Ungleichheit als Markenzeichen des Migrationsrechts

Article Authentication required
Subscibe in publisher´s online storeBuy in publisher´s online store Share via email
Ungleichheit als Markenzeichen des Migrationsrechts
Thym , Daniel

From the journal ZöR Zeitschrift für öffentliches Recht, Volume 74, December 2019, issue 4

Published by Verlag Österreich

article, 10926 Words
Original language: German
ZöR 2019, pp 905-928
https://doi.org/10.33196/zoer201904090501

Abstract Related content References

Abstract

Equal treatment is a fundamental principle of contemporary constitutionalism, which may challenge migration law, since the latter reiterates the basic distinction between citizens and aliens as well as among different categories of migrants. The contribution shows that constitutional law is based upon an – usually invisible – inequality threshold, which becomes evident when we consider rules on entry into the territory and the diverse distinctions among different migration statuses. Limits of equal treatment permeate the restrained case law of the ECtHR and define the judicial caution of the CJEU and the EU legislature in the interpretation and design of the Charter of Fundamental Rights and secondary law.

Author information

Daniel Thym

Keywords

Aufenthalt | Charta der Grundrechte | Einreise | EMRK | EuGH | Fremdenrecht | Gleichheit | Migrationsrecht | Nichtdiskriminierung | Sozialleistungen | Staatsangehörigkeit

