Abstract
Despite a long and productive history as a focus of research interest, the details of how humans detect motion in an image remain controversial. This debate has not been helped by the lack of a clear parametric description of motion discrimination for some of the more simple visual stimuli employed in the literature to date. With this in mind, in the present work, we examined a peculiarity observed in the perception of the motion of second-order (contrast-modulated) stimuli: Under certain stimulus conditions, there is a reversal in the perceived direction of motion of the pattern. The aim was to quantify this phenomenon, relate the reversal to forward (veridical) and ambiguous motion, and place the behavioral data in the context of the window of visibility model of spatiotemporal contrast sensitivity. The direction of motion of contrast-modulated patterns was measured as a function of temporal frequency and carrier contrast, under different critical stimulus conditions. The stimulus properties manipulated were spatial frequency, spatial-phase relationship of carrier and sidebands, color, duration, and, most critically, the retinal location of the stimulus. On a purely empirical basis, the data reconciled several conflicts in the recent literature. From a theoretical standpoint, the data were well explained by the window of visibility approach in the majority of conditions and were partially explained in the remaining conditions. The results raise some interesting questions about underlying motion detection mechanisms and the assumptions embodied in our approach to motion modeling and the visual system in general. Supplemental materials for this article may be downloaded from app.psychonomic-journals.org/content/supplemental.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Badcock, D. R., & Derrington, A. M. (1985). Detecting the displacement of periodic patterns. Vision Research, 25, 1253–1258.
Badcock, D. R., & Derrington, A. M. (1987). Detecting the displacements of spatial beats: A monocular capability. Vision Research, 27, 793–797.
Badcock, D. R., & Derrington, A. M. (1989). Detecting the displacements of spatial beats: No role for distortion products. Vision Research, 29, 731–739.
Badcock, D. R., & Khuu, S. K. (2001). Independent first- and secondorder motion energy analyses of optic flow. Psychological Research, 65, 50–56.
Benton, C. P., & Johnston, A. (1997). First-order motion from contrast modulated noise? Vision Research, 37, 3073–3078.
Benton, C. P., & Johnston, A. (2001). A new approach to analysing texture-defined motion. Proceedings of the Royal Society B, 268, 2435–2443.
Benton, C. P., Johnston, A., & McOwan, P. W. (1997). Perception of motion direction in luminance- and contrast-defined reversed-phi motion sequences. Vision Research, 37, 2381–2399.
Blakemore, C., & Campbell, F. W. (1968). Adaptation to spatial stimuli. Journal of Physiology, 200, 11P-13P.
Blakemore, C., & Campbell, F. W. (1969). On the existence of neurones in the human visual system selectively sensitive to the orientation and size of retinal images. Journal of Physiology, 203, 237–260.
Boulton, J. C., & Baker, C. L., Jr. (1993). Dependence on stimulus onset asynchrony in apparent motion: Evidence for two mechanisms. Vision Research, 33, 2013–2019.
Burr, D. C., Ross, J., & Morrone, M. C. (1986). Smooth and sampled motion. Vision Research, 26, 643–652.
Burton, G. J. (1973). Evidence for nonlinear response processes in the human visual system from measurements on the thresholds of spatial beat frequencies. Vision Research, 13, 1211–1225.
Campbell, F. W., & Robson, J. G. (1966). Application of Fourier analysis to the visibility of gratings. Journal of Physiology, 197, 551–566.
Cavanagh, P., & Mather, G. (1989). Motion: The long and short of it. Spatial Vision, 4, 103–129.
Chubb, C., & Sperling, G. (1988). Drift-balanced random stimuli: A general basis for studying non-Fourier motion perception. Journal of the Optical Society of America A, 5, 1986–2006.
Cropper, S. J. (1992). Human motion detection: Different patterns, different detectors? Unpublished doctoral thesis, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Newcastle, U.K.
Cropper, S. J. (1994). Velocity discrimination in chromatic gratings and beats. Vision Research, 34, 41–48.
Cropper, S. J. (1998). Detection of chromatic and luminance contrast modulation by the visual system. Journal of the Optical Society of America A, 15, 1969–1986.
Cropper, S. J. (2005). The detection of motion in chromatic stimuli: First-order and second-order spatial structure. Vision Research, 45, 265–280.
Cropper, S. J., & Badcock, D. R. (1994). Discriminating smooth from sampled motion: Chromatic and luminance stimuli. Journal of the Optical Society of America A, 11, 515–530.
