초록

This type of comparative studies on the Prologue of John and the Preface of 1 John in terms of stylistic and structural analysis has not been properly paid attention to. Scholars have paid heed just to the surface level of comparison such as vocabularies and theological terms (or ideas), although not so few Johannine scholars have put much their focuses on studies of the Prologue’s structure. The value of the comparative study of both structures and styles of the Prologue and the Preface lies in 1) probably providing certain solution to the issue of authorship, 2) giving certain light upon the other part of study interactively or inter-relationally, if we can discern the specific authorial type of linguistic pattern in use, such as complex parallelism, based on the close connectivity between the Prologue and the Preface, 3)promoting the further continuous studies of the other Johannine texts besides the Prologue and the preface, grounded on the detected, specific patterns of structure or style. In this comparative study, the Prologue is determined to have certain resembled phenomena, in style and structure, with the Preface that shows the Johannine complex parallelisms, designing a stunning,poetic style of structure. Its complex chiastic structure of the Prologue,A(1-2)-B1(3-5)-C(6-8)-B2(9-11)-X(12-13)-B´2(14)-C´(15)-B´1(16-17)-A´(18), demonstrates convincingly that the text should not be interpreted simply in logical or successive order, but in complex-chiastic or interrelational order. V. 1 needs to be interpreted in relation to v. 18,while vs. 3-5 in relation both to vs. 9-11 and vs. 16-17, v. 6-8 in relation to v. 15, and v. 14 in relation both to vs. 16-17 (or including v. 18) and to vs. 9-11, simultaneously.

키워드

요한복음 프롤로그, 요한일서 서문, 구조 연구, 요한 문체, 복합 병행법, 복합 역교차

참고문헌(42)open

  1. [단행본] Andreas J. Kostenberger / 2004 / John / Baker Academic : 20

  2. [단행본] Andreas J. Ko¨stenberger / 1999 / Encountering John: The Gospel in Historical, Literary, and Theological Perspective / Baker Books : 21 ~ 23

  3. [학위논문] Byung-Chan Go / 2009 / `Belief' and `Logos' in the Prologue of the Gospel of John: An Analysis of Complex Parallelism

  4. [단행본] Craig S. Keener / 2003 / The Gospel of John: A Commentary / Hendrickson : 364 ~ 426

  5. [단행본] Charles H. Talbert / 1992 / Reading John: A Literary and Theological Commentary on the fourth Gospel and the Johannine Epistles / Crossroad : 14

  6. [단행본] Colin G. Kruse / 2003 / The Gospel According to John: An Introduction and Commentary / Eerdmans : 58 ~ 61

  7. [단행본] D.A. Carson / 1991 / The Gospel According to John / Inter-Varsity Press : 113

  8. [단행본] Herman N. Ridderbos / 1997 / The Gospel According to John: A Theological Commentary / Eerdmans : 19

  9. [단행본] Hartmut Gese / 1977 / Der Johannesprolog. in: Zur biblicshen Theologie, Alttestamentliche Vorta¨rge / Kaiser Verlag : 152 ~ 201

  10. [단행본] Herman C. Waetjen / 2005 / The Gospel of the Beloved Disciple / T & T Clark : 81 ~ 87

  11. [단행본] K.E. Bailey / 1983 / Poet & Peasant and through Peasant Eyes: A Literary-Cultural Approach to the Parables of Luke / Eerdmans : 59

  12. [단행본] M.E. Boismard / 1957 / St John's Prologue / Blackfriars : 5

  13. [단행본] Leon Morris / 1977 / The Gospel According to John: The English Text with Introduction, Exposition and Notes / Eerdmans : 65

  14. [단행본] Gilbert Van Belle / 2009 / Theory of Repetitions and Variations in the Fourth Gospel: A Neglected Field of Research?. in: Repetitions and Variations in the Fourth Gospel: Style, Text, Interpretation / Uitgeverij Peeters : 26