Related content

References

  • 1. Abraham, David , Doing Justice on Two Fronts. The Liberal Dilemma in Immigration, Ethnic and Racial Studies 33 (2010) 968. DOI 10.1080/01419870903388303
  • 2. Abraham, David , Immigrant Integration and Social Solidarity in a Time of Crisis, Critical Historical Studies 1 (2014) 215. DOI 10.1086/677938
  • 3. Acosta, Arcarazo Diego , Civic Citizenship Reintroduced?, European Law Journal 21 (2015) 200. DOI 10.1111/eulj.12112
  • 4. Atrey, Shreya , Race Discrimination in EU law after Jyske Finans, Common Market Law Review 55 (2018) 625.
  • 5. Badura, Peter , § 47 Der räumliche Geltungsbereich der Grundrechte, in Detlef Merten/Hans-Jürgen Papier (Hg), Handbuch der Grundrechte in Deutschland und Europa. II: Grundrechte in Deutschland – Allgemeine Lehren I (2006) 1059. DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-66327-7_5
  • 6. Bernsdorff, Norbert , Artikel 15, in Meyer Jürgen (Hg), Die Charta der Grundrechte der Europäischen Union4 (2014) 311.
  • 7. Blauberger, Michael / Heindlmaier, Anita / Kramer, Dion / Sindbjerg, Martinsen Dorte / Sampson, Thierry Jessica / Schenk, Angelika / Werner, Benjamin , ECJ Judges Read the Morning Papers, Journal of European Public Policy 25 (2018) 1422. DOI 10.1080/13501763.2018.1488880
  • 8. Bommes, Michael , Migration und nationaler Wohlfahrtstaat (1999).
  • 9. Bosniak, Linda , Being Here. Ethical Territoriality and the Rights of Immigrants, Theoretical Inquiries in Law 8 (2007) 389. DOI 10.2202/1565-3404.1155
  • 10. Bribosia, Emmanuelle , Les politiques d’intégration de l’Union européenne et des États Membres à l’épreuve du principe de non-discrimination, in Pascouau Ives/Strik Tineke (Hg), Which Integration Policies for Migrants? (2012) 51.
  • 11. Brinkmann, Gisbert , Gleichbehandlung von Drittstaatsangehörigen nach den EU-Migrationsrichtlinien, in Beichel-Benedetti Stephan/Janda Constanze (Hg), Hohenheimer Horizonte. Festschrift für Klaus Barwig (2018) 101. DOI 10.5771/9783845278797-98
  • 12. Britz, Gabriele , Verfassungsrechtliche Grenzen der Ungleichbehandlung von Migrantenfamilien im Bereich der Familienleistungen, ZAR 2/2014, 56.
  • 13. Carlier, Jean-Yves , Droit d’asile et des réfugiés : de la protection aux droits (Volume 332) (2007). DOI 10.1163/1875-8096_pplrdc_ej.9789004171985.009_354
  • 14. Carlier, Jean-Yves / Leboeuf, Luc , Choice of Residence for Refugees and Subsidiary Protection Beneficiaries. Variations on the Equality Principle: Alo and Osso, Common Market Law Review 54 (2017) 631.
  • 15. Castles, Stephen , Understanding Global Migration. A Social Transformation Perspective, Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 36 (2010) 1565. DOI 10.1080/1369183x.2010.489381
  • 16. Crepaz, Markus M. , Rumors that Diversity is the Death of the Welfare State are Greatly Exaggerated, in Freeman Gary P./Mirilovic Nikola (Hg), Handbook on Migration and Social Policy (2016) 315. DOI 10.4337/9781783476299.00027
  • 17. De Schutter, Helder / Ypi, Lea , Mandatory Citizenship for Immigrants, British Journal of Political Science 45 (2015) 235. DOI 10.1017/s0007123414000568
  • 18. de Vries, K.M. (Karin) , Rewriting Abdulaziz, European Journal of Migration Law 18 (2016) 467. DOI 10.1163/15718166-12342110
  • 19. de, Vries K.M. (Karin) , The Integration Exception, in Thym Daniel (Hg), Questioning EU Citizenship (2017) 267.
  • 20. de Waele, Henri , The Ever-Evolving Concept of EU Citizenship, in Talani Leila Simona (Hg), Globalisation, Migration and the Future of Europe (2011) 191.
  • 21. de Witte, Floris , Justice in the EU (2015). DOI 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198724346.001.0001
  • 22. Dembour, Marie-Bénédicte , Still Silencing the Racism Suffered by Migrants... The Limits of Current Developments under Art. 14 ECHR, European Journal of Migration Law 11 (2009) 221. DOI 10.1163/138836409x12469435402738
  • 23. Dembour, Marie-Bénédicte , When Humans Become Migrants (2015). DOI 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199667833.003.0018
  • 24. Dougan, Michael , Expanding the Frontiers of European Union Citizenship by Dismantling the Territorial Borders of the National Welfare States, in Barnard Catherine/Odudu Okeoghene (Hg), The Outer Limits of European Union Law (2009) 119. DOI 10.5040/9781472564702.ch-007
  • 25. Eichenhofer, Eberhard , Sozialrecht der Europäischen Union6 (2015).
  • 26. Fabbrini, Federico , Voting Rights for Non-Citizens, European Constitutional Law Review 7 (2011) 392. DOI 10.1017/s157401961130003x
  • 27. Ferrera, Maurizio , The Boundaries of Welfare (2005). DOI 10.1093/0199284660.001.0001