Cropper, S. J., & Badcock, D. R. (1995). Perceived direction of motion: It takes all orientations [Abstract]. Perception, 24, 106a.
Cropper, S. J., & Badcock, D. R. (2008). Perception of direction of motion reflects the early integration of first and second-order stimulus spatial properties. Journal of Vision, 8, 1–10.
Cropper, S. J., Badcock, D. R., & Hayes, A. (1994). On the role of second-order signals in the perceived direction of motion of type II plaid patterns. Vision Research, 34, 2609–2612.
Cropper, S. J., & Derrington, A. M. (1994). Motion of chromatic stimuli: First-order or second-order? Vision Research, 34, 49–58.
Cropper, S. J., & Derrington, A. M. (1996). Detection and motion detection in chromatic and luminance beats. Journal of the Optical Society of America A, 13, 401–407.
Cropper, S. J., & Johnston, A. (2001). The motion of contrast envelopes: Peace and noise. Journal of the Optical Society of America A, 18, 2237–2254.
Cropper, S. J., Johnston, A., & Benton, C. (2008). The detection of the motion of contrast modulation: Theoretical considerations. Manuscript in preparation.
Cropper, S. J., & Wuerger, S. M. (2005). The perception of motion in chromatic stimuli. Behavioural & Cognitive Neuroscience Reviews, 4, 192–217.
Derrington, A. M. (1994). Analysis of the motion of contrast modulated patterns. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science, 35, 1406.
Derrington, A. M., Allen, H. A., & Delicato, L. S. (2004). Visual mechanisms of motion analysis and motion perception. Annual Review of Psychology, 55, 181–205.
Derrington, A. M., Badcock, D. R., & Henning, G. B. (1993). Discriminating the direction of second-order motion at short stimulus durations. Vision Research, 33, 1785–1794.
Derrington, A. M., & Cox, M. (1998). Temporal resolution of dichoptic and second-order motion mechanisms. Vision Research, 38, 3531–3539.
Derrington, A. M., & Goddard, P. A. (1989). Failure of motion discrimination at high contrasts: Evidence for saturation. Vision Research, 29, 1767–1776.
Derrington, A. M., & Goddard, P. A. (1992). Does the human visual system combine information from motion analyses at different spatial scales? Journal of Physiology, 452, 283P.
Derrington, A. M., & Henning, G. B. (1987). Errors in directionof-motion discrimination with complex stimuli. Vision Research, 27, 61–75.
Derrington, A. M., & Henning, G. B. (1993). Linear and non-linear mechanisms in pattern vision. Current Biology, 3, 800–803.
Derrington, A. M., Krauskopf, J., & Lennie, P. (1984). Chromatic mechanisms in lateral geniculate nucleus of macaque. Journal of Physiology, 357, 241–265.
Duffy, C. J. (2004). The cortical analysis of optic flow. In L. Chalupa & J. S. Werner (Eds.), The visual neurosciences (Vol. 2, pp. 1260–1283). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Edwards, M., & Badcock, D. R. (1995). Global motion perception: No interaction between the first-order and second-order motion pathways. Vision Research, 35, 2589–2602.
Findlay, J. M. (1978). Estimates on probability functions: A more virulent PEST. Perception & Psychophysics, 23, 181–185.
Green, D. G. (1970). Regional variations in the visual acuity for interference fringes on the retina. Journal of Physiology, 207, 351–356.
Grossberg, S., & Pilly, P. K. (2008). Temporal dynamics of decisionmaking during motion perception in the visual cortex. Vision Research, 48, 1345–1373.
Henning, G. B., & Derrington, A. M. (1988). Direction-of-motion discrimination with complex patterns: Further observations. Journal of the Optical Society of America A, 5, 1759–1766.
Henning, G. B., Hertz, B. G., & Broadbent, D. E. (1975). Some experiments bearing on the hypothesis that the visual system analyses spatial patterns in independent bands of spatial frequency. Vision Research, 15, 887–897.
Holliday, I. E., & Anderson, S. J. (1994). Different processes underlie the detection of second-order motion at low and high temporal frequencies. Proceedings of the Royal Society B, 257, 165–173.
Hutchinson, C. V., & Ledgeway, T. (2006). Sensitivity to spatial and temporal modulations of first-order and second-order motion. Vision Research, 46, 324–335.
Jamar, J. H. T., Campagne, J. C., & Koenderink, J. J. (1982). Detectability of amplitude- and frequency-modulation of suprathreshold sine-wave gratings. Vision Research, 22, 407–416.
