Philosophy of Space. Basel: Birkhäuser, 2007.
Epifanovich, Sergey. Матерiалы къ изученiю жизни и творенiй преп. Максима Исповѣдника [Materials for a Study of the Life and the Works of St Maximus the Confessor]. Kiev: Типографiя Университета Св. Владимiра, 1917.
Eustratius of Nicaea. Опровержительные слова (Λόγοι ἀντιρρητικοί). Edited and translated by Alexei Barmin. Moscow: Издательство Московской Патриархии Русской Православной Церкви, 2016.
Evagrius Ponticus. Capita gnostica. Edited by Antoine Guillaumont, Les six centuries des ‘Kephalaia Gnostica’ d’Évagre le Pontique. Édition critique de la version syriaque commune et édition d’une nouvelle version syriaque, intégrale, avec une double traduction française. Turnhout: Brepols, 1985; first published in 1958.
Galluzzo, Gabriele. The Medieval Reception of Book Zeta of Aristotle’s Metaphysics. Vol. 1: Aristotle’s Ontology and the Middle Ages: The Tradition of Met., Book Zeta. Vol. 2: Pauli Veneti Expositio in duodecim libros Metaphisice Aristotelis, ‘Liber VII’. Leiden: Brill, 2013.
Gärdenfors, Peter. Conceptual Spaces: The Geometry of Thought. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2000.
Gardner, Martin. Logic Machines and Diagrams. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1958.
George Pachymeres. Συγγραφικαὶ ἱστορίαι. Edited by Albert Failler, George Pachymérès. Relations historiques. Vol. 2: Livres IV–VI. CFHB 24.2. Paris: Les Belles Lettres, 1984.
Gill, Joseph. Quae supersunt auctorum graecorum Concilii Florentini. II: Res Florentiae gestae. Rome: Pontificium Institutum Orientalium Studiorum, 1953.
Gounaridis, Paris. Τὸ κίνημα τῶν Ἀρσενιατῶν (1261–1310). Ἰδεολογικὲς διαμάχες τὴν ἐποχὴν τῶν πρώτων Παλαιολόγων. Athens: Δόμος, 1999.
Gregory Palamas. Λόγοι ἀποδεικτικοί. In PS, vol. 1.
Grumel, Venance. “La chronologie des patriarches grecs de Jérusalem au XIIIe siècle.” REB 20 (1962): 197–201.
Ioannidis, Nicholas Ch. Ο Ιωσήφ Βρυέννιος. Βίος – ΄Εργο – Διδασκαλία. Athens, 1985.
Joseph Bryennios. Τὰ εὑρεθέντα. Edited by Eugenios Voulgaris. Vol. 1. Leipzig: Βρεϊτκόπφ, 1768.
Kryaras, Emmanuel. Λέξικο της μεσαιωνικής ελληνικής δημώδους γραμματείας, 1100–1669. Vol. 4. Thessaloniki: Κέντρο Ελληνικής Γλώσσας, 1975.
Larchet, Jean-Claude, ed. La vie et l’œuvre théologique de Georges/Grégoire II de Chypre (1241–1290) patriarche de Constantinople. Paris: Cerf, 2012.
Lemanski, Jens. “Means or End? On the Valuation of Logic Diagrams.” Logic-Philosophical Studies. Yearbook of the St. Petersburg Logical Association 14 (2016): 98–121.
Lewis, Clarence Irving. A Survey of Symbolic Logic. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1918.
Lloyd, Antony C. “The Aristotelianism of Eustratios of Nicaea.” In Aristoteles – Werk und Wirkung. Vol. 2: Kommentierung, Überlieferung, Nachleben, edited by Jürgen Wiesner, 341–351. Berlin: de Gruyter, 1987.
Lourié, Basil. “L’attitude de S. Marc d’Éphèse aux débat sur la procession du Saint-Esprit à Florence. Ses fondements dans la théologie post-palamite.” Annuarium Historiae Conciliorum 21 (1989): 317–333.
Louth, Andrew. “The Eucharist and Hesychasm, with Special Reference to Theophanes III, Metropolitan of Nicaea.” In The Eucharist in Theology and Philosophy. Issues of Doctrinal History in East and West from the Patristic Age to the Reformation, edited by István Perczel, Réka Forrai, György Geréby, 199–205. Leuven: Leuven University Press, 2005.
