This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
A Single-Cylinder Engine Study of Methanol Fuel-Emphasis on Organic Emissions
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Exhaust emission and performance characteristics of a single-cylinder engine fueled with methanol are compared to those obtained either with gasoline or a methanol-water blend. Our measurements of engine efficiency and power, and CO and NOx emissions agree with trends established in the literature. Consequently, the emphasis is placed on organic emissions (unburned fuel including hydrocarbons, and aldehydes), an area in which there is no consensus in the literature.
In all cases with methanol fueling, the unburned fuel (UBF) emissions were virtually all methanol as opposed to hydrocarbon compounds. Without special measures to overcome methanol's large heat of vaporization, UBF emissions were four times greater with methanol than those with gasoline. Similarly, aldehyde emissions were an order of magnitude greater with methanol. These high levels of organic emissions with methanol were related to inadequate fuel-air mixture preparation, which was caused by methanol's large heat of vaporization. Modifying the single-cylinder engine intake system to improve vaporization reduced UBF emissions 80 to 90 percent with methanol and 30 to 50 percent with gasoline. Aldehyde emissions were also significantly reduced by improving mixture preparation, but remained three to four times greater for methanol than for gasoline.
Blending 10 percent water with methanol resulted in: 1) reduced engine efficiency and power, 2) increased UBF emissions, 3) no measurable effect on aldehyde and CO emissions, and 4) reduced NOx emissions. Our tests indicate that the advantages of blending water with methanol are outweighed by the disadvantages.
Authors
Citation
Hilden, D. and Parks, F., "A Single-Cylinder Engine Study of Methanol Fuel-Emphasis on Organic Emissions," SAE Technical Paper 760378, 1976, https://doi.org/10.4271/760378.Also In
References
- Pangborn J. Gillis J. “Alternative Fuels for Automotive Transportation - A Feasibility Study,” 1-3 U. S. Environmental Protection Agency July 1974
- Kant F. H. Cahn R. P. Cunningham A. R. Farmer M. H. Herbst W. Manny E. H. “Feasibility Study of Alternative Fuels for Automotive Transportation,” 1-3 U. S. Environmental Protection Agency June 1974
- Johnson R. T. “Energy and Synthetic Fuels for Transportation,” Central States Combustion Institute Symposium Madison, Wisconsin 1974
- Hurn R. W. “Characteristics of Conventional Fuels from Nonpetroleum Sources - An Experimental Study,” General Motors Research Laboratories Symposium - Future Automotive Fuels - Prospects, Performance, and Perspective Warren, Michigan October 1975
- Fleming R. D. Chamberlain T. W. “Methanol as Automotive Fuel, Part I - Straight Methanol,” SAE Paper 750121 February 1975
- Harrington J. A. Pilot R. M. “Combustion and Emission Characteristics of Methanol,” SAE Paper 750420 February 1975
- Bernhardt W. E. “Engine Performance and Exhaust Emission Characteristics from a Methanol-Fueled Automobile,” General Motors Research Laboratories Symposium - Future Automotive Fuels - Prospects, Performance, and Perspective Warren, Michigan October 1975
- Most W. J. Longwell J. P. “Single-Cylinder Engine Evaluation of Methanol - Improved Energy Economy and Reduced NO x ,” SAE Paper 750119 February 1975
- Ebersole G. D. Manning F. S. “Engine Performance and Exhaust Emissions: Methanol versus Iso-octane,” SAE Paper 720692 August 1972
- Adelman H. G. Andrews D. G. Devoto R. S. “Exhaust Emissions from a Methanol-Fueled Automobile,” SAE Paper 720693 August 1972
- Pefley R. K. Saad M. A. Sweeney M. A. Kilgroe J. D. “Performance and Emission Characteristics Using Blends of Methanol and Dissociated Methanol as an Automotive Fuel,” Paper 719008 Intersociety Energy Conversion Engineering Conference 1971
- Patterson D. J. Henein N. A. Emissions from Combustion Engines and Their Control Ann Arbor Science Publishers, Inc. Ann Arbor, Michigan 1972
- Altshuller A. P. Cohen I. R. “Structural Effects on the Rate of Nitrogen Oxide Formation in the Photo-Oxidation of Organic Compound-Nitric Oxide Mixtures in Air,” Journal of Air and Water Pollution 7 1963
- Beckman Instruments Fullerton, California April 1975
- Sawicki E. Hauser T. R. Stanley T. W. Elbert W. Analytical Chemistry 33 93 1961
- Ingamells J. C. Lindquist R. H. “Methanol as a Motor Fuel or a Gasoline Blending Component,” SAE Paper 750123 February 1975
- Wodkowski C. S. Weaver E. E. “The Effects of Engine Parameters, Fuel Composition, and Control Devices on Exhaust Aldehyde Emissions,” West Coast Air Pollution Control Association Meeting October 1970
- Lestz S. S. Meyer W. E. “The Effect of Direct-Cylinder Water Injection on Nitric Oxide Emission from an SI Engine,” Proc. 14th FISITA Congr. London, England June 1972
- Obert E. F. Internal Combustion Engines and Air Pollution Intext Educational Publishers New York, New York 1973
- “Basic Considerations in the Combustion of Hydrocarbon Fuels with Air,” NACA Report 1300 1959
- Taylor C. F. Taylor E. S. The Internal Combustion Engine Second International Textbook Company Scranton, Pennsylvania 1970
- General Motors Research Laboratories December 1975