Jamar, J. H. T., Kwakman, L. F. T., & Koenderink, J. J. (1984). The sensitivity of the peripheral visual system to amplitude-modulation and frequency-modulation of sine-wave patterns. Vision Research, 24, 243–249.
Johnston, A., & Benton, C. P. (1997). Speed discrimination thresholds for first- and second-order bars and edges. Vision Research, 37, 2217–2226.
Johnston, A., Benton, C. P., & McOwan, P. W. (1999). Induced mo tion at texture-defined motion boundaries. Proceedings of the Royal Society B, 266, 2441–2450.
Johnston, A., Benton, C. P., & Morgan, M. J. (1999). Concurrent measurement of perceived speed and speed discrimination threshold using the method of single stimuli. Vision Research, 39, 3849–3855.
Johnston, A., & Clifford, C. W. G. (1995). Perceived motion of contrast-modulated gratings: Predictions of the multi-channel gradient model and the role of full-wave rectification. Vision Research, 35, 1771–1784.
Julesz, B. (1971). Foundations of cyclopean perception. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Kitagawa, N., & Ichigara, S. (2002). Hearing visual motion in depth. Nature, 416, 172–174.
Ledgeway, T., & Hess, R. F. (2000). The properties of the motion-detecting mechanisms mediating perceived direction in stochastic displays. Vision Research, 40, 3585–3597.
Ledgeway, T., & Hess, R. F. (2002). Failure of direction identification for briefly presented second-order motion stimuli: Evidence for weak direction selectivity of the mechanisms encoding motion. Vision Research, 42, 1739–1758.
Ledgeway, T., Hess, R. F., & McGraw, P. V. (2002). Masking effects between local first-order and second-order motions in the extraction of global-motion direction depend critically on stimulus visibility. Perception, 31, 99–100.
Ledgeway, T., & Hutchinson, C. V. (2005). The influence of spatial and temporal noise on the detection of first-order and second-order orientation and motion direction. Vision Research, 45, 2081–2094.
Ledgeway, T., & Hutchinson, C. V. (2006). Is the direction of secondorder, contrast-defined motion patterns visible to standard motionenergy detectors: A model answer? Vision Research, 46, 556–567.
Ledgeway, T., & Smith, A. T. (1994a). The duration of the motion aftereffect following adaptation to first-order and second-order motion. Perception, 23, 1211–1219.
Ledgeway, T., & Smith, A. T. (1994b). Evidence for separate motiondetecting mechanisms for first-order and second-order motion in human vision. Vision Research, 34, 2727–2740.
Ledgeway, T., & Smith, A. T. (1995). The perceived speed of secondorder motion and its dependence on stimulus contrast. Vision Research, 35, 1421–1434.
Ledgeway, T., & Smith, A. T. (1997). Changes in perceived speed following adaptation to first-order and second-order motion. Vision Research, 37, 215–225.
Lennie, P., & Movshon, J. A. (2005). Coding of color and form in geniculostriate pathway. Journal of the Optical Society of America A, 22, 2013–2033.
Levinson, E., & Sekuler, R. (1975a). The independence of channels in human vision selective for direction of movement. Journal of Physiology, 250, 347–366.
Levinson, E., & Sekuler, R. (1975b). Inhibition and disinhibition of direction-specific mechanisms in human vision. Nature, 254, 692–694.
Lombrozo, T., Judson, J., & MacLeod, D. I. A. (2005). Flexibility of spatial averaging in visual perception. Proceedings of the Royal Society B, 272, 725–732.
Lu, Z.-L., & Sperling, G. (1995). The functional architecture of human visual motion perception. Vision Research, 35, 2697–2722.
Lu, Z.-L., & Sperling, G. (2001). Three systems theory of human visual motion perception: Review and update. Journal of the Optical Society of America A, 18, 2331–2370.
MacLeod, D. I. A., Williams, D. R., & Makous, W. (1992). A visual non-linearity fed by single cones. Vision Research, 32, 347–363.
Marr, D. (1982). Vision: A computational investigation into the human representation and processing of visual information. San Francisco: Freeman.
Marr, D., & Ullman, S. (1981). Directional selectivity and its use in early visual processing. Proceedings of the Royal Society B, 211, 151–180.
Mullen, K. T. (1985). The contrast sensitivity of human color vision to red-green and blue-yellow chromatic gratings. Journal of Physiology, 359, 381–400.
Mullen, K. T., & Boulton, J. C. (1992). Absence of smooth motion perception in color vision. Vision Research, 32, 483–488.