  15. [단행본] Gary M. Burge / 2000 / John: The NIV Application Commentary, From Biblical Text to Contemporary Life / Zondervan : 53 ~ 54

  16. [단행본] Gunnar Östenstad / 1998 / Patterns of Redemption in the Fourth Gospel: An Experiment in Structural Analysis / The Edwin Mellen Press : 85 ~ 93

  17. [단행본] Gerald L. Borchert / 1996 / John 1-11 / Broadman & Holman

  18. [학술지] Peder Borgen / 1970 / Observatioins on the Targumic Character of the Prologue of John / NTS 16 : 288 ~ 295

  19. [단행본] Peter F. Ellis / 1984 / The Genius of John: A Composition-Critical Commentary on the Fourth Gospel / Liturgical

  20. [학술지] Peter F. Ellis / 1999 / Inclusion, Chiasm, and the Division of the Fourth Gospel / SVTQ 43 : 269 ~ 338

  21. [단행본] Steven Richard Scott / 2010 / Parallel Chiasms in the Introduction and Conclusion of John / Presented in the SBL International Meeting at Turtu : 1 ~ 10

  22. [학술지] Sang-Hoon Kim / 2004 / Complex Parallelisms in 1John 1:1-4 / CTJ 12 : 223 ~ 242

  23. [단행본] Stephen S. Smalley / 1984 / 1, 2, 3 John / Word Books : 4

  24. [학술지] Sang-Hoon Kim / 2006 / Complex Parallelisms in 1 John 1:5-2:2 / Chongshin Theological Journal 11 : 46 ~ 67

  25. [학술지] Sang-Hoon Kim / 2008 / Complex Parallelisms in 1 John 2:3-11 / Chongshin Theological Journal 13 (1) : 66 ~ 91

  26. [학술지] Sang-Hoon Kim / 2010 / Johannine Complex Parallelisms in 1 John 2:29-3:10 / Chongshin Theological Journal 18 (1) : 113 ~ 142

  27. [단행본] Stephen Voorwinde / 2005 / Jesus' Emotions in the Fourth Gospel: Human or Divine? / T & T Clark : 67 ~ 72

  28. [단행본] Thomas Whitelaw / 1993 / Commentary on John / Kregel : 3

  29. [단행본] Thomas L. Brodie / 1993 / The Gospel According to John: A Literary and Theological Commentary / Oxford University Press : 76

  30. [단행본] M. Black / 1928 / An Aramaic Approach to the Gospel and Acts / Clarendo Press

  31. [단행본] Nigel Turner / 1976 / A Grammar of New Testament Greek: Style / T & T Clark : 64 ~ 79

  32. [학술지] N.W. Lund / 1931 / The Influence of Chiasmusupon the Structure of the Gospels / ATR 8 : 27 ~ 48

  33. [단행본] J.P. Fokkelman / 2001 / Reading Biblical Poetry: An Introduction Guide / WJK : 25

  34. [단행본] J.W. Pryor / 1992 / John: Evangelist of the Covenant People / InterVarsity : 9 ~ 10

  35. [단행본] Jerome H Neyrey, S.J. / 2007 / The Gospel of John / Cambridge University Press : 38

  36. [학술지] Jeff Staley / 1986 / The Structure of John's Prologue: Its Implications for the Gospel' Narrative Structure / CBQ 48 : 241 ~ 264

  37. [학위논문] John J. Gerhard / 1975 / The Literary Unity and Compositional methods of the Gospel of John

  38. [단행본] John Ronning / 2010 / The Jewish Targums and John's Logos Theology / Hendrickson

  39. [단행본] Raymond E. Brown / 1982 / The Epistles of John / The Anchor Bible : 176 ~ 177

  40. [단행본] Raymond E. Brown / 1966 / The Gospel According to John I-XII: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary / The Anchor Bible : 3 ~ 4

  41. [단행본] R. Kent Hughes / 1999 / John: That You May Believe / Crossway Books : 16

  42. [단행본] Rudolf Bultmann / 1971 / The Gospel of John: A Commentary / Westminster press