MacQueen, Gailand W. “The Logic Diagram.” MA thesis, McMaster University, 1967.
Markov, Smilen. “The Symbol as a Meeting Point of Energies and Categories – The Symbolical Status of the Eucharistic Gifts according to Theophanes of Nicaea.” Philosophia. E-Journal for Philosophy & Culture 1 (2012): 124–138.
Meyendorff, Jean. Introduction à l’étude de Grégoire Palamas. Patristica Sorbonensia 3. Paris: Éditions du Seuil, 1959. Russian translation of the corrected and supplemented edition, Жизнь и труды святителя Григория Паламы. Введение в изучение. Translated by Georgy Nachinkin, Igor Medvedev, and Basil Lourié. Subsidia byzantinorossica 2. St. Petersburg: Византинороссика, 1997.
Mineva, Εvelina. Το υμονγραφικό έργο του Μάρκου Ευγενικού. Athens: Κανάκη, 2004.
Moktefi, Amirouche, and Jens Lemanski. “On the Origin of Venn Diagrams.” Axiomathes 32 (2022): 887–900.
Moktefi, Amirouche, and Sun-Joo Shin. “A History of Logic Diagrams.” In Handbook of the History of Logic. Vol. 11: Logic: A History of Its Central Concepts, edited by Dov M. Gabbay, Francis J. Pelletier, and John Woods, 611–682. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 2012.
Nicephorus Blemmydes. Autobiographia, sive, Curriculum vitae; necnon, Epistula universalior. Edited by Joseph A. Munitiz. CCSG 13. Turnhout: Brepols, 1984.
Nicetas of Thessaloniki. Dialogi sex de processione Spiritus Sancti. Edited by Alessandra Bucossi and Luigi D’Amelia. CCSG 92. Turnhout: Brepols, 2021. Also edited by Nicola Festa, “Niceta di Maronea e i suoi dialoghi sulla processione delle Spirito Santo.” Bessarione 16 (1912): 80–107, 126–132, 266–286; 17 (1913): 104–113, 295–315; 18 (1914): 55–75, 243–259; 19 (1915): 239–246.
Nicholas Mouzalon. De processione Spiritus Sancti. Edited by Theodoros Ν. Zisis, “Ὁ πατριάρχης Νικόλαος Δ΄ Μουζάλων.” Ἐπιστημονικὴ Ἐπετηρίδα τῆς Θεολογικῆς Σχολῆς τοῦ Πανεπιστημίου Θεσσαλονίκης 23 (1978): 233–330, edition at 297–329.
Nicholas of Methone. Refutation of Proclus’ Elements of Theology. Edited by Athanasios D. Angelou. Corpus Philosophorum Medii Aevi, Philosophi Byzantini 1. Athens: Academy of Sciences; Leiden: Brill, 1984.
Papadakis, Aristeides. Crisis in Byzantium: The Filioque Controversy in the Patriarchate of Gregory II of Cyprus (1283–1289). Revised edn. Crestwood, NY: St Vladimir’s Seminary Press, 1996.
Passarelli, Gaetano. Macario Crisocefalo (1300–1382). L’omelia sulla festa dell’Ortodossia e la basilica di S. Giovanni di Filadelfia. OCA 210. Rome: Pontificium Institutum Orientalium Studiorum, 1980.
Patacsi, Gabriel. “Joseph Bryennios et les discussions sur un concile d’union (1414–1431).” Κληρονομία 5 (1973): 73–96.
Patriarch Photius. Bibliothèque. Vol. 5: ‘Codices’ 230–241. Edited and translated by René Henry. Paris: Les Belles Lettres, 1967.
Peter of Callinicum. Anti-Tritheist Dossier. Edited by Rifaat Y. Ebied, Albert van Roey, and Lionel R. Wickham. OLA 10. Leuven: Departement Oriëntalistik, 1981.
Platis, Michael. An Annotated Critical Edition of Joseph Bryennios’ Third Dialogue on the Procession of the Holy Spirit with a Brief Theological and Historical Commentary. PhD diss., Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, 2020.