Palmer, J., Huk, A. C., & Shadlen, M. N. (2005). The effect of stimulus strength on the speed and accuracy of a perceptual decision. Journal of Vision, 5, 376–404.
Pantle, A. (1992). Immobility of some second-order stimuli in human peripheral vision. Journal of the Optical Society of America A, 9, 863–867.
Robson, J. G. (1966). Spatial and temporal contrast sensitivity functions of the visual system. Journal of the Optical Society of America, 56, 1141–1142.
Schofield, A. J., & Georgeson, M. A. (2003). Sensitivity to contrast modulation: The spatial frequency dependence of second-order vision. Vision Research, 43, 243–259.
Seiffert, A. E., & Cavanagh, P. (1998). Position displacement, not velocity, is the cue to motion detection of second-order stimuli. Vision Research, 38, 3569–3582.
Serrano-Pedraza, I., Goddard, P., & Derrington, A. M. (2007). Evidence for reciprocal antagonism between motion sensors tuned to coarse and fine features. Journal of Vision, 7, 1–14.
Smith, A. T., Hess, R. F., & Baker, C. L., Jr. (1994). Direction identification thresholds for second-order motion in central and peripheral vision. Journal of the Optical Society of America A, 11, 506–514.
Smith, A. T., & Ledgeway, T. (1995). Second-order motion: The carrier is crucial [Abstract]. Perception, 24, 28a.
Smith, A. T., & Ledgeway, T. (1997). Separate detection of moving luminance and contrast modulations: Fact or artifact? Vision Research, 37, 45–62.
Smith, A. T., & Ledgeway, T. (1998). Sensitivity to second-order motion as a function of temporal frequency and eccentricity. Vision Research, 38, 403–410.
Smith, A. T., & Ledgeway, T. (2001). Motion detection in human vision: A unifying approach based on energy and features. Proceedings of the Royal Society B, 268, 1889–1899.
Solomon, J. A., & Sperling, G. (1995). 1st- and 2nd-order motion and texture resolution in central and peripheral vision. Vision Research, 35, 59–64.
Stone, L. S., & Thompson, P. (1992). Human speed perception is contrast dependent. Vision Research, 32, 1535–1549.
Thibos, L. N., Cheney, F. E., & Walsh, D. J. (1987). Retinal limits to the detection and resolution of gratings. Journal of the Optical Society of America A, 4, 1524–1529.
Thompson, P. (1982). Perceived rate of movement depends on contrast. Vision Research, 22, 377–380.
Thompson, P. (1984). The coding of velocity of movement in the human visual system. Vision Research, 24, 41–45.
Virsu, V., Rovamo, J., Laurinen, P., & Näsänen, R. (1982). Temporal contrast sensitivity and cortical magnification. Vision Research, 22, 1211–1217.
Wang, Y.-Z., Hess, R. F., & Baker, C. L., Jr. (1997). Second-order motion perception in peripheral vision: Limits of early filtering. Journal of the Optical Society of America A, 14, 3145–3154.
Warren, W. H. (2004). Optic flow. In L. Chalupa & J. S. Werner (Eds.), The visual neurosciences (pp. 1247–1259). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Watson, A. B., Ahumada, A., & Farrell, J. E. (1986). Window of visibility: A psychophysical theory of fidelity in time-sampled visual displays. Journal of the Optical Society of America A, 3, 300–307.
Watson, A. B., Thompson, P. G., Murphy, B. J., & Nachmias, J. (1980). Summation and discrimination of gratings moving in opposite directions. Vision Research, 20, 341–347.
Wilson, H. R., Ferrera, V. P., & Yo, C. (1992). A psychophysically motivated model for two-dimensional motion perception. Visual Neuroscience, 9, 79–97.
Wilson, H. R., & Kim, J. (1994). Perceived motion in the vector-sum direction. Vision Research, 34, 1835–1842.
Yo, C., & Wilson, H. R. (1992). Perceived direction of moving twodimensional patterns depends on duration, contrast and eccentricity. Vision Research, 32, 135–147.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
The work presented in this article was collected over a period of several years and was financially supported by grants from the Wellcome Trust and the Australian Research Council.
Electronic supplementary material
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Cropper, S.J., Kvansakul, J.G.S. & Johnston, A. The detection of the motion of contrast modulation: A parametric study. Attention, Perception, & Psychophysics 71, 757–782 (2009). https://doi.org/10.3758/APP.71.4.757
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3758/APP.71.4.757