This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Effect of Compression Ratio on Exhaust Emissions and Performance of a Methanol-Fueled Single-Cylinder Engine
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
One of the reasons methanol is considered an attractive alternative fuel for automobiles is its high octane quality, which may allow the use of high compression ratio (CR) engines. To evaluate compromises between engine efficiency and exhaust emissions, a methanol-fueled single-cylinder engine was run at CR's from 8 to 18. At each CR, engine speed and airflow were constant at 1200 rpm and about half throttle, respectively; equivalence ratio (ø) was varied from 0.7 to 1.1; and spark timing was varied from best power (MBT) to 10° retarded. Knock was observed only at CR = 18 with MBT spark timing.
Increasing CR from 8 to 18 while maintaining MBT spark timing increased efficiency about 16 percent, but also increased NOx and unburned fuel (UBF) emissions. Some previous studies have reported decreased NOx emissions with increased CR, possibly because MBT spark timing was not maintained. Results of this study indicate that constant NOx emissions can be maintained by retarding spark timing while increasing CR to improve efficiency. Retarding spark timing, however, only marginally reduced UBF emissions.
Vehicle tests are necessary to define the optimum CR for methanol fueling because exhaust emission trends and knocking tendency may be different than those observed with this single-cylinder engine.
Recommended Content
Authors
Citation
Brinkman, N., "Effect of Compression Ratio on Exhaust Emissions and Performance of a Methanol-Fueled Single-Cylinder Engine," SAE Technical Paper 770791, 1977, https://doi.org/10.4271/770791.Also In
References
- Pangborn J. Gillis J. “Alternative Fuels for Automotive Transportation - A Feasibility Study,” 1-3 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency July 1974
- Kant F. H. Cahn R. P. Cunningham A. R. Farmer M. H. Herbst W. Manny E. H. “Feasibility Study of Alternative Fuels for Automotive Transportation,” 1-3 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency June 1974
- Faltermayer E. “The Clean Synthetic Fuel That's Already Here,” Fortune September 1975 147 154
- Most W. J. Longwell J. P. “Single-Cylinder Engine Evaluation of Methanol - Improved Energy Economy and Reduced NO x ,” Paper 750119 SAE Automotive Engineering Congress and Exposition Detroit, Michigan February 1975
- Hilden D. L. Parks F. B. “A Single-Cylinder Engine Study of Methanol Fuel - Emphasis on Organic Emissions,” Paper 760378 SAE Automotive Engineering Congress and Exposition Detroit, Michigan February 1976
- Koenig A Lee W. Bernhardt W. “Technical and Economic Aspects of Methanol as an Automotive Fuel,” Paper 760545 SAE Fuels and Lubricants Powerplant Meeting St. Louis, Missouri June 1976
- LoRusso J. A. Tabaczynski R. J. “Combustion and Emissions Characteristics of Methanol, Methanol-Water, and Gasoline-Methanol Blends in a Spark Ignition Engine,” Paper 769019 Eleventh IECEC Conference Lake Tahoe, Nevada September 1976
- Fleming R. D. Chamberlain T. W. “Methanol as Automotive Fuel, Part I - Straight Methanol,” Paper 750121 SAE Automotive Engineering Congress and Exposition Detroit, Michigan February 1975
- Allsup J. R. “Experimental Results Using Methanol and Methanol/Gasoline Blends as Automotive Engine Fuel,” Energy Research and Development Administration Bartlesville, Oklahoma January 1977
- Ingamells J. C. Lindquist R. H. “Methanol as a Motor Fuel or a Gasoline Blending Component,” Paper 750123 SAE Automotive Engineering Congress and Exposition Detroit, Michigan February 1975
- Bernhardt W. E. Koenig A. Lee W. Menrad H. “Recent Progress in Automotive Alcohol Fuel Application,” NATO/CCMS Fourth International Symposium on Automotive Propulsion Systems Arlington, Virginia April 1977
- Brinkman N. D. “Vehicle Evaluation of Neat Methanol - Compromises Among Exhaust Emissions, Fuel Economy, and Driveability,” NATO/CCMS Fourth International Symposium on Automotive Propulsion Systems Arlington, Virginia April 1977
- Patterson D. J. Henein N. A. “Emissions from Combustion Engines and Their Control,” Ann Arbor Science Publishers, Inc. Ann Arbor, Michigan 1972
- Bernhardt W. E. “Combustion Technology for the Improvement of Engine Efficiency and Emission Characteristics,” Sixteenth Symposium on Combustion Massachusetts Institute of Technology Cambridge, Massachusetts August 1976
- Gumbleton J. J. Niepoth G. W. Currie J. H. “Effect of Energy and Emission Constraints on Compression Ratio,” Paper 760826 SAE Automobile Engineering Meeting Dearborn, Michigan October 1976
- Baker R. E. Daby E. E. Pratt J. W. “Selecting Compression Ratio for Optimum Fuel Economy with Emission Constraints,” Paper 770191 SAE Automotive Engineering Congress and Exposition Detroit, Michigan February 1977
- Parks F. B. “A Single-Cylinder Engine Study of Hydrogen-Rich Fuels,” Paper 760099 SAE Automotive Engineering Congress and Exposition Detroit, Michigan February 1976
- Caris D. F. Mitchell B. J. McDuffie A. D. Wyczalek F. A. “Mechanical Octane for Higher Efficiency,” SAE Transactions 64 1956 76 96
- Anderson V. L. McLean R. A. “Design of Experiments: A Realistic Approach,” Marcel Dekker, Inc. New York, New York 1974
- Caris D. F. Nelson E. E. “A New Look at High Compression Engines,” Paper #61A SAE Summer Meeting Atlantic City, New Jersey June 1958
- Aldrich W. L. “Matching Compression Ratio and Spark Advance to Engine Octane Requirements,” General Motors Engineering Journal October-November 1956 29
- Blumberg P. Kummer J. T. “Prediction of NO Formation in Spark-Ignition Engines,” Combustion Science and Technology 4 1971 73 95
- Aiman W. R. “A Critical Test for Models of the Nitric Oxide Formation Process in Spark-Ignition Engines,” Fourteenth Symposium on Combustion Pennsylvania State University August 1972
- Browning L. H. Pefley R. K. “Computer Predicted Compression Ratio Effects on NO x Emissions from a Methanol Fueled SI Engine,” Twelfth IECEC Conference Washington, D. C August-September 1977
- Quader A. A. “What Limits Lean Operation in Spark Ignition Engines - Flame Initiation or Propagation?” Paper 760760 SAE Automotive Engineering Meeting Dearborn, Michigan October 1976
- Gumbleton J. J. Bolton R. A. Lang H. W. “Optimizing Engine Parameters with Exhaust Gas Recirculation,” Paper 740104 SAE Automotive Engineering Congress Detroit, Michigan February-March 1974