Polemis, Ioannis D. Theophanes of Nicaea: His Life and Works. Wiener Byzantinistische Studien 20. Vienna: Verlag der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, 1996.
Priest, Graham. Beyond the Limits of Thought. 2nd edn. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002. Reprinted in 2006.
Proclus. Théologie platonicienne. Livre I. Edited and translated by Henri-Dominique Saffrey and Leendert G. Westerink. Paris: Les Belles Lettres, 1968.
Przhegorlinsky, Alexander. Византийская Церковь на рубеже XIII–XIV вв. Деятельность и наследие св. Феолипта, митрополита Филадельфийского [The Byzantine Church at the Turn of the 13th–14th Centuries. The Activities and Heritage of St. Theoleptos, Metropolitan of Philadelphia]. St. Petersburg: Алетейя, 2011.
Pseudo-Athanasius. De communi essentia. PG 28, 29D–80C.
Riebe, Alexandra. Rom in Gemeinschaft mit Konstantinopel. Patriarch Johannes XI. Bekkos als Verteidiger der Kirchenunion von Lyon (1274). Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz, 2005.
Safran, Linda. “Diagramming Byzantine Orthodoxy.” In The Diagram as Paradigm: Cross-Cultural Approaches, edited by Jeffrey F. Hamburger, David J. Roxburgh, and Linda Safran, 489–518. Washington, DC: Dumbarton Oaks Research Library and Collection, 2022.
Scholia in Aratum vetera. Edited by Jean Martin. Berlin: Teubner, 1974.
Schultze, Bernhard. Maksim Grek als Theologe. OCA 167. Rome: Pontificium Institutum Orientalium Studiorum, 1963.
Shin, Sun-Joo. The Logical Status of Diagrams. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1994.
Sotiropoulos, Charalambos. “Τὸ σχῆμα τοῦ κύκλου καὶ ἡ τάξις ἐν τῇ Ἁγίᾳ Τριάδι κατὰ τὸν Θεοφάνη Νικαίας. Ἐπὶ τῇ βάσει τοῦ ἀνεκδότου ἔργου του, Κατὰ Λατίνων, λόγοι τρεῖς.” Ἐπιστημονικὴ Ἑπετηρὶς τῆς Θεολογικῆς Σχολῆς τοῦ Πανεπιστημίου Ἀθηνῶν 27 (1986): 507–541.
Spyridon Lavriotis and Sophronios Eustratiades. Catalogue of the Greek Manuscripts in the Library of the Laura on Mount Athos. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1925.
Theodore II Laskaris. Περὶ χριστιανικῆς θεολογίας λόγοι. Edited by Christos Th. Krikonis. 3rd edn. Thessaloniki: University Studio Press, 1990.
Theodoroudis, Georgios P. Η εκπόρευσις του Αγίου Πνεύματος κατά τους συγγραφείς του ΙΓ΄ αιώνος. Thessaloniki: Κυρομάνος, 1990.
Theophanes of Nicaea. Ἀπόδειξις ὅτι ἐδύνατο ἐξ ἀϊδίου γεγένησθαι τὰ ὄντα καὶ ἀνατροπὴ ταύτης. Edited and translated by Ioannis D. Polemis. Corpus Philosophorum Medii Aevi. Philosophi byzantini 10. Athens: Ακαδημία Αθηνών, 2000.
Venn, John. Symbolic Logic. London: Macmillan, 1881.
Voicu, Sever J. “Il florilegio De communi essentia (CPG 2240), Severiano di Gabala e altri Padri.” Sacris Erudiri 55 (2016): 129–155.
Willson, Justin. “On the Aesthetics of Diagrams in Byzantine Art.” Speculum 98.3 (2023): forthcoming.
Великiя минеи четiи. Октябрь. Дни 1–3 [The Great Menologion. October, Days 1–3]. Edited by Spiridon N. Palauzov. St. Petersburg: Типография Императорской Академии наук, 1870.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2022 Studia Universitatis Babeș-Bolyai Theologia Orthodoxa
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
ISSN (print): 1224-0869, ISSN (online): 2065-9474, ISSN-L: 2065-9474