  • 28. FitzGerald, David Scott / Cook-Martin, David , Culling the Masses. The Democratic Origins of Racist Immigration Policy in the Americas (2014). DOI 10.4159/harvard.9780674369665
  • 29. Frederiksen, Halvard Haukeland / Franklin, Christian N. K. , Of Pragmatism and Principles. The EEA Agreement 20 years On, Common Market Law Review 52 (2015) 629.
  • 30. Goedings, Simone , Labor Migration in an Integrating Europe (2005).
  • 31. Groenendijk, Kees , Citizens and Third Country Nationals. Differential Treatment or Discrimination, in Carlier Jean-Yves/Guild Elspeth (Hg), L’avenir de la libre circulation des personnes dans l’U.E. (2006) 79.
  • 32. Groenendijk, Kees , Recent Developments in EU Law on Migration, European Journal of Mirgration Law 16 (2014) 313. DOI 10.1163/15718166-12342059
  • 33. Groenendijk, Kees / Guild, Elspeth , Converging Criteria. Creating an Area of Security of Residence for Europe’s Third Country Nationals, European Journal of Mirgration Law 3 (2001) 37. DOI 10.1163/15718160120959078
  • 34. Guild, Elspeth / Peers, Steve , Out of the Ghetto? The Personal Scope of EU Law, in Peers Steve/Rogers Nicola (Hg), EU Immigration and Asylum Law. Text and Commentary (2006) 81. DOI 10.1163/ej.9789004153745.i-1027.24
  • 35. Gundel, Jörg , § 198 Der grundrechtliche Status der Ausländer, in Isensee Josef/Kirchhof Paul (Hg), Handbuch des Staatsrechts IX3 (2011) 843.
  • 36. Hailbronner, Kay / Thym, Daniel , (Hg), EU Immigration and Asylum Law. Commentary2 (2016). DOI 10.5040/9781782257615
  • 37. Hammar, Tomas , Democracy and the Nation-State. Aliens, Denizens and Citizens in a World of International Migration (1990).
  • 38. Hathaway, James C. , The Rights of Refugees under International Law (2005). DOI 10.1017/cbo9780511614859
  • 39. Hecker, Jan , Zur Europäisierung des Ausländerrechts, ZAR 2011, 46.
  • 40. Heinig, Hans Michael , Der Sozialstaat im Dienst der Freiheit (2008). DOI 10.1628/978-3-16-151256-8
  • 41. Hofmann, Hasso , Die versprochene Menschenwürde, AöR 118 (1993) 353.
  • 42. Hublet, Cholé , The Scope of Article 12 of the Treaty of the European Communities vis-à-vis Third-Country Nationals, European Law Journal 15 (2009) 757. DOI 10.1111/j.1468-0386.2009.00489.x
  • 43. Iglesias Sánchez, Sara , Constitutional Identity and Integration. EU Citizenship and the Emergence of a Supranational Alienage Law, German Law Journal 18 (2017) 1797. DOI 10.1017/s2071832200022550
  • 44. Ipsen, Hans-Peter , Europäisches Gemeinschaftsrecht (1972).
  • 45. Janda, Constanze , Migranten im Sozialstaat (2012). DOI 10.1628/978-3-16-152161-4
  • 46. Jellinek, Georg , Das Recht des modernen Staates I2 (1905).
  • 47. Jellinek, Georg , Das System der subjektiven Rechte2 (1905).
  • 48. Jesse, Moritz , Integration Measures, Integration Exams, and Immigration Control, Common Market Law Review 53 (2016) 1065.
  • 49. Joppke, Christian , Citizenship and Immigration (2010).
  • 50. Kingreen, Thorsten , Soziale Rechte und Migration (2010). DOI 10.5771/9783845225791
  • 51. Lester, Eve , Article 23, in Zimmermann Andreas (Hg), The 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees. A Commentary (2011). DOI 10.1093/actrade/9780199542512.003.0040
  • 52. Lucassen, Jan / Lucassen, Leo , The Mobility Transition Revisited, 1500-1900, The Journal Of Global History 4 (2009) 347. DOI 10.1017/s174002280999012x
  • 53. Minderhoud, Paul , Social Security Rights of Third Country Nationals, Journal of Social Security Law 17 (2010) 227.
  • 54. Möllers, Christoph , Staat als Argument (2000).
  • 55. Mourão Permoser, Julia , Redefining Membership. Restrictive Rights and Categorisation in European Union Migration Policy, Journal of Ethnis and Migration Studies 43 (2017) 2536. DOI 10.1080/1369183x.2017.1301202
  • 56. Muir, Elise , EU Equality Law (2018).
  • 57. Müller, Lucien , Art 12, in Ehrenzeller Bernhard (Hg), Die Schweizerische Bundesverfassung. St. Galler Kommentar I3 (2014).
  • 58. Peers, Steve , Aliens, Workers, Citizens or Humans?, in Elspeth Guild/Carol Harlow (Hg), Implementing Amsterdam (2001) 291.
  • 59. Peters, Anne / König, Doris , Kapitel 21: Das Diskriminierungsverbot, in Dörr Oliver/Grote Rainer/Marauhn Thilo (Hg), EMRK/GG Konkordanzkommentar2 (2013).
  • 60. Putnam, Robert , E Pluribus Unum. Diversity and Community in the Twenty-first Century, Scandinavian Political Studies 30 (2007) 137.
  • 61. Rass, Christopher , Institutionalisierungsprozesse auf einem internationalen Arbeitsmarkt (2010).
  • 62. Reidegeld, Eckart , Armenpflege und Migration von der Gründung des Deutschen Bundes bis zum Erlass des Gesetzes über den Unterstützungswohnsitz, in Bommes Michael/Halfmann Jost (Hg), Migration in nationalen Wohlfahrtsstaaten (1998) 253.
  • 63. Rokkan, Stein , Staat, Nation und Demokratie in Europa (2000).
  • 64. Ruhs, Martin , The Price of Rights. Regulating International Labor Migration (2013).
  • 65. Somek, Alexander , Individualism. An Essay on the Authority of the European Union (2008).
  • 66. Spiro, Peter J. , Beyond Citizenship (2008).
  • 67. Thym, Daniel , Migrationsverwaltungsrecht (2010).
  • 68. Thym, Daniel , Freizügigkeit in Europa als Modell?, EuR 2011, 487. DOI 10.5771/0531-2485-2011-4-487
  • 69. Thym, Daniel , EU Migration Policy and its Constitutional Rationale. A Cosmopolitan Outlook, Common Market Law Review 50 (2013) 709.
  • 70. Thym, Daniel , Constitutional Foundations of the Judgments on the EEC-Turkey Association Agreement, in ders/Zoeteweij-Turhan Margarite (Hg), Rights of Third-Country Nationals under EU Association Agreements (2015) 13. DOI 10.1163/9789004300064_003
  • 71. Thym, Daniel , The Elusive Limits of Solidarity, Common Market Law Review 52 (2015) 17.
  • 72. Thym, Daniel , Family as Link, in Verschueren Herwig (Hg), Residence, Employment and Social Rights of Mobile Persons (2016) 11–38.
  • 73. Thym, Daniel , Long Term Residents Directive 2003/109/EC, in Hailbronner Kay/Thym Daniel (Hg), EU Immigration and Asylum Law. Commentary2 (2016) 427. DOI 10.5771/9783845259208-428
  • 74. Thym, Daniel , Towards a Contextual Conception of Social Integration in EU Immigration Law, European Journal of Migration Law 18 (2016) 89. DOI 10.1163/15718166-12342091
  • 75. Thym, Daniel , Migrationsfolgenrecht, VVDStRL 76 (2017) 169.
  • 76. Thym, Daniel , The Evolution of Citizens’ Rights in Light of the EU’s Constitutional Development, in ders (Hg), Questioning EU Citizenship (2017) 111.
  • 77. Thym, Daniel , Obergrenze für den Familiennachzug zu subsidiär Schutzberechtigten, NVwZ 2018, 1340.
  • 78. Thym, Daniel , Pläne zur Kindergeldreform: Was ist Gleichbehandlung?, Legal Tribune Online 10.08.2018, online unter <https://www.lto.de/recht/hintergruende/h/kindergeld-reform-kopplung-wohnsitz-einwanderung-europa-missbrauch/> (13.08.2019).
  • 79. Thym, Daniel , Rolle des EuGH in der Migrationspolitik: zwischen „Verwaltungsethos“ und „Verfassungsimagination“, EuR 2018, 672. DOI 10.5771/0531-2485-2018-6-672
  • 80. Thym, Daniel , Vom „Fremdenrecht“ über die „Denizenship“ zur „Bürgerschaft“, Der Staat 57 (2018) 77. DOI 10.3790/staa.57.1.77
  • 81. Thym, Daniel , Stellungnahme für die Öffentliche Anhörung des Innenausschusses des Deutschen Bundestags über das sog. Geordnete-Rückkehr-Gesetz, Ausschuss-Drucksache 19(4)286 B vom 03.06.2019.
  • 82. Thym, Daniel , Viel Lärm um Nichts?, ZAR 2019, 131.
  • 83. Tobler, Christa , Context-Related Interpretation of Association Agreements, in Thym Daniel/Zoeteweij-Turhan Margarite (Hg), Rights of Third-Country Nationals under EU Association Agreements (2015) 101. DOI 10.1163/9789004300064_006
  • 84. Tomuschat, Christian , § 178 Der fremdenrechtliche Mindeststandard im Völkerrecht, in Detlef Merten/Hans-Jürgen Papier (Hg), Handbuch der Grundrechte in Deutschland und Europa. VI/2: Europäische Grundrechte II – Universelle Menschenrechte (2009) 419.
  • 85. Verdross, Alfred / Simma, Bruno , Universelles Völkerrecht3 (1984).
  • 86. Verschueren, Herwig , Employment and Social Security Rights of Third-Country Labour Migrants under EU Law, European Journal of Migration Law 18 (2016) 373. DOI 10.1163/15718166-12342107
  • 87. von, Frisch Hans , Das Fremdenrecht (1910).
  • 88. Vosgerau, Ulrich , Staatliche Gemeinschaft und Staatengemeinschaft (2016). DOI 10.1628/978-3-16-152436-3
  • 89. Wiederin, Ewald , Sozialstaatlichkeit im Spannungsfeld von Eigenverantwortung und Fürsorge, VVDStRL 64 (2005) 53.
  • 90. Wiesbrock, Anja , Granting Citizenship-related Rights to Third-Country Nationals, European Journal of Migration Law 14 (2012) 63. DOI 10.1163/157181612x628282
  • 91. Wimmer, Andreas , Binnenintegration und Außenabschließung, in Bommes Michael/Halfmann Jost (Hg), Migration in nationalen Wohlfahrtsstaaten (1998) 199.
  • 92. Wimmer, Andreas / Glick, Schiller Nina , Methodological Nationalism, the Social Sciences, and the Study of Migration, International Migration Review 37 (2003) 576. DOI 10.1111/j.1747-7379.2003.tb00151.x
  • 93. Zacher, Hans F. , Grundfragen des internationalen Sozialrechts, in Becker Ulrich/Ruland Franz (Hg), Hans F. Zacher – Abhandlungen zum Sozialrecht II (1993) 431.
  • 94. Zacher, Hans F. , Sozialer Einschluss und Ausschluss im Zeichen von Nationalisierung und Internationalisierung, in Hockertz Hans Günter (Hg), Koordinaten deutscher Geschichte in der Epoche des Ost-West-Konflikts (2004) 103. DOI 10.1524/9783486594607.103